Originally posted by Chysil
you think a coach that might effect training percentages would not effect the long term build? Over a short career (440 days) + an average of 15 days for offseason and preseason that's 605 days where you earn 2 training points... which is 242 intense trains (I know you are not going to be training on intense every time but I'm keeping it simple). Even if it's just 5% additional train % (something that seems small) that's 12.1 points to an attribute (again that is highly simplified, the actual bonus is probably even more, because of the capping of skills faster leading to better natural gains etc etc etc)
in any case, I would say that's a significant addition to the players build...
the ability to craft eq that would be equal or better to really good advanced eq would probably change the long term build...
hell I could argue that even something that boosted performance on the field (like % chance to not fumble etc) would effect your build. It would give you more leeway and let you run more unbalanced builds without penalty, meaning you wouldn't have to break off your slow build plan to make your player more effective at lower levels. That means you can have more time pumping SPs into your primary stat etc... wouldn't be AS noticeable... but I bet it would effect the capped leagues for sure.
another point about coaches that I would say is that it adds a lot of complexity to the game. Sounds good? Well... balancing issues are already being tweaked constantly and flavor of the season plays and exploits are still pretty rampant. You throw coaches in there and you've got more things to possibly exploit, more combination of things to make an otherwise fine play or build overpowering. This also widens the gap between power gamers and the more casual ones. Even the people that game plan every game. Take a look at every MMO out there, after every major expansion, the power gamers got another step ahead of the casual players (I could pull like 5+ good examples without really thinking but don't want this to get too long).
In any case (more on topic), I grow even more worried about coaches being able to purchase equipment that would help the players on the team etc, because I think that would put more of an advantage on the slow build demotion teams that are sitting on 50 mil in the 14 cap league... it's not as big of an issue now, because a well managed team can start from scratch and still afford all the eq costs if they aren't going nuts on signing bonuses and they are decently competitive. Add additional equipment to buy (potentially for 10+ coaches per team) that's a bigger strain on finances, and that's not even counting their salaries and signing bonuses. I think there would have to be lots of major changes to make coaches viable, and I'm afraid of what those changes would do to the rest of the sim
Actually I think you've overcalculated the build advantage. Currently break through training is 1 in 8 training sessions on intense (on average)
Take into account that increases the % chance to have a break threw lets say 50% more likely your still only talking 1 in 6
Also on your final point I don't advocate coaches having any equipment.
I agree it adds to the games complexity which is certainly a challenge and something even I would like addressed. My posting is because I believe were going to have coaches and if were going to have them I want them
A. To be interesting for the GLB fabric
B. To not be as overpowering as some of the other options - I believe adding a certain % to plays will be way easier to exploit than the "types" I've come up with (i.e. essentially adding to VA's or off-season training regiments or "unlocking custom plays")
Of course right now the real "biggest" issue to me is the amount of time it takes to build, run , and revise a quality AI based on the opponent my #1 idea would be for some tools to streamline this.