Whats the over for this thread?
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
oldskool
offline
offline
Originally posted by jdbolick
18 times is not insignificant, but I'm not talking about expecting them to have equal numbers of pancakes. Miami having the edge is reasonable. 23-0 is not reasonable at all. If those types of outcomes are common in GLB, then GLB is guilty of being an inaccurate simulation and not representative of high level organized football.
25/100 is not high level, especially when the build's so bad it's more like 16/100.
18 times is not insignificant, but I'm not talking about expecting them to have equal numbers of pancakes. Miami having the edge is reasonable. 23-0 is not reasonable at all. If those types of outcomes are common in GLB, then GLB is guilty of being an inaccurate simulation and not representative of high level organized football.
25/100 is not high level, especially when the build's so bad it's more like 16/100.
wombat killer
offline
offline
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by jdbolick
18 times is not insignificant, but I'm not talking about expecting them to have equal numbers of pancakes. Miami having the edge is reasonable. 23-0 is not reasonable at all. If those types of outcomes are common in GLB, then GLB is guilty of being an inaccurate simulation and not representative of high level organized football.
25/100 is not high level, especially when the build's so bad it's more like 16/100.
Are you suggesting players are going to get to level 100?
Originally posted by jdbolick
18 times is not insignificant, but I'm not talking about expecting them to have equal numbers of pancakes. Miami having the edge is reasonable. 23-0 is not reasonable at all. If those types of outcomes are common in GLB, then GLB is guilty of being an inaccurate simulation and not representative of high level organized football.
25/100 is not high level, especially when the build's so bad it's more like 16/100.
Are you suggesting players are going to get to level 100?
oldskool
offline
offline
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by jdbolick
18 times is not insignificant, but I'm not talking about expecting them to have equal numbers of pancakes. Miami having the edge is reasonable. 23-0 is not reasonable at all. If those types of outcomes are common in GLB, then GLB is guilty of being an inaccurate simulation and not representative of high level organized football.
25/100 is not high level, especially when the build's so bad it's more like 16/100.
Are you suggesting players are going to get to level 100?
I'm saying if you assume that 100 is the level cap, you have to assume that the best of the best players in the best of the best "high level organized football" leagues (read: the NFL) are going to be at level 100.
If a "level 100" Manning can throw 6 INTs in a competitive matchup, how can you say it's not feasible for a "level 25" to throw 10, especially when it's such a horrible level 25?
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by jdbolick
18 times is not insignificant, but I'm not talking about expecting them to have equal numbers of pancakes. Miami having the edge is reasonable. 23-0 is not reasonable at all. If those types of outcomes are common in GLB, then GLB is guilty of being an inaccurate simulation and not representative of high level organized football.
25/100 is not high level, especially when the build's so bad it's more like 16/100.
Are you suggesting players are going to get to level 100?
I'm saying if you assume that 100 is the level cap, you have to assume that the best of the best players in the best of the best "high level organized football" leagues (read: the NFL) are going to be at level 100.
If a "level 100" Manning can throw 6 INTs in a competitive matchup, how can you say it's not feasible for a "level 25" to throw 10, especially when it's such a horrible level 25?
jdbolick
offline
offline
Originally posted by sjmay
Are you that braindead that you do not realize that there is no way to PULL PLAYERS FOR BAD PERFORMANCE IN GLB, unlike "real life" where those players got pulled, you don't have that luxury in GLB, so 10 picks in GLB is VERY VERY VERY equivalent to 5-6 picks in "real life" but I don't expect you to acknowledge or understand this easy point.
I acknowledge that you made a transparent, pathetic, and irrational attempt at an excuse. To have 5 or 6 interceptions be roughly equivalent to this 10, you'd need 200 to 167% of the total pass attempts. The problem for you is that you don't find anyone who has thrown 5 or 6 interceptions on just 20-25 passing attempts. Jay Slim threw a pick one out of every 5 throws. That is absurd.
Peyton Manning's 6 interception game came with 54 attempts. Culpepper's 5 interception game came on 37 attempts. He would have needed 4 more picks in his next 8 passes to equal Jay Slim. Brett Favre's five interception game against Cincinnati came on 39 attempts. Rich Gannon's five interceptions in the Super Bowl against Tampa Bay came on 44 attempts. The math is not in your favor.
Are you that braindead that you do not realize that there is no way to PULL PLAYERS FOR BAD PERFORMANCE IN GLB, unlike "real life" where those players got pulled, you don't have that luxury in GLB, so 10 picks in GLB is VERY VERY VERY equivalent to 5-6 picks in "real life" but I don't expect you to acknowledge or understand this easy point.
I acknowledge that you made a transparent, pathetic, and irrational attempt at an excuse. To have 5 or 6 interceptions be roughly equivalent to this 10, you'd need 200 to 167% of the total pass attempts. The problem for you is that you don't find anyone who has thrown 5 or 6 interceptions on just 20-25 passing attempts. Jay Slim threw a pick one out of every 5 throws. That is absurd.
Peyton Manning's 6 interception game came with 54 attempts. Culpepper's 5 interception game came on 37 attempts. He would have needed 4 more picks in his next 8 passes to equal Jay Slim. Brett Favre's five interception game against Cincinnati came on 39 attempts. Rich Gannon's five interceptions in the Super Bowl against Tampa Bay came on 44 attempts. The math is not in your favor.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 23:58:10
SCACE
offline
offline
Game 1
Nashville - 37 rushes, 2 pancakes
Miami - 30 rushes, 14 pancakes
Game 2
Nashville - 18 rushes, 0 panackes (you're right, they should have had 1 pancake, lol)
Rush Average by quarter...1st 0.33, 2nd 0.67, 3rd 1.33, 4th - no rushes (as you mentioned, the rushing average went up as the defense started to expect pass - the team just COULDN'T rush on this defense -- more of a problem with the offense vs. defense strength, which is being tweaked for season 4)
Miami - 42 rushes, 23 pancakes (If the teams were exactly the same and each game was exactly the same, sure, you could say that they should have had between 19-20 pancakes, or something around that. Either way, pancakes were not an oddity, sorry to say)
Edit: Once you factor in the difference in morale when comparing players in a tight game vs. players in a blowout, the slight differences are even less odd.
Nashville - 37 rushes, 2 pancakes
Miami - 30 rushes, 14 pancakes
Game 2
Nashville - 18 rushes, 0 panackes (you're right, they should have had 1 pancake, lol)
Rush Average by quarter...1st 0.33, 2nd 0.67, 3rd 1.33, 4th - no rushes (as you mentioned, the rushing average went up as the defense started to expect pass - the team just COULDN'T rush on this defense -- more of a problem with the offense vs. defense strength, which is being tweaked for season 4)
Miami - 42 rushes, 23 pancakes (If the teams were exactly the same and each game was exactly the same, sure, you could say that they should have had between 19-20 pancakes, or something around that. Either way, pancakes were not an oddity, sorry to say)
Edit: Once you factor in the difference in morale when comparing players in a tight game vs. players in a blowout, the slight differences are even less odd.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 23:59:49
Yukon Don
offline
offline
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by jdbolick
18 times is not insignificant, but I'm not talking about expecting them to have equal numbers of pancakes. Miami having the edge is reasonable. 23-0 is not reasonable at all. If those types of outcomes are common in GLB, then GLB is guilty of being an inaccurate simulation and not representative of high level organized football.
25/100 is not high level, especially when the build's so bad it's more like 16/100.
Are you suggesting players are going to get to level 100?
I'm saying if you assume that 100 is the level cap, you have to assume that the best of the best players in the best of the best "high level organized football" leagues (read: the NFL) are going to be at level 100.
If a "level 100" Manning can throw 6 INTs in a competitive matchup, how can you say it's not feasible for a "level 25" to throw 10, especially when it's such a horrible level 25?
No one will ever make lv100. By level 35-40 it'll take an entire season to level up naturally, 1-2 levels + boosting will be it. Schedule (w/ boosting will look something like this...
Season 1 Levels 1-10 (boost 3 to 13)
Season 2 Levels 13-19 (boost 3 to 22)
Season 3 Levels 22-26 (boost 3 to 29)
Season 4 Levels 29-33 (boost 3 to 36)
Season 4 Levels 36-38 (boost 3 to 41)
Season 5 Level 41-43 (boost 3 to 46)
Season 6 Level 46-48 (boost 3 to 51)
Season 8 Level 51-52 (boost 3 to 55)
Season 9 Level 55-56 (boost 3 to 59)
Season 10 (Plauteau)
Season 11 begin decline
Although i agree completely with the principle that a lv25 is not anywhere close to an NFL player. I'd argue NFL levels are around 38-40 and higher.
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by jdbolick
18 times is not insignificant, but I'm not talking about expecting them to have equal numbers of pancakes. Miami having the edge is reasonable. 23-0 is not reasonable at all. If those types of outcomes are common in GLB, then GLB is guilty of being an inaccurate simulation and not representative of high level organized football.
25/100 is not high level, especially when the build's so bad it's more like 16/100.
Are you suggesting players are going to get to level 100?
I'm saying if you assume that 100 is the level cap, you have to assume that the best of the best players in the best of the best "high level organized football" leagues (read: the NFL) are going to be at level 100.
If a "level 100" Manning can throw 6 INTs in a competitive matchup, how can you say it's not feasible for a "level 25" to throw 10, especially when it's such a horrible level 25?
No one will ever make lv100. By level 35-40 it'll take an entire season to level up naturally, 1-2 levels + boosting will be it. Schedule (w/ boosting will look something like this...
Season 1 Levels 1-10 (boost 3 to 13)
Season 2 Levels 13-19 (boost 3 to 22)
Season 3 Levels 22-26 (boost 3 to 29)
Season 4 Levels 29-33 (boost 3 to 36)
Season 4 Levels 36-38 (boost 3 to 41)
Season 5 Level 41-43 (boost 3 to 46)
Season 6 Level 46-48 (boost 3 to 51)
Season 8 Level 51-52 (boost 3 to 55)
Season 9 Level 55-56 (boost 3 to 59)
Season 10 (Plauteau)
Season 11 begin decline
Although i agree completely with the principle that a lv25 is not anywhere close to an NFL player. I'd argue NFL levels are around 38-40 and higher.
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 00:03:29
wombat killer
offline
offline
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by jdbolick
18 times is not insignificant, but I'm not talking about expecting them to have equal numbers of pancakes. Miami having the edge is reasonable. 23-0 is not reasonable at all. If those types of outcomes are common in GLB, then GLB is guilty of being an inaccurate simulation and not representative of high level organized football.
25/100 is not high level, especially when the build's so bad it's more like 16/100.
Are you suggesting players are going to get to level 100?
I'm saying if you assume that 100 is the level cap, you have to assume that the best of the best players in the best of the best "high level organized football" leagues (read: the NFL) are going to be at level 100.
If a "level 100" Manning can throw 6 INTs in a competitive matchup, how can you say it's not feasible for a "level 25" to throw 10, especially when it's such a horrible level 25?
I never said it wasn't feasible. I was just trying to understand what you were saying.
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by jdbolick
18 times is not insignificant, but I'm not talking about expecting them to have equal numbers of pancakes. Miami having the edge is reasonable. 23-0 is not reasonable at all. If those types of outcomes are common in GLB, then GLB is guilty of being an inaccurate simulation and not representative of high level organized football.
25/100 is not high level, especially when the build's so bad it's more like 16/100.
Are you suggesting players are going to get to level 100?
I'm saying if you assume that 100 is the level cap, you have to assume that the best of the best players in the best of the best "high level organized football" leagues (read: the NFL) are going to be at level 100.
If a "level 100" Manning can throw 6 INTs in a competitive matchup, how can you say it's not feasible for a "level 25" to throw 10, especially when it's such a horrible level 25?
I never said it wasn't feasible. I was just trying to understand what you were saying.
SCACE
offline
offline
Nowhere did I ever say that 9 INT's by a QB in one game wasn't odd. But a lot of it has to do with a crappy QB build running into a confidence/morale spiral, which is there so that agents don't neglect confidence -- those that do and also have crappy builds are in trouble.
Once again, the fix is two-fold...
1. Players need to put points into confidence to avoid this
2. Bort should put in a "pull" setting so that an owner can pull a player when their morale hits a certain %, to avoid this spiral and these odd results.
In my humble opinion, it is less to do with a "broken" sim and a lot to do with a need for more advanced tactics / options (another couple - throwing the ball away or eating a sack) and players actually not neglecting key attributes on their builds.
Right now, a QB throwing is FORCED to throw at a receiver - that is the inherent issue, more than anything else, esp. when you are in a spiral.
Once again, the fix is two-fold...
1. Players need to put points into confidence to avoid this
2. Bort should put in a "pull" setting so that an owner can pull a player when their morale hits a certain %, to avoid this spiral and these odd results.
In my humble opinion, it is less to do with a "broken" sim and a lot to do with a need for more advanced tactics / options (another couple - throwing the ball away or eating a sack) and players actually not neglecting key attributes on their builds.
Right now, a QB throwing is FORCED to throw at a receiver - that is the inherent issue, more than anything else, esp. when you are in a spiral.
trauty
offline
offline
The 1994 San Francisco 49ers, who wound up winning the Super Bowl that season, lost to the Philadelphia Eagles 40-8. The Eagles finished the season 7-9 and didn't even make the playoffs. Even in the NFL weird results happen.
SCACE
offline
offline
the max for an attribute is 100, I think -- not sure if you can go over that with equipment...the odds of a player reaching lvl 100 is slim to none. I do however think that lvl 10 is just the start of the plateau, and we could see a few seasons of plateau, with no training or game XP, but still boosting levels. Then a decline at some point after that which could be slowed by boosting.
Yukon Don
offline
offline
Originally posted by trauty
The 1994 San Francisco 49ers, who wound up winning the Super Bowl that season, lost to the Philadelphia Eagles 40-8. The Eagles finished the season 7-9 and didn't even make the playoffs. Even in the NFL weird results happen.
I'd almost suppressed that memory...thanks for nothing jerk.
The 1994 San Francisco 49ers, who wound up winning the Super Bowl that season, lost to the Philadelphia Eagles 40-8. The Eagles finished the season 7-9 and didn't even make the playoffs. Even in the NFL weird results happen.
I'd almost suppressed that memory...thanks for nothing jerk.
oldskool
offline
offline
Originally posted by rbedgood
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by jdbolick
18 times is not insignificant, but I'm not talking about expecting them to have equal numbers of pancakes. Miami having the edge is reasonable. 23-0 is not reasonable at all. If those types of outcomes are common in GLB, then GLB is guilty of being an inaccurate simulation and not representative of high level organized football.
25/100 is not high level, especially when the build's so bad it's more like 16/100.
Are you suggesting players are going to get to level 100?
I'm saying if you assume that 100 is the level cap, you have to assume that the best of the best players in the best of the best "high level organized football" leagues (read: the NFL) are going to be at level 100.
If a "level 100" Manning can throw 6 INTs in a competitive matchup, how can you say it's not feasible for a "level 25" to throw 10, especially when it's such a horrible level 25?
No one will ever make lv100. By level 35-40 it'll take an entire season to level up naturally, 1-2 levels + boosting will be it. Schedule (w/ boosting will look something like this...
Season 1 Levels 1-10 (boost 3 to 13)
Season 2 Levels 13-19 (boost 3 to 22)
Season 3 Levels 22-26 (boost 3 to 29)
Season 4 Levels 29-33 (boost 3 to 36)
Season 4 Levels 36-38 (boost 3 to 41)
Season 5 Level 41-43 (boost 3 to 46)
Season 6 Level 46-48 (boost 3 to 51)
Season 8 Level 51-52 (boost 3 to 55)
Season 9 Level 55-56 (boost 3 to 59)
Season 10 (Plauteau)
Season 11 begin decline
Although i agree completely with the principle that a lv25 is not anywhere close to an NFL player. I'd argue NFL levels are around 38-40 and higher.
Assume level 40, this means their QB is numerical-level-wise about five-eighths as good as a top-caliber NFL quarterback, and his build makes him significantly worse than that.
My argument stands
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by jdbolick
18 times is not insignificant, but I'm not talking about expecting them to have equal numbers of pancakes. Miami having the edge is reasonable. 23-0 is not reasonable at all. If those types of outcomes are common in GLB, then GLB is guilty of being an inaccurate simulation and not representative of high level organized football.
25/100 is not high level, especially when the build's so bad it's more like 16/100.
Are you suggesting players are going to get to level 100?
I'm saying if you assume that 100 is the level cap, you have to assume that the best of the best players in the best of the best "high level organized football" leagues (read: the NFL) are going to be at level 100.
If a "level 100" Manning can throw 6 INTs in a competitive matchup, how can you say it's not feasible for a "level 25" to throw 10, especially when it's such a horrible level 25?
No one will ever make lv100. By level 35-40 it'll take an entire season to level up naturally, 1-2 levels + boosting will be it. Schedule (w/ boosting will look something like this...
Season 1 Levels 1-10 (boost 3 to 13)
Season 2 Levels 13-19 (boost 3 to 22)
Season 3 Levels 22-26 (boost 3 to 29)
Season 4 Levels 29-33 (boost 3 to 36)
Season 4 Levels 36-38 (boost 3 to 41)
Season 5 Level 41-43 (boost 3 to 46)
Season 6 Level 46-48 (boost 3 to 51)
Season 8 Level 51-52 (boost 3 to 55)
Season 9 Level 55-56 (boost 3 to 59)
Season 10 (Plauteau)
Season 11 begin decline
Although i agree completely with the principle that a lv25 is not anywhere close to an NFL player. I'd argue NFL levels are around 38-40 and higher.
Assume level 40, this means their QB is numerical-level-wise about five-eighths as good as a top-caliber NFL quarterback, and his build makes him significantly worse than that.
My argument stands

jdbolick
offline
offline
Originally posted by SCACE
jdbolick - you're irritating basically everyone else on this thread with your nonsense.
Very compelling argument there. I suppose it's understandable that you'd respond this way once you realize that you were hopelessly outclassed in terms of knowledge, not only about football but programming as well.
Originally posted by
I've explained what happened, why it happened, and what the fix is from both the player's side and the SIM's side. You're just here being a dick that couldn't tell a pussy from an asshole. Honestly, get a clue.
No, you've given excuses, not explanations. You've tried to paint this absurd result as something reasonable when it's anything but. Statistics like this simply do not occur in actual football. Once in college football history a QB threw for 9 interceptions in a game, but on significantly more attempts than Jay Slim's 45 (John Reaves had 46% more attempts). As far as I know, no one in college football history or pro football history has ever come close to Slim's 1 interception every 5 passes for anyone with more than fifteen attempts.
Originally posted by
And your nonsense about pancakes and rushing yards show you have no clue what you are talking about. That just makes it even worse. You at least have a case with the INT's.
I freely admit that I am not an expert on Goal Line Blitz, as I'm fairly new to the game. I am an undisputed expert on football, however, and if GLB is intended to be a realistic simulation of actual football (whether college or professional or whatever), then the pancakes discrepancy and the rushing yardage were both extremely unlikely events. Taken together, those three things happening in one game is preposterously unrealistic. It is clear-cut, undeniable evidence of a flaw in the simulation programming.
Originally posted by oldskool
Peyton Manning would equate to a level 100 quarterback. Why is it not feasible that a quarterback at 25% his level and probably 10% his actual ability, at his very worst, would have 166% as many interceptions as Peyton did at his worst? If anything he should be thanking Bort because he didn't throw 24 INTs, as at least that would match up mathematically.
Wow. You, sir, are a mental giant.
trauty:
The score doesn't overly concern me. It's how that score was achieved that shows faulty simulation programming. In fact, with results that absurd I'm surprised that the score wasn't 80-0.
jdbolick - you're irritating basically everyone else on this thread with your nonsense.
Very compelling argument there. I suppose it's understandable that you'd respond this way once you realize that you were hopelessly outclassed in terms of knowledge, not only about football but programming as well.
Originally posted by
I've explained what happened, why it happened, and what the fix is from both the player's side and the SIM's side. You're just here being a dick that couldn't tell a pussy from an asshole. Honestly, get a clue.
No, you've given excuses, not explanations. You've tried to paint this absurd result as something reasonable when it's anything but. Statistics like this simply do not occur in actual football. Once in college football history a QB threw for 9 interceptions in a game, but on significantly more attempts than Jay Slim's 45 (John Reaves had 46% more attempts). As far as I know, no one in college football history or pro football history has ever come close to Slim's 1 interception every 5 passes for anyone with more than fifteen attempts.
Originally posted by
And your nonsense about pancakes and rushing yards show you have no clue what you are talking about. That just makes it even worse. You at least have a case with the INT's.
I freely admit that I am not an expert on Goal Line Blitz, as I'm fairly new to the game. I am an undisputed expert on football, however, and if GLB is intended to be a realistic simulation of actual football (whether college or professional or whatever), then the pancakes discrepancy and the rushing yardage were both extremely unlikely events. Taken together, those three things happening in one game is preposterously unrealistic. It is clear-cut, undeniable evidence of a flaw in the simulation programming.
Originally posted by oldskool
Peyton Manning would equate to a level 100 quarterback. Why is it not feasible that a quarterback at 25% his level and probably 10% his actual ability, at his very worst, would have 166% as many interceptions as Peyton did at his worst? If anything he should be thanking Bort because he didn't throw 24 INTs, as at least that would match up mathematically.
Wow. You, sir, are a mental giant.
trauty:
The score doesn't overly concern me. It's how that score was achieved that shows faulty simulation programming. In fact, with results that absurd I'm surprised that the score wasn't 80-0.
Last edited Jul 15, 2008 00:15:42
SCACE
offline
offline
lol - you call me irritating and I say that you are irritating the rest of us, but when I say it, it isn't a compelling argument.
Sorry, I may be a lot of things, but outclassed by a douchebag like you...not on the list.
That's enough of this for tonight, you are a broken record sir, and your incessant blabbering has made me tired.
Sorry, I may be a lot of things, but outclassed by a douchebag like you...not on the list.
That's enough of this for tonight, you are a broken record sir, and your incessant blabbering has made me tired.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























