Bump...can we at least get an ETA on the date this feature will go into production?
Forum > Announcements > Defense AI Interface
San Diego Chargers
offline
offline
Originally posted by TideSpot
If I have 2 inputs, say 2nd and 5, and all the parameters are the same for both inputs except for offensive formation, will the AI pick the one with the correct offensive formation, even though it may be lower down the list?
Yes, it will go down the list until it finds an input that matches the current scenario. If there isn't one, it will use your basic (current) tactics.
If I have 2 inputs, say 2nd and 5, and all the parameters are the same for both inputs except for offensive formation, will the AI pick the one with the correct offensive formation, even though it may be lower down the list?
Yes, it will go down the list until it finds an input that matches the current scenario. If there isn't one, it will use your basic (current) tactics.
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by turnerhero
Now, I realize the O and D AI scripts need to go live together, but what about the 3-4 option on defense? I've had my roster set since this past offseason to turn 3-4 and still have depth - basically this means I have about 3 extra LBs who're riding the bench and shouldn't be that much. While they're being patient and not demanding to be traded or whatever, I'm thinking they're probably getting upset about it by now...
is there ANY chance in hell the 3-4 will hit before th entire AI packages?
On that tangent, I kinda wish we could switch base defenses based on individual plays.
Now, I realize the O and D AI scripts need to go live together, but what about the 3-4 option on defense? I've had my roster set since this past offseason to turn 3-4 and still have depth - basically this means I have about 3 extra LBs who're riding the bench and shouldn't be that much. While they're being patient and not demanding to be traded or whatever, I'm thinking they're probably getting upset about it by now...
is there ANY chance in hell the 3-4 will hit before th entire AI packages?
On that tangent, I kinda wish we could switch base defenses based on individual plays.
FredEx
offline
offline
Originally posted by Shorteous
It would be nice if we could create multiple depth charts and give them saved names. Then on the Advanced AI screen have a pull down that would allow you to select one of your saved depth charts!!! I think this could be the best way and would allow you to have the exact personnel in for each output and not just for each formation.
YES this is VERY important... especially for teams planning to use a hybrid 4-3/3-4 and play DEs at OLB in the 3-4...
It would be nice if we could create multiple depth charts and give them saved names. Then on the Advanced AI screen have a pull down that would allow you to select one of your saved depth charts!!! I think this could be the best way and would allow you to have the exact personnel in for each output and not just for each formation.
YES this is VERY important... especially for teams planning to use a hybrid 4-3/3-4 and play DEs at OLB in the 3-4...
FredEx
offline
offline
Hey how come a team with a 4-3 base can play a 3-4 nickel, dime, or quarter but not a 3-4 base?
I don't like this at all. (And sorry if it's been mentioned)
I don't like this at all. (And sorry if it's been mentioned)
Last edited Jul 3, 2008 14:43:34
RIP Al Davis
offline
offline
Originally posted by FredEx
Hey how come a team with a 4-3 base can play a 3-4 nickel, dime, or quarter but not a 3-4 base?
I don't like this at all. (And sorry if it's been mentioned)
I'm pretty sure by the time this comes out 3-4s will be out as well
Hey how come a team with a 4-3 base can play a 3-4 nickel, dime, or quarter but not a 3-4 base?
I don't like this at all. (And sorry if it's been mentioned)
I'm pretty sure by the time this comes out 3-4s will be out as well
islander1
offline
offline
I think what Fred means is, we can't switch from a 4-3 base to a 3-4 base for a given response to a given play.
Which I agree with him, completely.
Which I agree with him, completely.
TideSpot
offline
offline
Originally posted by islander1
I think what Fred means is, we can't switch from a 4-3 base to a 3-4 base for a given response to a given play.
Which I agree with him, completely.
Yeah, i agree also. The only way to have a base 3-4 right now is to come up with a whole new playbook with the 3-4 base...
It would be much nicer to have a base 3-4 and base 4-3 as a pull down option in the formation menu.
I think what Fred means is, we can't switch from a 4-3 base to a 3-4 base for a given response to a given play.
Which I agree with him, completely.
Yeah, i agree also. The only way to have a base 3-4 right now is to come up with a whole new playbook with the 3-4 base...
It would be much nicer to have a base 3-4 and base 4-3 as a pull down option in the formation menu.
lawdog
offline
offline
Originally posted by islander1
On that tangent, I kinda wish we could switch base defenses based on individual plays.
You can do this. You select the defensive formation for each input.
On that tangent, I kinda wish we could switch base defenses based on individual plays.
You can do this. You select the defensive formation for each input.
Last edited Jul 5, 2008 23:13:21
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by lawdog
Originally posted by islander1
On that tangent, I kinda wish we could switch base defenses based on individual plays.
You can do this. You select the defensive formation for each input.
You cannot switch from a base 4-3 to a base 3-4. You only have one place to choose the base defense, at the very top.
Now, output responses include the opposite defense's nickel and dime formations. But even those it's not clear if we are ALLOWED to actually use those, or if it's just bad coding to allow us to see options unavailable to us (I'm hoping it isnt the latter)
Originally posted by islander1
On that tangent, I kinda wish we could switch base defenses based on individual plays.
You can do this. You select the defensive formation for each input.
You cannot switch from a base 4-3 to a base 3-4. You only have one place to choose the base defense, at the very top.
Now, output responses include the opposite defense's nickel and dime formations. But even those it's not clear if we are ALLOWED to actually use those, or if it's just bad coding to allow us to see options unavailable to us (I'm hoping it isnt the latter)
San Diego Chargers
offline
offline
All I want is formation specific depth charts. My team is going to be running a base 3-4 and moving one of our faster DE's to OLB. The problem is that if we go into Dime, Nickel, or Quarter he will sub out for a CB rather than moving to DE. And for 3-4 Quarter or 4-3 Quarter, is the only difference the number of D-Lineman? Obviously you cant have an actual 4-3 or 3-4 quarter as 4DL +3LB +5CB +2S = 14 players. So I'm guessing the 4-3 would remain the same for who subs out but what about the 3-4? Their would 3 DL, 5 CB, 2 S, and then which ILB stays in?
Thanks for all the hard work Bort. With multiple depth charts I would be in heaven!
Thanks for all the hard work Bort. With multiple depth charts I would be in heaven!
Quack
offline
offline
Originally posted by San Diego Chargers
All I want is formation specific depth charts. My team is going to be running a base 3-4 and moving one of our faster DE's to OLB. The problem is that if we go into Dime, Nickel, or Quarter he will sub out for a CB rather than moving to DE. And for 3-4 Quarter or 4-3 Quarter, is the only difference the number of D-Lineman? Obviously you cant have an actual 4-3 or 3-4 quarter as 4DL +3LB +5CB +2S = 14 players. So I'm guessing the 4-3 would remain the same for who subs out but what about the 3-4? Their would 3 DL, 5 CB, 2 S, and then which ILB stays in?
Thanks for all the hard work Bort. With multiple depth charts I would be in heaven!
The LBs come out in this order in 4-3 formations: LOLB - ROLB - MLB. We can only guess at the order in 3-4 formations. 3-4 Nickel, 4-3 Dime, etc are just called 3-4 and 4-3 as a point of reference. Obviously a linebacker comes out to put in a CB and yo don't get extra men on the field. I would expect the 3-4 Nickel to take out one of the ILBs before an OLB but you never know, Bort may do things differently. I would, however, expect it to have the same OLB removal chain so if you want your DE at OLB in to blitz even in the nickel package or perhaps the dime (based on how the ILBs come out, yes if one first one last, no if both last), you should put him at ROLB. Having a Speed DE playing as a down lineman in a three linemen package isn't a smart idea, generally, unless it is a blatant passing situation (3rd down, Offense behind in score, 6+ yards to go) and even then, it isn't a good idea (though it may work in GLB, who knows).
All I want is formation specific depth charts. My team is going to be running a base 3-4 and moving one of our faster DE's to OLB. The problem is that if we go into Dime, Nickel, or Quarter he will sub out for a CB rather than moving to DE. And for 3-4 Quarter or 4-3 Quarter, is the only difference the number of D-Lineman? Obviously you cant have an actual 4-3 or 3-4 quarter as 4DL +3LB +5CB +2S = 14 players. So I'm guessing the 4-3 would remain the same for who subs out but what about the 3-4? Their would 3 DL, 5 CB, 2 S, and then which ILB stays in?
Thanks for all the hard work Bort. With multiple depth charts I would be in heaven!
The LBs come out in this order in 4-3 formations: LOLB - ROLB - MLB. We can only guess at the order in 3-4 formations. 3-4 Nickel, 4-3 Dime, etc are just called 3-4 and 4-3 as a point of reference. Obviously a linebacker comes out to put in a CB and yo don't get extra men on the field. I would expect the 3-4 Nickel to take out one of the ILBs before an OLB but you never know, Bort may do things differently. I would, however, expect it to have the same OLB removal chain so if you want your DE at OLB in to blitz even in the nickel package or perhaps the dime (based on how the ILBs come out, yes if one first one last, no if both last), you should put him at ROLB. Having a Speed DE playing as a down lineman in a three linemen package isn't a smart idea, generally, unless it is a blatant passing situation (3rd down, Offense behind in score, 6+ yards to go) and even then, it isn't a good idea (though it may work in GLB, who knows).
G.O.D Turner
offline
offline
Originally posted by mike_26
VERY CONFUSIN
That's why you're not programming it and Bort/minions are haha
VERY CONFUSIN
That's why you're not programming it and Bort/minions are haha
Shorteous
offline
offline
also wanted to spam this another time, want to make sure bort or somebody important has seen it:
It would be nice if we could create multiple depth charts and give them saved names. Then on the Advanced AI screen have a pull down that would allow you to select one of your saved depth charts!!! I think this could be the best way and would allow you to have the exact personnel in for each output and not just for each formation.
It would be nice if we could create multiple depth charts and give them saved names. Then on the Advanced AI screen have a pull down that would allow you to select one of your saved depth charts!!! I think this could be the best way and would allow you to have the exact personnel in for each output and not just for each formation.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























