User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by thebigcali
I should clarify Bort is almost always more responsive than this. But in this case, his rationale doesn't match the sad sad effect the code had on the player. I hate seeing plays like this, they do not reflect realism, period.



Didn't Leon Lett run completely the wrong direction with the ball and get a safety?

I think at least a few times in NFL history that has happened.

What about slipping and falling? That happens alot too. Sometimes with no one around. Jerome Bettis at the end of his career would often trip over his own linemen. Is that realism enough?

How many times in NFL games have you seen someone lose the ball without even being touched? Sometimes they are carrying it with one hand and it slips out of they spike it or something like Plaxico Burress.

I see alot of errors in the game, but this little cutback is not even in the top 50.

If you want non-realistic stats....how about the DE's that are on pace for 50+ sacks? 71 sacks for 1 DE last year. Over 40 sacks against non-gutted teams. That isn't realism when 15 to 23 sacks win the crown every year.

 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by thebigcali

I should clarify Bort is almost always more responsive than this. But in this case, his rationale doesn't match the sad sad effect the code had on the player. I hate seeing plays like this, they do not reflect realism, period.



Didn't Leon Lett run completely the wrong direction with the ball and get a safety?

I think at least a few times in NFL history that has happened.

What about slipping and falling? That happens alot too. Sometimes with no one around. Jerome Bettis at the end of his career would often trip over his own linemen. Is that realism enough?

How many times in NFL games have you seen someone lose the ball without even being touched? Sometimes they are carrying it with one hand and it slips out of they spike it or something like Plaxico Burress.

I see alot of errors in the game, but this little cutback is not even in the top 50.

If you want non-realistic stats....how about the DE's that are on pace for 50+ sacks? 71 sacks for 1 DE last year. Over 40 sacks against non-gutted teams. That isn't realism when 15 to 23 sacks win the crown every year.



Thanks for changing the subject. Feel free to contribute these thoughts on their relevant threads, which you usually do.
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by thebigcali

I should clarify Bort is almost always more responsive than this. But in this case, his rationale doesn't match the sad sad effect the code had on the player. I hate seeing plays like this, they do not reflect realism, period.



This isn't really as bad as it appears.

Check the path of the closest CB. Not sure about his speed, but his trajectory appeared to be overrunning the play and stopping the TD. In that case, it appeared that the RB was just cutting inside that CB who overshot his target for the easy TD.

OOPS! There were other players coming also.

Remember though for those of you who never played football before that you don't have full 180 degree vision. If this player only noticed the 1 CB and thought it would be smart to cut inside, I can't say it was horrible.

I see holes all the time that a NFL RB misses. I've seen real life RB's and kick returners make a cutback and get clobbered before. It happens all the time. A TD was not a given in this instance.

The CB most likely had an angle to cut him off. Maybe you say that he should have at least taken the yards down to the 1. I think you could argue that a cutback was a valid option too if he was looking to avoid that first CB. Maybe he just didn't see the rest of the pursuit?



sigh
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by thebigcali

I should clarify Bort is almost always more responsive than this. But in this case, his rationale doesn't match the sad sad effect the code had on the player. I hate seeing plays like this, they do not reflect realism, period.



Didn't Leon Lett run completely the wrong direction with the ball and get a safety?

I think at least a few times in NFL history that has happened.

What about slipping and falling? That happens alot too. Sometimes with no one around. Jerome Bettis at the end of his career would often trip over his own linemen. Is that realism enough?

How many times in NFL games have you seen someone lose the ball without even being touched? Sometimes they are carrying it with one hand and it slips out of they spike it or something like Plaxico Burress.

I see alot of errors in the game, but this little cutback is not even in the top 50.

If you want non-realistic stats....how about the DE's that are on pace for 50+ sacks? 71 sacks for 1 DE last year. Over 40 sacks against non-gutted teams. That isn't realism when 15 to 23 sacks win the crown every year.



No, Leon Lett's crackheaded ass was returning a fumble for a TD and Beebe caught his showboating ass from behind and knocked it out. He also tried to jump on a blocked FG against Miami on Thanksgiving and Miami recovered, kicked the FG, and won.
 
Grim Truth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
He just failed a vision check. Happens.


Are you kidding me? It shouldn't and you know it. How can a failed vision check result in a HB turning away from the endzone and running into defenders. A failed Vision check should result in not seeing a defender, NOT in not seeing THE ENDZONE and turning into people.

That's a bug or at the very least a fault in the sim.

Fix. The. Sim.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Grim Truth
Originally posted by Bort

He just failed a vision check. Happens.


Are you kidding me? It shouldn't and you know it. How can a failed vision check result in a HB turning away from the endzone and running into defenders. A failed Vision check should result in not seeing a defender, NOT in not seeing THE ENDZONE and turning into people.

That's a bug or at the very least a fault in the sim.

Fix. The. Sim.


lol no shit.

That's like Ray Charles running the ball. Gimme a break. You don't need vision to see daylight you can drive a dump truck through. You just need EYES.
 
Grim Truth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider


This isn't really as bad as it appears.

Check the path of the closest CB. Not sure about his speed, but his trajectory appeared to be overrunning the play and stopping the TD. In that case, it appeared that the RB was just cutting inside that CB who overshot his target for the easy TD.


Originally posted by SteelersInsider


If you want non-realistic stats....how about the DE's that are on pace for 50+ sacks? 71 sacks for 1 DE last year. Over 40 sacks against non-gutted teams. That isn't realism when 15 to 23 sacks win the crown every year.



Let me get this straight... You are going to defend this play, which is an obvious flaw, but then whine about well built DE's beating OT's for a lot of sacks... In two consecutive posts...

So, HB's running away from the endzone and into oncoming defenders is fine... But DE's beating OT's is not..?
 
BullFrogOnNet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Grim Truth
Originally posted by SteelersInsider



This isn't really as bad as it appears.

Check the path of the closest CB. Not sure about his speed, but his trajectory appeared to be overrunning the play and stopping the TD. In that case, it appeared that the RB was just cutting inside that CB who overshot his target for the easy TD.


Originally posted by SteelersInsider



If you want non-realistic stats....how about the DE's that are on pace for 50+ sacks? 71 sacks for 1 DE last year. Over 40 sacks against non-gutted teams. That isn't realism when 15 to 23 sacks win the crown every year.



Let me get this straight... You are going to defend this play, which is an obvious flaw, but then whine about well built DE's beating OT's for a lot of sacks... In two consecutive posts...

So, HB's running away from the endzone and into oncoming defenders is fine... But DE's beating OT's is not..?


SI has proven time and time to again to not have any clue of football common sense.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Grim Truth
Originally posted by Bort

He just failed a vision check. Happens.


Are you kidding me? It shouldn't and you know it. How can a failed vision check result in a HB turning away from the endzone and running into defenders. A failed Vision check should result in not seeing a defender, NOT in not seeing THE ENDZONE and turning into people.

That's a bug or at the very least a fault in the sim.

Fix. The. Sim.


+1000
 
Mofo
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=140095&pbp_id=3762305

Why run down the sideline when that pile of defenders is so close
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 15:52:47
 
hokeez
offline
Link
 
soft cap vision and combo running FTW IMO. just look at my running back
 
Indifference
offline
Link
 
...maybe a lack of confidence in this instance. Didn't have the confidence to back himself on the outside.
 
my9lives
offline
Link
 
It might not only be a vision check fail but that CB was fatser than that Back and the HB was trying to cut to the shortest route to the endzone which was straight ahead.
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
He just failed a vision check. Happens.


well if a vision check cant be passed 100% from 7 yards away from goalline then theres a problem. did he forget to wear his contacts?
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 


I asked my 9 year old son who has no clue how to play football and asked him what he thought of that play. He said that the player was stupid to run into a bunch of other players when he could of walked into the endzone the other way.

This is the stuff that needs to be fixed before anymore eye candy or fancy equipment stuff come out. With a broken sim or broken plays the game is doig nothing but hurting itself in the long run. That's if it has a proper "vision check".
Last edited Oct 5, 2008 20:09:26
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.