User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > has something changed in catching ..this was a bit to much to take
Page:
 
JD Cuda
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ron2288
Originally posted by jdupuy3

Originally posted by robelder


I'm seeing this issue most with fast receivers. it makes sense why lower level receivers don't have this problem. Are your guy over 80 in speed?


Yup.
Over 80 in Season 5.
Over 80 in Season 4.
Over 80 in Season 3. (part of it)


shows what you know..he is speed is not over 80...lol..another know it all that dont know...he is a possession wr...hmmmmmnm
I love how guys think they know a build w/o seeing it


huh? I was telling him the build of my WR. I can see my own build.

I'm lost.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ron2288
And TSE please dont pm me again telling me about your stupid guide...


LOL.
 
BigDaddyTim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by tonylieu

Originally posted by Perok


I can tell you out right higher catching means more caught passes.

If your dropping too many you obviously don't have enough in catching.
Same with DB's... maybe those 70 + speed DB's are great at getting close to the WR.. but whats your agility/vision.. maybe your being outjumped?

the answer is a better written description in the PbP,... not asking for another nerf.


QFT
Just for comparison purpose, my lvl-21 possession receiver has 60+ catching and he's doing fine with catching the ball


Well I don't want a possession receiver...I made a speed receiver for a reason.

I really don't see why people assume there's no problem just because it didn't happen to them.


speed receivers dont catch everything thrown at them. most of the time they miss catches that most people would make just because they are not that good a catching.

I am a Raider fan and trust me i know what i am talking about when it comes to speed receivers not catching the ball. We have watched the fastest of the fast drop balls that our 4 year olds could catch. You say you dont want a possession receiver but then cry when your speed guy dont catch everything. you chose to build a WR that cant catch then cry when he dont catch the ball. that would be like me building a WR with 99 catch and 3 speed and crying when he cant out run anyone.
 
tonylieu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by tonylieu

Originally posted by Perok


I can tell you out right higher catching means more caught passes.

If your dropping too many you obviously don't have enough in catching.
Same with DB's... maybe those 70 + speed DB's are great at getting close to the WR.. but whats your agility/vision.. maybe your being outjumped?

the answer is a better written description in the PbP,... not asking for another nerf.


QFT
Just for comparison purpose, my lvl-21 possession receiver has 60+ catching and he's doing fine with catching the ball


Well I don't want a possession receiver...I made a speed receiver for a reason.

I really don't see why people assume there's no problem just because it didn't happen to them.


Well then don't expect him to catch the ball as well as a possession wr. Am I missing something or you expect to have your speed receiver to catch the ball as well as my possession receiver? News flash!!!! speed != catching
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tonylieu
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Originally posted by tonylieu


Originally posted by Perok



I can tell you out right higher catching means more caught passes.

If your dropping too many you obviously don't have enough in catching.
Same with DB's... maybe those 70 + speed DB's are great at getting close to the WR.. but whats your agility/vision.. maybe your being outjumped?

the answer is a better written description in the PbP,... not asking for another nerf.


QFT
Just for comparison purpose, my lvl-21 possession receiver has 60+ catching and he's doing fine with catching the ball


Well I don't want a possession receiver...I made a speed receiver for a reason.

I really don't see why people assume there's no problem just because it didn't happen to them.


Well then don't expect him to catch the ball as well as a possession wr. Am I missing something or you expect to have your speed receiver to catch the ball as well as my possession receiver? News flash!!!! speed != catching


How often would you expect a guy that is fast to catch a ball thrown to him with no one within 5 yards of him and the ball extremely close to his proximity.

That is the question we're debating. Are you saying 10% is reasonable, 25%. I'm saying minimum 50% if the WR is worth anything. If he's not maybe 1/3. Right now we're at about 10% on these wide open passes.
 
BigDaddyTim
offline
Link
 
i am saying 15% if the guys is faster then his eye hand coordination then he is not going to catch the ball. have you not ever seen a speed guy running down the field and the ball hit him in the back because he was to stupid to turn around and look back for the ball? Well this is your WR. is is super fast but to stupid to look back for the ball that is hitting him in the back.
 
tonylieu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by robelder
Originally posted by tonylieu

Originally posted by Sik Wit It


Originally posted by tonylieu



Originally posted by Perok




I can tell you out right higher catching means more caught passes.

If your dropping too many you obviously don't have enough in catching.
Same with DB's... maybe those 70 + speed DB's are great at getting close to the WR.. but whats your agility/vision.. maybe your being outjumped?

the answer is a better written description in the PbP,... not asking for another nerf.


QFT
Just for comparison purpose, my lvl-21 possession receiver has 60+ catching and he's doing fine with catching the ball


Well I don't want a possession receiver...I made a speed receiver for a reason.

I really don't see why people assume there's no problem just because it didn't happen to them.


Well then don't expect him to catch the ball as well as a possession wr. Am I missing something or you expect to have your speed receiver to catch the ball as well as my possession receiver? News flash!!!! speed != catching


How often would you expect a guy that is fast to catch a ball thrown to him with no one within 5 yards of him and the ball extremely close to his proximity.

That is the question we're debating. Are you saying 10% is reasonable, 25%. I'm saying minimum 50% if the WR is worth anything. If he's not maybe 1/3. Right now we're at about 10% on these wide open passes.


Well let's do some quick rough math, shall we?

I would say a possession receiver with 100 catching and 100 vision should have about 100% chance of catching a ball thrown perfectly by a QB with 100 throwing and 100 strength and 100 vision. For your SPEED receiver let knock it down to 50%. But your QB is not perfect, so let assume he has 80 throwing, 50 strength, and 50 vision. So he will have about 20% chance of throwing a perfect ball to your SPEED receiver. That means the catch percentage drops to 10%. But your reciver is not perfect either, and with poor catching say of 50, the final chance that he can catch a ball is 5%.

Of course this is very rough calculation, so for the benefit of a doubt, lets just double that number to 10%. Hmm, that number looks somewhat familiar.
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdupuy3
Originally posted by ron2288

Originally posted by jdupuy3


Originally posted by robelder



I'm seeing this issue most with fast receivers. it makes sense why lower level receivers don't have this problem. Are your guy over 80 in speed?


Yup.
Over 80 in Season 5.
Over 80 in Season 4.
Over 80 in Season 3. (part of it)


shows what you know..he is speed is not over 80...lol..another know it all that dont know...he is a possession wr...hmmmmmnm
I love how guys think they know a build w/o seeing it


huh? I was telling him the build of my WR. I can see my own build.

I'm lost.


sorry my frustration got the better of me..I jumped to conclusion to quick
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 19:46:28
 
zollins5
offline
Link
 
OK, I am the receiver in question here at the beginning of this thread. I have read this one to the end, so I could get up to date, before posting anything stupid lol. I am going to give up a couple of my stats to help in this debate.
73 speed, 51 agility, 50 catching, 50 vision

I agree with what was said earlier about the low throw. No way could it have gotten past that CB if it had been a low throw. I know the dots aren't accurate, but it looks like he still has plenty of room before stepping out of bounds. I would love to see a better description on the pbp, or maybe even just a more accurate video representation of what is really happening. This would cut back on a lot of this complaining about what is or isn't happening(I know that would prob. be incredibly hard to put in, just saying I would like it).
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.