User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by uscbucsfan
well it seems that every league has 2-4 gutted teams...so I would say 40-50 would actually be reasonable...When a level 25 DE goes up against a 13 OT they should get 10 sacks...especially when they have a bad build


That breaks the NFL record by about 3 (if I remember right), so I assume in that case you'd be fine with QB's getting 30% over the NFL record yards passing when facing a gutted team, and running backs 30% over the NFL record yards rushing?
 
uscbucsfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by uscbucsfan

well it seems that every league has 2-4 gutted teams...so I would say 40-50 would actually be reasonable...When a level 25 DE goes up against a 13 OT they should get 10 sacks...especially when they have a bad build


That breaks the NFL record by about 3 (if I remember right), so I assume in that case you'd be fine with QB's getting 30% over the NFL record yards passing when facing a gutted team, and running backs 30% over the NFL record yards rushing?


people need to quit comparing this to the NFL...in the NFL there is not this many players, teams, plays....etc..but if you insist on comparing, yes a decent NFL DE would get 10-15 sacks on me...I mean thats basically what we are talking about with 10+ levels of difference...and bad builds...

ever play Madden? A football game? I have gotten 78 sacks in a season from that...video game...not real life, get it?
Last edited Nov 17, 2008 09:21:03
 
DavidD458
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by uscbucsfan


ever play Madden? A football game? I have gotten 78 sacks in a season from that...video game...not real life, get it?


I'm impressed.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by uscbucsfan
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by uscbucsfan


well it seems that every league has 2-4 gutted teams...so I would say 40-50 would actually be reasonable...When a level 25 DE goes up against a 13 OT they should get 10 sacks...especially when they have a bad build


That breaks the NFL record by about 3 (if I remember right), so I assume in that case you'd be fine with QB's getting 30% over the NFL record yards passing when facing a gutted team, and running backs 30% over the NFL record yards rushing?


people need to quit comparing this to the NFL...in the NFL there is not this many players, teams, plays....etc..but if you insist on comparing, yes a decent NFL DE would get 10-15 sacks on me...I mean thats basically what we are talking about with 10+ levels of difference...and bad builds...

ever play Madden? A football game? I have gotten 78 sacks in a season from that...video game...not real life, get it?


It's an attempt to simulate real life, just as Madden is. And yes, I play Madden, and I play with the sliders until I get realistic results. A couple games neither team gets a sack, down go the pass blocking sliders for both human and cpu (since I play "coaching only," like in this game, it's especially comparable).

If both teams pass for 400+ yards one game, up goes the knockdown slider or down goes the pass accuracy slider, both human and cpu.

I've already said that whatever the stat, the best players getting double what usually leads the NFL is fine in GLB. The averages (average yards per rush/pass attempt, number of sacks recorded by the average team) should be as close to NFL and NCAA levels as possible. That requires, due to greater talent and build differences, that the top guys can get about double real life in whatever category.

But whatever level you want to call acceptable, you have to accept it across the board. Some of the same people who say a DE averaging 8 sacks a game is fine scream about QB's who pass for 400 yards a game, even though that wouldn't break the NFL record while the 8 sacks in a game would.
 
arcadecowboy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by uscbucsfan
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by uscbucsfan


well it seems that every league has 2-4 gutted teams...so I would say 40-50 would actually be reasonable...When a level 25 DE goes up against a 13 OT they should get 10 sacks...especially when they have a bad build


That breaks the NFL record by about 3 (if I remember right), so I assume in that case you'd be fine with QB's getting 30% over the NFL record yards passing when facing a gutted team, and running backs 30% over the NFL record yards rushing?


people need to quit comparing this to the NFL...in the NFL there is not this many players, teams, plays....etc..but if you insist on comparing, yes a decent NFL DE would get 10-15 sacks on me...I mean thats basically what we are talking about with 10+ levels of difference...and bad builds...

ever play Madden? A football game? I have gotten 78 sacks in a season from that...video game...not real life, get it?


You always hear these back-and-forth arguments on sports sim sites, and while you're right, this isn't real life and this isn't the NFL, many of us playing and paying *want* the stats to be similar to the NFL (or even DIA football), we want it to resemble the game we recognize. It's the same reason most people want people on TV shows and movies to behave like we think real people would or could behave. It's the very reason Madden bored me once I got the hang of it, and the same reason I stopped paying for EA's college football game. Some people don't care if it's realistic, some do.
 
uscbucsfan
offline
Link
 
200+ points is realistic? Because I have seen that often...100 points happens regularly ...its a game, there are tons of things that are unrealistic...I seriously doubt any NFL game has ever come close to having 90-100 plays on one side of the ball either...thats like 40-50 more plays than in real life(which contributes to the higher stats as well)...too many factors make this unrealistic, and it's stupid to try to argue this. There is no reason why lower level bad builds should be able to stop a DE...Ive seen OTs with 12 speed, 17 agility, and 80 blocking...why should that statue be able to stop a DE with 70 agility 70 speed?

if you completely gut the DEs, which is what you are asking, then scores would be over 300 normally...and that would be realistic?
Last edited Nov 17, 2008 09:42:05
 
uscbucsfan
offline
Link
 
I have a DE with 8 sacks in 2 games...1 game was against an OT who was 13 levels lower, another was against a lower level horrible build OT. 1 game I played against a great build and got 0 sacks, a couple hurries...but that is realistic. If you make it to where the DEs don't get sacks against garbage players, then OTs on their level will dominate them

I feel like some of you aren't thinking logically about this...low levels and bad builds are going to give up sacks....good builds and even levels are not....get it?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by uscbucsfan
200+ points is realistic? Because I have seen that often...100 points happens regularly ...its a game, there are tons of things that are unrealistic...I seriously doubt any NFL game has ever come close to having 90-100 plays on one side of the ball either...thats like 40-50 more plays than in real life...too many factors make this unrealistic, and it's stupid to try to argue this. There is no reason why lower level bad builds should be able to stop a DE...Ive seen OTs with 12 speed, 17 agility, and 80 blocking...why should that statue be able to stop a DE with 70 agility 70 speed?

if you completely gut the DEs, which is what you are asking, then scores would be over 300 normally...and that would be realistic?


You aren't getting it. I'm not asking to gut the DE's, but to bring them in line with reality.

Oronis, who's been angry at "DE whiners," accepted my points as reasonable.

You'd be right that an OT with 12 Speed and 17 Agility shouldn't be able to stop a good DE. But very few OT's have Agility nearly that low, and while 12 Speed is too low for an OT he also shouldn't give up sack after sack.

Or, to use Oronis' post, which quoted mine...

Originally posted by oronis
Originally posted by Ken1

I'm sure of three things:

1) Speed helps DE's too much. The very description of "evasive" pass rushing says the player uses his "agility."

2) Strength isn't important enough to DE's, and (most importantly)

3) There are WAY too many sacks by the best pass rushing DE's.


Thanks for the thoughtful response. I like this list, it's much more balanced and rational than what the majority of complainers are posting. I don't have a problem with DEs needing more Agility to swim and rip past the OT, rather than raw speed to avoid the block all together. I've always thought positions should either have relative stats, or position caps (IE, a WR with 30 speed is faster than a C with 30 speed / or a WR's speed softcap starts at 70 instead of 48, while a C's speed softcap is at 30 instead of 48).

As for Strength, I don't have a problem with that either. If you force contact through natural game mechanics, rather than just hotfixing it and requiring them to lock because Bort can't figure a better way around it, this is probably already taken care of.

And lastly, I don't have problems with reducing sacks for the most powerful DEs, but not at the expense of other DEs. There are some DEs that get 1 or 2 sacks a year. Don't make them even less relevant because they didn't dump all their points into Speed and Agility. Also, as you reduce sacks, you have to give something in return. That way having a DE isn't boring. You either need to increase hurries and the radius of pressure, or somehow figure out a way to get them more involved in the run stopping. Perhaps allow them to attempt tackles even though they are engaged with a blocker more often. Right now a lot of RBS can rush right over the D-line if they are engaged with an O-lineman.


Oronis has a reasonable position.

You don't, and seem to think that if you have a fast enough DE he should be able to decimate the opposing offense.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by uscbucsfan
I have a DE with 8 sacks in 2 games...1 game was against an OT who was 13 levels lower, another was against a lower level horrible build OT. 1 game I played against a great build and got 0 sacks, a couple hurries...but that is realistic. If you make it to where the DEs don't get sacks against garbage players, then OTs on their level will dominate them

I feel like some of you aren't thinking logically about this...low levels and bad builds are going to give up sacks....good builds and even levels are not....get it?


Then a QB against a bad secondary should pass for 800 yards, right?
 
uscbucsfan
offline
Link
 
no you are not being realistic...you are asking sack totals to be lowered but go look at who is giving up the sacks...bad players, some are awful players. If you lower those sacks than any DE no matter how good would never ever get a sack on a decent OT...do you understand this?

If you want to put this in a real perspective, how many sacks would you give up to an NFL DE? I bet he would decimate any record...10+ levels of difference is a ton I think there should be 20 sacks against that player, I think it has been nerfed enough
 
uscbucsfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by uscbucsfan

I have a DE with 8 sacks in 2 games...1 game was against an OT who was 13 levels lower, another was against a lower level horrible build OT. 1 game I played against a great build and got 0 sacks, a couple hurries...but that is realistic. If you make it to where the DEs don't get sacks against garbage players, then OTs on their level will dominate them

I feel like some of you aren't thinking logically about this...low levels and bad builds are going to give up sacks....good builds and even levels are not....get it?


Then a QB against a bad secondary should pass for 800 yards, right?


Bad secondarys give up 200 points...but that is realistic apparently and the sacks aren't, it's all relative
 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zable
Originally posted by Bort
Also, I'm thinking of improving "Protector" a little maybe to give more of a speed/turning ability boost, and also giving a bonus to side-to-side movement to avoid losing too much speed when blocking.


Bort im sure you realize that the Protector skill does nothing for the Right Offensive Tackle according to the skill description so how will that help them out?


That exactly. Shock Block on the other hand seems perfect to fix the issue. Bort would just have to balance it for being a lesser tier SA. But the OT "smashing into the defender" seems to be exactly the issue. If the DE is all speed, then he'd be "stunned" momentarily. The OT would still need enough Agility and maybe Speed to get that initial "smash".

 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by uscbucsfan
If you want to put this in a real perspective, how many sacks would you give up to an NFL DE?


I already know I'd get OWNED. At some point I'd just go 'Last Boy Scout' and shoot the bastard.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TJ Spikes
But the OT "smashing into the defender" seems to be exactly the issue. If the DE is all speed, then he'd be "stunned" momentarily. The OT would still need enough Agility and maybe Speed to get that initial "smash".


I agree. That's why I posted the following set of replays where my OT gets beat for two sacks by a very good and exceptionally fast speed-rushing DE (had 100 sacks last season) who was three levels higher. You can get an idea of the DE's speed/agility by his pursuit away from the LOS.

Yet, outside of those two sacks, you see my OT making contact and getting those 'smashes' in against the DE....sometimes several on the same play. The interaction looks very realistic to me and shows what is possible in the game as it is now and prior to any future OT/DE updates:

Originally posted by SAGA45
Originally posted by SAGA45


Here's a couple plays of my OT(LvL 33 at the time of these replays) getting beat by a LvL 36 speed DE:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419932
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419862

Here are the rest of the pass plays in that same game where my OT faced the same DE:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419709
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419744
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419802
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419809
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419879
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419978
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419982
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419992
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420022
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420025
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420040
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420048
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420072
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420095
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420101

As you can see, outside of the 1 play where the DE just blew by my OT for the sack, none were plays where the two didn't engage.

Also, my OT did a solid job of keeping the DE at bay when facing him 1-on-1 with no help from a RB.

You always see my OT getting back, set quickly, and then engage the DE - keeping him at bay except for the two sacks. But even on one of those the DE had to work for it by shedding my OT's block first.

Again, this was against a speed DE who was 3 levels higher. Some good, realistic battles to. Probably the result of a couple of good builds going at it.


If possible, I'd like to get Bort's thoughts on what's likely happening under the hood on these replays as far as the math and interaction between my OT and the DE. I doubt Bort responds but I'm just curious, especially since that DE was one of the 100+ sack guys in season 5 that prompted the code adjustments.
Last edited Nov 17, 2008 10:19:34
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by uscbucsfan
no you are not being realistic...you are asking sack totals to be lowered but go look at who is giving up the sacks...bad players, some are awful players. If you lower those sacks than any DE no matter how good would never ever get a sack on a decent OT...do you understand this?

If you want to put this in a real perspective, how many sacks would you give up to an NFL DE? I bet he would decimate any record...10+ levels of difference is a ton I think there should be 20 sacks against that player, I think it has been nerfed enough


I wouldn't be even Level 1 now that I've aged and gotten out of shape, and at my best I was about a Level 8 poorly built FS or CB. So, yeah, I'd probably give up a sack or hurry on every single play. I would have when I was in my 20's, too, even though back then I was faster than some NFL OT's...because Speed isn't everything.

I wasn't ever nearly strong enough to play even high school OT, even when I was well beyond high school age.

But in my early 20's the way GLB's current sim is set up I wouldn't be a truly awful DE; in a Level 13 capped league I'd probably get some sacks as my 22 year old self just because I was very fast and accelerated very quickly...even though I never had any Strength. That's part of the problem.

In real life had I played DE against a decent high school team, even when I was 22, their OT would pancake me 2/3 of the time.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.