User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > A WPL WITHOUT MM-OFGand WW IS BS
Page:
 
xcoach2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Originally posted by Joebarber

current format is good, it will all get worked out in the long run




Does GLB have a "long run?"
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
As far as things getting 'worked out in the long run', my question then is this:

How will it get worked out?

I mean, let's assume the 4 playoff conference finalists from each league go up. How is this going to change next season? Or are we ditching one system (the everyone gets 4 teams) for the next after one season? In that case, why even bother putting the crappy teams up there to begin with.

Just let the two league title finalists (16 teams) get autobids, then have 16 more wild cards.


I mean the idea that Bort will start with 4 teams per region, but let them relegate out without replacement after one season is utterly foolish.


Honestly, I see that as the best option.

* Take the 16 league championship participants. Remove the teams that are gutting, replace them with they beat in the conference championship, if that team is gutting as well, take the other conference championship particpant.

* Fill the 16 wild cards with the Final Four (or Elite 8) from the PWT and Hazy's tourneys and the top ranked teams according to the GLB Top Pro Teams poll and the LARS system.

Simple. No muss, no fuss.

This leaves all regions with at least two participants in the WPL. Every season, relegate the 16 teams that don't make the playoffs and promote the league championship participants.
 
Dudeamis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Firenze
Originally posted by tdm13

if they lost in the format, they don't deserve to go imo. Should have won their semi if they were that good :|




 
Joebarber
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
I mean, to me there's two system options that make sense.

1) the system that puts the best 32 teams in the league - region regardless
2) the system that flips the conference finalists each and every year, previous results in World League regardless.

If it's 2, then ok, but anything other then 2(that starts out as a 2) is simply wasteful. We already know which conference finalists suck.


except for the fact that for option 1 there is not a current system in place to decide who are the best 32 teams are.
 
Link
 
The best 32 teams?

GLB + BCS = 5000 page bitchtastic thread of d00m.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
I think Islander distills the argument very clearly.

Is the World League to be...

1) The best teams in GLB every year as represented by the best of every region, although some regions may be more represented than others.
2) The 4 conference finalists from each region.

1 and 2 are very different leagues.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joebarber
Originally posted by islander1

I mean, to me there's two system options that make sense.

1) the system that puts the best 32 teams in the league - region regardless
2) the system that flips the conference finalists each and every year, previous results in World League regardless.

If it's 2, then ok, but anything other then 2(that starts out as a 2) is simply wasteful. We already know which conference finalists suck.


except for the fact that for option 1 there is not a current system in place to decide who are the best 32 teams are.


Sure there is. Results from tournaments, primarily, secondarily strength of league.
You'll get some arguments from the bubble teams for sure...but the top 20 teams are no brainers.

edit: note this doesn't even factor in rankings systems currently in place (which of course, could be included, but I'm choosing not to). So no 'BCS'. You think your OPL/SEAPL/whatever not USAPL/CPL team is legit. Don't get beat by 30 in the second round of tournaments.
Edited by islander1 on Jul 27, 2009 08:16:30
 
Joebarber
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Joebarber

Originally posted by islander1


I mean, to me there's two system options that make sense.

1) the system that puts the best 32 teams in the league - region regardless
2) the system that flips the conference finalists each and every year, previous results in World League regardless.

If it's 2, then ok, but anything other then 2(that starts out as a 2) is simply wasteful. We already know which conference finalists suck.


except for the fact that for option 1 there is not a current system in place to decide who are the best 32 teams are.


Sure there is. Results from tournaments, primarily, secondarily strength of league.
You'll get some arguments from the bubble teams for sure...but the top 20 teams are no brainers.


Not accurate really. Not all top teams compete in tourneys and this seasons tourneys had skewed results because of the mentor glitching. Also who gets to decide strength of league? It's all subjective...
With the current system everything will be worked out after 2-3 seasons, the conferences with strong teams will be able to keep teams in the WPL while the weak conferences will always just have their 4 newly promoted ones.

 
Joebarber
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1

You think your OPL/SEAPL/whatever not USAPL/CPL team is legit. Don't get beat by 30 in the second round of tournaments.


wat
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joebarber
With the current system everything will be worked out after 2-3 seasons, the conferences with strong teams will be able to keep teams in the WPL while the weak conferences will always just have their 4 newly promoted ones.


Why should weak conferences be guaranteed 4 slots in the world league? I'd say they shouldn't. You make it sound like conferences whose teams stick in the WPL will never send more up to the WPL. It shouldn't have to be one goes down, one goes up.

* demote the 16 teams that missed the playoffs, regardless of conference.
* promote the 16 conference champions.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joebarber
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by Joebarber


Originally posted by islander1



I mean, to me there's two system options that make sense.

1) the system that puts the best 32 teams in the league - region regardless
2) the system that flips the conference finalists each and every year, previous results in World League regardless.

If it's 2, then ok, but anything other then 2(that starts out as a 2) is simply wasteful. We already know which conference finalists suck.


except for the fact that for option 1 there is not a current system in place to decide who are the best 32 teams are.


Sure there is. Results from tournaments, primarily, secondarily strength of league.
You'll get some arguments from the bubble teams for sure...but the top 20 teams are no brainers.


Not accurate really. Not all top teams compete in tourneys and this seasons tourneys had skewed results because of the mentor glitching. Also who gets to decide strength of league? It's all subjective...
With the current system everything will be worked out after 2-3 seasons, the conferences with strong teams will be able to keep teams in the WPL while the weak conferences will always just have their 4 newly promoted ones.



Pretty much all the best Pro teams compete in the PWT. Even teams like the Benitos. The only team I know of that refused to bother with the PWT was the Green Bay Maulers.

It's VERY accurate. A system that gives every league 4 teams is just going to make for a joke of a first season. We all know half of the USAPL teams can drill the vast majority of the 'promoting' teams not from north america.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Joebarber
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by Joebarber


Originally posted by islander1



I mean, to me there's two system options that make sense.

1) the system that puts the best 32 teams in the league - region regardless
2) the system that flips the conference finalists each and every year, previous results in World League regardless.

If it's 2, then ok, but anything other then 2(that starts out as a 2) is simply wasteful. We already know which conference finalists suck.


except for the fact that for option 1 there is not a current system in place to decide who are the best 32 teams are.


Sure there is. Results from tournaments, primarily, secondarily strength of league.
You'll get some arguments from the bubble teams for sure...but the top 20 teams are no brainers.


Not accurate really. Not all top teams compete in tourneys and this seasons tourneys had skewed results because of the mentor glitching. Also who gets to decide strength of league? It's all subjective...
With the current system everything will be worked out after 2-3 seasons, the conferences with strong teams will be able to keep teams in the WPL while the weak conferences will always just have their 4 newly promoted ones.



The four team thing is likely a one-time deal to fill out the league. Otherwise you'd be relegating the entire league after each season.

I suspect only one team from each pro league will advance to the WPL starting next season. That would leave 8 teams being relegated (25% of the league). 2 teams advancing each season would mean anyone not making the playoffs would get kicked off the island, which seems a little much.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joebarber
Originally posted by islander1


You think your OPL/SEAPL/whatever not USAPL/CPL team is legit. Don't get beat by 30 in the second round of tournaments.


wat


edit:never mind, I thought initially you were making a case for your own team
Edited by islander1 on Jul 27, 2009 08:26:49
 
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Joebarber

Originally posted by islander1


Originally posted by Joebarber



Originally posted by islander1




I mean, to me there's two system options that make sense.

1) the system that puts the best 32 teams in the league - region regardless
2) the system that flips the conference finalists each and every year, previous results in World League regardless.

If it's 2, then ok, but anything other then 2(that starts out as a 2) is simply wasteful. We already know which conference finalists suck.


except for the fact that for option 1 there is not a current system in place to decide who are the best 32 teams are.


Sure there is. Results from tournaments, primarily, secondarily strength of league.
You'll get some arguments from the bubble teams for sure...but the top 20 teams are no brainers.


Not accurate really. Not all top teams compete in tourneys and this seasons tourneys had skewed results because of the mentor glitching. Also who gets to decide strength of league? It's all subjective...
With the current system everything will be worked out after 2-3 seasons, the conferences with strong teams will be able to keep teams in the WPL while the weak conferences will always just have their 4 newly promoted ones.



Pretty much all the best Pro teams compete in the PWT. Even teams like the Benitos. The only team I know of that refused to bother with the PWT was the Green Bay Maulers.

It's VERY accurate. A system that gives every league 4 teams is just going to make for a joke of a first season. We all know half of the USAPL teams can drill the vast majority of the 'promoting' teams not from north america.


I imagine some teams would have paid *much* more attention to the PWT if they had been told it would affect their team's chances to be promoted.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PatricktheDookie

I suspect only one team from each pro league will advance to the WPL starting next season. That would leave 8 teams being relegated (25% of the league). 2 teams advancing each season would mean anyone not making the playoffs would get kicked off the island, which seems a little much.


So, if only one team advances from each league each season, how exactly would "things work out" in a season or two?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.