User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Or how players actually build their guys needs to be taken into consideration before they start dumping mad points in one skill.

We have our winner.

If you deliberately ignore speed, you don't get to bitch about how the sim fucked you over and how horrible the code must be when everybody runs past you, and you certainly don't get to run around accusing people of being ass-kissers when they point out just whose fault it is when it comes down to brass tacks.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
You cant compare a game that happened in 1916 to now. It was 1916!

If low confidence is the reason, why dont lvl 5 QBs throw 10 INT's a game.


because they are playing against lvl 5 cb's? Honestly, you add very little to nothing to this conversation. Isn't it past your bedtime?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by superman8456


You cant compare a game that happened in 1916 to now. It was 1916!

If low confidence is the reason, why dont lvl 5 QBs throw 10 INT's a game.


Because they play against level 4 CBs, cmon now.


But if they throw 1 INTs dont you think it will start to come in masses because the player has low confidence?


Are you being serious? Because if you are, that's scary, if you aren't, then what is your point?

LVL 5 QBs play in DLEAGUE or they should if they plan on getting enough XP, they don't throw 10 INT because the DLEAGUE runs 50/50 run/pass and 98/99 energy, which means if you are on a team with 4 QB it rotates them so you get about 20 snaps etc, that includes the run and pitches so you aren't going to be in a situation where you are passing 50 times like Nashville was
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by superman8456


You cant compare a game that happened in 1916 to now. It was 1916!

If low confidence is the reason, why dont lvl 5 QBs throw 10 INT's a game.


Because they play against level 4 CBs, cmon now.


But if they throw 1 INTs dont you think it will start to come in masses because the player has low confidence?


Not if the CB's suck just as bad because they are low level builds. You are dealing with a shitty QB build throwing at solid CB builds and running into super low morale issues, thus killing his already shitty attributes even more.
 
vrock627
offline
Link
 
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 23:33:46
 
vrock627
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1916_Cumberland_vs._Georgia_Tech_football_game



reminds me of lopsided GLB sims lol
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
You keep ignoring the reality...8 INT's by one QB in a game HAS happened in the NFL before. 9 in NCAA. How many times does this have to be put in your face before you read and comprehend it. These types of games are oddities, but THEY DO HAPPEN.

You are beginning to irritate me. You have pointed out the most extreme oddities in the history of the NFL and college football, yet even those do not equal what happened here. You're arguing that because the unlikeliest games in the history of football ALMOST equaled what happened to Nashville, that it should somehow be acceptable. Last I checked, we're not playing with horseshoes or hand grenades, so you can take your "almost" somewhere else.
Originally posted by
I'm not trying to kiss Bort's ass.

Yes, you clearly are, and it's ok. It's a pretty natural psychological phenomenon for this type of situation.


Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Colts vs Chargers two relatively even teams except the Colts have Peyton Manning. One of the best QB's to play the game in the FA era. And he threw 6 picks in that game.

Do I really need to point out that 6 < 10? If I have to give basic arithmetic lessons in this thread then I don't really think it's worth the effort. And again, nowhere in actual football do you see a horrible game by the quarterback (even if we momentarily overlook the fact that this was a worse performance than any in real history) coupled with such utter futility by a running game, plus absurd domination by the lines. This kind of result should only be possible if a AA team was playing an A team. It's just not remotely realistic, which is a huge problem for a simulation that people obviously expect to produce believable results.
 
Warhawk
Moderator
offline
Link
 
For the record, the QB on Brainerd, in the same conference as Nashville, has thrown 37 interceptions this season, including the first playoff game, in which he threw 4, and no touchdowns.

And Brainerd won that playoff game 27-13, and went 13-2-1 in the regular season.

We beat you 26-3 when he threw 4 picks.

Maybe y'all just need a better team.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by SCACE

You keep ignoring the reality...8 INT's by one QB in a game HAS happened in the NFL before. 9 in NCAA. How many times does this have to be put in your face before you read and comprehend it. These types of games are oddities, but THEY DO HAPPEN.

You are beginning to irritate me. You have pointed out the most extreme oddities in the history of the NFL and college football, yet even those do not equal what happened here. You're arguing that because the unlikeliest games in the history of football ALMOST equaled what happened to Nashville, that it should somehow be acceptable. Last I checked, we're not playing with horseshoes or hand grenades, so you can take your "almost" somewhere else.
Originally posted by

I'm not trying to kiss Bort's ass.

Yes, you clearly are, and it's ok. It's a pretty natural psychological phenomenon for this type of situation.


Originally posted by driftinggrifter

Colts vs Chargers two relatively even teams except the Colts have Peyton Manning. One of the best QB's to play the game in the FA era. And he threw 6 picks in that game.

Do I really need to point out that 6 < 10? If I have to give basic arithmetic lessons in this thread then I don't really think it's worth the effort. And again, nowhere in actual football do you see a horrible game by the quarterback (even if we momentarily overlook the fact that this was a worse performance than any in real history) coupled with such utter futility by a running game, plus absurd domination by the lines. This kind of result should only be possible if a AA team was playing an A team. It's just not remotely realistic, which is a huge problem for a simulation that people obviously expect to produce believable results.


Are you that braindead that you do not realize that there is no way to PULL PLAYERS FOR BAD PERFORMANCE IN GLB, unlike "real life" where those players got pulled, you don't have that luxury in GLB, so 10 picks in GLB is VERY VERY VERY equivalent to 5-6 picks in "real life" but I don't expect you to acknowledge or understand this easy point.
 
superman8456
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by superman8456

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by superman8456



You cant compare a game that happened in 1916 to now. It was 1916!

If low confidence is the reason, why dont lvl 5 QBs throw 10 INT's a game.


Because they play against level 4 CBs, cmon now.


But if they throw 1 INTs dont you think it will start to come in masses because the player has low confidence?


Are you being serious? Because if you are, that's scary, if you aren't, then what is your point?

LVL 5 QBs play in DLEAGUE or they should if they plan on getting enough XP, they don't throw 10 INT because the DLEAGUE runs 50/50 run/pass and 98/99 energy, which means if you are on a team with 4 QB it rotates them so you get about 20 snaps etc, that includes the run and pitches so you aren't going to be in a situation where you are passing 50 times like Nashville was


What about when a team plays a gutted team? You cant blame this solely on confidence. Its important, but you guys are acting like its more important than vision and other attributes.

Just because a CB doesnt put points into catching doesnt mean he wont get INT's. You see DE's with 10 catching get INT's.

Low lvl QBs have low confidence. If confidence is what you're telling me, than QB's should have games like this all the time. Low confidence + 1-2 INT's thrown because of bad build = a 9 INT game because the QB will have low morale?
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
jdbolick - you're irritating basically everyone else on this thread with your nonsense. Do you even realize the number of games that SIM on a daily basis? Or that the starting QB only matched worst college game in history by a QB (Yes, 9 = 9, if you didn't know)?

I've explained what happened, why it happened, and what the fix is from both the player's side and the SIM's side. You're just here being a dick that couldn't tell a pussy from an asshole. Honestly, get a clue.

And your nonsense about pancakes and rushing yards show you have no clue what you are talking about. That just makes it even worse. You at least have a case with the INT's.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Do I really need to point out that 6 < 10? If I have to give basic arithmetic lessons in this thread then I don't really think it's worth the effort. And again, nowhere in actual football do you see a horrible game by the quarterback (even if we momentarily overlook the fact that this was a worse performance than any in real history) coupled with such utter futility by a running game, plus absurd domination by the lines. This kind of result should only be possible if a AA team was playing an A team. It's just not remotely realistic, which is a huge problem for a simulation that people obviously expect to produce believable results.

Peyton Manning would equate to a level 100 quarterback. Why is it not feasible that a quarterback at 25% his level and probably 10% his actual ability, at his very worst, would have 166% as many interceptions as Peyton did at his worst? If anything he should be thanking Bort because he didn't throw 24 INTs, as at least that would match up mathematically.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
superman, for the last time, confidence was the reason for the spiral starting after he threw a couple picks and got sacked 3-4 times early.

You couple that with...

1. A great defense he is throwing into
2. Horrible throwing attribute for his level
3. Horrible strength attribute for his level
4. Only moderate vision for his level, declined by low morale

And you see what you see.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by superman8456


Originally posted by sjmay



Originally posted by superman8456




You cant compare a game that happened in 1916 to now. It was 1916!

If low confidence is the reason, why dont lvl 5 QBs throw 10 INT's a game.


Because they play against level 4 CBs, cmon now.


But if they throw 1 INTs dont you think it will start to come in masses because the player has low confidence?


Are you being serious? Because if you are, that's scary, if you aren't, then what is your point?

LVL 5 QBs play in DLEAGUE or they should if they plan on getting enough XP, they don't throw 10 INT because the DLEAGUE runs 50/50 run/pass and 98/99 energy, which means if you are on a team with 4 QB it rotates them so you get about 20 snaps etc, that includes the run and pitches so you aren't going to be in a situation where you are passing 50 times like Nashville was


What about when a team plays a gutted team? You cant blame this solely on confidence. Its important, but you guys are acting like its more important than vision and other attributes.

Just because a CB doesnt put points into catching doesnt mean he wont get INT's. You see DE's with 10 catching get INT's.

Low lvl QBs have low confidence. If confidence is what you're telling me, than QB's should have games like this all the time. Low confidence + 1-2 INT's thrown because of bad build = a 9 INT game because the QB will have low morale?


Maybe you just don't get it, this QB had LOW strength, LOW confidence, LOW vision, LOW throwing, but he did have high stamina. So in essence, you have a LVL 14-16 QB throwing against, what LVL 23-25 CBs.

With me so far?

So you have that, then you have this same QB throw a pick, drop the low confidence, lower, it affects the oline, and the wr, throw another pick, same thing, now...2 picks is ok right? well he goes and does it again, now he has no confidence along with no vision, no throwing, no strength, but he still has high stamina so he is still playing because there is no way to pull him in GLB, so he throws another, and another, and another, well there you are at six right there, thats ok right, i mean FAvre and Manning have done it, but now, in addition to his having no stats, now his Oline is brutal, and his WR are brutal, so he throws 3 more....because he has high stamina and IS STILL IN THE GAMe.

What is so hard about this to understand??????????????
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
The fact is that one team barely rushed this game, making it hard if not impossible to register pancakes as they were pass blocking the majority of the game.

18 times is not insignificant, but I'm not talking about expecting them to have equal numbers of pancakes. Miami having the edge is reasonable. 23-0 is not reasonable at all. If those types of outcomes are common in GLB, then GLB is guilty of being an inaccurate simulation and not representative of high level organized football.
Originally posted by
Given the increase in rushing this game, 23 is NOT AN ODDITY.

There are two separate issues with this argument. First, you're still seeing a substantial change in the pancake percentages from the first game, both increasing for Miami and decreasing for Nashville, so let's not pretend that they occurred at the same frequency as before even after you adjust for the changes in number of carries. Secondly and more importantly, having that kind of disparity is an inexplicable oddity for actual football. It just wouldn't happen. Now if GLB is not supposed to resemble actual football, then ok, but I was under the impression that it was intended to do so.
Originally posted by
Again, not an oddity.

Here is where your lack of knowledge about football is limiting your understanding. Teams in a blowout facing obvious passing situations don't continue to hold opponents to less than 1 yard per carry. It doesn't happen in actual football. Defenses may have great success early on in neutralizing a team's running attack, but they won't continue to stone them for less than 1 yard per carry when they're expecting the pass.
Originally posted by
The only oddity is the INT's, which I've explained both the problem and the fix. You just keep ignoring it.

Me failing to accept an irrational excuse is not ignoring you. I'm acknowledging what you've said and explaining why it's invalid. Moreover, you have yet to admit that you can't give any example of a game in reality where something like this actually happened. You've come up with examples that came close in one aspect or another, but not one that fully met these circumstances. You can't because it does not happen in reality.


Look, I am not an expert on Goal Line Blitz, but I am an expert on football. I can definitively tell you what is and what is absolutely not a reasonable result. This game unquestionably falls with the latter.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.