Originally posted by uscbucsfan
200+ points is realistic? Because I have seen that often...100 points happens regularly ...its a game, there are tons of things that are unrealistic...I seriously doubt any NFL game has ever come close to having 90-100 plays on one side of the ball either...thats like 40-50 more plays than in real life...too many factors make this unrealistic, and it's stupid to try to argue this. There is no reason why lower level bad builds should be able to stop a DE...Ive seen OTs with 12 speed, 17 agility, and 80 blocking...why should that statue be able to stop a DE with 70 agility 70 speed?
if you completely gut the DEs, which is what you are asking, then scores would be over 300 normally...and that would be realistic?
You aren't getting it. I'm not asking to gut the DE's, but to bring them in line with reality.
Oronis, who's been angry at "DE whiners," accepted my points as reasonable.
You'd be right that an OT with 12 Speed and 17 Agility shouldn't be able to stop a good DE. But very few OT's have Agility nearly that low, and while 12 Speed is too low for an OT he also shouldn't give up sack after sack.
Or, to use Oronis' post, which quoted mine...
Originally posted by oronis
Originally posted by Ken1
I'm sure of three things:
1) Speed helps DE's too much. The very description of "evasive" pass rushing says the player uses his "agility."
2) Strength isn't important enough to DE's, and (most importantly)
3) There are WAY too many sacks by the best pass rushing DE's.
Thanks for the thoughtful response. I like this list, it's much more balanced and rational than what the majority of complainers are posting. I don't have a problem with DEs needing more Agility to swim and rip past the OT, rather than raw speed to avoid the block all together. I've always thought positions should either have relative stats, or position caps (IE, a WR with 30 speed is faster than a C with 30 speed / or a WR's speed softcap starts at 70 instead of 48, while a C's speed softcap is at 30 instead of 48).
As for Strength, I don't have a problem with that either. If you force contact through natural game mechanics, rather than just hotfixing it and requiring them to lock because Bort can't figure a better way around it, this is probably already taken care of.
And lastly, I don't have problems with reducing sacks for the most powerful DEs, but not at the expense of other DEs. There are some DEs that get 1 or 2 sacks a year. Don't make them even less relevant because they didn't dump all their points into Speed and Agility. Also, as you reduce sacks, you have to give something in return. That way having a DE isn't boring. You either need to increase hurries and the radius of pressure, or somehow figure out a way to get them more involved in the run stopping. Perhaps allow them to attempt tackles even though they are engaged with a blocker more often. Right now a lot of RBS can rush right over the D-line if they are engaged with an O-lineman.
Oronis has a reasonable position.
You don't, and seem to think that if you have a fast enough DE he should be able to decimate the opposing offense.