User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by william78



The intiial levels of helping players gain more "break through training" or more and cheaper eq options will have a minimal impact while these coaches build up and become part of the fabric of the game.



Sorry, but there's a significant porton of the community that doesn't want "coaches" to impact player builds in anything but a temporary fashion (IF even that).


It's just asking for trouble, honestly. We all know the balancing act we've had to go through with VAs. Coaches will be even worse, and for what gain? At what expense? There are unresolved issues from like season 3 that need to be addressed. Giving even a moment's consideration to coaching at this time does harm to the integrity of the sim and of GLB in general.
 
william78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Sorry, but there's a significant porton of the community that doesn't want "coaches" to impact player builds in anything but a temporary fashion (IF even that).


Simple answer. Not that their is anything wrong with that. I respect your opinion Roadgrader I've read more than a few well though out suggestions from you........

But .....there are always those who fear change ....at some point coaching will figure into the fabric of GLB .....why not be as specific about that as possible.....the biggest impediment to progress on GLB is that insufficient testing was done prior to changes this system allows for testing in advance and for feedback from loyal customers

Biggest issues....we've let naysayers impact the game by limiting creativity instead of adding to our gameplay we've come out with mickey mouse cookie cutter solutions (like nothing daily to do after level 30, or uncompetitiveness below the AA level) without thinking it through all the way. Band aid solutions wait for triage fixes...instead of examining thoroughly the aspects of any change we've lobbied bort to make it as simplistic as possible....simplistic leads to min/maxing and is boring

Change happens ....I believe my system if implemented properly would add progress not pain to the GLB world.
Edited by william78 on Dec 25, 2009 05:51:47
Edited by william78 on Dec 25, 2009 05:51:15
 
Link
 
Originally posted by william78
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


Sorry, but there's a significant porton of the community that doesn't want "coaches" to impact player builds in anything but a temporary fashion (IF even that).


Simple answer. Not that their is anything wrong with that. I respect your opinion Roadgrader I've read more than a few well though out suggestions from you........

But .....there are always those who fear change ....at some point coaching will figure into the fabric of GLB .....why not be as specific about that as possible.....the biggest impediment to progress on GLB is that insufficient testing was done prior to changes this system allows for testing in advance and for feedback from loyal customers

Biggest issues....we've let naysayers impact the game by limiting creativity instead of adding to our gameplay we've come out with mickey mouse cookie cutter solutions (like nothing daily to do after level 30, or uncompetitiveness below the AA level) without thinking it through all the way. Band aid solutions wait for triage fixes...instead of examining thoroughly the aspects of any change we've lobbied bort to make it as simplistic as possible....simplistic leads to min/maxing and is boring

Change happens ....I believe my system if implemented properly would add progress not pain to the GLB world.



Sorry, but our position isn't grounded on any imaginary resistance to change. Instead its based on a couple of principles:

1) Customers PAY FOR the players--they and only they should impact the LONG-TERM build. Its fine that some future development (be it "coaches" or some other idea) provide TEMPORARY boosts to on-the-field performance, but the customer and the customer alone should affect (for better or worse) the LONG-TERM build.

2) Nothing that dramatically affects game play should be implemented without public input, internal testing, and then a period for the customer base to see the results of that testing and provide commentary. Lest anyone discount the importance of customer feedback, one only need to review what the new VAs were PROPOSED to become (at the 11th hour) versus what the customer base was able to shape them into via helpful feedback. There were holes aplenty in what was handed us--in the few hours that remained before the preseason began, the customer base (and a couple of helpful testers) were able to salvage the new VAs into something that at the least didn't further inbalance the sim.


Edited by Larry Roadgrader on Dec 25, 2009 09:17:46
 
aceinthehouse
offline
Link
 
Just replying to basic Bort thread here...

Money for Coaches to spend money on...hmmmmm
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#1)Pre-selected Offensive and Defensive Playbooks
#2)Ability to scout all Players attributes from previously former position ONLY (everyone in the game with no blockage)
Call it "Scouting Transcript" that the Coach purchases.
#3)Ability to purchase "Spygate Security" This inables All teams with the inability to scout your team with the "Scout" tab. They must use the play-by-play to see anything of use.
#4)"Coaching Tokens" (why the hell not..lol) The Coaching tokens coincides with my preselected playbook I have at #1 above. Like 8 bonus tokens upgrades advanced equipment....the Coaching tokens upgrades the Coaches playbook. Whether it be adds plays,formations or Coaches Special Abilites,etc.
#5)Coaches with Special Abilities! Coaches with Special Abilites like players can click on certain abilities like Halftime Adjustments,Trick plays,Conservative or Aggressive playcalling,Players Coach,Tactician,Gutsy,Coaches with a lead,Coaches from behind,etc. (These can be upgraded with Coaches Tokens...the higher the upgrade/level,the better he is at this Special Ability)




 
Sexyrichards
offline
Link
 
Coaches should get extra bonuses if they have acquired any trophies during their time of play. That would be cool.
 
william78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Sorry, but our position isn't grounded on any imaginary resistance to change. Instead its based on a couple of principles:

1) Customers PAY FOR the players--they and only they should impact the LONG-TERM build. Its fine that some future development (be it "coaches" or some other idea) provide TEMPORARY boosts to on-the-field performance, but the customer and the customer alone should affect (for better or worse) the LONG-TERM build.

2) Nothing that dramatically affects game play should be implemented without public input, internal testing, and then a period for the customer base to see the results of that testing and provide commentary. Lest anyone discount the importance of customer feedback, one only need to review what the new VAs were PROPOSED to become (at the 11th hour) versus what the customer base was able to shape them into via helpful feedback. There were holes aplenty in what was handed us--in the few hours that remained before the preseason began, the customer base (and a couple of helpful testers) were able to salvage the new VAs into something that at the least didn't further inbalance the sim.




I agree with your second point....thus the forum post.

On the first one I dont think the long term impact on player builds is anything but negligible. I think we just have to agree to disagree on that point
 
Magneto
offline
Link
 
I'm sorry, IMO there is so many things that would make this game more fun than "coaches"

 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by william78
I agree with your second point....thus the forum post.

On the first one I dont think the long term impact on player builds is anything but negligible. I think we just have to agree to disagree on that point


you think a coach that might effect training percentages would not effect the long term build? Over a short career (440 days) + an average of 15 days for offseason and preseason that's 605 days where you earn 2 training points... which is 242 intense trains (I know you are not going to be training on intense every time but I'm keeping it simple). Even if it's just 5% additional train % (something that seems small) that's 12.1 points to an attribute (again that is highly simplified, the actual bonus is probably even more, because of the capping of skills faster leading to better natural gains etc etc etc)

in any case, I would say that's a significant addition to the players build...

the ability to craft eq that would be equal or better to really good advanced eq would probably change the long term build...

hell I could argue that even something that boosted performance on the field (like % chance to not fumble etc) would effect your build. It would give you more leeway and let you run more unbalanced builds without penalty, meaning you wouldn't have to break off your slow build plan to make your player more effective at lower levels. That means you can have more time pumping SPs into your primary stat etc... wouldn't be AS noticeable... but I bet it would effect the capped leagues for sure.

another point about coaches that I would say is that it adds a lot of complexity to the game. Sounds good? Well... balancing issues are already being tweaked constantly and flavor of the season plays and exploits are still pretty rampant. You throw coaches in there and you've got more things to possibly exploit, more combination of things to make an otherwise fine play or build overpowering. This also widens the gap between power gamers and the more casual ones. Even the people that game plan every game. Take a look at every MMO out there, after every major expansion, the power gamers got another step ahead of the casual players (I could pull like 5+ good examples without really thinking but don't want this to get too long).




In any case (more on topic), I grow even more worried about coaches being able to purchase equipment that would help the players on the team etc, because I think that would put more of an advantage on the slow build demotion teams that are sitting on 50 mil in the 14 cap league... it's not as big of an issue now, because a well managed team can start from scratch and still afford all the eq costs if they aren't going nuts on signing bonuses and they are decently competitive. Add additional equipment to buy (potentially for 10+ coaches per team) that's a bigger strain on finances, and that's not even counting their salaries and signing bonuses. I think there would have to be lots of major changes to make coaches viable, and I'm afraid of what those changes would do to the rest of the sim
 
william78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chysil
you think a coach that might effect training percentages would not effect the long term build? Over a short career (440 days) + an average of 15 days for offseason and preseason that's 605 days where you earn 2 training points... which is 242 intense trains (I know you are not going to be training on intense every time but I'm keeping it simple). Even if it's just 5% additional train % (something that seems small) that's 12.1 points to an attribute (again that is highly simplified, the actual bonus is probably even more, because of the capping of skills faster leading to better natural gains etc etc etc)

in any case, I would say that's a significant addition to the players build...

the ability to craft eq that would be equal or better to really good advanced eq would probably change the long term build...

hell I could argue that even something that boosted performance on the field (like % chance to not fumble etc) would effect your build. It would give you more leeway and let you run more unbalanced builds without penalty, meaning you wouldn't have to break off your slow build plan to make your player more effective at lower levels. That means you can have more time pumping SPs into your primary stat etc... wouldn't be AS noticeable... but I bet it would effect the capped leagues for sure.

another point about coaches that I would say is that it adds a lot of complexity to the game. Sounds good? Well... balancing issues are already being tweaked constantly and flavor of the season plays and exploits are still pretty rampant. You throw coaches in there and you've got more things to possibly exploit, more combination of things to make an otherwise fine play or build overpowering. This also widens the gap between power gamers and the more casual ones. Even the people that game plan every game. Take a look at every MMO out there, after every major expansion, the power gamers got another step ahead of the casual players (I could pull like 5+ good examples without really thinking but don't want this to get too long).




In any case (more on topic), I grow even more worried about coaches being able to purchase equipment that would help the players on the team etc, because I think that would put more of an advantage on the slow build demotion teams that are sitting on 50 mil in the 14 cap league... it's not as big of an issue now, because a well managed team can start from scratch and still afford all the eq costs if they aren't going nuts on signing bonuses and they are decently competitive. Add additional equipment to buy (potentially for 10+ coaches per team) that's a bigger strain on finances, and that's not even counting their salaries and signing bonuses. I think there would have to be lots of major changes to make coaches viable, and I'm afraid of what those changes would do to the rest of the sim


Actually I think you've overcalculated the build advantage. Currently break through training is 1 in 8 training sessions on intense (on average)

Take into account that increases the % chance to have a break threw lets say 50% more likely your still only talking 1 in 6

Also on your final point I don't advocate coaches having any equipment.

I agree it adds to the games complexity which is certainly a challenge and something even I would like addressed. My posting is because I believe were going to have coaches and if were going to have them I want them

A. To be interesting for the GLB fabric
B. To not be as overpowering as some of the other options - I believe adding a certain % to plays will be way easier to exploit than the "types" I've come up with (i.e. essentially adding to VA's or off-season training regiments or "unlocking custom plays")

Of course right now the real "biggest" issue to me is the amount of time it takes to build, run , and revise a quality AI based on the opponent my #1 idea would be for some tools to streamline this.
 
RiverRat2
offline
Link
 
This:

Giving even a moment's consideration to coaching at this time does harm to the integrity of the sim and of GLB in general.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by william78


On the first one I dont think the long term impact on player builds is anything but negligible.



Make it absolutely zero effect on long-term builds and you'll find the customer-base more inclined (though not necessarily convinced) of the proposal. Again, the customers PAY for their dots--their long-term build should NOT be at the mercy of anyone but their own good-or-bad decisions regarding the allocation of training, SPs, and VAs.
 
oldbaldone
offline
Link
 
the idea the customer is always right and should always get what he wants is (how should I put this ) dumb. Most of the time the customer is wrong but let's not go into that now.

I don't think coaches should influence player builds outside of game time. coaches do effect the outcome of games and of a teams success so I don't see why we shouldn't have them. Some coaches have major impacts on teams for a number of reasons. would the cowboys have been as great without jimmy johnson as there coach ? Would the patriots got to the superbowl without the coach they have ? would the raiders have been as good without john madden ? I doubt it.

They don't have super trick plays or training secrets no other coach has. They simply use there personnel better and call a better game. They give players the confidence that they are going to win no matter what the situation is and that is what and all glb's coaches should do.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldbaldone
the idea the customer is always right and should always get what he wants is (how should I put this ) dumb. Most of the time the customer is wrong but let's not go into that now.

I don't think coaches should influence player builds outside of game time. coaches do effect the outcome of games and of a teams success so I don't see why we shouldn't have them. Some coaches have major impacts on teams for a number of reasons. would the cowboys have been as great without jimmy johnson as there coach ? Would the patriots got to the superbowl without the coach they have ? would the raiders have been as good without john madden ? I doubt it.

They don't have super trick plays or training secrets no other coach has. They simply use there personnel better and call a better game. They give players the confidence that they are going to win no matter what the situation is and that is what and all glb's coaches should do.


This is a pretty good statement about what should happen if coaches come in. They should be like a piece of EQ that the team owns - helps you now, makes you better, but no effect on you should you move to another team.
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldbaldone
the idea the customer is always right and should always get what he wants is (how should I put this ) dumb. Most of the time the customer is wrong but let's not go into that now.

I don't think coaches should influence player builds outside of game time. coaches do effect the outcome of games and of a teams success so I don't see why we shouldn't have them. Some coaches have major impacts on teams for a number of reasons. would the cowboys have been as great without jimmy johnson as there coach ? Would the patriots got to the superbowl without the coach they have ? would the raiders have been as good without john madden ? I doubt it.

They don't have super trick plays or training secrets no other coach has. They simply use there personnel better and call a better game. They give players the confidence that they are going to win no matter what the situation is and that is what and all glb's coaches should do.


but in that sense, the coaches are already in GLB in the form of the people that set the AI, and it's pretty obvious that some DCs / OCs are better than others. I'd say they already make a significant impact in the games with gameplans etc, and the addition of coaches as well might make the "coaching" aspect of the game more significant that it really is
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
I should mention that Bort himself is against coaches giving permenant bonuses or extra training combos. It got pointed out to him in the discussion when coaching was coming, and he saw the light. Mentioned it in the Project Bort thread on extra training combos.
Originally posted by Bort
Argument:

Gives some players access to permanent training bonuses that others do not have access to, thereby making teams with a full compliment of coaches (likely the winning teams or all-one-man teams) even more attractive.



Originally posted by Bort
It just sorta puts those who don't have access to a coach at a disadvantage. This could discourage some players who don't have a network of friends, or play more casually, or are newer.

We'd also likely see farm teams that serve no purpose other than being a training ground for players via a set of training-only coaches, which puts those who have a network of teams at a larger advantage.

So he sees the negatives and probably won't have coaches add new bonuses that affect them beyond when they leave the team.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.