User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sarg01
Originally posted by Warlock


Not quite. My OT has 35 speed, 56 agility, 64 strength, 62 blocking, 49 vision, 35 confidence and 41 stamina (with a decent selection of SAs). Those are his natural attributes, show me where I neglected anything, as much or more, than any speed rush DE...


I've got a speed DE 11 levels under you that has supposedly-neglected strength greater than your speed. Obviously his support attributes aren't in the same realm being 80-ish skill points behind you, but why can't an argument be made that you've neglected speed?


Could the perception of 'GLB speed' be the problem here? Perhaps I'm wrong but I see speed/agility working in tandem in GLB as trying to emulate the 'speed of the game' relevant to the level of competition you're facing and not speed functioning alone as 40-yd dash timed speed. Anybody else agree?
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
omg and the same guy saying this crap about Freeney.

imo, let's just design GLB based on a Colts homer's ridiculous views of what his team is like.
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock

OTs need... strength, blocking, agility, vision and speed.
DEs need... speed, agility, vision.


DEs need much higher numbers than OTs need. Also, this all assumes the DE doesn't care about run support, for which he does need strength and tackling in which case you're right back to 5:5.

Here's the issue. Most OTs build for run support first. They consider Strength and Blocking their majors (and the game helps support this claim) - but I consider Strength and Agility to be their majors, Blocking and Speed to be their secondaries and Stamina, Confidence and Vision to be their minors. If they build like this, they can get both big pancake numbers AND be a wall against the pass. DEs must specialize, because 2nd-capped spd and agi won't get it done.



 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Azure Dreams
omg and the same guy saying this crap about Freeney.

imo, let's just design GLB based on a Colts homer's ridiculous views of what his team is like.


I already said I was a Texans fan - I used the Colts as an example because 1) we played them yesterday, so it's on my mind and 2) they're far less obstinate about their gameplan than most teams and will change it in a second and 3) I think most NFL fans (even those of us that, like me, hate the Colts) would acknowledge that Manning has a pretty damn good grasp of what the threats to the passing game really are.

Substitute whatever sack specialist you want for Freeney. Substitute whatever NFL OL you want. They all double team elite pass-rushers. They all keep backs in to block at times. None of them are looking for a 20 yard gain on every play like 90% of GLB teams.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sarg01
Originally posted by Azure Dreams

omg and the same guy saying this crap about Freeney.

imo, let's just design GLB based on a Colts homer's ridiculous views of what his team is like.


I already said I was a Texans fan - I used the Colts as an example because 1) we played them yesterday, so it's on my mind and 2) they're far less obstinate about their gameplan than most teams and will change it in a second and 3) I think most NFL fans (even those of us that, like me, hate the Colts) would acknowledge that Manning has a pretty damn good grasp of what the threats to the passing game really are.

Substitute whatever sack specialist you want for Freeney. Substitute whatever NFL OL you want. They all double team elite pass-rushers. They all keep backs in to block at times. None of them are looking for a 20 yard gain on every play like 90% of GLB teams.


No decent GLB OC looks for a 20-yard gain on every play against any team.

The thing is, if you take fairly evenly matched teams (any NFL team against another, for example), even if a team intended to throw 20 yards on 80% of their pass plays and never kept a back in to block, and the opposing front four was really good, then they'd probably give up 6 or 7 sacks, still no more than three to any one player. They'd also give up at least as many hurries as sacks.

That's still a lot of sack damage, and would occur because of a very flawed game plan.

Now, probably 2/3 of GLB matchups are as close as the best NFL teams against the worst, so even in the worst case those matchups should go like that.

Nothing wrong with keeping a back in to block, or having to. I'd do that in real life, and before we got the option to do that in GLB, I took plays out of my team's playbook that had no back in to block. Now I can use them when I force a back to stay in. And there's nothing wrong with mixing screens in and the like.

I don't mind that at all, because I'd do that in real life.

That's my quest for realism, to be able to coach as I would in real life and get the kinds of results that I'd get in real life.
 
uscbucsfan
offline
Link
 
Warlock I didn't see where you said natural...I must have just skimmed over it
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sarg01
Originally posted by Warlock


OTs need... strength, blocking, agility, vision and speed.
DEs need... speed, agility, vision.


DEs need much higher numbers than OTs need. Also, this all assumes the DE doesn't care about run support, for which he does need strength and tackling in which case you're right back to 5:5.

Here's the issue. Most OTs build for run support first. They consider Strength and Blocking their majors (and the game helps support this claim) - but I consider Strength and Agility to be their majors, Blocking and Speed to be their secondaries and Stamina, Confidence and Vision to be their minors. If they build like this, they can get both big pancake numbers AND be a wall against the pass. DEs must specialize, because 2nd-capped spd and agi won't get it done.





Dude, it's simple...

Primary attributes for a DE
Speed and agility

Primary attributes for an OT
Blocking and agility (pass blocking) or Blocking and strength (run blocking)

Secondary attributes for a DE
Vision and tackling

Secondary attributes for an OT
Strength or agility (depending on focus), vision and speed

That's one less attribute that the DE doesn't have to worry about, in the current state of things. So that's probably at least 23 SP more that a DE can spend on whatever they want to. Some even partially neglect tackling and vision, giving even more points to throw into speed and agility.

So while most OTs did in-fact work on strength as a primary, rather than a secondary, it still doesn't mean that it's "alright" for a DE to basically ignore his secondary attributes. DE's that ignored strength are DOMINATING (not just the OT, but the game too)... a sack can completely change the scope of a drive.

Once OTs catch up (because DEs are at 5+ points per increase), DEs will be getting DOMINATED in both the pass and the run. Which will lead to the tables being reversed... neither option is acceptable IMHO. Balance is the key and it doesn't exist atm, all or nothing is the current trend.

If DEs were forced to at least focus on strength a little bit, like OTs have to focus on speed now, things would be a bit more balanced... although, the pathing and blocking system would need tweaking (which is where the primary issue is TBPH). This running right around players is horseshit (especially when it's not just crappy builds).
 
Jdawg2332
offline
Link
 
Don't suck?
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jdawg2332
Don't suck?


lol!
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jdawg2332
Don't suck?


Don't breed?
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 

Originally posted by Warlock
If DEs were forced to at least focus on strength a little bit, like OTs have to focus on speed now, things would be a bit more balanced


My level 23 speed DE would be over the 2nd cap in both speed and agi even if he had diverted enough points to softcap strength.

Originally posted by Warlock
So while most OTs did in-fact work on strength as a primary, rather than a secondary, it still doesn't mean that it's "alright" for a DE to basically ignore his secondary attributes.


An OT that ignores his secondaries can dominate in the run game.

Originally posted by Warlock
Once OTs catch up (because DEs are at 5+ points per increase), DEs will be getting DOMINATED in both the pass and the run.


So are you agreeing with me that DEs don't need a nerf, OTs need to fix their builds, and that even the most broken OT can do this in one season if they boost?





 
lump7502
offline
Link
 
no i dont agree with you de dont run completely around tackle in real life no matter what level and if they tried they just end up running right out of the play
 
Link
 
Originally posted by lump7502
no i dont agree with you de dont run completely around tackle in real life no matter what level and if they tried they just end up running right out of the play


Exactly. If anything, one side on defense is usually overloaded, or have a LB blitzing which will free someone of a block. (then it depends on who the offense keeps in to pick up blitzers, maybe HB's and FB's should be able to pick up blitzers better in this game?) This is what may look like someone is running around someone. If a DE tries this head up on a OT, the OT will gladly keep pushing him further back into the backfield behind the QB. As long as it's not a coverage sack, the DE will run himself out of the play every time just like lump mentioned.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sarg01
My level 23 speed DE would be over the 2nd cap in both speed and agi even if he had diverted enough points to softcap strength.


Kind of like an OT that 2nd caps agility and blocking, with enough left over to soft cap strength? The difference here is that, how good would an OT be with no strength? A DE without strength can still be somewhat effective in the running game, their high agility allows them to shed blocks and make plays (at least a hell of a lot more often then a slow OT can block a speed rush DE).

Originally posted by Sarg01
An OT that ignores his secondaries can dominate in the run game.


Dominate? No. Perform? Yes.

Originally posted by Sarg01
So are you agreeing with me that DEs don't need a nerf, OTs need to fix their builds, and that even the most broken OT can do this in one season if they boost?


No I'm not agreeing with you. Nor am I calling for DEs to be nerfed, this is where you seem to not "get it". I want it balanced, nothing more, nothing less. DEs aren't balanced and due to the shitty blocking/pathing, they're ineffective without this imbalance... although, very shortly they'll be even worse off, because no DE build will be viable to get sacks.

 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Kind of like an OT that 2nd caps agility and blocking, with enough left over to soft cap strength?


I think you significantly overestimate the importance of blocking, I wouldn't consider it a major in either run or pass support. My LT and my RG who has become a RT since he's the only other OL with capped speed on the team both have only 1-capped blocking. My LT was on the league leaderboard for pancakes in Seasons 4 and 5, though more in the 8-10 range.

I guess that's my problem. My LT is dominant in the run game (vs. weak DEs, the subject of this discussion) and pretty good, though not completely Mr. Shutdown, against the pass. This is without TE help, without keeping backs in to block and running mostly medium with the occasional long pass play. Anything that makes him block the pass better at this point would IMO be game-breaking for pass rushers.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.