Has it been stated whether the bonus SA will be any SA not already in the trees, or will there be some other limit?
Maddoc
offline
offline
You hadn't noticed that they "D&D'd" football the second you joined?
Because there have always been numerical attributes, equipment that gives unnaturally significant(one might even say magical) boosts to natural capabilities, different positions(or classes) that get access to different special abilities who are naturally predisposed toward certain attributes, and actions during games decided by a random number generator and modified by your attributes and circumstances.
Because there have always been numerical attributes, equipment that gives unnaturally significant(one might even say magical) boosts to natural capabilities, different positions(or classes) that get access to different special abilities who are naturally predisposed toward certain attributes, and actions during games decided by a random number generator and modified by your attributes and circumstances.
Hagalaz
offline
offline
Originally posted by Book
Late to the party, but it seems to me that they've just D&D'd football. I hate D&D. And they are making me hate football.
NEWSFLASH: GLB has been d&d football since 2008. We're in 2010.
Late to the party, but it seems to me that they've just D&D'd football. I hate D&D. And they are making me hate football.
NEWSFLASH: GLB has been d&d football since 2008. We're in 2010.
The thread What the Archetypes Should Have Been has been merged into this thread
jdbolick
offline
offline
The biggest problem with the archetypes as proposed is the hang-up on having the same number of majors for each option at a particular position. That has forced the choices into certain boxes where it's clear that some options are clearly superior over others, to the point that you'd have to be ignorant or crazy to select some. If you get over that desire to have equal majors, then it becomes much easier to create balance between different types.
Here is what those archetypes might have looked like if they were created by people chosen for their familiarity with and knowledge of builds rather than their proximity to Seattle:
Quarterbacks
QB Pocket Passer
6'0" - 6'6", 200-260 Lbs
Major Confidence Throwing Vision (+.67)
Minor Agility Stamina Strength (+.33)
Bonus SA's - Tight Spiral, Field General
Penalty SA's - Dump Pass, On The Run
(Changes: Field General would improve the PP archetype and put it more on par with the Deep Passer. Also considered adding carrying as a minor, but you don't want strength to fall off too much. This way, QB owners will have to decide whether or not they really care about decreasing fumbles.)
QB Deep Passer
6'0" - 6'6", 200-260 Lbs
Major Strength Throwing Vision (+.67)
Minor Agility Confidence Stamina (+.33)
Bonus SA's - Tight Spiral, Turn The Shoulder
Penalty SA's - Dump Pass, On The Run
(Changes: None.)
QB Scrambler
5'11" - 6'3", 190-230 Lbs
Major Speed Carrying Throwing Vision (+.5)
Minor Agility Stamina Strength (+.33)
Bonus SA's - On The Run, Dump Pass
Penalty SA's - Pump Fake, Tight Spiral
(Changes: Added a fourth major, both because having the Scrambler get the same bonus to thr/vis as the other two seems silly, and because the whole archetype is pointless without high speed. Also substituted stamina for confidence since it needed to be in there somewhere.)
Halfbacks
HB Power
5'11" - 6'4", 210-260 Lbs
Major Agility Carrying Confidence Strength (+.5)
Minor Jumping Speed Stamina Vision (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Lower Shoulder, Power Thru
Penalty SA's - First Step, Spin
(Changes: Replaced Catching with jumping since that supposedly helps to avoid tackles. Also, you don't want power backs being natural pass catchers.)
HB Elusive
5'6" - 6'2", 180-220 Lbs
Major Agility Carrying Speed Vision (+.5)
Minor Catching Confidence Strength Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Head Fake, Juke
Penalty SA's - Lower Shoulder, Power Thru
(Changes: Replaced jumping with strength. If power has speed as a minor, then elusive deserves to have strength as one.)
HB Scat Back
5'6" - 6'2", 180-220 Lbs
Major Agility Carrying Catching Speed (+.5)
Minor Vision Confidence Jumping Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Quick Cut, First Step
Penalty SA's - Lower Shoulder, Power Thru
(Changes: Swapped Carrying & Vision to limit knocked loose and put it more on par with the other choices.)
HB Combo
5'9" - 6'2", 200-230 Lbs
Major Strength Carrying Confidence Speed Vision (+.4)
Minor Agility Catching Stamina Strength (+.25)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
(Changes: Added strength as a fifth major because the Combo needs to be in between power & elusive. Would anyone in their right mind choose the proposed combo with Confidence as a major over elusive with Agility? No. This way the combo will be good at breaking tackles, but not as good as the power archetype. He'll also be fast, but not as fast as the elusive.)
Fullbacks
FB Running
5'10" - 6'3", 230-250 Lbs
Major Agility Carrying Confidence Strength (+.5)
Minor Vision Speed Stamina Blocking (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Power Thru, Quick Cut
Penalty SA's - Lead Block, Pancake
(Changes: Replaced catching with blocking. A fullback is a fullback is a fullback. Just because you want a guy who is faster than normal doesn't mean that they should be a HB playing FB. All fullbacks should have blocking as a major or minor, just as all quarterbacks should have throwing. Also, if other archetypes have catching then there's no point for a FB Scat Back to exist.)
FB Blocking
5'10" - 6'3", 230-270 Lbs
Major Agility Blocking Strength Vision (+.5)
Minor Carrying Confidence Speed Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Lead Block, Pancake
Penalty SA's - Power Thru, Quick Cut
(Changes: None)
FB Combo - ELIMINATED
(Reason: If this exists as proposed, then no one in their right mind would ever choose Blocking. Moreover, there's no need for four types of fullbacks.)
FB Scat Back
5'10" - 6'3", 230-250 Lbs
Major Agility Catching Speed Vision (+.5)
Minor Carrying Confidence Blocking Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Sticky Hands, Quick Cut
Penalty SA's - Lead Block, Pancake
(Changes: Replaced jumping with blocking because a fullback is a fullback is a fullback. Plus, scat backs should also be competent in blitz pick-up.)
Wide Receivers
WR Speedster
5'8" - 6'2", 175-215 Lbs
Major Confidence Agility Catching Speed Vision (+.4)
Minor Carrying Jumping Stamina (+.33)
Bonus SA's - First Step, Quick Cut
Penalty SA's - Route Run, Sticky Hands
(Changes: Bumped confidence from minor to major because otherwise no one would ever choose Possession. Speed and jumping are not equally valuable to receivers.)
WR Possession
6'0" - 6'6", 195-235 Lbs
Major Carrying Agility Catching Jumping Vision (+.4)
Minor Confidence Speed Stamina (+.33)
Bonus SA's - Route Run, Sticky Hands
Penalty SA's - First Step, Quick Cut
(Changes: Bumped carrying from minor to major to put it on equal terms with Speedster, and because it makes sense that Possession types will hang on to the ball better.)
WR Power
6'0" - 6'6", 205-235 Lbs
Major Agility Carrying Catching Strength Vision (+.4)
Minor Confidence Speed Stamina (+.33)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
(Changes: Bumped vision to balance it with the others, and because +.5 strength seems like an awful lot for a receiver.)
Tight Ends
TE Blocker
6'2" - 6'8", 250-280 Lbs
Major Agility Blocking Strength Vision (+.5)
Minor Catching Confidence Speed Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Get Low, Pancake
Penalty SA's - Route Run, Quick Cut
(Changes: None, but holy crap are blocking TEs going to be overpowered.)
TE Power
6'2" - 6'8", 250-280 Lbs
Major Agility Carrying Catching Strength (+.5)
Minor Confidence Speed Stamina Blocking(+.25)
Bonus SA's - Cover Up, Lower Shoulder
Penalty SA's - Get Low, Pancake
(Changes: Replaced vision with blocking because every TE should have it somewhere, and +.25 is suitably weak.)
TE Receiver
6'0" - 6'6", 230-260 Lbs
Major Agility Catching Speed Vision (+.5)
Minor Carrying Blocking Stamina Strength (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Route Run, Quick Cut
Penalty SA's - Get Low, Pancake
(Changes: Replaced jumping with blocking for the reason stated above.)
TE Combo
6'2" - 6'8", 250-280 Lbs
Major Agility Blocking Catching Strength Vision (+.4)
Minor Confidence Jumping Speed Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
(Changes: Added stamina as a minor since every archetype should have it somewhere. Also bumped vision up to major because the combo shouldn't be as strong as the blocker or as good at catching passes as the receiver. Right now you'd have to be insane to choose the blocker archetype over combo.)
Offensive Line
Pass Blocking
(C) 6'0" - 6'4", 230-300 Lbs
(G) 6'2" - 6'5", 290-325 Lbs
(T) 6'2" - 6'6", 280-320 Lbs
Major Agility Blocking Confidence (+.67)
Minor Vision Speed Strength (+.33)
Bonus SA's (C/G) - Pass Block, Foundation
Bonus SA's (T) - Pass Block, Protector
Penalty SA's - Get Low, Pancake
(Changes: None. I felt like stamina should be in there as a minor, but you can't without screwing up the points or taking away speed, which would really devalue the option.)
Run Blocking
(C) 6'2" - 6'6", 280-330 Lbs
(G) 6'2" - 6'7", 310-360 Lbs
(T) 6'4" - 6'9", 300-350 Lbs
Major Blocking Confidence Strength (+.67)
Minor Agility Stamina Vision (+.33)
Bonus SA's - Get Low, Pancake
Penalty SA's (C/G) - Pass Block, Foundation
Penalty SA's (T) - Pass Block, Protector
(Changes: None.)
Defensive Line
Strength DL
(DE) 6'2" - 6'8", 275-330 Lbs
(DT) 6'0" - 6'8", 300-360 Lbs
Major Agility Strength Tackling (+.67)
Minor Vision Speed Stamina (+.33)
Bonus SA's (DE) - Wall, Strong Base
Bonus SA's (DT) - Wall, Break Thru
Penalty SA's (DE) - First Step, Tunnel Vision
Penalty SA's (DT) - Shed Block, Swat Ball
(Changes: None.)
Speed DL
(DE) 5'11" - 6'4", 240-280 Lbs
(DT) 6'0" - 6'5", 250-300 Lbs
Major Agility Speed Vision (+.67)
Minor Stamina Strength Tackling (+.33)
Bonus SA's (DE) - First Step, Tunnel Vision
Bonus SA's (DT) - Shed Block, Swat Ball
Penalty SA's (DE) - Wall, Strong Base
Penalty SA's (DT) - Wall, Break Thru
(Changes: None.)
Combo DL
(DE) 6'2" - 6'6", 260-300 Lbs
(DT) 6'0" - 6'8", 280-330 Lbs
Major Speed Strength Vision (+.67)
Minor Agility Stamina Tackling (+.33)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
(Changes: None.)
Linebackers
Coverage LB
5'10" - 6'3", 220-250 Lbs
Major Agility Jumping Speed Vision (+.5)
Minor Confidence Stamina Strength Tackling (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Diving Tackle, Swat Ball
Penalty SA's - Monster Hit, Shed Block
(Changes: None.)
Blitzing LB
5'10" - 6'6", 240-270 Lbs
Major Agility Confidence Speed Strength (+.5)
Minor Jumping Stamina Tackling Vision (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Shed Block, Big Sack
Penalty SA's - Aura of Int, Diving Tackle
(Changes: Swapped confidence for jumping and strength for tackling, as those would seem to make more sense for the blitzing role. I also changed one of the Penalty SAs from Monster Hit to Diving Tackle since the blitzer should still be a hard hitter.)
Hard Hitting LB
5'10" - 6'6", 240-270 Lbs
Major Agility Strength Tackling Vision (+.5)
Minor Confidence Jumping Speed Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Snarl, Monster Hit
Penalty SA's - Swat Ball, Big Sack
(Changes: None.)
Combo LB
5'10" - 6'6", 230-260 Lbs
Major Agility Confidence Speed Tackling Vision (+.4)
Minor Jumping Stamina Strength (+.33)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
(Changes: Moved confidence up to a major because right now this archetype is too damn good. Combo archetypes should be jacks of all trades and masters of none, not guys who are just as fast and skilled as the other options.)
Secondary
Man Specialist
(CB) 5'8" - 6'3", 170-210 Lbs
(SS) 5'9" - 6'5", 195-230 Lbs
(FS) 5'8" - 6'4", 185-220 Lbs
Major Agility Jumping Speed Vision (+.5)
Minor Catching Confidence Stamina Tackling (+.25)
Bonus SA's (CB) - Shutdown Coverage
Bonus SA's (SS) - Change Direction
Bonus SA's (FS) - Shutdown Coverage
Penalty SA's (CB) - Closing Speed
Penalty SA's (SS) - Big Hit
Penalty SA's (FS) - Big Hit
(Changes: None.)
Zone Specialist
(CB) 5'8" - 6'3", 170-210 Lbs
(SS) 5'9" - 6'5", 195-230 Lbs
(FS) 5'8" - 6'4", 185-220 Lbs
Major Agility Speed Tackling Vision (+.5)
Minor Catching Confidence Jumping Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Super Vision
Penalty SA's (CB) - Shutdown Coverage
Penalty SA's (SS) - Change Direction
Penalty SA's (FS) - Shutdown Coverage
(Changes: None.)
Hard Hitter
(CB) 5'10" - 6'3", 190-210 Lbs
(SS) 5'11" - 6'5", 205-230 Lbs
(FS) 5'10" - 6'4", 195-220 Lbs
Major Speed Strength Tackling Vision (+.5)
Minor Agility Confidence Jumping Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's (CB) - Closing Speed
Bonus SA's (SS) - Big Hit
Bonus SA's (FS) - Big Hit
Penalty SA's - Change Direction
(Changes: Swapped speed for agility, since I doubt that anyone would pick a secondary archetype with that much of a speed penalty.)
Combo Secondary
(CB) 5'8" - 6'3", 170-210 Lbs
(SS) 5'9" - 6'5", 195-230 Lbs
(FS) 5'8" - 6'4", 185-220 Lbs
Major Agility Speed Strength Tackling (+.5)
Minor Confidence Jumping Stamina Vision (+.25)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
(Changes: None.)
Kickers
Boomer
5'8" - 6'5", 180-230 Lbs
Major Confidence Kicking Strength (+.67)
Minor Agility Jumping Vision (+.33)
(Changes: None.)
Finesse
5'8" - 6'5", 180-230 Lbs
Major Confidence Kicking Vision (+.67)
Minor Agility Jumping Strength (+.33)
(Changes: None.)
Punter
Boomer
5'11" - 6'5", 180-250 Lbs
Major Confidence Punting Strength (+.67)
Minor Agility Jumping Vision (+.33)
(Changes: None.)
Finesse
5'11" - 6'5", 180-250 Lbs
Major Confidence Punting Vision (+.67)
Minor Agility Jumping Strength (+.33)
(Changes: None.)
Special Teams Only Player
Major: Agility Blocking Speed Stamina Tackling (+.4)
Minor: Confidence Strength Vision (+.33)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
(Changes: Bumped stamina up to a major to keep these builds from competing with natural position archetypes, plus it makes sense that they would have better conditioning since special teams is such a drain on energy.)
Returner (only HB/WR/CB eligible)
(HB) 5'6" - 6'0", 180-220 Lbs
(WR) 5'8" - 6'2", 175-215 Lbs
(CB) 5'8" - 6'2", 170-210 Lbs
Major: Agility Carrying Speed Stamina Vision (+.4)
Minor: Confidence Jumping Strength (+.33)
Bonus SA's (HB/WR) - First Step, Quick Cut
Bonus SA's (CB) - Change Direction, Return Spec.
Penalty SA's (HB) - Stiff Arm, Power Thru
Penalty SA's (WR) - Route Run, Sticky Hands
Penalty SA's (CB) - Super Vision, Shutdown Coverage
(Changes: Bumped stamina up to a major for the same reasons as listed above.)
Here is what those archetypes might have looked like if they were created by people chosen for their familiarity with and knowledge of builds rather than their proximity to Seattle:
Quarterbacks
QB Pocket Passer
6'0" - 6'6", 200-260 Lbs
Major Confidence Throwing Vision (+.67)
Minor Agility Stamina Strength (+.33)
Bonus SA's - Tight Spiral, Field General
Penalty SA's - Dump Pass, On The Run
(Changes: Field General would improve the PP archetype and put it more on par with the Deep Passer. Also considered adding carrying as a minor, but you don't want strength to fall off too much. This way, QB owners will have to decide whether or not they really care about decreasing fumbles.)
QB Deep Passer
6'0" - 6'6", 200-260 Lbs
Major Strength Throwing Vision (+.67)
Minor Agility Confidence Stamina (+.33)
Bonus SA's - Tight Spiral, Turn The Shoulder
Penalty SA's - Dump Pass, On The Run
(Changes: None.)
QB Scrambler
5'11" - 6'3", 190-230 Lbs
Major Speed Carrying Throwing Vision (+.5)
Minor Agility Stamina Strength (+.33)
Bonus SA's - On The Run, Dump Pass
Penalty SA's - Pump Fake, Tight Spiral
(Changes: Added a fourth major, both because having the Scrambler get the same bonus to thr/vis as the other two seems silly, and because the whole archetype is pointless without high speed. Also substituted stamina for confidence since it needed to be in there somewhere.)
Halfbacks
HB Power
5'11" - 6'4", 210-260 Lbs
Major Agility Carrying Confidence Strength (+.5)
Minor Jumping Speed Stamina Vision (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Lower Shoulder, Power Thru
Penalty SA's - First Step, Spin
(Changes: Replaced Catching with jumping since that supposedly helps to avoid tackles. Also, you don't want power backs being natural pass catchers.)
HB Elusive
5'6" - 6'2", 180-220 Lbs
Major Agility Carrying Speed Vision (+.5)
Minor Catching Confidence Strength Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Head Fake, Juke
Penalty SA's - Lower Shoulder, Power Thru
(Changes: Replaced jumping with strength. If power has speed as a minor, then elusive deserves to have strength as one.)
HB Scat Back
5'6" - 6'2", 180-220 Lbs
Major Agility Carrying Catching Speed (+.5)
Minor Vision Confidence Jumping Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Quick Cut, First Step
Penalty SA's - Lower Shoulder, Power Thru
(Changes: Swapped Carrying & Vision to limit knocked loose and put it more on par with the other choices.)
HB Combo
5'9" - 6'2", 200-230 Lbs
Major Strength Carrying Confidence Speed Vision (+.4)
Minor Agility Catching Stamina Strength (+.25)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
(Changes: Added strength as a fifth major because the Combo needs to be in between power & elusive. Would anyone in their right mind choose the proposed combo with Confidence as a major over elusive with Agility? No. This way the combo will be good at breaking tackles, but not as good as the power archetype. He'll also be fast, but not as fast as the elusive.)
Fullbacks
FB Running
5'10" - 6'3", 230-250 Lbs
Major Agility Carrying Confidence Strength (+.5)
Minor Vision Speed Stamina Blocking (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Power Thru, Quick Cut
Penalty SA's - Lead Block, Pancake
(Changes: Replaced catching with blocking. A fullback is a fullback is a fullback. Just because you want a guy who is faster than normal doesn't mean that they should be a HB playing FB. All fullbacks should have blocking as a major or minor, just as all quarterbacks should have throwing. Also, if other archetypes have catching then there's no point for a FB Scat Back to exist.)
FB Blocking
5'10" - 6'3", 230-270 Lbs
Major Agility Blocking Strength Vision (+.5)
Minor Carrying Confidence Speed Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Lead Block, Pancake
Penalty SA's - Power Thru, Quick Cut
(Changes: None)
FB Combo - ELIMINATED
(Reason: If this exists as proposed, then no one in their right mind would ever choose Blocking. Moreover, there's no need for four types of fullbacks.)
FB Scat Back
5'10" - 6'3", 230-250 Lbs
Major Agility Catching Speed Vision (+.5)
Minor Carrying Confidence Blocking Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Sticky Hands, Quick Cut
Penalty SA's - Lead Block, Pancake
(Changes: Replaced jumping with blocking because a fullback is a fullback is a fullback. Plus, scat backs should also be competent in blitz pick-up.)
Wide Receivers
WR Speedster
5'8" - 6'2", 175-215 Lbs
Major Confidence Agility Catching Speed Vision (+.4)
Minor Carrying Jumping Stamina (+.33)
Bonus SA's - First Step, Quick Cut
Penalty SA's - Route Run, Sticky Hands
(Changes: Bumped confidence from minor to major because otherwise no one would ever choose Possession. Speed and jumping are not equally valuable to receivers.)
WR Possession
6'0" - 6'6", 195-235 Lbs
Major Carrying Agility Catching Jumping Vision (+.4)
Minor Confidence Speed Stamina (+.33)
Bonus SA's - Route Run, Sticky Hands
Penalty SA's - First Step, Quick Cut
(Changes: Bumped carrying from minor to major to put it on equal terms with Speedster, and because it makes sense that Possession types will hang on to the ball better.)
WR Power
6'0" - 6'6", 205-235 Lbs
Major Agility Carrying Catching Strength Vision (+.4)
Minor Confidence Speed Stamina (+.33)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
(Changes: Bumped vision to balance it with the others, and because +.5 strength seems like an awful lot for a receiver.)
Tight Ends
TE Blocker
6'2" - 6'8", 250-280 Lbs
Major Agility Blocking Strength Vision (+.5)
Minor Catching Confidence Speed Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Get Low, Pancake
Penalty SA's - Route Run, Quick Cut
(Changes: None, but holy crap are blocking TEs going to be overpowered.)
TE Power
6'2" - 6'8", 250-280 Lbs
Major Agility Carrying Catching Strength (+.5)
Minor Confidence Speed Stamina Blocking(+.25)
Bonus SA's - Cover Up, Lower Shoulder
Penalty SA's - Get Low, Pancake
(Changes: Replaced vision with blocking because every TE should have it somewhere, and +.25 is suitably weak.)
TE Receiver
6'0" - 6'6", 230-260 Lbs
Major Agility Catching Speed Vision (+.5)
Minor Carrying Blocking Stamina Strength (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Route Run, Quick Cut
Penalty SA's - Get Low, Pancake
(Changes: Replaced jumping with blocking for the reason stated above.)
TE Combo
6'2" - 6'8", 250-280 Lbs
Major Agility Blocking Catching Strength Vision (+.4)
Minor Confidence Jumping Speed Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
(Changes: Added stamina as a minor since every archetype should have it somewhere. Also bumped vision up to major because the combo shouldn't be as strong as the blocker or as good at catching passes as the receiver. Right now you'd have to be insane to choose the blocker archetype over combo.)
Offensive Line
Pass Blocking
(C) 6'0" - 6'4", 230-300 Lbs
(G) 6'2" - 6'5", 290-325 Lbs
(T) 6'2" - 6'6", 280-320 Lbs
Major Agility Blocking Confidence (+.67)
Minor Vision Speed Strength (+.33)
Bonus SA's (C/G) - Pass Block, Foundation
Bonus SA's (T) - Pass Block, Protector
Penalty SA's - Get Low, Pancake
(Changes: None. I felt like stamina should be in there as a minor, but you can't without screwing up the points or taking away speed, which would really devalue the option.)
Run Blocking
(C) 6'2" - 6'6", 280-330 Lbs
(G) 6'2" - 6'7", 310-360 Lbs
(T) 6'4" - 6'9", 300-350 Lbs
Major Blocking Confidence Strength (+.67)
Minor Agility Stamina Vision (+.33)
Bonus SA's - Get Low, Pancake
Penalty SA's (C/G) - Pass Block, Foundation
Penalty SA's (T) - Pass Block, Protector
(Changes: None.)
Defensive Line
Strength DL
(DE) 6'2" - 6'8", 275-330 Lbs
(DT) 6'0" - 6'8", 300-360 Lbs
Major Agility Strength Tackling (+.67)
Minor Vision Speed Stamina (+.33)
Bonus SA's (DE) - Wall, Strong Base
Bonus SA's (DT) - Wall, Break Thru
Penalty SA's (DE) - First Step, Tunnel Vision
Penalty SA's (DT) - Shed Block, Swat Ball
(Changes: None.)
Speed DL
(DE) 5'11" - 6'4", 240-280 Lbs
(DT) 6'0" - 6'5", 250-300 Lbs
Major Agility Speed Vision (+.67)
Minor Stamina Strength Tackling (+.33)
Bonus SA's (DE) - First Step, Tunnel Vision
Bonus SA's (DT) - Shed Block, Swat Ball
Penalty SA's (DE) - Wall, Strong Base
Penalty SA's (DT) - Wall, Break Thru
(Changes: None.)
Combo DL
(DE) 6'2" - 6'6", 260-300 Lbs
(DT) 6'0" - 6'8", 280-330 Lbs
Major Speed Strength Vision (+.67)
Minor Agility Stamina Tackling (+.33)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
(Changes: None.)
Linebackers
Coverage LB
5'10" - 6'3", 220-250 Lbs
Major Agility Jumping Speed Vision (+.5)
Minor Confidence Stamina Strength Tackling (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Diving Tackle, Swat Ball
Penalty SA's - Monster Hit, Shed Block
(Changes: None.)
Blitzing LB
5'10" - 6'6", 240-270 Lbs
Major Agility Confidence Speed Strength (+.5)
Minor Jumping Stamina Tackling Vision (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Shed Block, Big Sack
Penalty SA's - Aura of Int, Diving Tackle
(Changes: Swapped confidence for jumping and strength for tackling, as those would seem to make more sense for the blitzing role. I also changed one of the Penalty SAs from Monster Hit to Diving Tackle since the blitzer should still be a hard hitter.)
Hard Hitting LB
5'10" - 6'6", 240-270 Lbs
Major Agility Strength Tackling Vision (+.5)
Minor Confidence Jumping Speed Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Snarl, Monster Hit
Penalty SA's - Swat Ball, Big Sack
(Changes: None.)
Combo LB
5'10" - 6'6", 230-260 Lbs
Major Agility Confidence Speed Tackling Vision (+.4)
Minor Jumping Stamina Strength (+.33)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
(Changes: Moved confidence up to a major because right now this archetype is too damn good. Combo archetypes should be jacks of all trades and masters of none, not guys who are just as fast and skilled as the other options.)
Secondary
Man Specialist
(CB) 5'8" - 6'3", 170-210 Lbs
(SS) 5'9" - 6'5", 195-230 Lbs
(FS) 5'8" - 6'4", 185-220 Lbs
Major Agility Jumping Speed Vision (+.5)
Minor Catching Confidence Stamina Tackling (+.25)
Bonus SA's (CB) - Shutdown Coverage
Bonus SA's (SS) - Change Direction
Bonus SA's (FS) - Shutdown Coverage
Penalty SA's (CB) - Closing Speed
Penalty SA's (SS) - Big Hit
Penalty SA's (FS) - Big Hit
(Changes: None.)
Zone Specialist
(CB) 5'8" - 6'3", 170-210 Lbs
(SS) 5'9" - 6'5", 195-230 Lbs
(FS) 5'8" - 6'4", 185-220 Lbs
Major Agility Speed Tackling Vision (+.5)
Minor Catching Confidence Jumping Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Super Vision
Penalty SA's (CB) - Shutdown Coverage
Penalty SA's (SS) - Change Direction
Penalty SA's (FS) - Shutdown Coverage
(Changes: None.)
Hard Hitter
(CB) 5'10" - 6'3", 190-210 Lbs
(SS) 5'11" - 6'5", 205-230 Lbs
(FS) 5'10" - 6'4", 195-220 Lbs
Major Speed Strength Tackling Vision (+.5)
Minor Agility Confidence Jumping Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's (CB) - Closing Speed
Bonus SA's (SS) - Big Hit
Bonus SA's (FS) - Big Hit
Penalty SA's - Change Direction
(Changes: Swapped speed for agility, since I doubt that anyone would pick a secondary archetype with that much of a speed penalty.)
Combo Secondary
(CB) 5'8" - 6'3", 170-210 Lbs
(SS) 5'9" - 6'5", 195-230 Lbs
(FS) 5'8" - 6'4", 185-220 Lbs
Major Agility Speed Strength Tackling (+.5)
Minor Confidence Jumping Stamina Vision (+.25)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
(Changes: None.)
Kickers
Boomer
5'8" - 6'5", 180-230 Lbs
Major Confidence Kicking Strength (+.67)
Minor Agility Jumping Vision (+.33)
(Changes: None.)
Finesse
5'8" - 6'5", 180-230 Lbs
Major Confidence Kicking Vision (+.67)
Minor Agility Jumping Strength (+.33)
(Changes: None.)
Punter
Boomer
5'11" - 6'5", 180-250 Lbs
Major Confidence Punting Strength (+.67)
Minor Agility Jumping Vision (+.33)
(Changes: None.)
Finesse
5'11" - 6'5", 180-250 Lbs
Major Confidence Punting Vision (+.67)
Minor Agility Jumping Strength (+.33)
(Changes: None.)
Special Teams Only Player
Major: Agility Blocking Speed Stamina Tackling (+.4)
Minor: Confidence Strength Vision (+.33)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
(Changes: Bumped stamina up to a major to keep these builds from competing with natural position archetypes, plus it makes sense that they would have better conditioning since special teams is such a drain on energy.)
Returner (only HB/WR/CB eligible)
(HB) 5'6" - 6'0", 180-220 Lbs
(WR) 5'8" - 6'2", 175-215 Lbs
(CB) 5'8" - 6'2", 170-210 Lbs
Major: Agility Carrying Speed Stamina Vision (+.4)
Minor: Confidence Jumping Strength (+.33)
Bonus SA's (HB/WR) - First Step, Quick Cut
Bonus SA's (CB) - Change Direction, Return Spec.
Penalty SA's (HB) - Stiff Arm, Power Thru
Penalty SA's (WR) - Route Run, Sticky Hands
Penalty SA's (CB) - Super Vision, Shutdown Coverage
(Changes: Bumped stamina up to a major for the same reasons as listed above.)
Jeff Van Gundy
offline
offline
(Changes: Replaced jumping with blocking because a fullback is a fullback is a fullback. Plus, scat backs should also be competent in blitz pick-up.)
You decided a "scat back fullback" needs blocking
Lock er up
You decided a "scat back fullback" needs blocking

Lock er up
Maddoc
offline
offline
And saw nothing wrong with Zone SS getting a penalty to Change Direction.
Srsly, pretty much every SS is going to be forced into Combo Secondary.
Srsly, pretty much every SS is going to be forced into Combo Secondary.
Catch22
offline
offline
The thread Will the best HB archetype be a Returner has been merged into this thread
dnooner
offline
offline
Returner (only HB/WR/CB eligible)
(HB) 5'6" - 6'0", 180-220 Lbs
(WR) 5'8" - 6'2", 175-215 Lbs
(CB) 5'8" - 6'2", 170-210 Lbs
Major: Agility Carrying Speed Vision (+.5)
Minor: Confidence Jumping Stamina Strength (+.25)
Speed Agility and Carrying as majors, with Strength as a minor, almost seems like the best choice to me.
(HB) 5'6" - 6'0", 180-220 Lbs
(WR) 5'8" - 6'2", 175-215 Lbs
(CB) 5'8" - 6'2", 170-210 Lbs
Major: Agility Carrying Speed Vision (+.5)
Minor: Confidence Jumping Stamina Strength (+.25)
Speed Agility and Carrying as majors, with Strength as a minor, almost seems like the best choice to me.
pottsman
offline
offline
Also depends on what the "NEW SHINY ARCHETYPE SA" is
But yeah, that seems somewhat overpowered.
But yeah, that seems somewhat overpowered.
MRIGUY
offline
offline
But that build will only be elusive because there is a penalty to power through and LTS so no way someone could go combo.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























