User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ICRockets
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by lukin83



Yeah. I would rather see the WL not happen at all if it is not going to be done right. That is why am I am so invested in this. That and the fact that I wanted to put this thing together 5+ seasons ago. Turnit is a good sounding board, so I am happy that he is questioning my thoughts. If everyone approved of one idea, there would be things overlooked with it.

When I say getting it done right, I mean this...

1. Each region should have equal representation. Sure, it will not be an even playing field now, but if we give it time players will start to migrate to the inferior regions and create parity. I have always been for equality between regions since OPL has always got a bad rap and USAPL have always been the golden boys. it has never been fair in recruiting players, landing coordinators, or getting recognition from the GLB community. An equal 4 teams across the board, steers us in the right direction.

2. Regional affiliations should be kept. This is to preserve rivalries and team locations. If my team is from Ghana, I want to be in Africa.

I really think it is as simple as those two things (unless I am forgetting something - posing in this thread has gotten tiresome).


The more I do think about it I really agree with both 1 and 2. If those two things can not happen then I don't want a world league either.


I don't understand why you feel each region should have equal representation. INITIALLY that seems obvious. You have to start it out by taking the Top 4 from each region. But after that, the divisional system mucks things up in a seemingly irreparable fashion. You can't FORCE parity. That's just bullshit.

If the Conference Champions of each region all get promoted each season, the parity will happen long-term as players realize that going to League A provides them an easier path to the WPL than League C. Then League A gets overloaded a bit, so League F becomes the new "worst" Pro league. Will there be some fluctuations every few seasons? Probably, yeah. But over time it will even out.


Without equal representation, you cannot keep your regional affiliation. Whether we like it or not, regional affiliation is important to most teams in this game. Teams have created rivalries within their regions, they have friends within their regions, and their team location is from their region. My team is from Oceania. I am proud of that. I want to represent my region in the WL and I want to go back there when I am demoted. Without limiting the WL to 4 teams from each region, there is no way this is possible.
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by Bort

I think the main problem I can see with the 4 per region "division" idea is that it makes it possible for playoff teams to get demoted over non-playoff teams. We'd have to demote the worst of each division, and it's possible for one region to send 4 teams who will be in the playoffs via wildcard spots, while another region has no wildcards.


To that I would say .... tough. And I doubt one region would have no wildcards. If it did....it would work itself out over time. If you create set numbers from each league (which most agree you should) then parity will ensue. If you decide to just show love to USAPL, SAPL, or CPL and ignore people like EEP, OPL, SEA I fear for the future of the game and the riots that will ensue over that one.


You can't say this plan works because you "doubt" the scenario in which it doesn't work will come to fruition. That's terribly illogical.

You pick the plan for which the problem scenario has a SOLUTION, not for which the problem scenario is least likely. Jesus.
 
Link
 
Once a system is agreed upon you should put up the exact same poll w/ the system you choose. My vote would change drastically depending on the system. If it doesn't show equality amongst leagues I don't want the WPL.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Dirtmcgirt66

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Knightman



OK, it's been a while since I posted my suggestion, and since Bort has said he doesn't like the divisions idea....

What about the idea of assigning a pot of money to WPL teams based on their original regions?

This would promote parity as if OPL has only 2 teams splitting a pot and USAPL has 6, each OPL team will get 3 times as much money as the USAPL teams. Since EQ upgrades at the levels we're talking about cost much more than a level boost, and players will only level 5 times a season, giving a team that extra cash may be enough to compensate for lower level players it may have. Even if it gets demoted, it has a wad of cash to dole out to recruits who want EQ upgrades for their players, thus giving them a recruiting advantage. Higher level players migrate to the teams that have the cash, and Voila!----parity!!!

This system can continue even after parity exists, since presumably each league will have the same number of teams in the WPL and get the same amount of money.

Now that the issue of parity gets addressed, there's no problem with allowing teams to go back to their original regions and resume their rivalries/friendships with familiar foes. After all, remember when GLB was touted as much as a social networking game as it was football? Why destroy the social networking aspect of it by randomizing demotion?


Interesting and out of the box at the very least. Kinda like taking the idea of media revenue and splitting it by representation in the league.


Except that a pot of money doesnt overcome teams with talented coordinators.


No, but it can't hurt.

I just think it's some interesting out of the box thinking. We don't have to be constricted to one type of idea and ignore all other concepts.


I agree with it being interesting out of the box thinking and not getting stuck in the same idea over and over again. That doesnt mean I cant bash it though.
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
The other point about "coordinators" is that this inequity is going to be present no matter WHAT scheme you use for WPL. Whether you use a division setup or pot of money setup or whatever, teams with the best coordinators are going to win. However, if you can spread the talent around a little better, you can get more parity.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by Bort

I think the main problem I can see with the 4 per region "division" idea is that it makes it possible for playoff teams to get demoted over non-playoff teams. We'd have to demote the worst of each division, and it's possible for one region to send 4 teams who will be in the playoffs via wildcard spots, while another region has no wildcards.


To that I would say .... tough. And I doubt one region would have no wildcards. If it did....it would work itself out over time. If you create set numbers from each league (which most agree you should) then parity will ensue. If you decide to just show love to USAPL, SAPL, or CPL and ignore people like EEP, OPL, SEA I fear for the future of the game and the riots that will ensue over that one.


Agreed.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by Bort

I think the main problem I can see with the 4 per region "division" idea is that it makes it possible for playoff teams to get demoted over non-playoff teams. We'd have to demote the worst of each division, and it's possible for one region to send 4 teams who will be in the playoffs via wildcard spots, while another region has no wildcards.


To that I would say .... tough. And I doubt one region would have no wildcards. If it did....it would work itself out over time. If you create set numbers from each league (which most agree you should) then parity will ensue. If you decide to just show love to USAPL, SAPL, or CPL and ignore people like EEP, OPL, SEA I fear for the future of the game and the riots that will ensue over that one.


I don't think there has to be a forced and arbitrary set number in the league from each region at all times. I think that teams should have to fight to stay and winning should be the factor in determining who stays and who goes. All regions would get 2 teams promoted to the world league every season. How is that not equal opportunity?
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ICRockets
Originally posted by lukin83

Originally posted by turnit643


Originally posted by lukin83



Originally posted by turnit643



Originally posted by lukin83





WL could essentially end up being 25 USAPL teams and one team from each remaining region without a method that ensures 4 teams make it from each region. Looking at that as an owner, why would I want to go to an inferior league? Give me USA please.


The unlikely max from the other suggestion would be 18 from one region and 2 from each of the others. But, along the way to that number, all leagues would have had the same opportunity to get in. And all league would have had the same opportunity to be bumped back out. Min = 2 max = 18, more likely 8-10 from one region at a high point. All regions feed in the same way = all regions can attract the same type of FA's and the "lesser" regions have the "easier" path in the early going. Eventually it evens as teams settle into the WL and FA's find their way from USA to other leagues. I don't see how it continues to promote the USAPL or offers any less of a chance to other regions than the divisions idea.


The divisions idea guarantees 4 spots to each region. The other ideas do not guarantee that many spots. That alone makes the inferior regions less attractive than USAPL. Without a way of keeping regional affiliations, former USAPL teams are going to find their ways to inferior regions, which in turn makes those regions less attractive. If nothing is done to make us think that OPL can be equal to USAPL (allowing 4 teams from each region in the WL would do this), then how are we ever supposed to get past the current concept that USAPL is #1? The answer is that we cannot, which will result in USAPL remaining the premier pro league.


But why have to guarantee 4 teams each season? Four teams will go in from each league to start. Two more will go in each season from each league. Why make it so the teams that don't earn their place get to keep it? And how does that improve a league's perceived value ... each year two teams go in for sure, but two will also come out for sure ... instead of each season two go in and may get to stay if they perform well enough and be joined by more from their league. Access to the WL would be the same in each system, why not let it take shape by who earns the right to stay?


I guess where we differ is in how we decide who gets to stay. Try looking at it this way...


I am an owner in an uncapped league and will be promoting to a AA league next season. I take a look at the WL. I see 18 USA teams and 2 from each of the other regions (if we were to take the best teams in the game right now, I think we can all agree it would be USA heavy). I think to myself, "Self, USA is where it is at. Those other regions are clearly inferior."


If we do not give players a reason to think USAPL is no longer superior, it will continue to be superior.


Ok, so your goal is to get into the World Pro League. You believe USAPL teams are the best. Doesn't that mean you would AVOID that region? To take the perceived EASIER path to WPL? If enough teams do that, then the other regions get more good teams coming up through the ranks.

Guess what that's called?


If those best teams are already in the WL then they are no longer in USA.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think the main problem I can see with the 4 per region "division" idea is that it makes it possible for playoff teams to get demoted over non-playoff teams. We'd have to demote the worst of each division, and it's possible for one region to send 4 teams who will be in the playoffs via wildcard spots, while another region has no wildcards.


Or you could make it a cap of 3 teams getting to the playoffs from each division so that there is always a 4th to demote. Kind of like the current BCS limit with the number of teams a conference can have in a BCS bowl game.
 
The Lurker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dirtmcgirt66
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Dirtmcgirt66


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by Knightman




OK, it's been a while since I posted my suggestion, and since Bort has said he doesn't like the divisions idea....

What about the idea of assigning a pot of money to WPL teams based on their original regions?

This would promote parity as if OPL has only 2 teams splitting a pot and USAPL has 6, each OPL team will get 3 times as much money as the USAPL teams. Since EQ upgrades at the levels we're talking about cost much more than a level boost, and players will only level 5 times a season, giving a team that extra cash may be enough to compensate for lower level players it may have. Even if it gets demoted, it has a wad of cash to dole out to recruits who want EQ upgrades for their players, thus giving them a recruiting advantage. Higher level players migrate to the teams that have the cash, and Voila!----parity!!!

This system can continue even after parity exists, since presumably each league will have the same number of teams in the WPL and get the same amount of money.

Now that the issue of parity gets addressed, there's no problem with allowing teams to go back to their original regions and resume their rivalries/friendships with familiar foes. After all, remember when GLB was touted as much as a social networking game as it was football? Why destroy the social networking aspect of it by randomizing demotion?


Interesting and out of the box at the very least. Kinda like taking the idea of media revenue and splitting it by representation in the league.


Except that a pot of money doesnt overcome teams with talented coordinators.


No, but it can't hurt.

I just think it's some interesting out of the box thinking. We don't have to be constricted to one type of idea and ignore all other concepts.


I agree with it being interesting out of the box thinking and not getting stuck in the same idea over and over again. That doesnt mean I cant bash it though.


Yeah, it's more along the lines of something to add in addition to other ideas. Money alone will do next to nothing to address parity.
 
BBVD
offline
Link
 
if we take the top teams in the last GLB Poll by turnit, we'd have this:

11 USA Pro
5 APL
4 CPL
4 SAPL
3 WEPL
3 SEAPL
2 EEPL
0 OPL
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by ICRockets

Originally posted by lukin83


Originally posted by turnit643



Originally posted by lukin83




Originally posted by turnit643




Originally posted by lukin83






WL could essentially end up being 25 USAPL teams and one team from each remaining region without a method that ensures 4 teams make it from each region. Looking at that as an owner, why would I want to go to an inferior league? Give me USA please.


The unlikely max from the other suggestion would be 18 from one region and 2 from each of the others. But, along the way to that number, all leagues would have had the same opportunity to get in. And all league would have had the same opportunity to be bumped back out. Min = 2 max = 18, more likely 8-10 from one region at a high point. All regions feed in the same way = all regions can attract the same type of FA's and the "lesser" regions have the "easier" path in the early going. Eventually it evens as teams settle into the WL and FA's find their way from USA to other leagues. I don't see how it continues to promote the USAPL or offers any less of a chance to other regions than the divisions idea.


The divisions idea guarantees 4 spots to each region. The other ideas do not guarantee that many spots. That alone makes the inferior regions less attractive than USAPL. Without a way of keeping regional affiliations, former USAPL teams are going to find their ways to inferior regions, which in turn makes those regions less attractive. If nothing is done to make us think that OPL can be equal to USAPL (allowing 4 teams from each region in the WL would do this), then how are we ever supposed to get past the current concept that USAPL is #1? The answer is that we cannot, which will result in USAPL remaining the premier pro league.


But why have to guarantee 4 teams each season? Four teams will go in from each league to start. Two more will go in each season from each league. Why make it so the teams that don't earn their place get to keep it? And how does that improve a league's perceived value ... each year two teams go in for sure, but two will also come out for sure ... instead of each season two go in and may get to stay if they perform well enough and be joined by more from their league. Access to the WL would be the same in each system, why not let it take shape by who earns the right to stay?


I guess where we differ is in how we decide who gets to stay. Try looking at it this way...


I am an owner in an uncapped league and will be promoting to a AA league next season. I take a look at the WL. I see 18 USA teams and 2 from each of the other regions (if we were to take the best teams in the game right now, I think we can all agree it would be USA heavy). I think to myself, "Self, USA is where it is at. Those other regions are clearly inferior."


If we do not give players a reason to think USAPL is no longer superior, it will continue to be superior.


Ok, so your goal is to get into the World Pro League. You believe USAPL teams are the best. Doesn't that mean you would AVOID that region? To take the perceived EASIER path to WPL? If enough teams do that, then the other regions get more good teams coming up through the ranks.

Guess what that's called?


If those best teams are already in the WL then they are no longer in USA.


And now your observation and your conclusion have essentially no bearing on eachother. Congratulations, you think like an idiot.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

I don't think there has to be a forced and arbitrary set number in the league from each region at all times. I think that teams should have to fight to stay and winning should be the factor in determining who stays and who goes. All regions would get 2 teams promoted to the world league every season. How is that not equal opportunity?


Yes!
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by Bort


I think the main problem I can see with the 4 per region "division" idea is that it makes it possible for playoff teams to get demoted over non-playoff teams. We'd have to demote the worst of each division, and it's possible for one region to send 4 teams who will be in the playoffs via wildcard spots, while another region has no wildcards.


To that I would say .... tough. And I doubt one region would have no wildcards. If it did....it would work itself out over time. If you create set numbers from each league (which most agree you should) then parity will ensue. If you decide to just show love to USAPL, SAPL, or CPL and ignore people like EEP, OPL, SEA I fear for the future of the game and the riots that will ensue over that one.


I don't think there has to be a forced and arbitrary set number in the league from each region at all times. I think that teams should have to fight to stay and winning should be the factor in determining who stays and who goes. All regions would get 2 teams promoted to the world league every season. How is that not equal opportunity?


Can you keep your regional affiliation with that method?
 
DL24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BBVD
if we take the top teams in the last GLB Poll by turnit, we'd have this:

11 USA Pro
5 APL
4 CPL
4 SAPL
3 WEPL
3 SEAPL
2 EEPL
0 OPL


No, just have each league start with 4 teams in, and promote 2 teams from each region in each season. If all 4 teams from say OPL need to be relegated, so be it. 2 new teams will jump in to keep places for that region in place though.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.