locked leagues
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Sorting promoting teams by record this season?
TrevJo
offline
offline
Originally posted by TrevJo
I don't have time to read the whole thread to see if there were new ideas suggested, but I'm voting No because I think there are some flaws in doing this by record:
-A team that starts out as level 1 dots will be in a Cap 14 league and misses the playoffs will remain in Cap 14. But since they had a losing record, they will be Bronze or at most Silver. Yet they will be starting the next season with all of their players at or near the league's level cap.
-A team that drops down from a higher league because their players retired, might have had a good record the previous season. They'll get put in Lv 14 silver or gold because of their record, yet they are starting over with level 1 players.
-A team goes 12-4 in Lv 22 bronze and thus promotes two levels and gets put into gold. They'll face teams that went 11-5 in Lv 26 gold.
There's got to be a better way to do it than pure record and/or overall rating. Here's a suggestion:
At the end of day 41, promote/demote teams to the appropriate Minors level, but don't assign them to gold/silver/copper.
At the end of the offseason, after teams have had a chance to sign players, recruit, etc, allow teams to request gold, or silver, or copper, or gold or silver, or silver or copper, or any.
In rollover (maintenance), while handling the requests, deny some teams gold or copper depending on the following:
-Deny copper if the team has X number of players over the league's level cap.
-Deny copper if the team has X number of players that are a full season older than the expected age of a team at that level, or any players that are two (?) seasons older than the expected age of a team at that level.
-Deny gold if the team requested a promotion or demotion, instead of being promoted automatically.
-Deny gold if the team failed to make the playoffs in an equal or lower level cap the previous season.
-Deny gold and silver if the team is CPU owned and/or does not meet some basic level of # of human players or overall rating.
-At that point, you will have some number of teams with successful gold requests, successful silver requests, and successful copper requests.
-Then balance it out with the teams that requested "gold or silver" or "silver or copper".
-If you still need to break ties to make the number of gold and silver teams divisible by 32, then break ties by previous season's league cap first, and previous season's record second.
I don't have time to read the whole thread to see if there were new ideas suggested, but I'm voting No because I think there are some flaws in doing this by record:
-A team that starts out as level 1 dots will be in a Cap 14 league and misses the playoffs will remain in Cap 14. But since they had a losing record, they will be Bronze or at most Silver. Yet they will be starting the next season with all of their players at or near the league's level cap.
-A team that drops down from a higher league because their players retired, might have had a good record the previous season. They'll get put in Lv 14 silver or gold because of their record, yet they are starting over with level 1 players.
-A team goes 12-4 in Lv 22 bronze and thus promotes two levels and gets put into gold. They'll face teams that went 11-5 in Lv 26 gold.
There's got to be a better way to do it than pure record and/or overall rating. Here's a suggestion:
At the end of day 41, promote/demote teams to the appropriate Minors level, but don't assign them to gold/silver/copper.
At the end of the offseason, after teams have had a chance to sign players, recruit, etc, allow teams to request gold, or silver, or copper, or gold or silver, or silver or copper, or any.
In rollover (maintenance), while handling the requests, deny some teams gold or copper depending on the following:
-Deny copper if the team has X number of players over the league's level cap.
-Deny copper if the team has X number of players that are a full season older than the expected age of a team at that level, or any players that are two (?) seasons older than the expected age of a team at that level.
-Deny gold if the team requested a promotion or demotion, instead of being promoted automatically.
-Deny gold if the team failed to make the playoffs in an equal or lower level cap the previous season.
-Deny gold and silver if the team is CPU owned and/or does not meet some basic level of # of human players or overall rating.
-At that point, you will have some number of teams with successful gold requests, successful silver requests, and successful copper requests.
-Then balance it out with the teams that requested "gold or silver" or "silver or copper".
-If you still need to break ties to make the number of gold and silver teams divisible by 32, then break ties by previous season's league cap first, and previous season's record second.
Edited by TrevJo on Jan 20, 2010 20:08:13
Edited by TrevJo on Jan 20, 2010 20:03:04
Edited by TrevJo on Jan 20, 2010 20:00:34
Originally posted by j10er
As an OC/owner of a capped team, I love the idea of increased competition. Besides tweaking auto adjust in order to learn how to use it properly, I game-planned for two games this season: the semi-finals and the finals.
But, as many have alluded to, SSB just kills this. Full SSB teams are unbeatable by a regular team and even a team with just an SSB RB has an extreme advantage. And then there's everything in between.
How the heck can we clear up the SSB mess by tomorrow??
Personally, I won't be happy if I find myself in a league packed with SSB teams, when we're not. I don't think anyone would.
How bout (easy to do):
Rank teams based on record. Save this rank.
Rank teams based on overall. Save this rank.
Take the average between the two ranks. Sort teams by combined rank.
As an OC/owner of a capped team, I love the idea of increased competition. Besides tweaking auto adjust in order to learn how to use it properly, I game-planned for two games this season: the semi-finals and the finals.
But, as many have alluded to, SSB just kills this. Full SSB teams are unbeatable by a regular team and even a team with just an SSB RB has an extreme advantage. And then there's everything in between.
How the heck can we clear up the SSB mess by tomorrow??
Personally, I won't be happy if I find myself in a league packed with SSB teams, when we're not. I don't think anyone would.
How bout (easy to do):
Rank teams based on record. Save this rank.
Rank teams based on overall. Save this rank.
Take the average between the two ranks. Sort teams by combined rank.
rellascout
offline
offline
Originally posted by Kotoll
Customer is not always right.
I agree 100%. My issue is that he has not chosen to address the merits of any of my statements but instead chosen the high road and attack my business acumen.
Customer is not always right.
I agree 100%. My issue is that he has not chosen to address the merits of any of my statements but instead chosen the high road and attack my business acumen.
maxxmisery DTD
offline
offline
Originally posted by WalterManning
locked leagues
best answer to all of this madness imo
locked leagues
best answer to all of this madness imo
jamz
offline
offline
Originally posted by trentw
I will say one thing Bort, this has certainly livened up day 41.
True, now if he'll just have the graphics dude and Thorn get color coded stickies implemented by S14, I'll forgive him for putting off a solution to SSB until S15.
I will say one thing Bort, this has certainly livened up day 41.
True, now if he'll just have the graphics dude and Thorn get color coded stickies implemented by S14, I'll forgive him for putting off a solution to SSB until S15.
Godzirra
offline
offline
Originally posted by cwrujosh
I brought this up - there will be a ton of 13 and 12 win teams that got 9 of those wins off of CPUs and SSBs. That's a real problem with this.
YUP!
Again... this really needs to be thought out more.
I brought this up - there will be a ton of 13 and 12 win teams that got 9 of those wins off of CPUs and SSBs. That's a real problem with this.
YUP!
Again... this really needs to be thought out more.
Rulabula
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
How bout (easy to do):
Rank teams based on record. Save this rank.
Rank teams based on overall. Save this rank.
Take the average between the two ranks. Sort teams by combined rank.
Not bad
How bout (easy to do):
Rank teams based on record. Save this rank.
Rank teams based on overall. Save this rank.
Take the average between the two ranks. Sort teams by combined rank.
Not bad
jamz
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
How bout (easy to do):
Rank teams based on record. Save this rank.
Rank teams based on overall. Save this rank.
Take the average between the two ranks. Sort teams by combined rank.
That method penalizes the best teams, by forcing them to play SSB teams who are 2-3 seasons ahead of them in training.
How bout (easy to do):
Rank teams based on record. Save this rank.
Rank teams based on overall. Save this rank.
Take the average between the two ranks. Sort teams by combined rank.
That method penalizes the best teams, by forcing them to play SSB teams who are 2-3 seasons ahead of them in training.
roronoa_zoro
offline
offline
Originally posted by trentw
I will say one thing Bort, this has certainly livened up day 41.
I will say one thing Bort, this has certainly livened up day 41.
j10er
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
How bout (easy to do):
Rank teams based on record. Save this rank.
Rank teams based on overall. Save this rank.
Take the average between the two ranks. Sort teams by combined rank.
Heh - I don't know, let me compare my team's bars vs. a few slow-built teams' bars and I'll get back to ya
How bout (easy to do):
Rank teams based on record. Save this rank.
Rank teams based on overall. Save this rank.
Take the average between the two ranks. Sort teams by combined rank.
Heh - I don't know, let me compare my team's bars vs. a few slow-built teams' bars and I'll get back to ya

Robbnva
offline
offline
Originally posted by jamz
Originally posted by Bort
How bout (easy to do):
Rank teams based on record. Save this rank.
Rank teams based on overall. Save this rank.
Take the average between the two ranks. Sort teams by combined rank.
That method penalizes the best teams, by forcing them to play SSB teams who are 2-3 seasons ahead of them in training.
explain
Originally posted by Bort
How bout (easy to do):
Rank teams based on record. Save this rank.
Rank teams based on overall. Save this rank.
Take the average between the two ranks. Sort teams by combined rank.
That method penalizes the best teams, by forcing them to play SSB teams who are 2-3 seasons ahead of them in training.
explain
roronoa_zoro
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
How bout (easy to do):
Rank teams based on record. Save this rank.
Rank teams based on overall. Save this rank.
Take the average between the two ranks. Sort teams by combined rank.
You need to take levels into account aswell
How bout (easy to do):
Rank teams based on record. Save this rank.
Rank teams based on overall. Save this rank.
Take the average between the two ranks. Sort teams by combined rank.
You need to take levels into account aswell
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























