So...will this thing be in by the playoffs? Or do we know yet or what?
Forum > Announcements > Defense AI Interface
Shorteous
offline
offline
we havn't heard a peep from the DEVS on when this is going to go live. I wish we could get some time of info from them 
<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>>>>>>>
'M YELLING TO GET ATTENTION FROM THE BOSS'S!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
It would be nice if we could create multiple depth charts and give them saved names. Then on the Advanced AI screen have a pull down that would allow you to select one of your saved depth charts!!! I think this could be the best way and would allow you to have the exact personnel in for each output and not just for each formation.

<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>>>>>>>
'M YELLING TO GET ATTENTION FROM THE BOSS'S!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
It would be nice if we could create multiple depth charts and give them saved names. Then on the Advanced AI screen have a pull down that would allow you to select one of your saved depth charts!!! I think this could be the best way and would allow you to have the exact personnel in for each output and not just for each formation.
TideSpot
offline
offline
Originally posted by islander1
I just found a huge issue for me with the defensive AI.
I've created a playbook with about 250 plays.
The issue is I cannot 'insert' a new input/rule anywhere I want. So my rule set is going to be a complete clusterfuck of mass confusion trying to add another 200+ rules and being completely unable to logically group them together so I can make sure I don't forget any.
This is an absolute mess.
You can move each input up and down the list. But if you want to move an input way down the list, you have to keep moving it down one input at a time.
So far, the AI is not set up to adequately organize 250 play scenarios in one package, so to speak. 250 is a bunch anyways and might be overkill.
Just my 2 cents..
I just found a huge issue for me with the defensive AI.
I've created a playbook with about 250 plays.
The issue is I cannot 'insert' a new input/rule anywhere I want. So my rule set is going to be a complete clusterfuck of mass confusion trying to add another 200+ rules and being completely unable to logically group them together so I can make sure I don't forget any.
This is an absolute mess.
You can move each input up and down the list. But if you want to move an input way down the list, you have to keep moving it down one input at a time.
So far, the AI is not set up to adequately organize 250 play scenarios in one package, so to speak. 250 is a bunch anyways and might be overkill.
Just my 2 cents..
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by TideSpot
Originally posted by islander1
I just found a huge issue for me with the defensive AI.
I've created a playbook with about 250 plays.
The issue is I cannot 'insert' a new input/rule anywhere I want. So my rule set is going to be a complete clusterfuck of mass confusion trying to add another 200+ rules and being completely unable to logically group them together so I can make sure I don't forget any.
This is an absolute mess.
You can move each input up and down the list. But if you want to move an input way down the list, you have to keep moving it down one input at a time.
So far, the AI is not set up to adequately organize 250 play scenarios in one package, so to speak. 250 is a bunch anyways and might be overkill.
Just my 2 cents..
Overkill perhapsfor those not dedicated to winning.
Once (If?) its feasible, the playbook will have over double the amount of these plays by the time I finish the original starting version.
and offensively, I'd be damn sure if I were an OC that my playbook dictated every single play, because the offensive AI in place now is awful. Nothing says following the game plan like a dozen halfback screen passes when you have the halfback pass set to 1%.
Truth be told, the defensive AI isn't half bad. Still, I'll fine tune it for my team, and make us a stronger team for it. Assuming it becomes actual manageable to have a serious playbook at some point. Else why even bother having these options available?
People too lazy to do a job like this right may as well not bother doing them at all. The game itself will think better then you will.
Originally posted by islander1
I just found a huge issue for me with the defensive AI.
I've created a playbook with about 250 plays.
The issue is I cannot 'insert' a new input/rule anywhere I want. So my rule set is going to be a complete clusterfuck of mass confusion trying to add another 200+ rules and being completely unable to logically group them together so I can make sure I don't forget any.
This is an absolute mess.
You can move each input up and down the list. But if you want to move an input way down the list, you have to keep moving it down one input at a time.
So far, the AI is not set up to adequately organize 250 play scenarios in one package, so to speak. 250 is a bunch anyways and might be overkill.
Just my 2 cents..
Overkill perhapsfor those not dedicated to winning.
Once (If?) its feasible, the playbook will have over double the amount of these plays by the time I finish the original starting version.
and offensively, I'd be damn sure if I were an OC that my playbook dictated every single play, because the offensive AI in place now is awful. Nothing says following the game plan like a dozen halfback screen passes when you have the halfback pass set to 1%.
Truth be told, the defensive AI isn't half bad. Still, I'll fine tune it for my team, and make us a stronger team for it. Assuming it becomes actual manageable to have a serious playbook at some point. Else why even bother having these options available?
People too lazy to do a job like this right may as well not bother doing them at all. The game itself will think better then you will.
Last edited Jun 30, 2008 21:53:27
San Diego Chargers
offline
offline
Originally posted by Shorteous
It would be nice if we could create multiple depth charts and give them saved names. Then on the Advanced AI screen have a pull down that would allow you to select one of your saved depth charts!!! I think this could be the best way and would allow you to have the exact personnel in for each output and not just for each formation.
Still one of my favorite idea's.
It would be nice if we could create multiple depth charts and give them saved names. Then on the Advanced AI screen have a pull down that would allow you to select one of your saved depth charts!!! I think this could be the best way and would allow you to have the exact personnel in for each output and not just for each formation.
Still one of my favorite idea's.
Last edited Jul 1, 2008 00:33:42
oukurt
offline
offline
Originally posted by San Diego Chargers
Originally posted by Shorteous
It would be nice if we could create multiple depth charts and give them saved names. Then on the Advanced AI screen have a pull down that would allow you to select one of your saved depth charts!!! I think this could be the best way and would allow you to have the exact personnel in for each output and not just for each formation.
Still one of my favorite idea's.
Big thumbs up.
Originally posted by Shorteous
It would be nice if we could create multiple depth charts and give them saved names. Then on the Advanced AI screen have a pull down that would allow you to select one of your saved depth charts!!! I think this could be the best way and would allow you to have the exact personnel in for each output and not just for each formation.
Still one of my favorite idea's.
Big thumbs up.
SunDevil03
offline
offline
Does a preset we make in this version still stay when it is actually online? I was thinking about getting a headstart on my gameplanning...
San Diego Chargers
offline
offline
Originally posted by SunDevil03
Does a preset we make in this version still stay when it is actually online? I was thinking about getting a headstart on my gameplanning...
Yes, you can start now.
Does a preset we make in this version still stay when it is actually online? I was thinking about getting a headstart on my gameplanning...
Yes, you can start now.
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by San Diego Chargers
Originally posted by SunDevil03
Does a preset we make in this version still stay when it is actually online? I was thinking about getting a headstart on my gameplanning...
Yes, you can start now.
Just be really careful how you add plays, because right now it's completely impractical to make adjustments once you populate your play database and then decide its time to make scenario adjustments.

Originally posted by SunDevil03
Does a preset we make in this version still stay when it is actually online? I was thinking about getting a headstart on my gameplanning...
Yes, you can start now.
Just be really careful how you add plays, because right now it's completely impractical to make adjustments once you populate your play database and then decide its time to make scenario adjustments.

Buck Nutty
offline
offline
Originally posted by SunDevil03
Does a preset we make in this version still stay when it is actually online? I was thinking about getting a headstart on my gameplanning...
I made one ... and then tried to load it ...Yes after saving it .... it was set right back to default when I tried to load my setting.
Does a preset we make in this version still stay when it is actually online? I was thinking about getting a headstart on my gameplanning...
I made one ... and then tried to load it ...Yes after saving it .... it was set right back to default when I tried to load my setting.
ptompkins
offline
offline
Since I don't think my team is going to make it to the playoffs. I'm more then happy to test this out for our scrimmages 

blitz2670
offline
offline
Originally posted by San Diego Chargers
Originally posted by Shorteous
It would be nice if we could create multiple depth charts and give them saved names. Then on the Advanced AI screen have a pull down that would allow you to select one of your saved depth charts!!! I think this could be the best way and would allow you to have the exact personnel in for each output and not just for each formation.
Still one of my favorite idea's.
Excellent Idea! They can also get Depth Charts for Kickoff and Punts as well.
Originally posted by Shorteous
It would be nice if we could create multiple depth charts and give them saved names. Then on the Advanced AI screen have a pull down that would allow you to select one of your saved depth charts!!! I think this could be the best way and would allow you to have the exact personnel in for each output and not just for each formation.
Still one of my favorite idea's.
Excellent Idea! They can also get Depth Charts for Kickoff and Punts as well.
TideSpot
offline
offline
If I have 2 inputs, say 2nd and 5, and all the parameters are the same for both inputs except for offensive formation, will the AI pick the one with the correct offensive formation, even though it may be lower down the list?
G.O.D Turner
offline
offline
Now, I realize the O and D AI scripts need to go live together, but what about the 3-4 option on defense? I've had my roster set since this past offseason to turn 3-4 and still have depth - basically this means I have about 3 extra LBs who're riding the bench and shouldn't be that much. While they're being patient and not demanding to be traded or whatever, I'm thinking they're probably getting upset about it by now...
is there ANY chance in hell the 3-4 will hit before th entire AI packages?
is there ANY chance in hell the 3-4 will hit before th entire AI packages?
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.



























