User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > A WPL WITHOUT MM-OFGand WW IS BS
Page:
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PatricktheDookie
If you're denying that the roster cap didn't impact WSI more than any other team, then I'd say you're crazy.

If you had S9 WSI versus USA Pro, they're likely a playoff team.

If you had S5 - S8 WSI versus USA Pro, they're a championship contender.

So yes, WSI owned OPL for several seasons. They were extremely good. In season 10, they weren't. That doesn't mean all of OPL is horrible simply because they lost to WSI when WSI was at the top of their game.


LOL! You either underestimate USAPL or overestimate WSI. You assume that WSI now sucks because of the roster cap this season, well every other team they played had the same roster cap. The more likely solution is WSI is playing far tougher teams, or they managed the transition to the roster cap poorly. Perhaps a bit of both.

Either way, we all know WSI would have gone 16-0 in OPL this season...and couldn't even come close to beating a USAPL team that had a winning record.
 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist


I know all those guys and I know for a fact you lost because your tactics suck.



I don't see anyone on ***O*** arguing that point. We won last season because of better tactics. We lost this season because of worse ones. How many special players do you think ***O*** has? How many special players are even in the game? Not a lot. If you compared players position by position for the Elite 8 teams in US Pro how different do you think the builds would be? My guess is that there wouldn't be many glaring differences.

What do you think makes the difference at this point? Players? Maybe 20% unless you have a couple of the special ones, but even these players can be contained if you know what you are doing. We didn't contain Cooter, we lost. Not rocket science. What, what kind of scientist are you again?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Either way, we all know WSI would have gone 16-0 in OPL this season...and couldn't even come close to beating a USAPL team that had a winning record.


Washington Wolfpack is a pretty decent team, right? BDC is in OPL and came pretty close to beating them.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=672531

MEM is a pretty decent team, right? Voodoo is in OPL and came pretty close to beating them.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=675028

There are teams in OPL that are better than WSI atm.
 
maizenhops
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by PatricktheDookie

If you're denying that the roster cap didn't impact WSI more than any other team, then I'd say you're crazy.

If you had S9 WSI versus USA Pro, they're likely a playoff team.

If you had S5 - S8 WSI versus USA Pro, they're a championship contender.

So yes, WSI owned OPL for several seasons. They were extremely good. In season 10, they weren't. That doesn't mean all of OPL is horrible simply because they lost to WSI when WSI was at the top of their game.


LOL! You either underestimate USAPL or overestimate WSI. You assume that WSI now sucks because of the roster cap this season, well every other team they played had the same roster cap. The more likely solution is WSI is playing far tougher teams, or they managed the transition to the roster cap poorly. Perhaps a bit of both.

Either way, we all know WSI would have gone 16-0 in OPL this season...and couldn't even come close to beating a USAPL team that had a winning record.


Look at season 7 WSI http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?season=7&team_id=2016 pretty damn good IYAM they beat the almighty USAPL MEM, Shockers, and Lincoln. Also beat Marblehead that season. I could care less if they had more time to gameplan, that's a dumb ass excuse as most teams don't spend hours and hours gameplanning for every game anyways, at least the good ones don't. WSI had a MUCH different team back in the day.One of the main reasons for their downfall was Havoc and them splitting. If you don't think that played an impact you are on crack. The reason WSI isn't good isn't just because they are in USAPL. It has much more to do with their best players and GMs leaving/

I have no bias in this whatsoever, I just get annoyed when people talk out of their egofilled ass
Edited by kalkmanc on Jul 27, 2009 07:27:39
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
^ I'll give you way back in S7, WSI was damn good, maybe the best in the game. Welcome to 4 seasons ago.

Regarding WW and BDC, that was in the group play for the PWT and I know the WW were trying some things out as it was the third week of the season. *shrug*

I can't speak for MEM vs Voodoo. But again, a win is a win.

kalkmanc, if that is the case, then folks should try and sell WSI's demise as a result of the roster limit.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tdm13
if they lost in the format, they don't deserve to go imo. Should have won their semi if they were that good :|


False. They are in a league where 8 of the 16 best teams in the game are in. Should be 8 usa pro, 2 africa representitives. This isn't a welfare game, bort make this shit happen.
 
Joebarber
offline
Link
 
current format is good, it will all get worked out in the long run
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Not sure how this thread turned to talk of WSI -


As a token GM - and player on the team for the last 4-5 seasons (I think) -

Yes - WSI has had some painful "changes" - Havoc moving on was HUGE - losing runhard's players was HUGE - and there have been some other issues as well.


I know it is always fun to debate that which cannot be proven - but my personal position is - each season's record speaks for itself.

Season 10 was awful - we got our asses kicked repeatedly - over and over by great teams - and not as great teams alike.

We have also had some seasons (in the past) where our record - and our wins - would indicate we were a great, great team - I don't believe that can be argued.

But that being said - beating a top USAPRO team (or several teams) in a tournament - IS an accomplishment - and IS a feather in the cap...but beating a top USAPRO team one time in a season is easier (in my opinion) than facing the full USAPRO season - where you have to face teams in the regular season - and then beat them again in the playoffs.


I hope that doesn't come across wrong - I'm just trying to say that I see both sides of the argument - and in all reality - and in the big picture - playing a full season in USAPRO - where you have to make the playoffs - then win multiple games against the best of the best; in a row - is more impressive than going 3-0 or 4-0 or 5-0 against top usapro teams in tournies and friendlies -

That being said - I don't happen to believe that WSI having a total crap season 10 should tarnish past seasons - each season should be judged on its own merits - without ruining past success and without erasing past failures.
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joebarber
current format is good, it will all get worked out in the long run


 
Jiddy78
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joebarber
current format is good, it will all get worked out in the long run


Try not to botch this one...but I think this is how it goes:

Needs more Pimps IMO
 
PsychoMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
Not sure how this thread turned to talk of WSI -


As a token GM - and player on the team for the last 4-5 seasons (I think) -

Yes - WSI has had some painful "changes" - Havoc moving on was HUGE - losing runhard's players was HUGE - and there have been some other issues as well.


I know it is always fun to debate that which cannot be proven - but my personal position is - each season's record speaks for itself.

Season 10 was awful - we got our asses kicked repeatedly - over and over by great teams - and not as great teams alike.

We have also had some seasons (in the past) where our record - and our wins - would indicate we were a great, great team - I don't believe that can be argued.

But that being said - beating a top USAPRO team (or several teams) in a tournament - IS an accomplishment - and IS a feather in the cap...but beating a top USAPRO team one time in a season is easier (in my opinion) than facing the full USAPRO season - where you have to face teams in the regular season - and then beat them again in the playoffs.


I hope that doesn't come across wrong - I'm just trying to say that I see both sides of the argument - and in all reality - and in the big picture - playing a full season in USAPRO - where you have to make the playoffs - then win multiple games against the best of the best; in a row - is more impressive than going 3-0 or 4-0 or 5-0 against top usapro teams in tournies and friendlies -

That being said - I don't happen to believe that WSI having a total crap season 10 should tarnish past seasons - each season should be judged on its own merits - without ruining past success and without erasing past failures.


Good post.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
As far as things getting 'worked out in the long run', my question then is this:

How will it get worked out?

I mean, let's assume the 4 playoff conference finalists from each league go up. How is this going to change next season? Or are we ditching one system (the everyone gets 4 teams) for the next after one season? In that case, why even bother putting the crappy teams up there to begin with.

Just let the two league title finalists (16 teams) get autobids, then have 16 more wild cards.


I mean the idea that Bort will start with 4 teams per region, but let them relegate out without replacement after one season is utterly foolish.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
As far as things getting 'worked out in the long run', my question then is this:

How will it get worked out?

I mean, let's assume the 4 playoff conference finalists from each league go up. How is this going to change next season? Or are we ditching one system (the everyone gets 4 teams) for the next after one season? In that case, why even bother putting the crappy teams up there to begin with.

Just let the two league title finalists (16 teams) get autobids, then have 16 more wild cards.


I mean the idea that Bort will start with 4 teams per region, but let them relegate out without replacement after one season is utterly foolish.


I imagine the 8 worst teams will get relegated back to their Pro Leagues, and the 8 Champions will take their places.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
I mean, to me there's two system options that make sense.

1) the system that puts the best 32 teams in the league - region regardless
2) the system that flips the conference finalists each and every year, previous results in World League regardless.

If it's 2, then ok, but anything other then 2(that starts out as a 2) is simply wasteful. We already know which conference finalists suck.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PatricktheDookie
Originally posted by islander1

As far as things getting 'worked out in the long run', my question then is this:

How will it get worked out?

I mean, let's assume the 4 playoff conference finalists from each league go up. How is this going to change next season? Or are we ditching one system (the everyone gets 4 teams) for the next after one season? In that case, why even bother putting the crappy teams up there to begin with.

Just let the two league title finalists (16 teams) get autobids, then have 16 more wild cards.


I mean the idea that Bort will start with 4 teams per region, but let them relegate out without replacement after one season is utterly foolish.


I imagine the 8 worst teams will get relegated back to their Pro Leagues, and the 8 Champions will take their places.


Right, but if this happens, why obsess over balancing it to start with when you're only keeping it one season. Seems like a waste of a season.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.