I think the key here is to make sure the endorsements do not provide too overpowering a bonus. The idea of an MVP race is fun, but we don't want to see the endorsement provide such a powerful effect (as some of the already awarded ones did) that the next year the MVP race would be a blowout, because of the endorsement. I think they should be primarily status items that are sought after as a special thing, not a massive in-game bonus. In my opinion, if they gave a player money, the status of getting one, and some temporary stat points or even temporary veteran ability points, that would be enough, and wouldn't be game-breaking.
Forum > Suggestions > Endorsements - What I am thinking
Malachorn
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
1. We come up with a MVP calculation. Base it on the current "top threats" calculations, combined with the fame value. Since you don't gain much, if any, fame from playing gutted teams, it will help to balance out the formula.
Was it discussed at all what exactly this means and how it would be "combined with the fame value?"
If a player's previous fame is factored in then that would benefit any players that were moving to lower leagues probably, IMO.
If a player's previous fame is NOT factored in then won't we still be rewarding players on the best teams?
What is the benefit of factoring in fame then?!?!?
1. We come up with a MVP calculation. Base it on the current "top threats" calculations, combined with the fame value. Since you don't gain much, if any, fame from playing gutted teams, it will help to balance out the formula.
Was it discussed at all what exactly this means and how it would be "combined with the fame value?"
If a player's previous fame is factored in then that would benefit any players that were moving to lower leagues probably, IMO.
If a player's previous fame is NOT factored in then won't we still be rewarding players on the best teams?
What is the benefit of factoring in fame then?!?!?
Luckeroll
offline
offline
Originally posted by seayjoel
One thing i'd' like to see is for local endorsements in lower leagues take the suggested levels for leagues like BBB and A and either 1) Throw them out the window and get rid of suggested levels altogether 2) Change the formula alot to make it so slow build/CPU teams have reduced effect. Now I think this because you just can't compete in an uncapped league with players that are in the suggested levels. I mean just to give you an example USA from my own tier USA BBB 14 has a max suggested cap of 23 now IMO that's ridiculous someone is going to get promoted from there however the best team there probably can't find players because the suggested levels are so low.
Now just an example from my own league that I own a team in. In USA BBB #10 the max suggested cap is 31. Mostly because
1) the eastern conference sucks and always has.
2) slow build teams in both conferences take the median way down.
Big picture is because of those reasons the suggested levels are so low it hurts teams that want to compete like mine and some others in my conference playing with our current roster were probably looking at a 14-2 or 13-3 record if we had to play with in the suggested levels we'd probably finish about like 8-8. I mean there are about 8-9 teams that want to compete this year and the other 21-22 screw the cap.
Also get rid of suggested levels in capped leagues. Last year there were a lot of players in East Europe BBB that missed out on endorsements this year because they were outside the cap which was low last year I mean if there is no way to sign players outside the cap so why penalize the best players that are boosting?
+1
One thing i'd' like to see is for local endorsements in lower leagues take the suggested levels for leagues like BBB and A and either 1) Throw them out the window and get rid of suggested levels altogether 2) Change the formula alot to make it so slow build/CPU teams have reduced effect. Now I think this because you just can't compete in an uncapped league with players that are in the suggested levels. I mean just to give you an example USA from my own tier USA BBB 14 has a max suggested cap of 23 now IMO that's ridiculous someone is going to get promoted from there however the best team there probably can't find players because the suggested levels are so low.
Now just an example from my own league that I own a team in. In USA BBB #10 the max suggested cap is 31. Mostly because
1) the eastern conference sucks and always has.
2) slow build teams in both conferences take the median way down.
Big picture is because of those reasons the suggested levels are so low it hurts teams that want to compete like mine and some others in my conference playing with our current roster were probably looking at a 14-2 or 13-3 record if we had to play with in the suggested levels we'd probably finish about like 8-8. I mean there are about 8-9 teams that want to compete this year and the other 21-22 screw the cap.
Also get rid of suggested levels in capped leagues. Last year there were a lot of players in East Europe BBB that missed out on endorsements this year because they were outside the cap which was low last year I mean if there is no way to sign players outside the cap so why penalize the best players that are boosting?
+1
Schaffer05
offline
offline
This is a lot better for an idea. Just kind of wondering why this wasn't put up prior to actually being released to the community? Having this put into the Test server prior to being here should have brought up some of these issues.
Has anybody suggested giving flex points as compensation for those who are having endorsements taken away?
Capaneus
offline
offline
Originally posted by Gart888
Has anybody suggested giving flex points as compensation for those who are having endorsements taken away?
TBH, I'd favor that over bonus tokens. It has been suggested, though. Don't know if Bort saw, though.
Has anybody suggested giving flex points as compensation for those who are having endorsements taken away?
TBH, I'd favor that over bonus tokens. It has been suggested, though. Don't know if Bort saw, though.
Originally posted by Capaneus
Originally posted by Gart888
Has anybody suggested giving flex points as compensation for those who are having endorsements taken away?
TBH, I'd favor that over bonus tokens. It has been suggested, though. Don't know if Bort saw, though.
Yup, it seems like the best choice to me. Keep those who are losing their endorsements happy, while not giving them an in-game suggestion. I'd say 1000 flex sounds about fair.
Originally posted by Gart888
Has anybody suggested giving flex points as compensation for those who are having endorsements taken away?
TBH, I'd favor that over bonus tokens. It has been suggested, though. Don't know if Bort saw, though.
Yup, it seems like the best choice to me. Keep those who are losing their endorsements happy, while not giving them an in-game suggestion. I'd say 1000 flex sounds about fair.
Mightyhalo
offline
offline
Originally posted by Capaneus
Originally posted by Gart888
Has anybody suggested giving flex points as compensation for those who are having endorsements taken away?
TBH, I'd favor that over bonus tokens. It has been suggested, though. Don't know if Bort saw, though.
I don't see why he would give out extra. He already said you will keep the cash. He announced this the morning after he ran the script so it's not like you didn't have any warning.
If anything, just throw them a couple shopping tokens, bonus tokens seems to be a little too generous.
Originally posted by Gart888
Has anybody suggested giving flex points as compensation for those who are having endorsements taken away?
TBH, I'd favor that over bonus tokens. It has been suggested, though. Don't know if Bort saw, though.
I don't see why he would give out extra. He already said you will keep the cash. He announced this the morning after he ran the script so it's not like you didn't have any warning.
If anything, just throw them a couple shopping tokens, bonus tokens seems to be a little too generous.
butler312
offline
offline
Originally posted by Gart888
Originally posted by Capaneus
Originally posted by Gart888
Has anybody suggested giving flex points as compensation for those who are having endorsements taken away?
TBH, I'd favor that over bonus tokens. It has been suggested, though. Don't know if Bort saw, though.
Yup, it seems like the best choice to me. Keep those who are losing their endorsements happy, while not giving them an in-game suggestion. I'd say 1000 flex sounds about fair.
I'd be happy with that. I just really hope it isn't cash, because cash is useless from an individual standpoint in this game.
Originally posted by Capaneus
Originally posted by Gart888
Has anybody suggested giving flex points as compensation for those who are having endorsements taken away?
TBH, I'd favor that over bonus tokens. It has been suggested, though. Don't know if Bort saw, though.
Yup, it seems like the best choice to me. Keep those who are losing their endorsements happy, while not giving them an in-game suggestion. I'd say 1000 flex sounds about fair.
I'd be happy with that. I just really hope it isn't cash, because cash is useless from an individual standpoint in this game.
Veg
offline
offline
LOL@giving flex because an endorsement got taken away. Keep the cash behappy you even got that much.
Cash is stilluseful for those who are getting to the big boy upgrades on team who havent been in the pro's since this started.
Cash is stilluseful for those who are getting to the big boy upgrades on team who havent been in the pro's since this started.
Last edited Feb 27, 2009 07:43:56
Capaneus
offline
offline
Originally posted by Gart888
Yup, it seems like the best choice to me. Keep those who are losing their endorsements happy, while not giving them an in-game suggestion. I'd say 1000 flex sounds about fair.
Wow, not sure if you're serious. I was thinking 100-200 flex. It's not like you were going to get to keep the endorse EQ for more than one season. Not you specifically, but some of the stuff people are asking for, I hope he lets them keep the endorse EQ before he starts handing out treats like that.
Yup, it seems like the best choice to me. Keep those who are losing their endorsements happy, while not giving them an in-game suggestion. I'd say 1000 flex sounds about fair.
Wow, not sure if you're serious. I was thinking 100-200 flex. It's not like you were going to get to keep the endorse EQ for more than one season. Not you specifically, but some of the stuff people are asking for, I hope he lets them keep the endorse EQ before he starts handing out treats like that.
Drew Brees
offline
offline
This all comes down to a bunch of people whining cause they didn't get there way. If any one of the whiners on here would have gotten an endorsement they would be on the other side of the argument. Just leave the people who got them be and fix it and have the system right for next season. Why go and take away what was already given? That's a horrible idea. Whiney Babys on here are ridiculous. Grow a pair and move on.
Capaneus
offline
offline
Originally posted by Saints4Life08
This all comes down to a bunch of people whining cause they didn't get there way. If any one of the whiners on here would have gotten an endorsement they would be on the other side of the argument. Just leave the people who got them be and fix it and have the system right for next season. Why go and take away what was already given? That's a horrible idea. Whiney Babys on here are ridiculous. Grow a pair and move on.
By the same token, thinking you're entitled to an endorsement when you won it in an RNG lottery is a bit silly. But, as I said, I have no endorsements, and if Bort lets people keep them for this season, that's fine with me, as long as he continues to improve the system.
This all comes down to a bunch of people whining cause they didn't get there way. If any one of the whiners on here would have gotten an endorsement they would be on the other side of the argument. Just leave the people who got them be and fix it and have the system right for next season. Why go and take away what was already given? That's a horrible idea. Whiney Babys on here are ridiculous. Grow a pair and move on.
By the same token, thinking you're entitled to an endorsement when you won it in an RNG lottery is a bit silly. But, as I said, I have no endorsements, and if Bort lets people keep them for this season, that's fine with me, as long as he continues to improve the system.
Last edited Feb 27, 2009 08:04:50
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























