User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Kira

Carrying has a much larger impact than strength in fumbling. If your personal results are different, it's because of a number of things mainly competition, energy and morale.


The formula for deciding if you hang on to the ball would agree with you.


Stats would argue against it Bort. And I'm sure I've got some supporters that are aware of it as well.
 
Snipeshow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Kira

Carrying has a much larger impact than strength in fumbling. If your personal results are different, it's because of a number of things mainly competition, energy and morale.


The formula for deciding if you hang on to the ball would agree with you.


 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by Iceman16


Originally posted by Ken1



Bort made a mistake in scaling back breaking tackles before. All that happened is it allowed people to go back to Speed, Speed, Speed.

Basically, a good meter is that if your Speed + Agility > Strength + Tackling, you should not be able to consistently tackle power backs. People should have to train LBs' Strength and Tackling close to how they train CBs' Speed and Agility. That's much more like football.

There should be no number that consistently (meaning 90% or something) tackles someone who's gone all out as a power back (unless you went all out on stopping them, like 90 Tackling and 80 Strength), but you should do a very good job if, say, Strength and Tackling are second capped and you have most of your equipment in Tackling.

Bort needs to stand his ground here. No more Speed-only players succeeding at positions where they don't in real life.


Agility should NOT work as a negative.


Not in tackling itself, you're right. I was using it as a measure of how much people devote to being real fast compared to having the strength to fight strength.


I'm aware of your point, but agility has a lot to do with balance and footwork. I understand how speed can work against you. Agility NEVER will work against anyone in a sports situation.


reggie bush in cooege???
 
Cyred
offline
Link
 
This whole thread is about tackling. Why have a tackling stat if it was not the main purpose of tackling?
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whatspeakyou
100 str vs. 20 str? and that should end in a tackle? get out of here. you just made power backs useless. they thrive on trucking over the first defender to get their extra yards.


Yes it should end in a tackle. I don't care how strong you are, if you are tripped up - you go down. That's why people trip over cats .. you think that a cat is as strong as the grown man that trips over it?
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Kira


Carrying has a much larger impact than strength in fumbling. If your personal results are different, it's because of a number of things mainly competition, energy and morale.


The formula for deciding if you hang on to the ball would agree with you.


Stats would argue against it Bort. And I'm sure I've got some supporters that are aware of it as well.


i wouldnt argue against it...
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IIAMLEGEND
Originally posted by Ken1

Bort made a mistake in scaling back breaking tackles before. All that happened is it allowed people to go back to Speed, Speed, Speed.

Basically, a good meter is that if your Speed + Agility > Strength + Tackling, you should not be able to consistently tackle power backs. People should have to train LBs' Strength and Tackling close to how they train CBs' Speed and Agility. That's much more like football.

There should be no number that consistently (meaning 90% or something) tackles someone who's gone all out as a power back (unless you went all out on stopping them, like 90 Tackling and 80 Strength), but you should do a very good job if, say, Strength and Tackling are second capped and you have most of your equipment in Tackling.

Bort needs to stand his ground here. No more Speed-only players succeeding at positions where they don't in real life.




Tbh all this goes back to a key philosophy for this game.


"Balanced builds suck."

Quote me on that. Either you build strong well tackling LB's and get > by speed backs, or build pass rushing speed back killing monsters and get ran over. You can't have it both ways.


Actually a fairly balanced build will do pretty well right now at tackling. It's the guys whose Speed is much higher than their Strength or Tackling that will get run over, and rightly so. If you have 70 Tackling and 60 Strength, to go with the 60 Speed you might have at level 40 with those stats, you'll miss some tackles but make more than you miss even on power backs. But if you went all out for Speed, as so many did, you should be run over, and will.
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
I think having less random fumbles and having more fumbles when players with low carry or even 48 carry when hit by a 60/60+ guy would make the 60/60+ STR/TKL build a viable option.
 
Snipeshow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by whatspeakyou

100 str vs. 20 str? and that should end in a tackle? get out of here. you just made power backs useless. they thrive on trucking over the first defender to get their extra yards.


Yes it should end in a tackle. I don't care how strong you are, if you are tripped up - you go down. That's why people trip over cats .. you think that a cat is as strong as the grown man that trips over it?


The better question is who allowed cats on the football field?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by whatspeakyou

100 str vs. 20 str? and that should end in a tackle? get out of here. you just made power backs useless. they thrive on trucking over the first defender to get their extra yards.


Yes it should end in a tackle. I don't care how strong you are, if you are tripped up - you go down. That's why people trip over cats .. you think that a cat is as strong as the grown man that trips over it?


Because they don't see the cat.

They see the tackler. The tackler's a weakling and tries to wrap them up, they'll just burst out of his grasp.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by the man of doom
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by Ken1


Originally posted by Iceman16



Originally posted by Ken1




Bort made a mistake in scaling back breaking tackles before. All that happened is it allowed people to go back to Speed, Speed, Speed.

Basically, a good meter is that if your Speed + Agility > Strength + Tackling, you should not be able to consistently tackle power backs. People should have to train LBs' Strength and Tackling close to how they train CBs' Speed and Agility. That's much more like football.

There should be no number that consistently (meaning 90% or something) tackles someone who's gone all out as a power back (unless you went all out on stopping them, like 90 Tackling and 80 Strength), but you should do a very good job if, say, Strength and Tackling are second capped and you have most of your equipment in Tackling.

Bort needs to stand his ground here. No more Speed-only players succeeding at positions where they don't in real life.


Agility should NOT work as a negative.


Not in tackling itself, you're right. I was using it as a measure of how much people devote to being real fast compared to having the strength to fight strength.


I'm aware of your point, but agility has a lot to do with balance and footwork. I understand how speed can work against you. Agility NEVER will work against anyone in a sports situation.


reggie bush in cooege???


You're backing what I said, right?
 
fletch03
offline
Link
 
I honestly don't see anything wrong with the way it is right now. I GM teams that rarely miss tackles, but we also have power backs that rack up 8-10 miss tackles a game. That doesn't mean they break all those tackles for long gains (sometimes), but usually break one tackle get another 2-3 yards and get tackled by some one else.

I think someone said that NFL corners always tackle RB's. I have to laugh at this, when a RB is one on one with a CB, the CB routinely misses the tackle or at least the RB stiff arms them for another 5 yard gain.

If you actually watch NFL game there are missed tackles all the time. This doesn't mean guys are squaring up with the RB and completely misses the tackle (it does happen) but usually are diving after the RB and can't get his arms around them. I think a team missing 5-10 tackles a game is pretty realistic.

Just my opinion though.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by EastBayFunk



My point is, you don't need to be some hulking monster to make a tackle.


LOL, tell that to the guys in the secondary who try to tackle Brandon Jacobs. Brandon Jacobs is the modern day power back.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EG-zdAgJcO0


Do you seriously want me to pull out every highlight reel hit Jacobs delivered? That dude was lucky, he dove high. One of only three fumbles he had all season.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
I think having less random fumbles and having more fumbles when players with low carry or even 48 carry when hit by a 60/60+ guy would make the 60/60+ STR/TKL build a viable option.


Add in that the 60/60+ guy isn't using wrap up, and emphasize fewer random fumbles, and I'd call that a reasonable request.
 
epsilonomega
offline
Link
 
Make more tackling AND strength needed in order to bring power RBs down (moreso on strength), but also require more carrying for HBs or the ball could be easily stripped.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.