User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
Hmm, for some, that would be before the playoffs, since a lot hold off on boost till playoffs. I could see it getting held off till the offseason potentially, but in all likelihood, it wouldn't go into effect until next season.


I'd like to see it ready on day 41. But really there is no reason (other than not enough time to implement it) not to realease it on day 32.
 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by itsme4
so besides the
- bonus/penalty SA's
- additional SA chosen at creation

are the LB SA trees remaining the same?


For the most part yes, but Catch plans to revisit SA's and which are working and which are useless. Some may get a buff or toned down.
 
itsme420
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
For the most part yes, but Catch plans to revisit SA's and which are working and which are useless. Some may get a buff or toned down.


gotcha, thx

as for the timing of this being released...I don't see how it can happen before the playoffs but I could be dead wrong
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
This may have been mentioned already, but I haven't seen it yet.

Why isn't there an Elusive WR option? It's kind of silly, considering WRs get HF, Juke and Spin, which are all elusive abilities.

There's a Power WR but no Elusive, which doesn't make much sense to me.


Wouldn't speedster be the same thing with just selecting those 2 SA's?
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jbleich
Wouldn't speedster be the same thing with just selecting those 2 SA's?


This is the way I would envision an Elusive WR in comparison to a Speedster WR:


WR Speedster
5'8" - 6'2", 175-215 Lbs
Major Agility Catching Speed Vision (+.5)
Minor Carrying Confidence Jumping Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's - First Step, Quick Cut
Penalty SA's - Route Run, Sticky Hands


WR Elusive
5'8" - 6'2", 175-215 Lbs
Major Agility Carrying Speed Vision (+.5) (could make the case for Confidence to replace Speed)
Minor Confidence Catching Stamina Jumping (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Head Fake, Juke
Penalty SA's - First Step, Route Run


I think there'd be enough of a difference, and it would be the only WR with a Bonus to HF/Juke. Could put Spin in place of one of those, for even more options. Actually, that'd probably be better, as you could differentiate this archetype even more.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
This is the way I would envision an Elusive WR in comparison to a Speedster WR:


WR Speedster
5'8" - 6'2", 175-215 Lbs
Major Agility Catching Speed Vision (+.5)
Minor Carrying Confidence Jumping Stamina (+.25)
Bonus SA's - First Step, Quick Cut
Penalty SA's - Route Run, Sticky Hands


WR Elusive
5'8" - 6'2", 175-215 Lbs
Major Agility Carrying Speed Vision (+.5) (could make the case for Confidence to replace Speed)
Minor Confidence Catching Stamina Jumping (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Head Fake, Juke
Penalty SA's - First Step, Route Run


I think there'd be enough of a difference, and it would be the only WR with a Bonus to HF/Juke. Could put Spin in place of one of those, for even more options. Actually, that'd probably be better, as you could differentiate this archetype even more.


Slight difference, I can see your point though.
 
toobad4u_00
offline
Link
 
Honestly, I hate the idea overall. I am pretty sure in the survey just put out I noted that i like the flexibility to at any point create any type of player you wanted and change that thought process a little later and still be able to go into it with some degree of ability to be successful This will take that ability away a bit. This does lie more in line though with the other thing I like about the game. It is fairly realistic with how development should happen and be successful (especially early) in real life. Start with physical tools, then work on seeing plays, followed by improving those physical tools with added abilities. Most great players had that development process. Those physical tools are a product of the limitations sometimes that their bodies will allow. However, it is important to realize this will take away some of the ability we have at creating physical specimen that don't fit certain criteria yet still show abilities that don't fit that, and those exist in real life as well. I think this moves you several steps back and only 1 step forward. Bad move for a game overall don't you think?

Having said this.. I think the values make sense overall.
Since this is set in stone apparently.
 
AggieSig
offline
Link
 
I'm going to go ahead and whine, I never get on this forum nor do I complain about changes. It looks as though GLB can't make up its mind how to allow agents to build their players and will forever remain in the Beta stage. This whole idea dumb downs the game for those that don't understand or fail to spend the time to read to actually create a decent player. We should all get 100% refunds on our created players so we can implement the new builds since they will be superior to our current ones. Seeing a 5'11" 260 lb. hb that is 40 lbs heavier than my current two power hbs is crap. I'm nearing the end of my days on GLB because the game is still in the same place it was over a year ago.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Another suggestion that I think would be nice....

A "Census" that would show how many archetypes are in the game, much the way the player creation page has the demand for each position. It would be nice to know if there were an excess or lack of a certain archetype before I picked one.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AggieSig
because the game is still in the same place it was over a year ago.


Really? You seriously think that?
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg
Hmm, for some, that would be before the playoffs, since a lot hold off on boost till playoffs. I could see it getting held off till the offseason potentially, but in all likelihood, it wouldn't go into effect until next season.


That would really suck, imo. The powers that be should really aim for a Day30 release or so, imo. Even if they have to leave something until the postseason (such as the extra SA or something) the archetype selection/ALGs should be in place for when everyone is getting ready to boost for this season. Do otherwise will increase the "retirement" problem. I think if they want to avoid a large number of dots retiring, getting this ready to go ASAP this season is almost a must.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
That would really suck, imo. The powers that be should really aim for a Day30 release or so, imo. Even if they have to leave something until the postseason (such as the extra SA or something) the archetype selection/ALGs should be in place for when everyone is getting ready to boost for this season. Do otherwise will increase the "retirement" problem. I think if they want to avoid a large number of dots retiring, getting this ready to go ASAP this season is almost a must.


Agreed, and you make some solid points.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
DAMAGE CONTROL OPPORTUNITY

You want and many of us want Coaching.

Do it NOW together, same time, with Archetypes.

That way people can make all of their adjustments at the same time, and all these retired players can have a function in coaching slots.

Gets two batches of griping out of the way with one large game improving patch.
 
GregB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1
DAMAGE CONTROL OPPORTUNITY

You want and many of us want Coaching.

Do it NOW together, same time, with Archetypes.

That way people can make all of their adjustments at the same time, and all these retired players can have a function in coaching slots.

Gets two batches of griping out of the way with one large game improving patch.


Either this, or table coaches altogether.
 
GregB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
^ the only thing I ask is that the ability for an existing player to choose their archetype be available BEFORE the end of this season so we can pick our archetype and then boost our players...instead of having to boost under the old system.


this
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.