User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
You guys keep ignoring the fact that the 10 INTs (which is obviously ridiculous itself) weren't the only statistical aberration. As they noted, the pancakes were 23-0, and despite being a strong rushing team, Nashville averaged less than a yard per carry. The result is not remotely realistic, not even on a team's absolute worst day. It's basically like something in the simulation transformed Nashville into a much lower level team.

I have no dog in this fight, I'm just concerned about the reliability of a game I've already spent money on and planned to spend more on. Those of you who think you are doing the right thing by sucking up to Bort are not doing him any favors. Consumer confidence is critically important for any service, and people need to believe that the results are both realistic and justified. Nashville getting blown out by Miami is possible even though they're similarly ranked. Nashville experiencing that many extraordinary statistical anomalies is not in any way realistic, and is clear proof of something being faulty in the simulation programming.


And you keep ignoring the fact that Nashville had a grand total of 2 pancakes the last time the two teams faced off, compared to 14 for Miami. That game was much closer, so Miami passed more throughout the game and Nashville ran more often.

Sorry, the pancake argument holds no weight, its actually laughable. How does a team in pass protection register massive pancake numbers in a game? Answer - it does not. And the team could only register 2 pancakes in a game where they did run. Sorry, epic phail for you.

As for the INT's, I've pointed out that an NFL QB has thrown 8 on his own before and a NCAA Div 1 QB has thrown 9 in a game. Sure, it doesn't happen often, but it can happen.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
You guys keep ignoring the fact that the 10 INTs (which is obviously ridiculous itself) weren't the only statistical aberration. As they noted, the pancakes were 23-0, and despite being a strong rushing team, Nashville averaged less than a yard per carry. The result is not remotely realistic, not even on a team's absolute worst day. It's basically like something in the simulation transformed Nashville into a much lower level team.

I have no dog in this fight, I'm just concerned about the reliability of a game I've already spent money on and planned to spend more on. Those of you who think you are doing the right thing by sucking up to Bort are not doing him any favors. Consumer confidence is critically important for any service, and people need to believe that the results are both realistic and justified. Nashville getting blown out by Miami is possible even though they're similarly ranked. Nashville experiencing that many extraordinary statistical anomalies is not in any way realistic, and is clear proof of something being faulty in the simulation programming.


14-2 pancakes for Miami in a close game
23-0 pancakes for Miami in a route
Not that big of a diffrence between the two games considering if you go by the play types then Nash should of got pancaked even more.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
You guys keep ignoring the fact that the 10 INTs (which is obviously ridiculous itself) weren't the only statistical aberration. As they noted, the pancakes were 23-0, and despite being a strong rushing team, Nashville averaged less than a yard per carry. The result is not remotely realistic, not even on a team's absolute worst day. It's basically like something in the simulation transformed Nashville into a much lower level team.

I have no dog in this fight, I'm just concerned about the reliability of a game I've already spent money on and planned to spend more on. Those of you who think you are doing the right thing by sucking up to Bort are not doing him any favors. Consumer confidence is critically important for any service, and people need to believe that the results are both realistic and justified. Nashville getting blown out by Miami is possible even though they're similarly ranked. Nashville experiencing that many extraordinary statistical anomalies is not in any way realistic, and is clear proof of something being faulty in the simulation programming.


Okay...wait a strong rushing team shut down in the playoffs. Like the 2006 Kansas City Chiefs? Okay they didn't have 10 INTs, but individually any one of these occurrences doesn't prove the SIM is broken. As a collection they are separate random events. Does it suck...yes. But remember when the QB is sucking and he is your "field general" I'm guessing just like he would pick your team up, he drags your team down!!!
 
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
Originally posted by jdbolick

You guys keep ignoring the fact that the 10 INTs (which is obviously ridiculous itself) weren't the only statistical aberration. As they noted, the pancakes were 23-0, and despite being a strong rushing team, Nashville averaged less than a yard per carry. The result is not remotely realistic, not even on a team's absolute worst day. It's basically like something in the simulation transformed Nashville into a much lower level team.

I have no dog in this fight, I'm just concerned about the reliability of a game I've already spent money on and planned to spend more on. Those of you who think you are doing the right thing by sucking up to Bort are not doing him any favors. Consumer confidence is critically important for any service, and people need to believe that the results are both realistic and justified. Nashville getting blown out by Miami is possible even though they're similarly ranked. Nashville experiencing that many extraordinary statistical anomalies is not in any way realistic, and is clear proof of something being faulty in the simulation programming.


Okay...wait a strong rushing team shut down in the playoffs. Like the 2006 Kansas City Chiefs? Okay they didn't have 10 INTs, but individually any one of these occurrences doesn't prove the SIM is broken. As a collection they are separate random events. Does it suck...yes. But remember when the QB is sucking and he is your "field general" I'm guessing just like he would pick your team up, he drags your team down!!!


As your QB goes so does your offense. Just ask the Panthers last year.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamyp
Originally posted by SCACE

Originally posted by jamyp


Everyone keeps saying it's still in beta blah blah blah. Well if the game isn't ready i think we shouldn't be playing with real money then should we?


I haven't said that, I don't think it is a good argument. I could say that technically you don't have to spend money to play, but I pay money too. It is a growing game, I understood that when I put money in, and I'm sure you did as well. Things are going to change from season to season, more tactics and options will be added, settings will be tweaked, etc.

Patience is a virtue.

As a mother of 2 I am quite patient. And i don't mind spending $$ if i enjoy myself but when the entertainment loses its luster I supose you are right and it's time to move on.



If it gets to that point for me, I'll be gone as well, but right now I'm taking the game in stride and enjoying watching it develop. It isn't perfect, probably won't be for a while, but its fun, and while losses hurt, you learn from them, pick yourself up and move on to the next game / season.

Again, the loss was rough...no fun at all to be had in watching that SIM, but it exposed a variable in the SIM (confidence spiral) that had been brought up and discussed, but maybe not in this detail -- playoff games tend to bring out the emotions even more.

And, it showed you something about the build of your team's QB.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamyp
Originally posted by SCACE

Originally posted by jamyp


Everyone keeps saying it's still in beta blah blah blah. Well if the game isn't ready i think we shouldn't be playing with real money then should we?


I haven't said that, I don't think it is a good argument. I could say that technically you don't have to spend money to play, but I pay money too. It is a growing game, I understood that when I put money in, and I'm sure you did as well. Things are going to change from season to season, more tactics and options will be added, settings will be tweaked, etc.

Patience is a virtue.

As a mother of 2 I am quite patient. And i don't mind spending $$ if i enjoy myself but when the entertainment loses its luster I supose you are right and it's time to move on.



SCACE,

Never question patience to her again, EVER lol, I have a 2 year old at home, I can't imagine dealing with 2. Luckily my wife is a saint lol
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Only for those who want to avoid responsibility and try to blame elsewhere.

Just shut your mouth unless you have something intelligent to say. I am not on Nashville and I don't know anyone who is. What I am is someone with an extensive knowledge of professional and college football (I write about it for a living), so I know what is and what is not realistic. I'm also someone with both programming (although nothing anywhere near this complex) and beta testing experience. Any fully functional adult can see that something went awry here, and you sucking up to Bort is not helping.

The game statistics have all the hallmarks of a classic programming flaw whereby a negative feedback result cascades and produces a result well beyond what was ever envisioned or intended. Anyone who isn't wrapped up in trying to kiss the site owner's ass can see that. Again, it's not the fact that Nashville got blown out that is the concern. It's the degree to which they were annihilated that is clear and undeniable evidence that the sim programming needs to be adjusted. A relatively simple fix might be boundaries on negative feedback instead of allowing modifiers to continue growing larger and larger. Whatever the eventual solution, something clearly needs to be done in order to insure the integrity of results.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
lol - I wasn't questioning anyone's patience, it was a comment about the fact that this game is growing and needs patience
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jamyp
Originally posted by SCACE

Originally posted by jamyp


Everyone keeps saying it's still in beta blah blah blah. Well if the game isn't ready i think we shouldn't be playing with real money then should we?


I haven't said that, I don't think it is a good argument. I could say that technically you don't have to spend money to play, but I pay money too. It is a growing game, I understood that when I put money in, and I'm sure you did as well. Things are going to change from season to season, more tactics and options will be added, settings will be tweaked, etc.

Patience is a virtue.

As a mother of 2 I am quite patient. And i don't mind spending $$ if i enjoy myself but when the entertainment loses its luster I supose you are right and it's time to move on.



It's one game, a playoff game and that does hurt more than normal, but you got next season to look forward too with the way your team handled during the season. A lot there to build upon for future success and fun. Rome wasn't built in a day and no championship team was built in a year, well maybe the ol Packers squad before the SB era, but you have pieces there in place to succeed.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

Only for those who want to avoid responsibility and try to blame elsewhere.

Just shut your mouth unless you have something intelligent to say. I am not on Nashville and I don't know anyone who is. What I am is someone with an extensive knowledge of professional and college football (I write about it for a living), so I know what is and what is not realistic. I'm also someone with both programming (although nothing anywhere near this complex) and beta testing experience. Any fully functional adult can see that something went awry here, and you sucking up to Bort is not helping.

The game statistics have all the hallmarks of a classic programming flaw whereby a negative feedback result cascades and produces a result well beyond what was ever envisioned or intended. Anyone who isn't wrapped up in trying to kiss the site owner's ass can see that. Again, it's not the fact that Nashville got blown out that is the concern. It's the degree to which they were annihilated that is clear and undeniable evidence that the sim programming needs to be adjusted. A relatively simple fix might be boundaries on negative feedback instead of allowing modifiers to continue growing larger and larger. Whatever the eventual solution, something clearly needs to be done in order to insure the integrity of results.


If you write about it, then you should know that 9 INT's in college and 8 INT's in the NFL by a QB in a game have both happened before.

That said, I agree with you about the cascade effect, but it is a DIRECT result of the QB's neglect of confidence, and it was COMPLETELY exposed in this game.

Fixes - QB ups his confidence to avoid this happening again. Bort adds a sub setting where you can get your QB out of a cascading loss due to low confidence and in turn, low in game morale after mistakes.

This ensures that QB's don't avoid confidence, or aren't rewarded for neglecting confidence, and there is a solution put in so that teams in a situation with low QB confidence + mistakes can get out of it with a backup.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

Only for those who want to avoid responsibility and try to blame elsewhere.

Just shut your mouth unless you have something intelligent to say. I am not on Nashville and I don't know anyone who is. What I am is someone with an extensive knowledge of professional and college football (I write about it for a living), so I know what is and what is not realistic. I'm also someone with both programming (although nothing anywhere near this complex) and beta testing experience. Any fully functional adult can see that something went awry here, and you sucking up to Bort is not helping.

The game statistics have all the hallmarks of a classic programming flaw whereby a negative feedback result cascades and produces a result well beyond what was ever envisioned or intended. Anyone who isn't wrapped up in trying to kiss the site owner's ass can see that. Again, it's not the fact that Nashville got blown out that is the concern. It's the degree to which they were annihilated that is clear and undeniable evidence that the sim programming needs to be adjusted. A relatively simple fix might be boundaries on negative feedback instead of allowing modifiers to continue growing larger and larger. Whatever the eventual solution, something clearly needs to be done in order to insure the integrity of results.



My mouth is shut actually, until I open it to drink my beer. This is the internet though and no need to open my mouth at all. So you don't have to avoid responsibility but you are blaming elsewhere and since you cover these sports then what is so unrealistic about it?
Can you tell me the biggest blow out in college football history? Hint: one team had over 100pts scored against them.
People have already given real life NFL and College stats that prove these games DO happen in RL.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
Okay...wait a strong rushing team shut down in the playoffs. Like the 2006 Kansas City Chiefs? Okay they didn't have 10 INTs, but individually any one of these occurrences doesn't prove the SIM is broken. As a collection they are separate random events. Does it suck...yes. But remember when the QB is sucking and he is your "field general" I'm guessing just like he would pick your team up, he drags your team down!!!

I highlighted the portion of the post that completely undermines your own objection. A 10 interception game between two relatively well matched teams would be enough to raise eyebrows and suggest a need to review simulation programming (some people have survived 10k+ feet falls, but that doesn't change the fact that a parachuting simulation shouldn't have you bounce up and run a marathon after your chute fails to open). But a 10 interception game plus all the other statistical oddities from that game shows anyone with even the slightest bit of programming experience, or even a cursory understanding of probability theory, should tell you that something isn't right.

Yes, in rare cases people have survived falls when their chute didn't open. Some people have also survived gun shots to the head. Other people have survived being lit on fire. Now let's calculate the survival odds of someone being lit on fire, shot in the face, and dropped out of an airplane at 10k feet. Individually, maybe you could try to explain them away as some extreme aberration, but the chances of all those extreme aberrations happening at the same time are infinitesimal. It just doesn't add up.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 23:15:00
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by rbedgood

Okay...wait a strong rushing team shut down in the playoffs. Like the 2006 Kansas City Chiefs? Okay they didn't have 10 INTs, but individually any one of these occurrences doesn't prove the SIM is broken. As a collection they are separate random events. Does it suck...yes. But remember when the QB is sucking and he is your "field general" I'm guessing just like he would pick your team up, he drags your team down!!!

I highlighted the portion of the post that completely undermines your own objection. A 10 interception game between two relatively well matched teams would be enough to raise eyebrows and suggest a need to review simulation programming (some people have survived 10k+ feet falls, but that doesn't change the fact that a parachuting simulation shouldn't have you bounce up and run a marathon after your chute fails to open). But a 10 interception game plus all the other statistical oddities from that game shows anyone with even the slightest bit of programming experience, or even a cursory understanding of probability theory, should tell you that something isn't right.

Yes, in rare cases people have survived falls when their chute didn't open. Some people have also survived gun shots to the head. Other people have survived being lit on fire. Now let's calculate the survival odds of someone being lit on fire, shot in the face, and dropped out of an airplane at 10k feet. It just doesn't add up.


Considering the pancakes were NOT a statistical oddity, as has been mentioned more than once, and the rushing yards were also NOT a statistical oddity (just look at the last game between the same teams where the starting Nashville HB averaged 1.9 per carry, the backup 2.4), I'm not sure what other oddities you are talking about.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Can you tell me the biggest blow out in college football history? Hint: one team had over 100pts scored against them.

Cumberland vs. Georgia Tech. Try asking me something I didn't know when I was ten years old.
Originally posted by
People have already given real life NFL and College stats that prove these games DO happen in RL.

No, these types of results do not happen. Those trying to kiss Bort's ass have repeatedly pointed out that the highest interception totals in the history of the NFL almost equaled what happened here, and that's momentarily ignoring the fact that this wasn't a match-up between two clearly disparate opponents.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

Can you tell me the biggest blow out in college football history? Hint: one team had over 100pts scored against them.

Cumberland vs. Georgia Tech. Try asking me something I didn't know when I was ten years old.
Originally posted by

People have already given real life NFL and College stats that prove these games DO happen in RL.

No, these types of results do not happen. Those trying to kiss Bort's ass have repeatedly pointed out that the highest interception totals in the history of the NFL almost equaled what happened here, and that's momentarily ignoring the fact that this wasn't a match-up between two clearly disparate opponents.


Except that, these two teams WERENT EQUAL, A. you had a Miami team that had CLEARLY BETTER BUILDS, and they had BOOSTED RIGHT BEFORE THE GAME, B. you had a Nashville QB who couldn't hit the broadside of a barn, let alone, see it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.