Originally posted by Bort
Really, though, you all can't see how this is a good middle ground solution? People were just pissing and moaning about how some top teams wouldn't get to be part of the "world title" and how officializing a tourney might be a better idea. We have been discussing doing a world tourney of some sort since season 2, after the world league was massively poo-poohed by most of the posters in a thread just like this. R8 posts a random post from the test server, and now I've "promised" something that random people in some thread had worked out the details of?
I don't particularly like the problems that the league idea introduces. People already like playing the the PWT and see it as a good method of finding the "top" team, and have suggested making it official over and over and over again. Officializing that tournament is somehow now the WORST IDEA EVER(tm) and signals the DOWNFALL OF MANKIND(tm)?
No, I (for one) can't see this as a good, middle-ground solution. Like TexanInMA said, I don't usually get involved in these discussions. However, it's hard to fathom that a single-elimination tournament seeding 64 teams from 8 regions is the answer. An answer, certainly...but not the right one.
Has anyone looked into how many CPU teams there are in the Pro leagues? How many will there be in the next two or three days?
It seems to me that there are two plausible answers for demoting teams from the World League. One, they won't choose to remain active. With the inception of the World League in Season 11, I would guess that the vast majority of the players in that first season will be Season 1 players, with a handful of Season 2 players thrown in. Facing demotion or retirement, it's likely that many teams would choose retirement. Second, instead of promoting up from the AAA levels to replace CPU teams, demote from the World League to replace CPU teams. This lessens the trickle-down effect mentioned in another post and also helps to keep the integrity of the league structure.
I fear that pushing forward with a Tournament without the "blessing" of the 32 teams that would have made up the WPL will only lead to disaster.
Really, though, you all can't see how this is a good middle ground solution? People were just pissing and moaning about how some top teams wouldn't get to be part of the "world title" and how officializing a tourney might be a better idea. We have been discussing doing a world tourney of some sort since season 2, after the world league was massively poo-poohed by most of the posters in a thread just like this. R8 posts a random post from the test server, and now I've "promised" something that random people in some thread had worked out the details of?
I don't particularly like the problems that the league idea introduces. People already like playing the the PWT and see it as a good method of finding the "top" team, and have suggested making it official over and over and over again. Officializing that tournament is somehow now the WORST IDEA EVER(tm) and signals the DOWNFALL OF MANKIND(tm)?
No, I (for one) can't see this as a good, middle-ground solution. Like TexanInMA said, I don't usually get involved in these discussions. However, it's hard to fathom that a single-elimination tournament seeding 64 teams from 8 regions is the answer. An answer, certainly...but not the right one.
Has anyone looked into how many CPU teams there are in the Pro leagues? How many will there be in the next two or three days?
It seems to me that there are two plausible answers for demoting teams from the World League. One, they won't choose to remain active. With the inception of the World League in Season 11, I would guess that the vast majority of the players in that first season will be Season 1 players, with a handful of Season 2 players thrown in. Facing demotion or retirement, it's likely that many teams would choose retirement. Second, instead of promoting up from the AAA levels to replace CPU teams, demote from the World League to replace CPU teams. This lessens the trickle-down effect mentioned in another post and also helps to keep the integrity of the league structure.
I fear that pushing forward with a Tournament without the "blessing" of the 32 teams that would have made up the WPL will only lead to disaster.






























