User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Post many people need to read right now before going further:

Originally posted by Jed

OK, so you can confirm that there is nothing in place behind the scenes that pre-determines one player will always, say, run a route faster, block better, or throw more accurately than another player with the same exact skills, SA's, VA's, and equipment? If there is/ever will be something behind the scenes, it'll be like what you describe there, to make things more random?


Originally posted by Bort

I agree that any "hidden" stuff is or will be random like I'm talking about. I think game to game and play to play randomness to be very important and interesting ideas, that mirror real life events. Sometimes players show up for the game, other times don't for whatever reason. Abilities to affect those factors are my favorite ones, actually. I love the streaky ability, though it might need some updates to work less all or nothing. I also like clutch. Some players tend to come up big more often in real life.


Can we get some of Bort's previous quotes in that thread so it can be taken in context?
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DL24
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by Mightyhalo


Do we know for a fact adding strength doesn't slow you down? Is this some kind of written in stone thing Bort has confirmed?


If that is true, that seems completely stupid.


Exactly why we need different types of Strength. We also need an acceleration attribute, new cap systems, player creation needs to be overhauled, lots of things...

This way, if you pump "Upper body strength" to 61 or w/e(People will not take skills as high with up to 20 attributes, and 10 or so important to each position), then even if you had 80 Speed, 60 Agility and 60 Acceleration, you should get a -2% or something to all of those attributes. Because IRL, being able to bench 500 pounds won't make you faster.


I agree, we also should have stuff like Man Coverage, Zone Coverage, Pass rushing, run stuffing, pass blocking, run blocking, elusive running, power running, etc.
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Instead of bitching, let's try and figure out what the x-factor might be. Bort seems to imply that if there is one, we can affect it somehow, so it has to be something that we can do.

1. RNG--Clutch could simply be a way to directly affect the RNG in contrast to all other VAs/SAs/PAs that try to improve your roll, which is then affected by the RNG

2. Ratios--Sps in PAs to Sps in SAs; Physical Skills compared to Football Skills; or just total sps in football skills

3. Game day experience--essentially, players get better naturally based upon their experience playing in big games or making big plays.

4. Other player builds--the dots adjust what they attempt to do based upon their teammates (e.g. a wr won't run as fast because his qb isn't as strong or has lower throwing)

 
Mofo
offline
Link
 
Why is bort posting this stuff in the mod forum and not in here?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Post many people need to read right now before going further:

Originally posted by Jed

OK, so you can confirm that there is nothing in place behind the scenes that pre-determines one player will always, say, run a route faster, block better, or throw more accurately than another player with the same exact skills, SA's, VA's, and equipment? If there is/ever will be something behind the scenes, it'll be like what you describe there, to make things more random?


Originally posted by Bort

I agree that any "hidden" stuff is or will be random like I'm talking about. I think game to game and play to play randomness to be very important and interesting ideas, that mirror real life events. Sometimes players show up for the game, other times don't for whatever reason. Abilities to affect those factors are my favorite ones, actually. I love the streaky ability, though it might need some updates to work less all or nothing. I also like clutch. Some players tend to come up big more often in real life.


Apparently it's not simple game-to-game randomness though. There are players who are showing up every single game playing way faster than they should.
 
Badhands
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kevin Smith


The fact that he hasnīt looked at the OP and said "Hmm, thatīs weird, Iīll have a look at that and see whatīs causing it." is a pretty strong indication that he knows exactly what is causing it. Ie: confirmation of the x-factor.


 
DL24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
Instead of bitching, let's try and figure out what the x-factor might be. Bort seems to imply that if there is one, we can affect it somehow, so it has to be something that we can do.

1. RNG--Clutch could simply be a way to directly affect the RNG in contrast to all other VAs/SAs/PAs that try to improve your roll, which is then affected by the RNG

2. Ratios--Sps in PAs to Sps in SAs; Physical Skills compared to Football Skills; or just total sps in football skills

3. Game day experience--essentially, players get better naturally based upon their experience playing in big games or making big plays.

4. Other player builds--the dots adjust what they attempt to do based upon their teammates (e.g. a wr won't run as fast because his qb isn't as strong or has lower throwing)



Moderately high attributes(taken to 68 instead of the 73 or 77 extremes), with a good does of confidence(60 or so), add in maxed Streaky and Clutch. Just imo, of course.
 
monsterkill
offline
Link
 
x factor is not a fix for build diversity. i cant believe anyone is even suggesting that.

for example: say the max level was 10 and you got 1 sp each level and there's only 2 things to invest your sp in but they max out at 5. everyone would be 5/5, duh. if you want build diversity, make it so they cant be everything at once. 3 ways to do it:
- add more options to invest in for player development using the same currency
- make it so you can take the current options higher
- reduce the total amount of currency used in a player build at max level

how would this translate to glb?
- add more SAs or make improve some of the weaker SAs to make them a viable option. and i'm talking about things to invest SP, not a new currency like VAs. or add more attributes or split existing attributes
- allow SP to be spent to take SAs higher than 10
- reduce the number of seasons before decline

go for one of those 3 avenues for build diversity. x factor just has a bunch of people maxing out the known good attributes and throwing their hands up in the air when they're still worse that someone else with the same build. when someone does try a new build, if they arent x factor, they'll never show up on the radar anyways.

took too long to type, people already mentioned this stuff but i'll post it anyways because i agree
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by DL24

Originally posted by jrry32


Originally posted by Mightyhalo



Do we know for a fact adding strength doesn't slow you down? Is this some kind of written in stone thing Bort has confirmed?


If that is true, that seems completely stupid.


Exactly why we need different types of Strength. We also need an acceleration attribute, new cap systems, player creation needs to be overhauled, lots of things...

This way, if you pump "Upper body strength" to 61 or w/e(People will not take skills as high with up to 20 attributes, and 10 or so important to each position), then even if you had 80 Speed, 60 Agility and 60 Acceleration, you should get a -2% or something to all of those attributes. Because IRL, being able to bench 500 pounds won't make you faster.


I agree, we also should have stuff like Man Coverage, Zone Coverage, Pass rushing, run stuffing, pass blocking, run blocking, elusive running, power running, etc.


They should be on which position you pick instead of stuff like punting and kicking that's worthless to HBs.
 
Danger Dog
offline
Link
 
Can anyone tell me why they call him "Bucksnort Bort"? I've always wanted to know but have never asked.
 
RobertRJS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
HEY GUYS DID SOME OF YOU FORGET THERE IS A RNG?


do you understand probabilities with a RNG? my guess is no
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
Can't we get a straight answer. "No there is no hidden variables connected with players but only RNG", and then a nice explanation for the OP.


I'm pretty sure that's about as straight-forward as you're going to get. He said that there is and never will be any kind of hidden attribute which always favors one player over another.

Originally posted by Saris
Can we get some of Bort's previous quotes in that thread so it can be taken in context?


Bort was talking about how he likes the idea of things like Clutch, which is more behind the scenes, which is more random, but at the same time, we can affect with the Clutch VA and building out further from there. He wouldn't confirm or deny that there are or will be others like that now or in the future.
 
RobertRJS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mofo
Why is bort posting this stuff in the mod forum and not in here?


 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
For Dog Dude http://userscripts.org/scripts/show/53096
 
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by Jed

Post many people need to read right now before going further:

Originally posted by Jed


OK, so you can confirm that there is nothing in place behind the scenes that pre-determines one player will always, say, run a route faster, block better, or throw more accurately than another player with the same exact skills, SA's, VA's, and equipment? If there is/ever will be something behind the scenes, it'll be like what you describe there, to make things more random?


Originally posted by Bort


I agree that any "hidden" stuff is or will be random like I'm talking about. I think game to game and play to play randomness to be very important and interesting ideas, that mirror real life events. Sometimes players show up for the game, other times don't for whatever reason. Abilities to affect those factors are my favorite ones, actually. I love the streaky ability, though it might need some updates to work less all or nothing. I also like clutch. Some players tend to come up big more often in real life.


Apparently it's not simple game-to-game randomness though. There are players who are showing up every single game playing way faster than they should.




And THAT is the first thing we need clarification on: "Bug" or "Feature" (and destined to be an unpopular one if its the latter!).
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.