User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
Link
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1916_Cumberland_vs._Georgia_Tech_football_game

http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/461650/november_27_1966_nfls_highest_scoring.html

http://cbs.sportsline.com/nfl/story/10475592
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

Can you tell me the biggest blow out in college football history? Hint: one team had over 100pts scored against them.

Cumberland vs. Georgia Tech. Try asking me something I didn't know when I was ten years old.
Originally posted by

People have already given real life NFL and College stats that prove these games DO happen in RL.

No, these types of results do not happen. Those trying to kiss Bort's ass have repeatedly pointed out that the highest interception totals in the history of the NFL almost equaled what happened here, and that's momentarily ignoring the fact that this wasn't a match-up between two clearly disparate opponents.



You are saying these results, don't happen, so Favre didn't throw six picks in the early 2000's <forget which year> vs St. Louis???
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

Can you tell me the biggest blow out in college football history? Hint: one team had over 100pts scored against them.

Cumberland vs. Georgia Tech. Try asking me something I didn't know when I was ten years old.
Originally posted by

People have already given real life NFL and College stats that prove these games DO happen in RL.

No, these types of results do not happen. Those trying to kiss Bort's ass have repeatedly pointed out that the highest interception totals in the history of the NFL almost equaled what happened here, and that's momentarily ignoring the fact that this wasn't a match-up between two clearly disparate opponents.


You keep ignoring the reality...8 INT's by one QB in a game HAS happened in the NFL before. 9 in NCAA. How many times does this have to be put in your face before you read and comprehend it. These types of games are oddities, but THEY DO HAPPEN.

I'm not trying to kiss Bort's ass. There are issues with the game, and the spiral is one of them, that is mostly on the player but partly on the SIM for not having a sub option to get the QB out of the game before 9 picks happens. The offense vs. defense strength disparity at the higher levels is also an issue that Bort has said WILL be addressed for season 4.
 
superman8456
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by jdbolick

Originally posted by driftinggrifter


Can you tell me the biggest blow out in college football history? Hint: one team had over 100pts scored against them.

Cumberland vs. Georgia Tech. Try asking me something I didn't know when I was ten years old.
Originally posted by


People have already given real life NFL and College stats that prove these games DO happen in RL.

No, these types of results do not happen. Those trying to kiss Bort's ass have repeatedly pointed out that the highest interception totals in the history of the NFL almost equaled what happened here, and that's momentarily ignoring the fact that this wasn't a match-up between two clearly disparate opponents.


Except that, these two teams WERENT EQUAL, A. you had a Miami team that had CLEARLY BETTER BUILDS, and they had BOOSTED RIGHT BEFORE THE GAME, B. you had a Nashville QB who couldn't hit the broadside of a barn, let alone, see it.


These teams were equal. Bad QB build doesnt mean the whole team has bad builds.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

Can you tell me the biggest blow out in college football history? Hint: one team had over 100pts scored against them.

Cumberland vs. Georgia Tech. Try asking me something I didn't know when I was ten years old.
Originally posted by

People have already given real life NFL and College stats that prove these games DO happen in RL.

No, these types of results do not happen. Those trying to kiss Bort's ass have repeatedly pointed out that the highest interception totals in the history of the NFL almost equaled what happened here, and that's momentarily ignoring the fact that this wasn't a match-up between two clearly disparate opponents.


So then what is so unrealistic about the sim since you already know all this other stuff? We are not playing at the NFL level yet anyways so quit comparing this to the NFL.

 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by jdbolick


Originally posted by driftinggrifter



Can you tell me the biggest blow out in college football history? Hint: one team had over 100pts scored against them.

Cumberland vs. Georgia Tech. Try asking me something I didn't know when I was ten years old.
Originally posted by



People have already given real life NFL and College stats that prove these games DO happen in RL.

No, these types of results do not happen. Those trying to kiss Bort's ass have repeatedly pointed out that the highest interception totals in the history of the NFL almost equaled what happened here, and that's momentarily ignoring the fact that this wasn't a match-up between two clearly disparate opponents.


Except that, these two teams WERENT EQUAL, A. you had a Miami team that had CLEARLY BETTER BUILDS, and they had BOOSTED RIGHT BEFORE THE GAME, B. you had a Nashville QB who couldn't hit the broadside of a barn, let alone, see it.


These teams were equal. Bad QB build doesnt mean the whole team has bad builds.


It's a great indication of it,
 
Link
 
Colts vs Chargers two relatively even teams except the Colts have Peyton Manning. One of the best QB's to play the game in the FA era. And he threw 6 picks in that game.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
I don't get why some of you can't understand that this was a low confidence leading to low morale spiral...and the right answer isn't correct the SIM so I can keep low confidence and not throw high pick numbers.

The correct answer is..

1. For the QB - boost confidence, avoid this pattern
2. For the SIM - add an advanced sub setting to pull a starter when morale <X%

simple as that...keeps confidence WORKING AS INTENDED so agents don't neglect the major attribute....gives owners an option to avoid a confidence/morale spiral and maybe have a chance to get back into a game.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Considering the pancakes were NOT a statistical oddity, as has been mentioned more than once, and the rushing yards were also NOT a statistical oddity (just look at the last game between the same teams where the starting Nashville HB averaged 1.9 per carry, the backup 2.4), I'm not sure what other oddities you are talking about.

Yes, the pancakes were an oddity, just a more plausible one like someone being shot in the head and surviving. That probably happens every day in the United States, even if the chances of survival are still low. Ditto for the rushing yards, which aren't out of the realm of believability, just like someone surviving being lit on fire. The interceptions total is what stands out as utterly preposterous, while the other unlikely results together conclusively prove that something went wrong with the programming. It's simple probability theory. When you have an impossibly unlikely event coinciding with a very unlikely one and an unlikely one, the chances of that happening naturally are astronomical.

Again, I understand why some people would feel motivated to suck up to Bort, but it's not even like this is realistically debatable. Results like this game should not happen. Everyone knows that. I'd just like to see the people in charge acknowledge that it should not have happened and not hide behind petty excuses like confidence or the QB's build. If confidence and the QB's build actually are responsible for this ridiculously impossible outcome, then how those elements are programmed needs to be adjusted.
 
Link
 
Or how players actually build their guys needs to be taken into consideration before they start dumping mad points in one skill.
 
superman8456
offline
Link
 
You cant compare a game that happened in 1916 to now. It was 1916!

If low confidence is the reason, why dont lvl 5 QBs throw 10 INT's a game.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by SCACE

Considering the pancakes were NOT a statistical oddity, as has been mentioned more than once, and the rushing yards were also NOT a statistical oddity (just look at the last game between the same teams where the starting Nashville HB averaged 1.9 per carry, the backup 2.4), I'm not sure what other oddities you are talking about.

Yes, the pancakes were an oddity, just a more plausible one like someone being shot in the head and surviving. That probably happens every day in the United States, even if the chances of survival are still low. Ditto for the rushing yards, which aren't out of the realm of believability, just like someone surviving being lit on fire. The interceptions total is what stands out as utterly preposterous, while the other unlikely results together conclusively prove that something went wrong with the programming. It's simple probability theory. When you have an impossibly unlikely event coinciding with a very unlikely one and an unlikely one, the chances of that happening naturally are astronomical.

Again, I understand why some people would feel motivated to suck up to Bort, but it's not even like this is realistically debatable. Results like this game should not happen. Everyone knows that. I'd just like to see the people in charge acknowledge that it should not have happened and not hide behind petty excuses like confidence or the QB's build. If confidence and the QB's build actually are responsible for this ridiculously impossible outcome, then how those elements are programmed needs to be adjusted.


LOL Holy christ, you are worse than Larry hanging on to your argument when it is CLEAR you have no idea.

The Pancakes arenot an anomaly, a flaw, a fluke, whatever you want to call them, THEY HAPPENED, because, here is where you have to follow me closely ok, BECAUSE MIAMI RAN THE BALL MORE BECAUSE THEY WERE LEADING they were going to get more pancakes based solely on that fact. NASHVILLE THOUGH, HAD TO PASS THE BALL BECAUSE, WELL, THEY WERE LOSING, they were bound to get LESS pancakes because of that fact.

Can you at least acknowledge that, as long as you are the professional football writer this should make sense.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
You cant compare a game that happened in 1916 to now. It was 1916!

If low confidence is the reason, why dont lvl 5 QBs throw 10 INT's a game.


Because they play against level 4 CBs, cmon now.
 
superman8456
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by superman8456

You cant compare a game that happened in 1916 to now. It was 1916!

If low confidence is the reason, why dont lvl 5 QBs throw 10 INT's a game.


Because they play against level 4 CBs, cmon now.


But if they throw 1 INTs dont you think it will start to come in masses because the player has low confidence?
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by SCACE

Considering the pancakes were NOT a statistical oddity, as has been mentioned more than once, and the rushing yards were also NOT a statistical oddity (just look at the last game between the same teams where the starting Nashville HB averaged 1.9 per carry, the backup 2.4), I'm not sure what other oddities you are talking about.

Yes, the pancakes were an oddity, just a more plausible one like someone being shot in the head and surviving. That probably happens every day in the United States, even if the chances of survival are still low. Ditto for the rushing yards, which aren't out of the realm of believability, just like someone surviving being lit on fire. The interceptions total is what stands out as utterly preposterous, while the other unlikely results together conclusively prove that something went wrong with the programming. It's simple probability theory. When you have an impossibly unlikely event coinciding with a very unlikely one and an unlikely one, the chances of that happening naturally are astronomical.

Again, I understand why some people would feel motivated to suck up to Bort, but it's not even like this is realistically debatable. Results like this game should not happen. Everyone knows that. I'd just like to see the people in charge acknowledge that it should not have happened and not hide behind petty excuses like confidence or the QB's build. If confidence and the QB's build actually are responsible for this ridiculously impossible outcome, then how those elements are programmed needs to be adjusted.


Honestly, I don't think you know what you are talking about. Sometimes you seem to have a clue, but this post takes you away from reality.

The fact is that one team barely rushed this game, making it hard if not impossible to register pancakes as they were pass blocking the majority of the game. Couple that with the fact that in their close game, Nashville only registered 2 pancakes, so their OL did not overpower Miami's DL enough to register a lot of pancakes.

Now, go to the reverse side of the ball. Miami rushed a lot, esp. in the second half of the game with a big lead. More rushing = more opportunity for pancakes as they are run blocking. Last game that was close, they registered 14, meaning they have an OL that can at times overpower Nashville's DL. Given the increase in rushing this game, 23 is NOT AN ODDITY.

Now, go to rushing yards. In the close game, where Nashville rushed more often, not just when the team was near top energy early in the game, they managed 1.9 average from their top HB, 2.4 average from their #2. A total of about 70 yards combined rushing. This game, they had a rough time running early against a solid defense when that defense was at peak energy levels. They didn't have the opportunity to rush on this defense when it was more tired, leading to lower rushing average totals. Again, not an oddity.

The only oddity is the INT's, which I've explained both the problem and the fix. You just keep ignoring it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.