User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > whats the deal with casual teams, cap?
Page:
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MeatBomb
One problem I keep seeing. For the Trading/Collusion thing.

Just set up a bar that would disallow an owner from trading between teams he owns. Sure it can be done along the same lines as the whole non-tradeclause/level cap thing in the code. Wouldn't eliminate all problems associated but would eliminate many. It'll be imperfect either way.

Also, I really like LT's idea with a bit of a twist. Set the leagues up in a ladder each season based on average levels and adjust the cap based simply on league average + X levels. Like if the league average was 17, cap it at 22 or 23. If the league average was 8, cap it at 13 or 14. Each league in the "ladder" has a different cap and teams are moved every season based on their level average either up or down the ladder. The higher league can even have low end caps and of course the top league will be unlimited.

But to do all of this, you'd have to first have a first season, and I think an opening cap of 17 or 25 would be fine.

Please don't eliminate the stadium or finances/equipment. I'd rather see you do something novel like institute a no-trade clause on EVERY contract before you eliminate the finance part of the game.


learning how to manage the stadium and finances is almost as important (maybe more) as all the play calling and such
 
MeatBomb
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GarrettFoster
Originally posted by MeatBomb

One problem I keep seeing. For the Trading/Collusion thing.

Just set up a bar that would disallow an owner from trading between teams he owns. Sure it can be done along the same lines as the whole non-tradeclause/level cap thing in the code. Wouldn't eliminate all problems associated but would eliminate many. It'll be imperfect either way.

Also, I really like LT's idea with a bit of a twist. Set the leagues up in a ladder each season based on average levels and adjust the cap based simply on league average + X levels. Like if the league average was 17, cap it at 22 or 23. If the league average was 8, cap it at 13 or 14. Each league in the "ladder" has a different cap and teams are moved every season based on their level average either up or down the ladder. The higher league can even have low end caps and of course the top league will be unlimited.

But to do all of this, you'd have to first have a first season, and I think an opening cap of 17 or 25 would be fine.

Please don't eliminate the stadium or finances/equipment. I'd rather see you do something novel like institute a no-trade clause on EVERY contract before you eliminate the finance part of the game.


Bort already said trades between teams for cash can't happen.


I understand that, but I also don't really see no need to trade three level 22 punters for some level 34 skill players with great builds. That counts as collusion too.

 
BarrySwitzer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Maybe we should just make them 13 capped?

I could make different cap levels, too, I suppose, and just let you choose with a dropdown like the new option on buy team.


I would like to see a 22-30 cap. It seems to be no mans land right now. You go from 13 to 21 then 40's in order to compete.
 
MeatBomb
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by reddogrw
Originally posted by MeatBomb

One problem I keep seeing. For the Trading/Collusion thing.

Just set up a bar that would disallow an owner from trading between teams he owns. Sure it can be done along the same lines as the whole non-tradeclause/level cap thing in the code. Wouldn't eliminate all problems associated but would eliminate many. It'll be imperfect either way.

Also, I really like LT's idea with a bit of a twist. Set the leagues up in a ladder each season based on average levels and adjust the cap based simply on league average + X levels. Like if the league average was 17, cap it at 22 or 23. If the league average was 8, cap it at 13 or 14. Each league in the "ladder" has a different cap and teams are moved every season based on their level average either up or down the ladder. The higher league can even have low end caps and of course the top league will be unlimited.

But to do all of this, you'd have to first have a first season, and I think an opening cap of 17 or 25 would be fine.

Please don't eliminate the stadium or finances/equipment. I'd rather see you do something novel like institute a no-trade clause on EVERY contract before you eliminate the finance part of the game.


learning how to manage the stadium and finances is almost as important (maybe more) as all the play calling and such


Agree 100%. finances and stadium building, ticket prices, equipment and contract management is one of the keys to ownership.

 
sorelion
offline
Link
 
I think lvl 13 capped to start is reasonable, but permacap I dont like at all.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
Originally posted by dansingingfool

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by britdevine316



Originally posted by britdevine316
I like

0-16
16-25
26-34
Uncapped




But then each season reconfigure the teams based on team level for competitive play


And also maybe even 9 team leagues, play each team twice to develop rivalry, the worst team doesn't make the playoffs


So no promotion/relegation - you just get reshuffled every season? Hmm...I dunno, it removes some of the "striving for the top" element of the game, and leaves NO opportunity for rivalries at all. Also, not all like leveled teams are perfectly equal. They are generally similar, but some just tend to try a bit harder than others.


True, everyone will never be equal. You can try to win your league, for one. And you can spend hours to recruit, to up your level, or you cannot to remain where you are. Day -4 or something they get shuffled. If you are not out of line with your current league's average level, no moving. That would be fun I think.

Although I do like the familiar faces year after year, moving up and seeing some old foes.....hmm.


The whole point of casual league is to enjoy the game, while not taking it to far complexity wise.

The league caps + a restructure every season will always be the best choice to keep the leagues somewhat competitive year in year out no matter what level players join.

GLB as a whole needs a complete restructure, but there would be to many complaints for it to ever work.

But start it off in the new casual league, let people get used to it, and you will find out you should have done this from the start, I can guarantee it.


The reason we don't have the permacaps and a much larger disparity in league revenue (we really wanted to do that in the first place) is complaining. I agree that if we try something new and it works well, it will be much easier to convince the masses that it's OK to try and adapt it to existing structures.

I guess the real question is where to start with it. There's currently ~ 500 people on the list. That's about 16 leagues if we do 32 team leagues. We could do something like:

8 leagues capped at 16, call them BBB for now
8 leagues capped at 26, call them A for now

We figure out how to reorganize them at season end, whether it's in a pyramid, or through a shuffle, etc over the next couple weeks, adding new CPU teams to fill holes, etc. We could even put it to a poll.

That allows us to get the teams started, people playing with them, and come up with a good plan that works.

I don't think most owners would care too much about what happens as long as they don't lose anything in the deal and get to play competitive games in the end.

An idea at least.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


The reason we don't have the permacaps and a much larger disparity in league revenue (we really wanted to do that in the first place) is complaining. I agree that if we try something new and it works well, it will be much easier to convince the masses that it's OK to try and adapt it to existing structures.

I guess the real question is where to start with it. There's currently ~ 500 people on the list. That's about 16 leagues if we do 32 team leagues. We could do something like:

8 leagues capped at 16, call them BBB for now
8 leagues capped at 26, call them A for now

We figure out how to reorganize them at season end, whether it's in a pyramid, or through a shuffle, etc over the next couple weeks, adding new CPU teams to fill holes, etc. We could even put it to a poll.

That allows us to get the teams started, people playing with them, and come up with a good plan that works.

I don't think most owners would care too much about what happens as long as they don't lose anything in the deal and get to play competitive games in the end.

An idea at least.


This sounds great. You have to start somewhere, and adjust from there with what works, what doesn't, and what people would like to see.

Alright, give me a team, let's do this.
 
seirus
offline
Link
 
get it done!
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by britdevine316

Originally posted by dansingingfool


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by britdevine316




Originally posted by britdevine316
I like

0-16
16-25
26-34
Uncapped




But then each season reconfigure the teams based on team level for competitive play


And also maybe even 9 team leagues, play each team twice to develop rivalry, the worst team doesn't make the playoffs


So no promotion/relegation - you just get reshuffled every season? Hmm...I dunno, it removes some of the "striving for the top" element of the game, and leaves NO opportunity for rivalries at all. Also, not all like leveled teams are perfectly equal. They are generally similar, but some just tend to try a bit harder than others.


True, everyone will never be equal. You can try to win your league, for one. And you can spend hours to recruit, to up your level, or you cannot to remain where you are. Day -4 or something they get shuffled. If you are not out of line with your current league's average level, no moving. That would be fun I think.

Although I do like the familiar faces year after year, moving up and seeing some old foes.....hmm.


The whole point of casual league is to enjoy the game, while not taking it to far complexity wise.

The league caps + a restructure every season will always be the best choice to keep the leagues somewhat competitive year in year out no matter what level players join.

GLB as a whole needs a complete restructure, but there would be to many complaints for it to ever work.

But start it off in the new casual league, let people get used to it, and you will find out you should have done this from the start, I can guarantee it.


The reason we don't have the permacaps and a much larger disparity in league revenue (we really wanted to do that in the first place) is complaining. I agree that if we try something new and it works well, it will be much easier to convince the masses that it's OK to try and adapt it to existing structures.

I guess the real question is where to start with it. There's currently ~ 500 people on the list. That's about 16 leagues if we do 32 team leagues. We could do something like:

8 leagues capped at 16, call them BBB for now
8 leagues capped at 26, call them A for now

We figure out how to reorganize them at season end, whether it's in a pyramid, or through a shuffle, etc over the next couple weeks, adding new CPU teams to fill holes, etc. We could even put it to a poll.

That allows us to get the teams started, people playing with them, and come up with a good plan that works.

I don't think most owners would care too much about what happens as long as they don't lose anything in the deal and get to play competitive games in the end.

An idea at least.


could you look at 4 8-team divisions?

this is a good way to test a few things

also, your higher capped leagues should be like 14-26 - no new FA signings out of that range - see how "hard" caps work
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
but fix the league and level cap issue for regular teams

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2059251
 
Kunou
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


The reason we don't have the permacaps and a much larger disparity in league revenue (we really wanted to do that in the first place) is complaining. I agree that if we try something new and it works well, it will be much easier to convince the masses that it's OK to try and adapt it to existing structures.

I guess the real question is where to start with it. There's currently ~ 500 people on the list. That's about 16 leagues if we do 32 team leagues. We could do something like:

8 leagues capped at 16, call them BBB for now
8 leagues capped at 26, call them A for now

We figure out how to reorganize them at season end, whether it's in a pyramid, or through a shuffle, etc over the next couple weeks, adding new CPU teams to fill holes, etc. We could even put it to a poll.

That allows us to get the teams started, people playing with them, and come up with a good plan that works.

I don't think most owners would care too much about what happens as long as they don't lose anything in the deal and get to play competitive games in the end.

An idea at least.


I like this idea, combined with LT's scrambling idea...

The 2 leagues you mentioned above Bort, at the end of the season, scramble them up based on level across the board. Top 256 teams in the top league, bottom 256 in the other. No other/standard form of promotion/demotion. Start with that, see how it works and go from there.
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by britdevine316

Originally posted by dansingingfool


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by britdevine316




Originally posted by britdevine316
I like

0-16
16-25
26-34
Uncapped




But then each season reconfigure the teams based on team level for competitive play


And also maybe even 9 team leagues, play each team twice to develop rivalry, the worst team doesn't make the playoffs


So no promotion/relegation - you just get reshuffled every season? Hmm...I dunno, it removes some of the "striving for the top" element of the game, and leaves NO opportunity for rivalries at all. Also, not all like leveled teams are perfectly equal. They are generally similar, but some just tend to try a bit harder than others.


True, everyone will never be equal. You can try to win your league, for one. And you can spend hours to recruit, to up your level, or you cannot to remain where you are. Day -4 or something they get shuffled. If you are not out of line with your current league's average level, no moving. That would be fun I think.

Although I do like the familiar faces year after year, moving up and seeing some old foes.....hmm.


The whole point of casual league is to enjoy the game, while not taking it to far complexity wise.

The league caps + a restructure every season will always be the best choice to keep the leagues somewhat competitive year in year out no matter what level players join.

GLB as a whole needs a complete restructure, but there would be to many complaints for it to ever work.

But start it off in the new casual league, let people get used to it, and you will find out you should have done this from the start, I can guarantee it.


The reason we don't have the permacaps and a much larger disparity in league revenue (we really wanted to do that in the first place) is complaining. I agree that if we try something new and it works well, it will be much easier to convince the masses that it's OK to try and adapt it to existing structures.

I guess the real question is where to start with it. There's currently ~ 500 people on the list. That's about 16 leagues if we do 32 team leagues. We could do something like:

8 leagues capped at 16, call them BBB for now
8 leagues capped at 26, call them A for now

We figure out how to reorganize them at season end, whether it's in a pyramid, or through a shuffle, etc over the next couple weeks, adding new CPU teams to fill holes, etc. We could even put it to a poll.

That allows us to get the teams started, people playing with them, and come up with a good plan that works.

I don't think most owners would care too much about what happens as long as they don't lose anything in the deal and get to play competitive games in the end.

An idea at least.


I wouldn't do all 500, I'd start with 256 at the max and even that is pushing it. Don't make it too big that it grows too fast before you have a plan.

And I still think a 9 team league is the way to go
Last edited Feb 12, 2009 20:33:24
 
Kunou
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by britdevine316


Originally posted by dansingingfool



Originally posted by Bort




Originally posted by britdevine316





Originally posted by britdevine316
I like

0-16
16-25
26-34
Uncapped




But then each season reconfigure the teams based on team level for competitive play


And also maybe even 9 team leagues, play each team twice to develop rivalry, the worst team doesn't make the playoffs


So no promotion/relegation - you just get reshuffled every season? Hmm...I dunno, it removes some of the "striving for the top" element of the game, and leaves NO opportunity for rivalries at all. Also, not all like leveled teams are perfectly equal. They are generally similar, but some just tend to try a bit harder than others.


True, everyone will never be equal. You can try to win your league, for one. And you can spend hours to recruit, to up your level, or you cannot to remain where you are. Day -4 or something they get shuffled. If you are not out of line with your current league's average level, no moving. That would be fun I think.

Although I do like the familiar faces year after year, moving up and seeing some old foes.....hmm.


The whole point of casual league is to enjoy the game, while not taking it to far complexity wise.

The league caps + a restructure every season will always be the best choice to keep the leagues somewhat competitive year in year out no matter what level players join.

GLB as a whole needs a complete restructure, but there would be to many complaints for it to ever work.

But start it off in the new casual league, let people get used to it, and you will find out you should have done this from the start, I can guarantee it.


The reason we don't have the permacaps and a much larger disparity in league revenue (we really wanted to do that in the first place) is complaining. I agree that if we try something new and it works well, it will be much easier to convince the masses that it's OK to try and adapt it to existing structures.

I guess the real question is where to start with it. There's currently ~ 500 people on the list. That's about 16 leagues if we do 32 team leagues. We could do something like:

8 leagues capped at 16, call them BBB for now
8 leagues capped at 26, call them A for now

We figure out how to reorganize them at season end, whether it's in a pyramid, or through a shuffle, etc over the next couple weeks, adding new CPU teams to fill holes, etc. We could even put it to a poll.

That allows us to get the teams started, people playing with them, and come up with a good plan that works.

I don't think most owners would care too much about what happens as long as they don't lose anything in the deal and get to play competitive games in the end.

An idea at least.


I wouldn't do all 500, I'd start with 256 at the max and even that is pushing it. Don't make it too big that it grows too fast before you have a plan.


Hey, I'm 400+ here, quit trying to rub me out!
 
WildBill76
offline
Link
 
I think a level 24 perma cap league would be the best result.
 
GarrettFoster
offline
Link
 
I'm not diggin the scrambling thing for a casual league. That promotes the best recruiters and not the best teams. Recruiting is one of the things that takes a long time and time is what we are trying to minimize with this league.

In essence scrambling would be against the spirit of a casual league.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.