User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
Link
 

Originally posted by yello1
DAMAGE CONTROL OPPORTUNITY

You want and many of us want Coaching.

Do it NOW together, same time, with Archetypes.

That way people can make all of their adjustments at the same time, and all these retired players can have a function in coaching slots.

Gets two batches of griping out of the way with one large game improving patch.


it's not coming, get over it
 
GregB
offline
Link
 
As an owner, I love this....it presents me with a challenge....I need to find the right parts....not just agents..but agents with the right archetypes...it is the role-playing part of this game that has been missing from inception...The Balanced Party Concept, 22 deep on a different playing field.

How do we use those archetypes? It provides endless thought and tinkering....Yes we have that now....but I think this improves it.

Much more thought into builds....instead of following what XYZ did cuz XYZ owns.

While I, like some of you, dispute that is a real BETA game due to the fundage thats "required" ( And let us not mix terms....if you want to play on a decent team its required). Still, this is long time on an initial game engine......Of course they have ideas how to balance it better now....we've never had a wipe....They've let us play....Lets be a little more positive here and HELP them out.....There is no way this would be done if everyone involved in its administration didn't think it was for the good of the game...

Put on your big boy pants....(if they are not on the ground) and give constructive feedback......

 
Hagalaz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
The main draw of GWs was the PvP, leveling was optional as you could create a PvP player (with all the bells and whistles) and PvP to your heart's content. The PvE aspect of GWs was merely an additional feature, kind of like being a coordinator in GLB (shitty and optional, but you need someone to do it to help the team/guild). The meat and potatoes of GW and GLB is the PvP model...


I beg to differ. I don't even consider GLB playing against other players. To me GLB is playing to make the most efficient player possible and see it triumph. The opponent might as well be the CPU for all I care.
 
Titan103
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GregB
this


+1

At least this.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
I don't know if it's been mentioned before....but a possible exploit here on both offense and defense.

Some positions get QC/CD as a base SA. What's to stop a player from picking the one they don't get and since they are basically the same thing, getting a 20 in QC/CD.

In other words, is this a potential abuse? bug? maybe just need to change QC to CD or vice versa so we only have one SA that deals with turning?


QC/CD are in essence the same - they won't be able to pick that as a bonus SA.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Hey Catch - while you're here and browsing, I wanted to see if the idea of an Elusive WR has been mentioned, or if it has any merit.

I know you've said no more/new Archetypes, but I figured no harm in trying

Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by jbleich

Wouldn't speedster be the same thing with just selecting those 2 SA's?


This is the way I would envision an Elusive WR in comparison to a Speedster WR:


WR Speedster
5'8" - 6'2", 175-215 Lbs
Major Agility Catching Speed Vision (+.5)
Minor Carrying Confidence Jumping Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's - First Step, Quick Cut
Penalty SA's - Route Run, Sticky Hands


WR Elusive
5'8" - 6'2", 175-215 Lbs
Major Agility Carrying Speed Vision (+.5) (could make the case for Confidence to replace Speed)
Minor Confidence Catching Stamina Jumping (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Head Fake, Juke
Penalty SA's - First Step, Route Run


I think there'd be enough of a difference, and it would be the only WR with a Bonus to HF/Juke. Could put Spin in place of one of those, for even more options. Actually, that'd probably be better, as you could differentiate this archetype even more.



I would actually switch it up a bit and make sure Spin was included, along with Strength for a minor (proaly instead of Jumping). This may require re-working the WR Speedster tree, though.
 
Link
 
What is the sense of having a OT with the same strength as a C or G?
 
r87
offline
Link
 
Re-posting:

"Should we go back to random height/weight rolls with the new archetypes???"

Originally posted by MIA99
Think about it, how many 6'8'' 360 lb. DTs will be created??? A good amount of teams will have max/max and min/min players, it might eventually get a little lame. I know GLB isn't the NFL, but how many 6'8'' DTs and 6'6'' WRs are there??? 360 lb. guards??? The game was a lot more fun when you had to waste precious hours rolling to get close to what you wanted. Maybe make a 6'8'' DT, but with a .05% chance of rolling him or something. That way if you really wanted your 6'8'' DT, you would actually have to be dedicated and put some time into it, right??? Let me know what you guys think. I guess this is more of a suggestion, so mods if you want to move fine by me.


 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by r87
Re-posting:

"Should we go back to random height/weight rolls with the new archetypes???"

Originally posted by MIA99

Think about it, how many 6'8'' 360 lb. DTs will be created??? A good amount of teams will have max/max and min/min players, it might eventually get a little lame. I know GLB isn't the NFL, but how many 6'8'' DTs and 6'6'' WRs are there??? 360 lb. guards??? The game was a lot more fun when you had to waste precious hours rolling to get close to what you wanted. Maybe make a 6'8'' DT, but with a .05% chance of rolling him or something. That way if you really wanted your 6'8'' DT, you would actually have to be dedicated and put some time into it, right??? Let me know what you guys think. I guess this is more of a suggestion, so mods if you want to move fine by me.




Edit - misread - thought you meant keep current system.
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by r87
Re-posting:

"Should we go back to random height/weight rolls with the new archetypes???"

Originally posted by MIA99

Think about it, how many 6'8'' 360 lb. DTs will be created??? A good amount of teams will have max/max and min/min players, it might eventually get a little lame. I know GLB isn't the NFL, but how many 6'8'' DTs and 6'6'' WRs are there??? 360 lb. guards??? The game was a lot more fun when you had to waste precious hours rolling to get close to what you wanted. Maybe make a 6'8'' DT, but with a .05% chance of rolling him or something. That way if you really wanted your 6'8'' DT, you would actually have to be dedicated and put some time into it, right??? Let me know what you guys think. I guess this is more of a suggestion, so mods if you want to move fine by me.




besides the fact that there are height/weight pre-requisites for archetypes -

we don't really know very much about the height/weight factor do we (beyond the initial attribute modifiers)?
 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I'd really hope so... Being able to choose isn't offering enough risk/reward. Everybody maxes out one side or the other. There needs to be a legitimate tradeoff. The -2+2 from the start is just silly. There need to be permanent disadvantages to making extreme players (and maybe there are, in the sim, that we don't know of )
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by r87
Re-posting:

"Should we go back to random height/weight rolls with the new archetypes???"



The problem with this is that it has been proven that folks won't accept a random height/weight, they'll keep rolling until they get what they want.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
Yeah, I'd really hope so... Being able to choose isn't offering enough risk/reward. Everybody maxes out one side or the other. There needs to be a legitimate tradeoff. The -2+2 from the start is just silly. There need to be permanent disadvantages to making extreme players (and maybe there are, in the sim, that we don't know of )


Perhaps it should be changed so that height/weight can add a small bonus to an ALG and a bigger (but still small) negative to an ALG. This would certainly make picking something outside the norm a risk/reward type thing.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
Originally posted by r87

Re-posting:

"Should we go back to random height/weight rolls with the new archetypes???"

Originally posted by MIA99


Think about it, how many 6'8'' 360 lb. DTs will be created??? A good amount of teams will have max/max and min/min players, it might eventually get a little lame. I know GLB isn't the NFL, but how many 6'8'' DTs and 6'6'' WRs are there??? 360 lb. guards??? The game was a lot more fun when you had to waste precious hours rolling to get close to what you wanted. Maybe make a 6'8'' DT, but with a .05% chance of rolling him or something. That way if you really wanted your 6'8'' DT, you would actually have to be dedicated and put some time into it, right??? Let me know what you guys think. I guess this is more of a suggestion, so mods if you want to move fine by me.




besides the fact that there are height/weight pre-requisites for archetypes -

we don't really know very much about the height/weight factor do we (beyond the initial attribute modifiers)?


You're right, we don't know a ton about height/weight factor, but that doesn't change the fact that the majority of people want to create an extreme player, right???
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
Yeah, I'd really hope so... Being able to choose isn't offering enough risk/reward. Everybody maxes out one side or the other. There needs to be a legitimate tradeoff. The -2+2 from the start is just silly. There need to be permanent disadvantages to making extreme players (and maybe there are, in the sim, that we don't know of )


Well said man
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.