User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by uscbucsfan
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by uscbucsfan


I have a DE with 8 sacks in 2 games...1 game was against an OT who was 13 levels lower, another was against a lower level horrible build OT. 1 game I played against a great build and got 0 sacks, a couple hurries...but that is realistic. If you make it to where the DEs don't get sacks against garbage players, then OTs on their level will dominate them

I feel like some of you aren't thinking logically about this...low levels and bad builds are going to give up sacks....good builds and even levels are not....get it?


Then a QB against a bad secondary should pass for 800 yards, right?


Bad secondarys give up 200 points...but that is realistic apparently and the sacks aren't, it's all relative


They only do when the rest of the team also sucks.

Games against gutted teams don't tell you much. But a lot of the 100 sack guys broke NFL sack records against some equal-level teams.
 
uscbucsfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by uscbucsfan

Originally posted by Ken1


Originally posted by uscbucsfan



I have a DE with 8 sacks in 2 games...1 game was against an OT who was 13 levels lower, another was against a lower level horrible build OT. 1 game I played against a great build and got 0 sacks, a couple hurries...but that is realistic. If you make it to where the DEs don't get sacks against garbage players, then OTs on their level will dominate them

I feel like some of you aren't thinking logically about this...low levels and bad builds are going to give up sacks....good builds and even levels are not....get it?


Then a QB against a bad secondary should pass for 800 yards, right?


Bad secondarys give up 200 points...but that is realistic apparently and the sacks aren't, it's all relative


They only do when the rest of the team also sucks.

Games against gutted teams don't tell you much. But a lot of the 100 sack guys broke NFL sack records against some equal-level teams.


I agree that against equal competition the most sacks a guy should give up is around 6...but I was just getting upset that people were giving examples of sacks coming from horrible builds and lower levels. I think the changes in the offseason helped that a bit
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by uscbucsfan
no you are not being realistic...you are asking sack totals to be lowered but go look at who is giving up the sacks...bad players, some are awful players. If you lower those sacks than any DE no matter how good would never ever get a sack on a decent OT...do you understand this?

If you want to put this in a real perspective, how many sacks would you give up to an NFL DE? I bet he would decimate any record...10+ levels of difference is a ton I think there should be 20 sacks against that player, I think it has been nerfed enough


Not quite. My OT has 35 speed, 56 agility, 64 strength, 62 blocking, 49 vision, 35 confidence and 41 stamina (with a decent selection of SAs). Those are his natural attributes, show me where I neglected anything, as much or more, than any speed rush DE...

First game of the season I got run around like I was standing still on at least 5 plays (we only had 38 passing plays).

I've already made adjustments, so whatever, I'm not really complaining. I would like to see the game made more realistic, so that it's not the DEs crying... once more OTs figure out to move their EQ. Although, not all OTs have an owner who can and/or is willing to pay for his players to get a second set of EQ (or replace current EQ).

The current system is all or nothing... that has the potential to be a major problem.

The whole premise of your argument is that it's only bad/horrible players getting smoked... now that I'm built like a blocking TE, I can block speed rush DEs... when I was built like an OT, not so much. The main difference was speed improved by 15 points, WTF should I have to have soft capped speed and 3rd capped agility to play OT?
 
uscbucsfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by uscbucsfan

no you are not being realistic...you are asking sack totals to be lowered but go look at who is giving up the sacks...bad players, some are awful players. If you lower those sacks than any DE no matter how good would never ever get a sack on a decent OT...do you understand this?

If you want to put this in a real perspective, how many sacks would you give up to an NFL DE? I bet he would decimate any record...10+ levels of difference is a ton I think there should be 20 sacks against that player, I think it has been nerfed enough


Not quite. My OT has 35 speed, 56 agility, 64 strength, 62 blocking, 49 vision, 35 confidence and 41 stamina (with a decent selection of SAs). Those are his natural attributes, show me where I neglected anything, as much or more, than any speed rush DE...

First game of the season I got run around like I was standing still on at least 5 plays (we only had 38 passing plays).

I've already made adjustments, so whatever, I'm not really complaining. I would like to see the game made more realistic, so that it's not the DEs crying... once more OTs figure out to move their EQ. Although, not all OTs have an owner who can and/or is willing to pay for his players to get a second set of EQ (or replace current EQ).

The current system is all or nothing... that has the potential to be a major problem.

The whole premise of your argument is that it's only bad/horrible players getting smoked... now that I'm built like a blocking TE, I can block speed rush DEs... when I was built like an OT, not so much. The main difference was speed improved by 15 points, WTF should I have to have soft capped speed and 3rd capped agility to play OT?


no offense, but those are pretty bad numbers for a level 34 OT...After reading those I thought you may be a 24 at most....that is why you got run, We have an OT on our team who is a 23 who has more speed strength and agility...he is probably a better OT

Last edited Nov 17, 2008 12:22:55
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock

Not quite. My OT has 35 speed, 56 agility, 64 strength, 62 blocking, 49 vision, 35 confidence and 41 stamina (with a decent selection of SAs). Those are his natural attributes, show me where I neglected anything, as much or more, than any speed rush DE...


I've got a speed DE 11 levels under you that has supposedly-neglected strength greater than your speed. Obviously his support attributes aren't in the same realm being 80-ish skill points behind you, but why can't an argument be made that you've neglected speed?

What I keep hearing is this insistence that OTs shouldn't have speed. No one's suggesting you double-cap it. With sufficient agility you can stop 95% of DEs cold with capped speed.

I think a lot of DE players would be OK with fewer sacks as long as pressure otherwise had an impact ... but it doesn't. You either get the sack or the DL is meaningless. Even credited hurries don't seem to complete appreciably less than non-hurried passes, and its much harder to get a "hurry" in GLB than in real football.

 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by uscbucsfan
no offense, but those are pretty bad numbers for a level 34 OT...After reading those I thought you may be a 24 at most....that is why you got run, We have an OT on our team who is a 23 who has more speed strength and agility...he is probably a better OT



Either you missed the part where I said those are natural (aka without EQ) or you're just flat out exaggerating.

55 point difference between me and a level 23, I doubt that I have more than 25 points in SAs... so it's impossible for this 23 to have better stats.

As for it being a bad build... then a good portion of OTs have absolutely terrible builds, by your reckoning.
 
GOLee
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by uscbucsfan
Originally posted by Warlock

Originally posted by uscbucsfan


no you are not being realistic...you are asking sack totals to be lowered but go look at who is giving up the sacks...bad players, some are awful players. If you lower those sacks than any DE no matter how good would never ever get a sack on a decent OT...do you understand this?

If you want to put this in a real perspective, how many sacks would you give up to an NFL DE? I bet he would decimate any record...10+ levels of difference is a ton I think there should be 20 sacks against that player, I think it has been nerfed enough


Not quite. My OT has 35 speed, 56 agility, 64 strength, 62 blocking, 49 vision, 35 confidence and 41 stamina (with a decent selection of SAs). Those are his natural attributes, show me where I neglected anything, as much or more, than any speed rush DE...

First game of the season I got run around like I was standing still on at least 5 plays (we only had 38 passing plays).

I've already made adjustments, so whatever, I'm not really complaining. I would like to see the game made more realistic, so that it's not the DEs crying... once more OTs figure out to move their EQ. Although, not all OTs have an owner who can and/or is willing to pay for his players to get a second set of EQ (or replace current EQ).

The current system is all or nothing... that has the potential to be a major problem.

The whole premise of your argument is that it's only bad/horrible players getting smoked... now that I'm built like a blocking TE, I can block speed rush DEs... when I was built like an OT, not so much. The main difference was speed improved by 15 points, WTF should I have to have soft capped speed and 3rd capped agility to play OT?


no offense, but those are pretty bad numbers for a level 34 OT...After reading those I thought you may be a 24 at most....that is why you got run, We have an OT on our team who is a 23 who has more speed strength and agility...he is probably a better OT



uscbucs, take a look at the bold part that I emphasized above. I highly doubt that your Lv23 OT beats those natural, pre-equipment numbers.
 
austin8214
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zable
Originally posted by Bort

Been working on trying various things the last few days. I agree that the 90 speed guys getting to the QB in 1 second is dumb.

One thing I will probably put in is the "jump the snap" delay based on vision, which means DE's who have no vision will not get off the line immediately every time.

I'm also experimenting with "holding" code, that would allow the lineman to get a handful of jersey and hold they guy back using primarily strength even if he's mostly gotten past him. Not done on that one, though. I'd need to get the penalty in for it as well. Seems reasonable, though, since NFL blockers pretty much hold on every play .

Also, I'm thinking of improving "Protector" a little maybe to give more of a speed/turning ability boost, and also giving a bonus to side-to-side movement to avoid losing too much speed when blocking.


Bort im sure you realize that the Protector skill does nothing for the Right Offensive Tackle according to the skill description so how will that help them out?


+1
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
WTF should I have to have soft capped speed and 3rd capped agility to play OT?


If you want to block Dwight Freeney one-on-one 100% of the time, you better BE a freak, yes. Though honestly, capped speed and 2nd capped agi would probably do it against all but the very best pass rushers, against whom you might need to do all the things they do in real football. Double-team them, keep a back in, shorten the passing game.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sarg01

I've got a speed DE 11 levels under you that has supposedly-neglected strength greater than your speed. Obviously his support attributes aren't in the same realm being 80-ish skill points behind you, but why can't an argument be made that you've neglected speed?

What I keep hearing is this insistence that OTs shouldn't have speed. No one's suggesting you double-cap it. With sufficient agility you can stop 95% of DEs cold with capped speed.

I think a lot of DE players would be OK with fewer sacks as long as pressure otherwise had an impact ... but it doesn't. You either get the sack or the DL is meaningless. Even credited hurries don't seem to complete appreciably less than non-hurried passes, and its much harder to get a "hurry" in GLB than in real football.



No. DEs that neglect str, now have a two attribute advantage over an OT. One attribute is enough of an advantage for a DE (and fair for the most part).

OTs need... strength, blocking, agility, vision and speed.
DEs need... speed, agility, vision.

So while my speed is on the lower end of the spectrum... it's probably even with a DEs tackling attribute.

OTs blocking/agility = DEs speed/agility. Vision cancels one another. Speed cancels tackling. SAs cancels one another. So now an OT needs strength or he's worthless for anything aside from blocking a speed DE... although, a DE doesn't need any strength, because their agility allows them to disengage and run down plays anyways.

That's why a speed/agility DE has neglected attributes more than I have... which is why it's imbalanced.

Once OTs catch up... we'll have threads where speed/agility DEs are complaining (unless the system changes). Mark my words.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sarg01
Originally posted by Warlock

WTF should I have to have soft capped speed and 3rd capped agility to play OT?


If you want to block Dwight Freeney one-on-one 100% of the time, you better BE a freak, yes. Though honestly, capped speed and 2nd capped agi would probably do it against all but the very best pass rushers, against whom you might need to do all the things they do in real football. Double-team them, keep a back in, shorten the passing game.


That's nuts. If OT's had to be like that in real life, they wouldn't have 300 pounders playing the position.

OT's outmuscle fast DE's most of the time-- even the best DE's-- which is why the league leader will average about 1 per game in real life (note that because of much greater disparity in competition, I think that league leaders in whatever with double real life league leaders' totals is fine-- meaning the best DE's in GLB should average 2 per game, or in the low 30's for the season).
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by Sarg01


I've got a speed DE 11 levels under you that has supposedly-neglected strength greater than your speed. Obviously his support attributes aren't in the same realm being 80-ish skill points behind you, but why can't an argument be made that you've neglected speed?

What I keep hearing is this insistence that OTs shouldn't have speed. No one's suggesting you double-cap it. With sufficient agility you can stop 95% of DEs cold with capped speed.

I think a lot of DE players would be OK with fewer sacks as long as pressure otherwise had an impact ... but it doesn't. You either get the sack or the DL is meaningless. Even credited hurries don't seem to complete appreciably less than non-hurried passes, and its much harder to get a "hurry" in GLB than in real football.



No. DEs that neglect str, now have a two attribute advantage over an OT. One attribute is enough of an advantage for a DE (and fair for the most part).

OTs need... strength, blocking, agility, vision and speed.
DEs need... speed, agility, vision.

So while my speed is on the lower end of the spectrum... it's probably even with a DEs tackling attribute.

OTs blocking/agility = DEs speed/agility. Vision cancels one another. Speed cancels tackling. SAs cancels one another. So now an OT needs strength or he's worthless for anything aside from blocking a speed DE... although, a DE doesn't need any strength, because their agility allows them to disengage and run down plays anyways.

That's why a speed/agility DE has neglected attributes more than I have... which is why it's imbalanced.

Once OTs catch up... we'll have threads where speed/agility DEs are complaining (unless the system changes). Mark my words.


The whole thing, which has been true in other areas of the game, is that Speed is overly important in these matchups.

Speed should matter to DE's, but pretty much only because if they get by the OT they need to run the QB or the play down.

They should need Strength not to be pancaked on runs and to avoid shock blocks on pass plays, and Agility + the Shed Block SA to shed blocks. Almost never should they be able to avoid contact.
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1

That's nuts. If OT's had to be like that in real life, they wouldn't have 300 pounders playing the position.



I'm a Texans fan (yeah, I know) and yesterday against the Colts for the entire first half the announcers kept going on about how Peyton clearly had a lot of respect for the Texans' front 4 because he ... gasp ... wasn't trying anything deep and kept throwing screens and running draws.

So, one of the best OLs in the league with one of the best pocket-presence QBs and one of the best WRs was willing to acknowledge they couldn't expect to just play their game and keep the pass rush at bay.



 
wlarson
offline
Link
 
if DEs dont need strength, why do OTs need it?
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sarg01
Originally posted by Ken1


That's nuts. If OT's had to be like that in real life, they wouldn't have 300 pounders playing the position.



I'm a Texans fan (yeah, I know) and yesterday against the Colts for the entire first half the announcers kept going on about how Peyton clearly had a lot of respect for the Texans' front 4 because he ... gasp ... wasn't trying anything deep and kept throwing screens and running draws.

So, one of the best OLs in the league with one of the best pocket-presence QBs and one of the best WRs was willing to acknowledge they couldn't expect to just play their game and keep the pass rush at bay.





lmfao at the Colts' OL being one of the best any more.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.