User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Endorsements - What I am thinking
Page:
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Capaneus
Originally posted by Gart888


Yup, it seems like the best choice to me. Keep those who are losing their endorsements happy, while not giving them an in-game suggestion. I'd say 1000 flex sounds about fair.


Wow, not sure if you're serious. I was thinking 100-200 flex. It's not like you were going to get to keep the endorse EQ for more than one season. Not you specifically, but some of the stuff people are asking for, I hope he lets them keep the endorse EQ before he starts handing out treats like that.


I actually thought 1000 was a little low, but was trying to be reasonable. 2000-3000 would be more appropriate imo. It's not like handing out flex points you know, costs Bort anything. It would just cause these players to either not retire their other guys so fast, or create new players.
 
goldielax25
offline
Link
 
has anyone suggested this yet? i think it would solve the "mvp is going to have inflated stats from playing blowouts". why not weigh close games based on record and overalls much higher, so that the player that contributes most to taking the above average team and helps them win all of their games against similar opposition and puts up fantastic numbers in those games, is the one that is "most valuable". if its going to be based only on stats and not on how the player affects the teams performance, just call it a player of the year award and not most valuable player. who is more valuable to the team, the running back who racks up 5000 yards in a 8000 yard rb tandem for a 16-0 team that wins its games by an average of 50 points, or the guy who runs for 4000 yards for the team who isnt as strong, and has to scrape for most of their wins, and finishes 13-3 by an average of 25 points for their wins. i would go with the 4000 yard runner, even though his stats are lower and they played the same teams. without him, their team may not have won some of their games, whereas the 5000 yard runner leaving wouldnt have killed that team because they were strong overall without him.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saints4Life08
This all comes down to a bunch of people whining cause they didn't get there way. If any one of the whiners on here would have gotten an endorsement they would be on the other side of the argument. Just leave the people who got them be and fix it and have the system right for next season. Why go and take away what was already given? That's a horrible idea. Whiney Babys on here are ridiculous. Grow a pair and move on.



Bort could just leave the equipment with the player but don't activate it. Nice middle ground there.
 
The Suthrner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saints4Life08
This all comes down to a bunch of people whining cause they didn't get there way. If any one of the whiners on here would have gotten an endorsement they would be on the other side of the argument. Just leave the people who got them be and fix it and have the system right for next season. Why go and take away what was already given? That's a horrible idea. Whiney Babys on here are ridiculous. Grow a pair and move on.


This guy is horrible and should have never gotten an endorsement, which is probably why your so reluctant to give it up.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1204058
Last edited Feb 27, 2009 08:11:43
 
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888

I actually thought 1000 was a little low, but was trying to be reasonable. 2000-3000 would be more appropriate imo. It's not like handing out flex points you know, costs Bort anything. It would just cause these players to either not retire their other guys so fast, or create new players.


Uh, wow. I've seen enough posts by you that I know you're generally sensible, but you really think people deserve the equivalent of 20-30$ for not getting to use a completely optional game feature that not everyone was going to get access to anyway? You realize some players who lose endorsements could well wind up getting them again. Would they have to give the flex back?
 
atm490
offline
Link
 
Full disclosure: one of my players received an endorsement. I'm NOT happy that my kicker is about to lose the +2 kicking, +2 confidence, +2 vision, +1 kicking tree that I was promised on Wednesday night, and I don't think that the $600k completely useless in-game cash is a worthy replacement AT ALL, but that has little bearing on my reasoning below.

Here's what I liked about the old system: It was a fun, once-a-season lottery. It was random, very few people won and a lot of people were unhappy: just like a real lottery. Instead of calling it endorsements, just call it the Super Equipment Lottery and move on.

Here's what I don't like about the new system: I have no idea what Bort's original post means at all. Maybe it's because I'm a casual player, but I don't get the tiers, the calculations, etc. I just don't understand it. I don't know if this is something I actively have to work for or something that will just happen.

Above all, it seems like an unnecessary element of the game that the Admins now have to monitor and hear complaints about. The lottery is easy - there are winners, losers, it happens once every off-season, and that's it. The new system is an ongoing thing that will take up time that could be better spent working on the sim.


 
The Suthrner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atm490
Full disclosure: one of my players received an endorsement. I'm NOT happy that my kicker is about to lose the +2 kicking, +2 confidence, +2 vision, +1 kicking tree that I was promised on Wednesday night, and I don't think that the $600k completely useless in-game cash is a worthy replacement AT ALL, but that has little bearing on my reasoning below.

Here's what I liked about the old system: It was a fun, once-a-season lottery. It was random, very few people won and a lot of people were unhappy: just like a real lottery. Instead of calling it endorsements, just call it the Super Equipment Lottery and move on.

Here's what I don't like about the new system: I have no idea what Bort's original post means at all. Maybe it's because I'm a casual player, but I don't get the tiers, the calculations, etc. I just don't understand it. I don't know if this is something I actively have to work for or something that will just happen.

Above all, it seems like an unnecessary element of the game that the Admins now have to monitor and hear complaints about. The lottery is easy - there are winners, losers, it happens once every off-season, and that's it. The new system is an ongoing thing that will take up time that could be better spent working on the sim.


Control your greed, so we can fix the old system that was flawed and that little tag at the top that says "Beta" means things can change at any time.
 
atm490
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Suthrner


Control your greed, so we can fix the old system that was flawed and that little tag at the top that says "Beta" means things can change at any time.


So I guess you just read the first paragraph of my post and not the rest. Nice.

It has nothing to do with greed. So what, I was lucky. My point is that the old system was easy and the new system is about to create a HUGE amount of problems DURING the season, which is not something this game needs.

Also, the "Beta" excuse is really cute.
 
Grimareaper
offline
Link
 
I think this is a good idea since endorsments are big thing in any sport,

Why not have team endorsments aswell since teams would make more money which would help players for equipment and also trading for players, the higher the league you are in the higher endorsments you get. Since many teams struggle to pay eqiupment to players and this would help.

Just an extra idea to make it more realistic
 
lump7502
offline
Link
 
so what would be put in place to stop teams from doing this

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_game_log.pl?season=7&player_id=1067922

100% wr screen the last 8 games of the season
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
off topic.
Last edited Feb 27, 2009 08:28:50
 
The Suthrner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lump7502
so what would be put in place to stop teams from doing this

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_game_log.pl?season=7&player_id=1067922

100% wr screen the last 8 games of the season


Looks like their opponents didn't catch on very well but I'll admit as a Defensive coordinator this play is very hard to stop even if you know it coming. They may been exploiting this and the stats were just a by product. A fix is needed: 1) A WR can't block more than one defender or 2) Better pathing for the second CB to run around the WR and CB who are engaged with each other.
 
The Suthrner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atm490
Originally posted by The Suthrner



Control your greed, so we can fix the old system that was flawed and that little tag at the top that says "Beta" means things can change at any time.


So I guess you just read the first paragraph of my post and not the rest. Nice.

It has nothing to do with greed. So what, I was lucky. My point is that the old system was easy and the new system is about to create a HUGE amount of problems DURING the season, which is not something this game needs.

Also, the "Beta" excuse is really cute.


Although this game is not operated like any other Beta game I've seen I still keep the idea in the back of my head.
 
acirema
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atm490
Full disclosure: one of my players received an endorsement. I'm NOT happy that my kicker is about to lose the +2 kicking, +2 confidence, +2 vision, +1 kicking tree that I was promised on Wednesday night, and I don't think that the $600k completely useless in-game cash is a worthy replacement AT ALL, but that has little bearing on my reasoning below.

Here's what I liked about the old system: It was a fun, once-a-season lottery. It was random, very few people won and a lot of people were unhappy: just like a real lottery. Instead of calling it endorsements, just call it the Super Equipment Lottery and move on.

Here's what I don't like about the new system: I have no idea what Bort's original post means at all. Maybe it's because I'm a casual player, but I don't get the tiers, the calculations, etc. I just don't understand it. I don't know if this is something I actively have to work for or something that will just happen.

Above all, it seems like an unnecessary element of the game that the Admins now have to monitor and hear complaints about. The lottery is easy - there are winners, losers, it happens once every off-season, and that's it. The new system is an ongoing thing that will take up time that could be better spent working on the sim.




you got it for free anyways so dont be mad that its being taken away cause they didnt have to give it in the first place
 
atm490
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by acirema

you got it for free anyways so dont be mad that its being taken away cause they didnt have to give it in the first place


Lol... I put the fact that I got an endorsement at the top of my post as a full disclosure clause - that way, people wouldn't discover it later and then consider all of my arguments tainted.

Instead, everyone is just reading about the fact that I got an endorsement and responding accordingly without addressing my actual argument:

The new system will cause a season long headache with constant complaints and "bug" reports. The old system would not, once everyone accepts that it's just a lottery.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.