User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
cannons call
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kevbk6222
i dont see how it doesnt make sense that they didnt know she was in the barn. from what we know, there have only been two people in the barn sense she went missing, otis and his wife. otis died before anyone knew she was missing and his wife could have easily missed her when she threw the chickens in the barn.

as far as the timeline goes, it could have happened within a 24 hour period if you assume that she lost her doll early on and it flowed down stream and that she wasnt the one sleeping in the barn.

day 1: rick leaves sophia, sophia drops the doll, gets bit.
day 2: sophia turns, otis goes out hunting, sees her, wrangles her and takes her back to the farm, goes back out hunting, shoots carl.

on that timeline it would be possible for her to stay in the farm house if she had been bit, but got away and ran there to hide and turned the next day. but that might not be possible given that we didnt see any obvious signs of blood in the house.


You are making a lot of assumptions to make the events fit together, while dispelling any assumptions that point to the contrary. This usually points to sloppy, incohesive writing. Like I said earlier the content of this season has generally been fine, I just think it could have been written in a more graceful and streamlined fashion.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Nah, not buying it. Not buying the timeline and not buying that nobody in Hershel's family were aware of a little girl zombie in the barn.

I do applaud them, though, for at least taking one small step towards the despair and brutality portrayed in the graphic novels. Taken out of the context of the lead-in to that scene, I think the last sequence would have been reasonably at home in the graphic novel. That said, the lead-up to it was marred by either sloppy or lazy writing. I kind of figured that was the direction they were heading since it puts the agendas of the two groups on a collision course, but I think it could have been handled much better.

So, yeah, two steps forwards and one step back...


The timeline of how she got there is irrelevant to the story.
 
kevbk6222
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cannons call
You are making a lot of assumptions to make the events fit together, while dispelling any assumptions that point to the contrary. This usually points to sloppy, incohesive writing. Like I said earlier the content of this season has generally been fine, I just think it could have been written in a more graceful and streamlined fashion.


what assumptions are there to the contrary?

regardless i dont see how the writers could have done better with the arc given that they wanted the big unavailing to be a surprise. they managed to make the event both surprising and plausible.
 
cannons call
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
Thats the beauty of it. They don't have to explain shit and there is no need to. The explanation of how she got there is irrelevant. All that matters is that the group grew to hate walkers so much that they forgot their humanity. So they felt they didn't see the world like Hershell does. But then when Sophia showed up out of the barn, nobody could come to shoot her. Except Rick, who of coarse is the one guy that Shane said couldn't make the tough decisions to lead the group and wouldn't make it in this world.

Its fuckin brilliant. I just wish the rest of the season wasn't such a toilet trash of a slow moving story line to have gotten us here. But I went from saying fuck this show to now im back interested again.


I agree, it was one of the few moments in the show that actually gave me the same feeling of dread as the comic. I think the writers kind of missed an opportunity when they didn't individually portray the killing of Herschels infected family members. They kind of just glanced over all the zombies like they were all of equal importance to him, instead of focusing on his reactions to the death of his wife and immediate family. Either way that is admittedly me just being nitpicky, it was still a great scene.

I also agree that the lead up to this event was basically a bunch of slow moving filler.
 
X
offline
Link
 
There is a pretty big difference in something being plausible and something being reasonable and likely. I never said the timeline or the sequence of events that would have to lead up to this wasn't plausible. It is. But it also isn't reasonable.

What it really came down to is that the writers had a pretty good idea how to tie-up a couple of these running storylines and further progress the story but didn't come up with a really good way to execute it. I admit that this would have been a tough plot point to write properly without spoiling the big reveal (though it seemed kind of obvious that was where they were heading anyway). So instead of scrapping it and going another route they decided to just throw it in with little to no explanation and hope that everybody bought what would have to be a fairly coincidental and implausible series of events that would have to lead up to that point. Which is fairly lazy and sloppy.

That said, again, I at least applaud the direction they took the show. I think that final sequence was a nice touch. I just think the way they got there was godawful.
Edited by X on Nov 28, 2011 13:27:10
Edited by X on Nov 28, 2011 13:26:27
 
cannons call
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kevbk6222
what assumptions are there to the contrary?

regardless i dont see how the writers could have done better with the arc given that they wanted the big unavailing to be a surprise. they managed to make the event both surprising and plausible.


I'm totally fine with build up and i'm totally fine with surprises. What i'm not fine with is a lead up full of red herrings and filler hastily thrown together to reach a conclusion. Half this season could have easily been condensed into a few episodes. I understand they wanted to give the story time to build tension, but that doesn't excuse them from providing little to no content in that span.
 
Link
 
This is a character drama, characters have to develop, if they don't, know one cares about them and what they do, thus not caring about the story.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by X
There is a pretty big difference in something being plausible and something being reasonable and likely. I never said the timeline or the sequence of events that would have to lead up to this wasn't plausible. It is. But it also isn't reasonable.

What it really came down to is that the writers had a pretty good idea how to tie-up a couple of these running storylines and further progress the story but didn't come up with a really good way to execute it. I admit that this would have been a tough plot point to write properly without spoiling the big reveal (though it seemed kind of obvious that was where they were heading anyway). So instead of scrapping it and going another route they decided to just throw it in with little to no explanation and hope that everybody bought what would have to be a fairly coincidental and implausible series of events that would have to lead up to that point. Which is fairly lazy and sloppy.

That said, again, I at least applaud the direction they took the show. I think that final sequence was a nice touch. I just think the way they got there was godawful.


A lot of people get it. Little to no explanation? Coincidental and implausible? I watch all the episodes and these things do not apply to what I comprehend from the events in the story told at all.
 
Link
 
The Walking Dead thread should be stickied over the Sons of Anarchy thread. The viewing ratings and the post count are a testament to that.
 
trentw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drake Slaughter
The Walking Dead thread should be stickied over the Sons of Anarchy thread. The viewing ratings and the post count are a testament to that.


No one pays attention to stickied threads, if it was stickied I would most likely always over look it.
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cannons call
Originally posted by kevbk6222

what assumptions are there to the contrary?

regardless i dont see how the writers could have done better with the arc given that they wanted the big unavailing to be a surprise. they managed to make the event both surprising and plausible.


I'm totally fine with build up and i'm totally fine with surprises. What i'm not fine with is a lead up full of red herrings and filler hastily thrown together to reach a conclusion. Half this season could have easily been condensed into a few episodes. I understand they wanted to give the story time to build tension, but that doesn't excuse them from providing little to no content in that span.


I don't particularly mind the time they spend between the key set pieces to build tension and character, even if some of that stuff is iffy. That was always kind of the philosophy behind the graphic novels anyway. To show that spans between running for your life from zombies that you just can't do in a two hour zombie movie. The slow burn of surviving the apocalypse, if you will.
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drake Slaughter
Originally posted by X

There is a pretty big difference in something being plausible and something being reasonable and likely. I never said the timeline or the sequence of events that would have to lead up to this wasn't plausible. It is. But it also isn't reasonable.

What it really came down to is that the writers had a pretty good idea how to tie-up a couple of these running storylines and further progress the story but didn't come up with a really good way to execute it. I admit that this would have been a tough plot point to write properly without spoiling the big reveal (though it seemed kind of obvious that was where they were heading anyway). So instead of scrapping it and going another route they decided to just throw it in with little to no explanation and hope that everybody bought what would have to be a fairly coincidental and implausible series of events that would have to lead up to that point. Which is fairly lazy and sloppy.

That said, again, I at least applaud the direction they took the show. I think that final sequence was a nice touch. I just think the way they got there was godawful.


A lot of people get it. Little to no explanation? Coincidental and implausible? I watch all the episodes and these things do not apply to what I comprehend from the events in the story told at all.


Oh, I get it. It was pretty plain what they were going for. Just poorly executed, that's all. As mentioned earlier, I don't really envy them having to resolve those two storylines concurrently. Which might have been a good indication that it shouldn't have been handled that way.
 
cannons call
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by X
I don't particularly mind the time they spend between the key set pieces to build tension and character, even if some of that stuff is iffy. That was always kind of the philosophy behind the graphic novels anyway. To show that spans between running for your life from zombies that you just can't do in a two hour zombie movie. The slow burn of surviving the apocalypse, if you will.


Yeah but the characters in the graphic novel are generally more interesting and likeable, which makes the slower points of the story arcs have substance. The slower parts of the show actually managed to make me like the characters less, and not in a way the writers intended.

Edited by cannons call on Nov 28, 2011 13:53:15
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cannons call
Originally posted by X

I don't particularly mind the time they spend between the key set pieces to build tension and character, even if some of that stuff is iffy. That was always kind of the philosophy behind the graphic novels anyway. To show that spans between running for your life from zombies that you just can't do in a two hour zombie movie. The slow burn of surviving the apocalypse, if you will.


yea but the characters in the graphic novel are generally more interesting and likeable, which makes the slower points of the story arcs have substance. The slower parts of the show actually managed to make me like the characters less, and not in a way the writers intended.



Agreed. Which is what I was alluding to when I said that stuff was "iffy". The writing and acting in the show is just generally bad. That said, I also don't want it to just be a constant stream of zombie attacks either because I've seen that all before. They need to find a balance between the length of those lulls in the action and the action itself, which they haven't done.
 
X
offline
Link
 
Most of the time I would disagree with the "omg moar z0mbeee akshun pl33zzz!!!!1" crowd, but in this case, they are right.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.