Originally posted by 1VBChaos
LOL - Are you serious??
(yes - I do have experience of doing REAL beta testing in the commercial market for a company FAR bigger than GLB, so please don't patronise me as, up until now, I don't think we've ever crossed swords)
As have I testing products far larger than GLB (world-wide products in the millions of dollars, even stalling the release of products which made the news). So lets not strut our feathers here and just agree that we've both got experience and leave it at that. And my intention wasn't to patronize you, but try and and explain, in brief that you are missing the big picture. Ultimately, nearly every product that we buy is a beta product, cars, computers, wrist watches, etc. Why? Because the time these products hit the streets, they are already outdated and the manufacturers are watching them to see what the flaws are to make improvements on the ones in R&D. Buying anything new is essentially funding the R&D process for the next generation. Additionally, no, we haven't crossed swords and I don't intend to - keep your's in your sheeth and I'll keep mine in mine.
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
And whilst loopholes are being found, the fact that they've been historically used to to benefit of the person(s) who've found them turns the concept of 'testing' into one of 'cheating'.
How else are users to find the extent of the loopholes? Is that they they aren't reported immediately?
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
And leaving aside the 'testing' exploits that seem to be getting focussed on, there are other things that have also been credited into the staff repetoire - multiple accounts, buying accounts, gutting teams (apt, given the thread topic) etc - how do you excuse those things??
We're not trying to excuse those things and they are dealt with when they're discovered.
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
I'd be the first to say that it's only a small minority who've brought ALL of your names into disrepute, but the sad thing is, we all know who I'm talking about. And the fact that no action has ever been taken against the people involved runs contrary to Bort's 'playing it straight' statement.
Why don't you stop playing charades and lay your cards on the table then? If you're that confident of what you're saying, then send the information to support which goes directly to the admins. Name names and lay out the evidence. The admins, to my knowledge, are diligent in at least contacting the relevant parties involved. Don't do it here as you'll only make the issue worse and end up getting the the thread locked or possibly even deleted. Make your accusations, sure, but be professional and respectful doing it. Taking the stance that you have only puts those that your conversing with into a defensive position right off the bat, which is not something you want to do if you're trying to get something accomplished. To start a fight and release some frustration and anger, yes. To actually get the other party to listen to you and be - willing - to help you, no.
Originally posted by demonicangel
Originally posted by norsemanvike
VB,
With all due respect, finding exploits, flaws, errors, etc. and exposing their possibilities is actually the job of - anyone - testing a software program, from Alpha stage testing, through Beta (which GLB is), into Release Candidate, and finally verifying and continual testing of issues found by others in the final release versions...
I dont think hes attacking your knowledge, I think hes more or less attacking peoples motives.
It wasn't taken that way and I agree, he was addressing the motives.