User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > A WPL WITHOUT MM-OFGand WW IS BS
Page:
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PatricktheDookie
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by Joebarber


Originally posted by islander1



Originally posted by Joebarber




Originally posted by islander1





I mean, to me there's two system options that make sense.

1) the system that puts the best 32 teams in the league - region regardless
2) the system that flips the conference finalists each and every year, previous results in World League regardless.

If it's 2, then ok, but anything other then 2(that starts out as a 2) is simply wasteful. We already know which conference finalists suck.


except for the fact that for option 1 there is not a current system in place to decide who are the best 32 teams are.


Sure there is. Results from tournaments, primarily, secondarily strength of league.
You'll get some arguments from the bubble teams for sure...but the top 20 teams are no brainers.


Not accurate really. Not all top teams compete in tourneys and this seasons tourneys had skewed results because of the mentor glitching. Also who gets to decide strength of league? It's all subjective...
With the current system everything will be worked out after 2-3 seasons, the conferences with strong teams will be able to keep teams in the WPL while the weak conferences will always just have their 4 newly promoted ones.



Pretty much all the best Pro teams compete in the PWT. Even teams like the Benitos. The only team I know of that refused to bother with the PWT was the Green Bay Maulers.

It's VERY accurate. A system that gives every league 4 teams is just going to make for a joke of a first season. We all know half of the USAPL teams can drill the vast majority of the 'promoting' teams not from north america.


I imagine some teams would have paid *much* more attention to the PWT if they had been told it would affect their team's chances to be promoted.


We didnt pay that much attention. We still made it to the elite 8.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by PatricktheDookie


I suspect only one team from each pro league will advance to the WPL starting next season. That would leave 8 teams being relegated (25% of the league). 2 teams advancing each season would mean anyone not making the playoffs would get kicked off the island, which seems a little much.


So, if only one team advances from each league each season, how exactly would "things work out" in a season or two?


Let's cut the league in half and look at one conference (just for simplicity's sake).

2 teams from each of the 8 pro leagues will (theoretically) compete next season. Let's assume the regular season standings end up like this.

(with 1 and 2 designating separate teams from each pro league)

1) USA-1
2) CPL-1
3) USA-2
4) SAPL-1
5) WEPL-1
6) APL-1
7) SEAPL-1
8) CPL-2
9) EEPL-1
10) OPL-1
11) APL-2
12) SAPL-2
13) SEAPL-2
14) OPL-2
15) EEPL-2
16) WEPL-2

In this scenario, Western Europe, Eastern Europe, Oceania, and South East Asia would all *lose* a team in the WPL. Four of the eight teams coming up would pop into this conference. Maybe it would be SEAPL, CPL, APL, and USA (just randomly picking here).

In that scenario, the conference would have the following breakdown for the next season:

3 USA
3 CPL
3 APL
2 SEAPL
2 SAPL
1 WEPL
1 EEPL
1 OPL

If USA holds serve, their league would likely gain one more representative each season after the first. This would also guarantee each pro league to have at least one representative each season.

I mean, it's all speculation, but this seems the most logical to me.
Edited by PatricktheDookie on Jul 27, 2009 08:35:58
 
Link
 
Originally posted by
We didnt pay that much attention. We still made it to the elite 8.


Explains why you want to use the PWT results, then.
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
a GLB without the Yokels is....BS IMO....
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PatricktheDookie
Originally posted by PackMan97

Originally posted by PatricktheDookie



I suspect only one team from each pro league will advance to the WPL starting next season. That would leave 8 teams being relegated (25% of the league). 2 teams advancing each season would mean anyone not making the playoffs would get kicked off the island, which seems a little much.


So, if only one team advances from each league each season, how exactly would "things work out" in a season or two?


Let's cut the league in half and look at one conference (just for simplicity's sake).

2 teams from each of the 8 pro leagues will (theoretically) compete next season. Let's assume the regular season standings end up like this.

(with 1 and 2 designating separate teams from each pro league)

1) USA-1
2) CPL-1
3) USA-2
4) SAPL-1
5) WEPL-1
6) APL-1
7) SEAPL-1
8) CPL-2
9) EEPL-1
10) OPL-1
11) APL-2
12) SAPL-2
13) SEAPL-2
14) OPL-2
15) EEPL-2
16) WEPL-2

In this scenario, Western Europe, Eastern Europe, Oceania, and South East Asia would all *lose* a team in the WPL. Four of the eight teams coming up would pop into this conference. Maybe it would be SEAPL, CPL, APL, and USA (just randomly picking here).

In that scenario, the conference would have the following breakdown for the next season:

3 USA
3 CPL
3 APL
2 SEAPL
2 SAPL
1 WEPL
1 EEPL
1 OPL

If USA holds serve, their league would likely gain one more representative each season after the first. This would also guarantee each pro league to have at least one representative each season.

I mean, it's all speculation, but this seems the most logical to me.


Let's review our GLB history....way back when only the conference champions promoted out of each league. The result were greatly unbalanced leagues in which some lower level leagues had BETTER talent than their parent leagues thanks to a slow turnover.

With 8 leagues feeding the World League you simply need quicker advancement than one league champion a season. Demote the non-playoff teams, promote the conference champs from each league.

Unlike your system which guarantees a league only one team a season, this guarantees two, but churns the teams much faster. Faster churn I think is very important to keep teams from bottlenecking the each pro league.

Of course, unless your goal is to make hard to ever demote from the World League?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by PatricktheDookie

Originally posted by PackMan97


Originally posted by PatricktheDookie




I suspect only one team from each pro league will advance to the WPL starting next season. That would leave 8 teams being relegated (25% of the league). 2 teams advancing each season would mean anyone not making the playoffs would get kicked off the island, which seems a little much.


So, if only one team advances from each league each season, how exactly would "things work out" in a season or two?


Let's cut the league in half and look at one conference (just for simplicity's sake).

2 teams from each of the 8 pro leagues will (theoretically) compete next season. Let's assume the regular season standings end up like this.

(with 1 and 2 designating separate teams from each pro league)

1) USA-1
2) CPL-1
3) USA-2
4) SAPL-1
5) WEPL-1
6) APL-1
7) SEAPL-1
8) CPL-2
9) EEPL-1
10) OPL-1
11) APL-2
12) SAPL-2
13) SEAPL-2
14) OPL-2
15) EEPL-2
16) WEPL-2

In this scenario, Western Europe, Eastern Europe, Oceania, and South East Asia would all *lose* a team in the WPL. Four of the eight teams coming up would pop into this conference. Maybe it would be SEAPL, CPL, APL, and USA (just randomly picking here).

In that scenario, the conference would have the following breakdown for the next season:

3 USA
3 CPL
3 APL
2 SEAPL
2 SAPL
1 WEPL
1 EEPL
1 OPL

If USA holds serve, their league would likely gain one more representative each season after the first. This would also guarantee each pro league to have at least one representative each season.

I mean, it's all speculation, but this seems the most logical to me.


Let's review our GLB history....way back when only the conference champions promoted out of each league. The result were greatly unbalanced leagues in which some lower level leagues had BETTER talent than their parent leagues thanks to a slow turnover.

With 8 leagues feeding the World League you simply need quicker advancement than one league champion a season. Demote the non-playoff teams, promote the conference champs from each league.

Unlike your system which guarantees a league only one team a season, this guarantees two, but churns the teams much faster. Faster churn I think is very important to keep teams from bottlenecking the each pro league.

Of course, unless your goal is to make hard to ever demote from the World League?


Part of the problem you mentioned was that pro league conferences were only relegating two teams per season IIRC.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
So your answer is to make a World League that effectively relegates half a team per league? 4 demotes divided among 8 leagues? brilliant.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by The Duff Man
Originally posted by ImTheScientist


Many of them were good or are good currently just because they out level people.


Level 64 vrs level 62 means a lot at this point. LOL. If you believe this you need a clue.


Im in the WPL so obviously I know something
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
So your answer is to make a World League that effectively relegates half a team per league? 4 demotes divided among 8 leagues? brilliant.


Fuzzy math is fuzzy.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Using any player created system to determine teams in the WPL is a bad idea. Any system needs to be 100% objective to be fair. I wouldn't put it beyond some committee teams to vote USA squads slightly higher to get them into the WPL faster if that mattered, or to set up the brackets in the PWT to make it a bit easier for certain teams to get to the WPL.

If the system is not 100% objective, there will be a shitstorm of epic proportions. Saying that each conference champion promotes to the world league each season is the most fair way to say that you know how you'll be promoted. It might suck for the leagues that are deeper, but with the decline and such coming up, there is no guarantee that USAPL will stay on top. It wasn't but 2 or 3 seasons ago that OPL was regarded as one of the top leagues in GLB, with many placing Zeta as the #3 conference in GLB. Sure, OPL took a sharp decline, but that right there is proof that you can't throw in more teams from one division, or try to move teams to 'weaker divisions' since stuff changes so fast in GLB.
Edited by MrMoose on Jul 27, 2009 08:56:42
 
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
Using any player created system to determine teams in the WPL is a bad idea. Any system needs to be 100% objective to be fair. I wouldn't put it beyond some committee teams to vote USA squads slightly higher to get them into the WPL faster if that mattered, or to set up the brackets in the PWT to make it a bit easier for certain teams to get to the WPL.

If the system is not 100% objective, there will be a shitstorm of epic proportions.


BCS
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PatricktheDookie
Originally posted by PackMan97

So your answer is to make a World League that effectively relegates half a team per league? 4 demotes divided among 8 leagues? brilliant.


Fuzzy math is fuzzy.


No, you have to account that you have 8 feeder leagues and not just two.

The Pro Leagues had problems when it was 2 demotions per conference into 2 leagues. Or one demotion per league. That wasn't enough churn. Now you propose 4 demotions into 8 leagues which is half a demotion per league.

That's my point. The system needs to have more churn than the bottom 8 teams. The simple solution is to make it non-playoff teams demote. Anything else won't allow enough churn, I'm not even sure if this will allow enough, to be honest.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PatricktheDookie
Originally posted by MrMoose

Using any player created system to determine teams in the WPL is a bad idea. Any system needs to be 100% objective to be fair. I wouldn't put it beyond some committee teams to vote USA squads slightly higher to get them into the WPL faster if that mattered, or to set up the brackets in the PWT to make it a bit easier for certain teams to get to the WPL.

If the system is not 100% objective, there will be a shitstorm of epic proportions.


BCS


Yeah, pretty much.

Fans bitch enough about how bad the BCS is. Imagine if the BCS style setup had a direct effect on something people are paying money for.
 
Galkuris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PatricktheDookie
Originally posted by

Outlevelling people is obviously the main issue. I know 10 SP makes a MASSIVE difference in a build at L60+. Of course, teams shouldn't be able to move freely either but I'm guessing Oceania is pretty happy that they were able to dump West Scranton into USAPL. It just means we're going to send teams to the World League that were worse than a 5-11 USAPL team.


West Scranton kicked the crap out of pretty much every team for several seasons. Their collapse in season 10 had more to do with the roster cap than anything. They couldn't pound teams into submission with depth alone anymore.

Using West Scranton's record to bitch about OPL is a poor argument.


Maybe you should check up on WSI the season before they moved. I'm fairly certain they got handled pretty easily in scrimmages while they still destroyed most of OPL.

I honestly just don't get how people say the leagues are even until a USAPL team mentioned moving to theirs. Make up your mind which side of the fence you are on people.

And ITS, levels mean something but certainly not everything. You seem to not realize that when the game started slow building was not very common. This means that the highest levels today (63+) built normally and many players 57-62 did slow build. I've seen quite a few level 60 players that are better then many 64+.
 
kmart
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by PatricktheDookie

Originally posted by PackMan97


So your answer is to make a World League that effectively relegates half a team per league? 4 demotes divided among 8 leagues? brilliant.


Fuzzy math is fuzzy.


No, you have to account that you have 8 feeder leagues and not just two.

The Pro Leagues had problems when it was 2 demotions per conference into 2 leagues. Or one demotion per league. That wasn't enough churn. Now you propose 4 demotions into 8 leagues which is half a demotion per league.

That's my point. The system needs to have more churn than the bottom 8 teams. The simple solution is to make it non-playoff teams demote. Anything else won't allow enough churn, I'm not even sure if this will allow enough, to be honest.


Yea I agree, make the non-playoff teams demote, and that allows all conference champions to take their place. It makes sense.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.