Originally posted by kevbk6222
i dont see how it doesnt make sense that they didnt know she was in the barn. from what we know, there have only been two people in the barn sense she went missing, otis and his wife. otis died before anyone knew she was missing and his wife could have easily missed her when she threw the chickens in the barn.
as far as the timeline goes, it could have happened within a 24 hour period if you assume that she lost her doll early on and it flowed down stream and that she wasnt the one sleeping in the barn.
day 1: rick leaves sophia, sophia drops the doll, gets bit.
day 2: sophia turns, otis goes out hunting, sees her, wrangles her and takes her back to the farm, goes back out hunting, shoots carl.
on that timeline it would be possible for her to stay in the farm house if she had been bit, but got away and ran there to hide and turned the next day. but that might not be possible given that we didnt see any obvious signs of blood in the house.
You are making a lot of assumptions to make the events fit together, while dispelling any assumptions that point to the contrary. This usually points to sloppy, incohesive writing. Like I said earlier the content of this season has generally been fine, I just think it could have been written in a more graceful and streamlined fashion.
i dont see how it doesnt make sense that they didnt know she was in the barn. from what we know, there have only been two people in the barn sense she went missing, otis and his wife. otis died before anyone knew she was missing and his wife could have easily missed her when she threw the chickens in the barn.
as far as the timeline goes, it could have happened within a 24 hour period if you assume that she lost her doll early on and it flowed down stream and that she wasnt the one sleeping in the barn.
day 1: rick leaves sophia, sophia drops the doll, gets bit.
day 2: sophia turns, otis goes out hunting, sees her, wrangles her and takes her back to the farm, goes back out hunting, shoots carl.
on that timeline it would be possible for her to stay in the farm house if she had been bit, but got away and ran there to hide and turned the next day. but that might not be possible given that we didnt see any obvious signs of blood in the house.
You are making a lot of assumptions to make the events fit together, while dispelling any assumptions that point to the contrary. This usually points to sloppy, incohesive writing. Like I said earlier the content of this season has generally been fine, I just think it could have been written in a more graceful and streamlined fashion.






























