User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Corners are too fast
Page:
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by chronoaug

For what it's worth, that's a really good CB. Hazy can attest for that and he dominated on the las vegas gamblers and normally he's a great CB. Probably a slight vision lapse or not getting first speed to activate. More things went into that specific WR being a superfast monster than purely speed but his speed was certainly at least above 122ish (unless it was a little lower and he had a Streaky VA good day)


There are plenty of examples of WRs getting separation. I just posted it as an example since a few posters were saying that slow CBs were catching WRs in pursuit a lot. Stamina, morale, in play breath, confidence and other stuff play roles though

I've seen a WR with 120+ speed pull away from a safety i know has 107 speed. It happens just not every time. Look at most big passing TDs like that. More goes into it still though


The first play of the game a RB gets chased down by a CB with 11 less points in speed, 1 less point in agility and 2 more points of stamina and only 1 point in closing speed. On the first play the RB catches a passes and is off to the races so unless seeing white lines hurts morale (which is possible) then he had 100 morale at the time. So why does the Rb run down the RB after sticking with a 120+ speed 70+ agility 10+ first step WR for 20 yards?


Honestly, i don't know man. There are definitely weird things that go into sim calculations. Individual tactics and other attributes play a role in speed i'm guessing. I wasn't really arguing against you but just providing some examples and data to look at instead of it just being a big party of everyone crying. Figured it would provide slightly more interesting and constructive conversation
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Except that Steellithium just agreed with me. It's not a Speed issue. Keep thinking that.

This is why you are such a laughingstock in these types of arguments. You don't argue on the basis of evidence or logic or anything of the sort. You "argue" simply by making the same declarative statement over and over again, as if repeating something enough times magically makes it true.

Look at the play again: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587165&pbp_id=11355220

Yes, the CB1 is hurt by coming up on the snap, thus giving up whatever cushion he had. However, if you look at the period of time from which the QB drops back behind the 10 yard line to when the pass is caught, both the CB and WR are running straight ahead as fast as they can. When the QB first crosses that threshold, the WR has a small amount of separation. That separation increases dramatically as the QB continues to drop back, even though the CB is not having vision checks and is just hauling ass upfield to try and catch the WR. This happens because the WR is faster. Once the WR catches the ball, his separation from the CB is over two dots in length, clearly a hell of a lot more than it was earlier in the play.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by PierreThomas

1) 4.5-4.6 guys aren't that slow. My CBs are playing with less speed than my DEs, LBs, FS, SS, RB and even a couple of my DTs are awefully close to the same speed.

Make up your mind. Back when you wanted to talk about how inferior 40 times caused players to drop in the draft, you were suggesting that 4.5-4.6 was slow. Now you want to pretend that it isn't slow. Pick one so I know what to respond to.

Originally posted by

2) You show me one corner that ran a 4.7 in the NFL, just one.

http://www.nfl.com/players/dwightlowery/profile?id=LOW556220

Originally posted by

3) Yes, a 4.5 guy can cover a 4.3 guy with proper technique and shut him down. I'm not saying Cbs need 130 speed to cover 130 speed WR. Not once I have I said this, in fact I have said just the opposite over and over and over and over and over but you guys just paint the picture that I want a foot race because it is the only way you guys can make an argument.

Sure, that's the only way we're able to make an argument. It's not like we've provided replays proving you wrong or anything. Nope, nobody posted anything like that.


I said running a 4.5-4.6 40 drops guys from the first round to late rounds. I didn't say 4.7-4.8 guys because I've never seen a decent corner prospect run that slow.



Despite becoming San Jose State’s first All-American in consecutive seasons, Lowery went from one of Mel Kiper Jr.’s top 25 prospects to a fourth-round selection in just one year. Lowery, who said he became a better player in ’07 and wasn’t challenged nearly as much, was timed at 4.54 seconds in the 40 at the combine.
http://www.newyorkjets.com/news/articles/show/2174-dwight-lowery-has-first-round-instincts

Try again.

I have said that there are a few select WRs that can beat corners deep all along. I'm saying the vast majority of speedsters don't do shit against much slower CBs.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Bukowski

Except that Steellithium just agreed with me. It's not a Speed issue. Keep thinking that.

This is why you are such a laughingstock in these types of arguments. You don't argue on the basis of evidence or logic or anything of the sort. You "argue" simply by making the same declarative statement over and over again, as if repeating something enough times magically makes it true.

Look at the play again: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587165&pbp_id=11355220

Yes, the CB1 is hurt by coming up on the snap, thus giving up whatever cushion he had. However, if you look at the period of time from which the QB drops back behind the 10 yard line to when the pass is caught, both the CB and WR are running straight ahead as fast as they can. When the QB first crosses that threshold, the WR has a small amount of separation. That separation increases dramatically as the QB continues to drop back, even though the CB is not having vision checks and is just hauling ass upfield to try and catch the WR. This happens because the WR is faster. Once the WR catches the ball, his separation from the CB is over two dots in length, clearly a hell of a lot more than it was earlier in the play.


I'm willing to bet that the fastest WR on your team can't beat my 88 speed cb one time in a friendly if you are up for it.
Edited by PierreThomas on Jul 10, 2009 00:34:28
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Bukowski

Except that Steellithium just agreed with me. It's not a Speed issue. Keep thinking that.

This is why you are such a laughingstock in these types of arguments. You don't argue on the basis of evidence or logic or anything of the sort. You "argue" simply by making the same declarative statement over and over again, as if repeating something enough times magically makes it true.

Look at the play again: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587165&pbp_id=11355220

Yes, the CB1 is hurt by coming up on the snap, thus giving up whatever cushion he had. However, if you look at the period of time from which the QB drops back behind the 10 yard line to when the pass is caught, both the CB and WR are running straight ahead as fast as they can. When the QB first crosses that threshold, the WR has a small amount of separation. That separation increases dramatically as the QB continues to drop back, even though the CB is not having vision checks and is just hauling ass upfield to try and catch the WR. This happens because the WR is faster. Once the WR catches the ball, his separation from the CB is over two dots in length, clearly a hell of a lot more than it was earlier in the play.


I don't know how many times it needs to be said.

There are other things at play, other than Speed.

Fuck you if you don't believe it, that's your problem.
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by jdbolick

Originally posted by Bukowski


Except that Steellithium just agreed with me. It's not a Speed issue. Keep thinking that.

This is why you are such a laughingstock in these types of arguments. You don't argue on the basis of evidence or logic or anything of the sort. You "argue" simply by making the same declarative statement over and over again, as if repeating something enough times magically makes it true.

Look at the play again: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587165&pbp_id=11355220

Yes, the CB1 is hurt by coming up on the snap, thus giving up whatever cushion he had. However, if you look at the period of time from which the QB drops back behind the 10 yard line to when the pass is caught, both the CB and WR are running straight ahead as fast as they can. When the QB first crosses that threshold, the WR has a small amount of separation. That separation increases dramatically as the QB continues to drop back, even though the CB is not having vision checks and is just hauling ass upfield to try and catch the WR. This happens because the WR is faster. Once the WR catches the ball, his separation from the CB is over two dots in length, clearly a hell of a lot more than it was earlier in the play.


I'm willing to bet that the fastest WR on your team can't beat my 88 speed cb one time in a friendly if you are up for it.


Why don't you PM the Washington Bullets and let Balls Deep give it a try against your guys. Balls Deep is a speedy monster. I'm guessing (i don't know anybody personally from that team) that he's 125ish speed and maybe even has streaky VA (and had a good day on that play). PM the owner of balls deep or the Bullets owner and ask maybe. Just curious because that guy looks really really fast. Maybe he'd let you in on his build somewhat since you used to be in usapl and i'm sure you sorta know him

Or you can wait till season 11 and give it a try as it seems pretty obvious you guys will promote this season
Edited by chronoaug on Jul 10, 2009 00:38:44
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Despite becoming San Jose State’s first All-American in consecutive seasons, Lowery went from one of Mel Kiper Jr.’s top 25 prospects to a fourth-round selection in just one year. Lowery, who said he became a better player in ’07 and wasn’t challenged nearly as much, was timed at 4.54 seconds in the 40 at the combine.
http://www.newyorkjets.com/news/articles/show/2174-dwight-lowery-has-first-round-instincts Try again.

http://www.usatoday.com/sports/football/nfl/2008-03-19-sw-defensive-backs_N.htm

Originally posted by USA Today
13. Dwight Lowery, San Jose State, 5-11, 190, 3rd/4th: Lowery has amazing ball instincts, evidenced by his 13 interceptions in only two years with the Spartans. That was not a surprise after he stole 13 passes and set a California community college record by returning them 439 yards the previous two years at Cabrillo Junior College. It's all a result of marvelous body control, exceptional hand/eye coordination and a coach's knowledge of the game that made him a natural to call defensive plays.

Although he showed decent coverage skills at East-West Shrine workouts, his 40 at the combine (ranging from 4.54 to 4.7 seconds) are a concern.

 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by jdbolick
This is why you are such a laughingstock in these types of arguments. You don't argue on the basis of evidence or logic or anything of the sort. You "argue" simply by making the same declarative statement over and over again, as if repeating something enough times magically makes it true.


I don't know how many times it needs to be said.

There are other things at play, other than Speed.

Fuck you if you don't believe it, that's your problem.

The fact that you didn't actually mean to prove my own statement about your behavior makes it all the more amusing.
Edited by jdbolick on Jul 10, 2009 00:42:24
 
Link
 
Someone should make a completely illogical thread to complain about something that isn't broken in the sim in an attempt to get Bort to nerf stuff by getting people to make it dozens of pages long. Oh wait.
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Bukowski

Except that Steellithium just agreed with me. It's not a Speed issue. Keep thinking that.

This is why you are such a laughingstock in these types of arguments. You don't argue on the basis of evidence or logic or anything of the sort. You "argue" simply by making the same declarative statement over and over again, as if repeating something enough times magically makes it true.

Look at the play again: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587165&pbp_id=11355220

Yes, the CB1 is hurt by coming up on the snap, thus giving up whatever cushion he had. However, if you look at the period of time from which the QB drops back behind the 10 yard line to when the pass is caught, both the CB and WR are running straight ahead as fast as they can. When the QB first crosses that threshold, the WR has a small amount of separation. That separation increases dramatically as the QB continues to drop back, even though the CB is not having vision checks and is just hauling ass upfield to try and catch the WR. This happens because the WR is faster. Once the WR catches the ball, his separation from the CB is over two dots in length, clearly a hell of a lot more than it was earlier in the play.


First Step fired on that receiver, and that is the key to the speed on this play. The CB didn't start accelerating till it was too late. Also he did get close to the WR, so it is possible he missed the bump he was trying for. Speed does matter, as that is what made the level of separation possible. But any receiver with around the same speed as the CB would have toasted him after the bump failed. The FS really screwed up.

Also the CB's First Step fired as well, it was just in the wrong direction.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Also the CB's First Step fired as well, it was just in the wrong direction.


I know...it's incredible that this hasn't been fixed yet. It's as if having First Step is a detriment to some CBs because they have to decelerate before going downfield.
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23
Originally posted by steellithium

Also the CB's First Step fired as well, it was just in the wrong direction.


I know...it's incredible that this hasn't been fixed yet. It's as if having First Step is a detriment to some CBs because they have to decelerate before going downfield.


It's even more annoying for Safeties in a deep zone who first step quickly backwards for no reason taking them out of run plays. If you're in zone coverage far back like that you don't need to jump back. I wish i could get rid of the first step from my FS but you need it to up your other SAs. Only useful for when he plays close to the line (which is rarely)
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23
Originally posted by steellithium

Also the CB's First Step fired as well, it was just in the wrong direction.


I know...it's incredible that this hasn't been fixed yet. It's as if having First Step is a detriment to some CBs because they have to decelerate before going downfield.


Yeah, but that wouldn't have happened without press coverage. If someone plans on playing press all the time, First Step probably isn't the way to go. Although it could be argued you get the bump on the receiver closer to the line.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23

Originally posted by steellithium


Also the CB's First Step fired as well, it was just in the wrong direction.


I know...it's incredible that this hasn't been fixed yet. It's as if having First Step is a detriment to some CBs because they have to decelerate before going downfield.


Yeah, but that wouldn't have happened without press coverage. If someone plans on playing press all the time, First Step probably isn't the way to go. Although it could be argued you get the bump on the receiver closer to the line.


lol at the fact I noticed it, and testers haven't.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23
Someone should make a completely illogical thread to complain about something that isn't broken in the sim in an attempt to get Bort to nerf stuff by getting people to make it dozens of pages long. Oh wait.


LMAO at a guy that has 5 players, all defensive backs under level 40 that has never accomplished anything at any level of this game acting like he knows what he is talking about.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.