User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by ImTheScientist


Originally posted by jamz



Originally posted by Bort




I'm personally currently leaning most towards the system where we have to demote extra teams.


This is the only way Bort, that the game will progress.

Again, what right does the extra 3-13 team in Pro League have to be there because there are 2 below him that already demoted, Promote the AAA Teams, Demote the WPL Teams as needed, and force more Pro teams that suck back to AAA.


I agree with Jamz.... teams that are 3-13 or 4-12 seem to stick around Pro leagues for ever....give people more of a chance. Plus it will increase the chance that new teams can work their way up the ranks faster and play in the WPL sooner than 9 seasons.


And give those teams a chance to maybe win some games in AAA instead?


Moving more up and more down would give people more of a chance to win. Winning turns franchises around, keeps guts from happening, increases team interest and morale. Hanging around the same league at 3-13 hurts/kills teams.


More teams will have the opportunity to play in the Pros, more quickly. It's what you've always been a proponent of, giving every team the chance to make it to the top league, by the end of a players career.

Teams have gone 3-13 in Pro Leagues, 4-12 and avoided relegation in all of the Pro Leagues for seasons. Taking up a spot, and a chance of a possibly more deserving AAA team, just because there were 2 below them that got the axe.

The extra demote gets to be more competitive in AAA, the Demoted WPL team gets a place in a Pro League and the AAA winners still advance.

WIN / WIN/ WIN
 
Link
 
Originally posted by DL24
Originally posted by Dirtmcgirt66

Originally posted by ImTheScientist


To have an "nfl style" league structure you could schedule the games as follows:

Have an East/West conference (for example):

East teams
EEPL - 4 teams
WEPL- 4 teams
OCPL- 4 teams
APL- 4 teams

West Teams
USAPL- 4 teams
SAPL- 4 teams
CPL- 4 teams
SEAPL - 4 teams

Regular Season
-You need 16 games so each team plays the teams in their own conference 1 time. That gives every team 15 games. The 16th game is random and you play an east team.

Playoffs
-Each division winner gets a home game (4 teams)
-The other 4 teams to get in the playoffs are a "wildcard entry". Best record/tiebreaker gets in.


Boo-ya...you have your NFL sytle structure, you can return poor teams that don't make the playoffs back to their regions, other teams moving into their respective slots, and everyone is happy.

Lets do it.


Extremely flawed in how you typed it up lol. You mention conferences only and then jump down to division winners. You cant have division winners if everyone is playing everyone else only 1 time in a conference. To have division winners you have to have...divisions. People playing each other 2 times a year etc...etc...do you watch football?


Actually no, you'd just take the USAPL team with the best record, the SLAP team with the best record, etc., and they are the division winners. Which would be pretty gay, tbh. So different divisions, maybe one from each region in that conference should be formed instead.


Actually I was right. He said an NFL style league structure. That isnt an NFL style league structure when you dont have division members playing each other twice a year blah blah blah.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Dirtmcgirt66
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

To have an "nfl style" league structure you could schedule the games as follows:

Have an East/West conference (for example):

East teams
EEPL - 4 teams
WEPL- 4 teams
OCPL- 4 teams
APL- 4 teams

West Teams
USAPL- 4 teams
SAPL- 4 teams
CPL- 4 teams
SEAPL - 4 teams

Regular Season
-You need 16 games so each team plays the teams in their own conference 1 time. That gives every team 15 games. The 16th game is random and you play an east team.

Playoffs
-Each division winner gets a home game (4 teams)
-The other 4 teams to get in the playoffs are a "wildcard entry". Best record/tiebreaker gets in.


Boo-ya...you have your NFL sytle structure, you can return poor teams that don't make the playoffs back to their regions, other teams moving into their respective slots, and everyone is happy.

Lets do it.


Extremely flawed in how you typed it up lol. You mention conferences only and then jump down to division winners. You cant have division winners if everyone is playing everyone else only 1 time in a conference. To have division winners you have to have...divisions. People playing each other 2 times a year etc...etc...do you watch football?


The 4 leagues are separated into divisions. Who says you have to play x2 to make it work and why would it not work? If every team in a "division" plays the same teams then there will be a number 1 seed in each division. Yes, I watch lots of football. Im trying to work up a system that is fair to all teams and work within a suggested structure that was presented.

ETA: Notice the " " marks around NFL. If you had been reading the thread you may have caught it.
Edited by ImTheScientist on Jul 27, 2009 21:14:56
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
I don't see parity coming from the divisional setup. I think the teams from weaker regions will get to WPL, go 5-11 to win their division, and then jump ship to the more successful WPL teams since they know they've got no shot at a WPL title. They're relegated to WPL Purgatory---too good to be demoted to win a Championship in a weaker league (their region's Pro) and too weak to seriously contend for a title in WPL.
 
BBVD
offline
Link
 
and let's mix up the conferences more in WPL

each conference could have one team from EVERY pro league conference

that's the point right? playing new teams

just always play your former pro conference rival in week 1
 
DL24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BBVD
and let's mix up the conferences more in WPL

each conference could have one team from EVERY pro league conference

that's the point right? playing new teams

just always play your former pro conference rival in week 1


Then there are no fucking rivalries from your old Pro leagues. That'd suck.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by lukin83


WL could essentially end up being 25 USAPL teams and one team from each remaining region without a method that ensures 4 teams make it from each region. Looking at that as an owner, why would I want to go to an inferior league? Give me USA please.


The unlikely max from the other suggestion would be 18 from one region and 2 from each of the others. But, along the way to that number, all leagues would have had the same opportunity to get in. And all league would have had the same opportunity to be bumped back out. Min = 2 max = 18, more likely 8-10 from one region at a high point. All regions feed in the same way = all regions can attract the same type of FA's and the "lesser" regions have the "easier" path in the early going. Eventually it evens as teams settle into the WL and FA's find their way from USA to other leagues. I don't see how it continues to promote the USAPL or offers any less of a chance to other regions than the divisions idea.


The divisions idea guarantees 4 spots to each region. The other ideas do not guarantee that many spots. That alone makes the inferior regions less attractive than USAPL. Without a way of keeping regional affiliations, former USAPL teams are going to find their ways to inferior regions, which in turn makes those regions less attractive. If nothing is done to make us think that OPL can be equal to USAPL (allowing 4 teams from each region in the WL would do this), then how are we ever supposed to get past the current concept that USAPL is #1? The answer is that we cannot, which will result in USAPL remaining the premier pro league.


But why have to guarantee 4 teams each season? Four teams will go in from each league to start. Two more will go in each season from each league. Why make it so the teams that don't earn their place get to keep it? And how does that improve a league's perceived value ... each year two teams go in for sure, but two will also come out for sure ... instead of each season two go in and may get to stay if they perform well enough and be joined by more from their league. Access to the WL would be the same in each system, why not let it take shape by who earns the right to stay?
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by ICRockets

Originally posted by turnit643

Originally posted by lukin83



WL could essentially end up being 25 USAPL teams and one team from each remaining region without a method that ensures 4 teams make it from each region. Looking at that as an owner, why would I want to go to an inferior league? Give me USA please.


The unlikely max from the other suggestion would be 18 from one region and 2 from each of the others. But, along the way to that number, all leagues would have had the same opportunity to get in. And all league would have had the same opportunity to be bumped back out. Min = 2 max = 18, more likely 8-10 from one region at a high point. All regions feed in the same way = all regions can attract the same type of FA's and the "lesser" regions have the "easier" path in the early going. Eventually it evens as teams settle into the WL and FA's find their way from USA to other leagues. I don't see how it continues to promote the USAPL or offers any less of a chance to other regions than the divisions idea.


If he doesn't understand that by now, using more words isn't going to help us.


Naw, luk is a friend and I'm not trying to bash, just trying to understand, because if he's that much in favor of an idea I'd bet there is something to it. I just personally really like the other one better right now and want to see if there is something I'm missing.


Yeah. I would rather see the WL not happen at all if it is not going to be done right. That is why am I am so invested in this. That and the fact that I wanted to put this thing together 5+ seasons ago. Turnit is a good sounding board, so I am happy that he is questioning my thoughts. If everyone approved of one idea, there would be things overlooked with it.

When I say getting it done right, I mean this...

1. Each region should have equal representation. Sure, it will not be an even playing field now, but if we give it time players will start to migrate to the inferior regions and create parity. I have always been for equality between regions since OPL has always got a bad rap and USAPL have always been the golden boys. it has never been fair in recruiting players, landing coordinators, or getting recognition from the GLB community. An equal 4 teams across the board, steers us in the right direction.

2. Regional affiliations should be kept. This is to preserve rivalries and team locations. If my team is from Ghana, I want to be in Africa.

I really think it is as simple as those two things (unless I am forgetting something - posing in this thread has gotten tiresome).
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist


They always stay the same. Borts goal and GLB's goal is to spread the talent across every region. Bort wants parity. This system would create it. The WPL in general will create a desire to play places like OPL and SEA. People initially just liked USA because most are americans.


You contradict yourself. First you say THIS SYSTEM creates parity. Then you acknowledge that the kind of parity you're talking about is INHERENT with any and all system that includes the mere existence of a new World Pro League.

Seriously guys, this isn't rocket science.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ICRockets
Originally posted by ImTheScientist



They always stay the same. Borts goal and GLB's goal is to spread the talent across every region. Bort wants parity. This system would create it. The WPL in general will create a desire to play places like OPL and SEA. People initially just liked USA because most are americans.


You contradict yourself. First you say THIS SYSTEM creates parity. Then you acknowledge that the kind of parity you're talking about is INHERENT with any and all system that includes the mere existence of a new World Pro League.

Seriously guys, this isn't rocket science.


Right the only question is do you make the first season of the World League as competitive as possible with the best teams from all of GLB, or make it the best 4 teams from every region.

ITS clearly doesn't want the most competitive league.
 
BBVD
offline
Link
 
let's sacrifice a little to gain more...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by Dirtmcgirt66

Originally posted by ImTheScientist


To have an "nfl style" league structure you could schedule the games as follows:

Have an East/West conference (for example):

East teams
EEPL - 4 teams
WEPL- 4 teams
OCPL- 4 teams
APL- 4 teams

West Teams
USAPL- 4 teams
SAPL- 4 teams
CPL- 4 teams
SEAPL - 4 teams

Regular Season
-You need 16 games so each team plays the teams in their own conference 1 time. That gives every team 15 games. The 16th game is random and you play an east team.

Playoffs
-Each division winner gets a home game (4 teams)
-The other 4 teams to get in the playoffs are a "wildcard entry". Best record/tiebreaker gets in.


Boo-ya...you have your NFL sytle structure, you can return poor teams that don't make the playoffs back to their regions, other teams moving into their respective slots, and everyone is happy.

Lets do it.


Extremely flawed in how you typed it up lol. You mention conferences only and then jump down to division winners. You cant have division winners if everyone is playing everyone else only 1 time in a conference. To have division winners you have to have...divisions. People playing each other 2 times a year etc...etc...do you watch football?


The 4 leagues are separated into divisions. Who says you have to play x2 to make it work and why would it not work? If every team in a "division" plays the same teams then there will be a number 1 seed in each division. Yes, I watch lots of football. Im trying to work up a system that is fair to all teams and work within a suggested structure that was presented.


Well I was simply pointing out where it was nothing like divisions in football. However, I do like the base idea of copying the NFL way. I would down for having the current pro leagues have their own division like you stated above but with people playing twice a year. So your schedule would be 6 division games,6 conference games,4 opposite conference games (or whatever #). And for promotion/relegation just take the top 4 from each place this year then move it down to only the pro league winner gets promoted and the bottom team in their respective division gets moved down.
 
Feudel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
List em.

Originally posted by DigitalDaggers

Originally posted by DigitalDaggers


if the league option wins out then DEMOTION is the hurdle we must leap over.

DEMOTION issue was a big reason we were leaning towards tourney.

someone want to start a new thread to compile all the demotion ideas in?


this thread is a place just for demotion ideas in case the world pro league idea is implemented.

note: this be offical thread


Bort Edit:

Caveats:

- Special treatment cannot be given to a certain region or regions, just because some people think that region is better. Biases should be determined by stats, wins, losses alone.
- Think long term. Encouraging the regions to even out as far as talent is a GOOD thing.
- Team owners would prefer to go back to the region they came from. If we can make that happen, it is best.



To the first point, she had the pics taken and without much resistance allowed them to be passed around. It wasn't some malicious computer nerd hacking her account and distributing them to everyone as you seem to be inferring with this statement. You also can gfy with this whole internet nerd virgin played out bs, you don't know who the **** any of us are or how much we get laid or don't get laid. If a girl with a nice rack gives tert pics to someone on a forum and then makes no effort in denying the fact I think it would make us gos to not want to see them. To the second point your post comes off as ridiculously pathetic and overcompensating. I get the feeling that you are one of those guys who is constantly life tilted that the girls you fall in love with always go for *******s and never want anything more from you than to be "just friends." I can imagine its really aggravating to put so much effort into bending over backwards for these girls only to time and time again have them go off and hook up with another guy who you deem to be an *******. Let me let you in on a little clue, girls like to be ****ed by *****, when you act like a little nurturing bitch its not gonna turn them on because they most likely see you as a pathetic figure who would likely cry after sex and profess your love to her the next day. So next time before projecting your insecurities out over internet how bout you unclench your ******* so your balls can finally drop into your sac and then maybe, just maaayyybbbee, you'll finally get the girl.
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
The divisional setup also creates an imbalance as teams in different "conferences" would rarely play each other. In ITS's fictional league, for example, USA teams would rarely play EE teams. This kind of defeats a lot of the appeal of a WPL imo because you don't get that regional rivalry except for the three regions in your conference. A two conference structure with at least one team from each region makes much more sense to me as it creates more of a sense of "global" league as opposed to a "hemispheric" one.
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
Seriously Pack, STFU. We're not putting in more USAPL teams off the bat just because you're butt-hurt. Grow up.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.