User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Ken1

Bort made a mistake in scaling back breaking tackles before. All that happened is it allowed people to go back to Speed, Speed, Speed.

Basically, a good meter is that if your Speed + Agility > Strength + Tackling, you should not be able to consistently tackle power backs. People should have to train LBs' Strength and Tackling close to how they train CBs' Speed and Agility. That's much more like football.

There should be no number that consistently (meaning 90% or something) tackles someone who's gone all out as a power back (unless you went all out on stopping them, like 90 Tackling and 80 Strength), but you should do a very good job if, say, Strength and Tackling are second capped and you have most of your equipment in Tackling.

Bort needs to stand his ground here. No more Speed-only players succeeding at positions where they don't in real life.


Agility should NOT work as a negative.


Not in tackling itself, you're right. I was using it as a measure of how much people devote to being real fast compared to having the strength to fight strength.
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Kira

Originally posted by Iceman16


Strength is more important for preventing fumbles than carrying is.


Now you're just being ridiculous. That's ridiculous.


Actually, from experience? It's not at all. That's why Strength backs with 30 carrying fumble way less than elusive backs with capped carrying.


That's ridiculous. Carrying has a much larger impact than strength in fumbling. If your personal results are different, it's because of a number of things mainly competition, energy and morale.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 21:42:16
 
ozzfan1317
offline
Link
 
I sya 70 tackling and Strength should be enough to consisently get the job done. In all honesty if your LB has 80 or 90 speed there is a reason why he should just stick to pass coverage.
 
whatspeakyou
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by Bort

Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too



To directly answer this - I'd think that 60+ Tackling with even 0 Strength should be enough to tackle... BUT I think that the Strengths should be compared - not for deciding if a tackle is successful or not, but to see how many extra yards the ball carrier can get. So a 100 Strength ball carrier vs a 20 Strength Defender should end in a tackle - even if the defender is dragged 5 yards before the tackle actually succeeds.



if i understand it correctly, the tackling skill is related to RL tackling form. The better you are at it, the more you tackles you get. But, if you don't have any strength behind the tackles, it's basically more of a nuisance than anything.

You can have the greatest form in the world, but if you bounce of Brandon Jacobs like you're trying to tackle a tire, it doesn't matter how good your form is now does it?


100 str vs. 20 str? and that should end in a tackle? get out of here. you just made power backs useless. they thrive on trucking over the first defender to get their extra yards.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ozzfan1317
I sya 70 tackling and Strength should be enough to consisently get the job done. In all honesty if your LB has 80 or 90 speed there is a reason why he should just stick to pass coverage.


+1
 
IIAMLEGEND
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Bort made a mistake in scaling back breaking tackles before. All that happened is it allowed people to go back to Speed, Speed, Speed.

Basically, a good meter is that if your Speed + Agility > Strength + Tackling, you should not be able to consistently tackle power backs. People should have to train LBs' Strength and Tackling close to how they train CBs' Speed and Agility. That's much more like football.

There should be no number that consistently (meaning 90% or something) tackles someone who's gone all out as a power back (unless you went all out on stopping them, like 90 Tackling and 80 Strength), but you should do a very good job if, say, Strength and Tackling are second capped and you have most of your equipment in Tackling.

Bort needs to stand his ground here. No more Speed-only players succeeding at positions where they don't in real life.




Tbh all this goes back to a key philosophy for this game.


"Balanced builds suck."

Quote me on that. Either you build strong well tackling LB's and get > by speed backs, or build pass rushing speed back killing monsters and get ran over. You can't have it both ways.
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Carrying has a much larger impact than strength in fumbling. If your personal results are different, it's because of a number of things mainly competition, energy and morale.
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Kira

Originally posted by Iceman16


Strength is more important for preventing fumbles than carrying is.


Now you're just being ridiculous. That's ridiculous.


Actually, from experience? It's not at all. That's why Strength backs with 30 carrying fumble way less than elusive backs with capped carrying.


STR should have nearly 0% affect on fumbles while carry should have a near 100% affect.

Start making the 30 carry guys with 90 STR 70 Speed fumble 4 times a game when hit by 60/60 STR/TKL defenders.
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 21:42:46
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kira
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by Kira


Originally posted by Iceman16



Strength is more important for preventing fumbles than carrying is.


Now you're just being ridiculous. That's ridiculous.


Actually, from experience? It's not at all. That's why Strength backs with 30 carrying fumble way less than elusive backs with capped carrying.


That's ridiculous.


Your argument against it is ridiculous.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kira
Carrying has a much larger impact than strength in fumbling. If your personal results are different, it's because of a number of things mainly competition, energy and morale.


The formula for deciding if you hang on to the ball would agree with you.
 
george96
offline
Link
 
I think the main factor affecting this should be tackling. Strength should not be a very high pre-requisite for making a tackle as small CB's can tackle RB's. However they should have some!

Say something like Strength + 1/2Carrying + Appropriate SA's = Chance to break a tackle

and

Tackling +1/2 Strength + Appropriate SA's = Chance to make a tackle
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
there Bort has spoken
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 21:43:19
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by Ken1


Bort made a mistake in scaling back breaking tackles before. All that happened is it allowed people to go back to Speed, Speed, Speed.

Basically, a good meter is that if your Speed + Agility > Strength + Tackling, you should not be able to consistently tackle power backs. People should have to train LBs' Strength and Tackling close to how they train CBs' Speed and Agility. That's much more like football.

There should be no number that consistently (meaning 90% or something) tackles someone who's gone all out as a power back (unless you went all out on stopping them, like 90 Tackling and 80 Strength), but you should do a very good job if, say, Strength and Tackling are second capped and you have most of your equipment in Tackling.

Bort needs to stand his ground here. No more Speed-only players succeeding at positions where they don't in real life.


Agility should NOT work as a negative.


Not in tackling itself, you're right. I was using it as a measure of how much people devote to being real fast compared to having the strength to fight strength.


I'm aware of your point, but agility has a lot to do with balance and footwork. I understand how speed can work against you. Agility NEVER will work against anyone in a sports situation.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by Kira


Originally posted by Iceman16



Strength is more important for preventing fumbles than carrying is.


Now you're just being ridiculous. That's ridiculous.


Actually, from experience? It's not at all. That's why Strength backs with 30 carrying fumble way less than elusive backs with capped carrying.


STR should have nearly 0% affect on fumbles while carry should have a near 100% affect.

Start making the 30 carry guys with 90 STR 70 Speed fumble 4 times a game when hit by 60/60 STR/TKL defenders.


I agree, but that's still not currently the case.
 
Snipeshow
offline
Link
 
inafterepic'd
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.