User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
king_katool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chappy2235
Timeline makes sense. She goes missing and gets bit by walker while walkers are chasing them. Otis finds and wrangles her in the early morning while hunting and then doesn't tell anybody cause he just shot a kid so it doesn't come up.

They developed the scared suicidal chick into the eventual sniper that she is in the graphic novels. Shane is a wild card cause Carl killed him a long time ago in the novels.


fuuuuuuccccckkkkkkk yoooooouuuuuuuu
 
TruBucfan22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Staxic
I agreed with the old farm owner / vet. Why don't they just go find their own farm and get off that poor dude's front lawn? Clean out a couple walkers, burn 'em in the backyard, and move into their own house. Then they can be neighbors instead of camping out in his yard.


+1
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by revolution17
.i've resisted reading the comics because i've loved my ignorance of the story


This mentality makes no sense to me. You are better off not having the show spoil the graphic novels for you because the graphic novels are 10X better than the show is.
 
revolution17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by X
This mentality makes no sense to me. You are better off not having the show spoil the graphic novels for you because the graphic novels are 10X better than the show is.


i'm sure the books are much better than the TV show. it's quite typical really. i just really enjoy the TV show right now since there isn't anything else i enjoy watching save for reruns of seinfeld or curb your enthusiasm

i really do enjoy a bit of ignorance on sunday evenings.

seeing as they have so many breaks with the TV series i'll likely lose patience and read my compendium of comics soon, but i've been resisting as much as possible. my friend read my compendium and is watching the show but not real impressed...i don't want that.
 
lVlellovv
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by X
This mentality makes no sense to me. You are better off not having the show spoil the graphic novels for you because the graphic novels are 10X better than the show is.


umm....it's way cooler to have a visual and not have to read. so, even if the comic is better written....spoiling the T.V would ruin it...and i'm sure going back over the comic after watching the show will be better than watching the comic and going over the T.V show.


it's like harry potter, if you read the books before the movie the movies weren't as good, but if you watched the movies and then read the books, they were both excellent.
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by revolution17
Originally posted by X

This mentality makes no sense to me. You are better off not having the show spoil the graphic novels for you because the graphic novels are 10X better than the show is.


i'm sure the books are much better than the TV show. it's quite typical really. i just really enjoy the TV show right now since there isn't anything else i enjoy watching save for reruns of seinfeld or curb your enthusiasm

i really do enjoy a bit of ignorance on sunday evenings.

seeing as they have so many breaks with the TV series i'll likely lose patience and read my compendium of comics soon, but i've been resisting as much as possible. my friend read my compendium and is watching the show but not real impressed...i don't want that.


Well, for the most part I think you are safe anyway. Pretty much every major moment that has happened in the comic isn't in the show and vice versa. I think the writers of the show are intentionally differentiating the two in that regards so that the big moments in one aren't spoiled by the other.

I'll still contend that anybody who forgoes the comic to keep from spoiling the show is making a mistake. Take the killing of Sophia in the show for example. In the comic those moments have such a gravity and are handled with such a cold efficiency and brutality from a writing standpoint that having known them beforehand would have severely lessened the impact. In the show, the lead-ins to these moments are often so drawn out that by the time they happen, unless you are a hopeless optimist, you've already come to terms with what has happened and knowing the outcome is irrelevant. That's a major weakness of the writing of the show, in my opinion.
Edited by X on Nov 30, 2011 14:17:13
 
Link
 
Originally posted by X


I'll still contend that anybody who forgoes the comic to keep from spoiling the show is making a mistake.


I second that.

 
revolution17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by X
I'll still contend that anybody who forgoes the comic to keep from spoiling the show is making a mistake.


Originally posted by Drake Slaughter
I second that


damn you both...don't start bringing intelligence and common sense into the discussion
 
Link
 
They are unique enough to enjoy both at the same time.
 
decribb83
offline
Link
 
I read the comics first but still enjoy the show very much. As others have said there is enough difference between the two in their major events that it's not that huge of a deal to have read the comics first. I actually like the fact that they have switched some of the stuff up from the comic and are taking the show in it's own direction.
 
Osmlol
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by X


I'll still contend that anybody who forgoes the comic to keep from spoiling the show is making a mistake.



Did you ever stop to think that your SPOILING THE COMIC FOR US TOO. I want to read the series after this season, no one is forgoing the comic for the tv show. We are just deep into the show before we knew of the comic and are putting the comic on the back burner till the show is done or is on a long break.

Ofcourse some may just not like comics and have no interest.


So please, everyone stop with your comic book spoilers and tv spoilers. Atleast make a big note at the top of the post that says


***********SPOILER**************
Edited by Osmlol on Nov 30, 2011 17:01:37
 
Dunadain
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lVlellovv
umm....it's way cooler to have a visual and not have to read. so, even if the comic is better written....spoiling the T.V would ruin it...and i'm sure going back over the comic after watching the show will be better than watching the comic and going over the T.V show.


it's like harry potter, if you read the books before the movie the movies weren't as good, but if you watched the movies and then read the books, they were both excellent.



Not quite the same since it comes from a graphic novel ( not a comic damnit!! lol joking) but there is visuals.. It is not like reading line after line of text.

I dig the shit out of the tv show, but the "comic" gets a tiny bit more approval
 
chappy2235
offline
Link
 
Wasn't really any spoilers except that Carl kills Shane in the graphic novels. I haven't actually read the novels but someone told me that.
 
trentw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chappy2235
Wasn't really any spoilers except that Carl kills Shane in the graphic novels. I haven't actually read the novels but someone told me that.



 
CharlieDay
offline
Link
 
FUCK YOU MAN, what the fuck is wrong with some people.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.