User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > Extended Plateau Discussion
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13
and shortens the 3 season plateau to a 2 season plateau.....and all I've been reading for a long time is how extending the plateau will make everything in GLB better, so why not go for the longer plateau?

Oh, that's right, because the teams with all S5 dots want one more season of glory, not more competition, that's why.


I want to play with my S5 dots for more than 1 season in the WL .... who wouldn't. Competition will even itself out because season 6 dots will hit lvl 72. Lets not act naive about this thing.
 
refguru
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ubasstards
Option 2 is the obvious choice, especially after teams made a ton of decisions today after the announcement. Option 2 hurts nobody and evens the playing field for season 6 dots.

EASY BUTTON


I've learned not to make decisions too quickly after announcements because they always seem to change many times before they are imped.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Snickerling
#2 would get my vote.... it's the least painless.


 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ubasstards
jdros, yours is the worst of all. If you extend to day 480 NO advantage exists. No good reason to go with yours and leave my dots with an advantage (training and BT) over everyone else


wtf are you talking about. If you roll it back, by the time the playoffs roll around next season the dots that start S17 at day 400 will be almost on an even playing field from a VA standpoint with the dots that start at 480 next season (they would be one VA point behind). So you would have a competitive base that spans about 80 days. The following season it would be extended to 120 days and it would stay there going forward.

Your plan gives S5 dots one more season with a leg up on everyone to start, then when the playoffs start the dots that begin next season at day 440 will be almost caught up to the 480's (40 day spread) and the following season it would extend to 80 days and stay there.

If you want a bigger competitive base, you need a bigger pool of competitive dots. Or we could just do this half-assed I guess.
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
well here's a huge argument in favor of option #1


Translation - We are WL'ers and our current dots rule, finally, after 2 years. If you take them away I quit.

 
Snickerling
offline
Link
 
I don't see how #1 helps with the lack of players at higher levels tho... but then maybe that's because I'm dense.
Wouldn't option #1 deplete the pool of higher leveled players and we're all back to complaining how AA and AAA are full of CPU teams because Pro and WL have all the dots that belong 2 tiers lower?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by refguru
I've learned not to make decisions too quickly after announcements because they always seem to change many times before they are imped.


Thats bullshit as far as Im concerned.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
I want to play with my S5 dots for more than 1 season in the WL .... who wouldn't. Competition will even itself out because season 6 dots will hit lvl 72. Lets not act naive about this thing.


I have no issue with that at all, but if the goal is to make the competitive pool bigger by extending the plateau, then extend the plateau so you can have 3-4 seasons worth of dots competing on a level playing field, not 2.
 
BP
offline
Link
 
should make a poll about this...right now this thread is ruled by World League guys who very much want their current team to be able to stay together for a long time. Not sure if that is in the best interest of the site D, find out what everybody wants...not just the 10-15 world league guys in here lobbying for more time with their dots who are currently at the top of the heap.
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snickerling
I don't see how #1 helps with the lack of players at higher levels tho... but then maybe that's because I'm dense.
Wouldn't option #1 deplete the pool of higher leveled players and we're all back to complaining how AA and AAA are full of CPU teams because Pro and WL have all the dots that belong 2 tiers lower?


They are still changing league structure for some reason.
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
Long term the game is better off with no training/VA's past day440 (3 seasons of equal plateau) While 1 batch of players may benefit from rollover, it is not a game-breaking benefit, and those players will be retired and gone after 2 seasons. It is not as if players (who know whats what) are still building AE in their decline season and as such needed BTs for that. If you push training stop back 40 days, it just puts L64/69 players at a greater unnecessary disadvantage.

Omg they got 40 more trainings and 8 more VPs. C'mon...


I disagree...it is a huge advantage especially for teams loaded with the right age dots this season. ~8 VAs...possibly 120 BTs...40+ more trainings. Maybe for one player it is not a big deal...but when you have 50 players on a roster like that it is 400 VA points...5500 BTs!...~10 points in team sp value. That is a big edge period...
 
DigitalDaggers
Admin
offline
Link
 
We are leaning towards option #1, tbh.
 
wdb
offline
Link
 
I think the change is good. It would have been better if you had figured out a way to work it in for everybody. My 531 day old FB is still playing and is working his way through decline. Now he will have to compete for a spot against players younger than him that have their decline postponed. Why can't the plateau be applied now and then his decline picked back up after that? Note, I'm not asking for skills to be returned (though they really should during the plateau), only that the decline stop for a while.. Heck, the more I think about it the more I think his skills should be returned to pre-decline levels for the plateau. Why the heck should he lose out compared to younger players? Or the question another way: Why are you screwing agents who have been playing longer and sunk just as much money into the game as anybody else? My boosts weren't cheaper than somebody else's who created a player a couple of seasons later.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
Translation - We are WL'ers and our current dots rule, finally, after 2 years. If you take them away I quit.



I was testing Hali.....I knew he would respond.......Translation for Gart..... I want #1 because I can't beat the Kai. Thats the TRUTH to all his whining. Wouldn't you cry if you lost by 50 points. That whole league is pathetic as far as Im concerned. Nothing but a bunch of GLB oldschoolers who group together. Notice how little is said in there anymore?
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snickerling
I don't see how #1 helps with the lack of players at higher levels tho... but then maybe that's because I'm dense.
Wouldn't option #1 deplete the pool of higher leveled players and we're all back to complaining how AA and AAA are full of CPU teams because Pro and WL have all the dots that belong 2 tiers lower?


All option 1 would do is clear out some of the current talent in the World League to allow some up and coming teams to move up in the new system. Otherwise those WL teams now, who are on top....will remain there. Option 2 guarantees no changes at the top for 3 seasons, option 1 speaks to more competitive WL situaiton...something that current WL teams don't want, hence the complaining in the thread.
Edited by BP on Jun 24, 2010 15:43:07
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.