User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Endorsements - What I am thinking
Page:
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kcirdor
Originally posted by mrmattregan



you can be maxed out... say you're a level 32 and you have something like 48 bonus tokens already.


you still can't Max out. there are bonus SP for ever 4 BT you get.


Thing is if bort designed it so you cant really wear two upgraded pieces until your a very high level or are a very low level because your normal equipment in most cases is better fully upgraded. Your second piece would need to be very nice and you have at least two upgrades on it to warrant removing a normal piece.
 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mrmattregan
Originally posted by Kcirdor

Originally posted by mrmattregan


Free SP?... that stuff is meaningless when you're a high level player and it takes about 5 or 6 of them to go up one skill point...


how is it meaningless when you can get 4 sp a season with 16 BT(estimate w/o doing the actual math). WHich most of us HIGHER level players end up having to save a couple skill points per level for the next level to be able to get the Atts they want or the SAs...


a couple? try 8 or 9 or even higher...


so your saying that you have to save 9 skill points per level so on the next level when you get your next 5 skill points you have to spend 14 skill points to raise an attribute?

Your numbers are ass backwards I understand that, but your arguement against the BT is a failure.
 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Animalmother
Originally posted by Kcirdor

Originally posted by mrmattregan




you can be maxed out... say you're a level 32 and you have something like 48 bonus tokens already.


you still can't Max out. there are bonus SP for ever 4 BT you get.


Thing is if bort designed it so you cant really wear two upgraded pieces until your a very high level or are a very low level because your normal equipment in most cases is better fully upgraded. Your second piece would need to be very nice and you have at least two upgrades on it to warrant removing a normal piece.


which can happen. you don't have to wear it to upgrade it.
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by l4boMb4
Originally posted by Animalmother

Originally posted by l4boMb4


Originally posted by Animalmother



Originally posted by l4boMb4




Originally posted by Animalmother





Before this all started i posted that it was like Christmas morning waiting to see if your parents got you clothes or the super Nintendo!
Would I be pissed or happy as a puppy with two peckers?!?!?!

Now If bort decides to rip these endorcments away its going to be like he packed the clothes into the empty super Nintendo box just to *uck with me




This isn't the super Nintendo, and you aren't 10...this is about right, wrong, and the proper allocation of something that can have a lasting impact upon a game that a lot people pay for.


Im missing the lasting impact on the game part.

<-------- I pay for the game as well if you click on my name.

My point was a very good analogy of how the players feel who will lose there endorcment so you can have another chance to get one.


Not a very good analogy if, as in your scenario, you got a nintendo....but it didn't work. Which is how this endorsement disbursement currently stands. Its all relative. You can't really get excited about something that truly never worked. I got excited about my HB in season 3 when he headfaked 8-10 players a play....i didn't cry when Bort nerfed it because I knew that it was too obvious to be neglected.


Since when did head fakes show up on replays in season 3?
Im calling BS amirite!


You are wrong. Its the only SA i had and it was obvious if you actually followed the sim and the replays...especially considering people outleveled me by 8-10 levels and were stopping dead in their tracks. My HB build was one of the main reasons that SA got nerfed.



I think bort knows people will be bummed out thats why he added it to the OP. We were trying to come up with suggestions to help ease the pain and 4 bonus token and 1 va wouldn't break the game.
That's 1 sp and 1 va. My lvl 33 qb has 9 Va's and my lvl 33 Hb has 5... omg games broke /rage quit? Only bort know hot vet points were given out to begin with and between me and a few friends with HUNDREDS of players nobody's va's match up.

the answer is just give out moar endorcments to EVERYONE so the 1% dont stand out and we can fix it next go around. Block the teams that have multiple players already from being eligible for the next batch....
Last edited Feb 26, 2009 22:58:49
 
ggnringo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Kk,

I've been hashing out some ideas, and I wanted to note them down for feedback:

1. We come up with a MVP calculation. Base it on the current "top threats" calculations, combined with the fame value. Since you don't gain much, if any, fame from playing gutted teams, it will help to balance out the formula. With a bit of fiddling, I think it could work pretty well, and add a fun element of "MVP race" to each league. This will make glamor players more glamorous as well. We'll run a full season on the test server and tweak our formula until it looks pretty good based on the full season's stats. We do a separate MVP list for Offense, Defense, and ST players, per conference....OK

2. We give 3 top "corporate" endorsements per conference at the end of the season, which will be taken from the current endorsements that are given for that league level. This is given to the top O/D/ST MVP's in the MVP race. They can take this item with them if they are promoted......EXPIRATION ON CONTRACT AND USE OF BONUS "ENDORSEMENT EQ" PLEASE

3. We give 1 "national" endorsement per team that is equal to the current endorsements from 2 tiers down, ranked by the same MVP system. Alternatively, we could do a lottery per team based on the MVP calculation = more tickets. We do this at week 8, and base it on the current league results....OK

4. We give 2 "local" endorsement per team that is equal to the current bottom tier endorsements. So Pro teams get the ones from BBB, which are +2's, and AAA gets +1's from the current pool of pee-wee items. We hand these out at weeks 4/8/12 based on the current season's rankings, with a general lottery system based on current fame values. These items last 4 weeks. I see this as a fun way to keep the items circulating and keep interest up throughout the season........I like the Idea Of An EXpiration ON The EQ, but A Full Season...???.....Though Not oposed to a mid-season shuffle.."to keep it fresh"........could get confusing and argumentitive fer sure....

- Teams cannot get more than 3 endorsements. If they already have 3, they lose out on national or local deals depending on if they got all the MVP awards or not.....YES....imagine what happens during shuffle periods....guess folks will have to learn to "appreciate a gift"......for the short time ya get to paly with it...what about PLAYOFFS??/....bad time to have that EQ shuffle out of your hands and into an opposing teams...????....maybe I don't get the idea of this Bonus EQ....

- A player cannot get more than 1 endorsement. ....AGREE!!

- Only 3 endorsements can be active in a game. This heads off MVP players who become FA's at the end of a season joining other teams to stack them......FOR SURE

- If you are traded or cut, you lose your item. (debatable since 3 endorsements active heads off a lot of problems)

- We scrap the "one per position" idea and just give out items that are made for the selected player's position. NO .PLEASE

- Leagues below AA are not eligible for the national or corporate endorsements, and instead each team gets 3 local endorsements....GREAT IDEA

- We remove the current items, let people keep their cash, and maybe give some BT's or something for their trouble. We then do our first set of per-team local items in 6 days. This should give some time to adapt the script I have and test it on the test server, though it'd be pretty straight forward.....OK

- If we can come up with an MVP formula everyone likes by week 8, we can do the national ones then. If not, we just wait on that until next season.....OK

Some feedback on the idea would be great; The folks I have pitched it to so far think it's pretty good and helps keep everyone feeling involved.

Note: Please try to keep things civil in this thread and help be constructive with ideas. The mods and I will not hesitate to suspend people for flaming and trolling.




 
l4boMb4
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Animalmother


I think bort knows people will be bummed out thats why he added it to the OP. We were trying to come up with suggestions to help ease the pain and 4 bonus token and 1 va wouldn't break the game.
That's 1 sp and 1 va. My lvl 33 qb has 9 Va's and my lvl 33 Hb has 5... omg games broke /rage quit? Only bort know hot vet points were given out to begin with and between me and a few friends with HUNDREDS of players nobody's va's match up.

the answer is just give out moar endorcments to EVERYONE so the 1% dont stand out and we can fix it next go around. Block the teams that have multiple players already from being eligible for the next batch....


My point is that while others have been forced to completely give up on builds due to nerfs with NO compensation, why should players that never got nerfed or actually affected in game get some sort of bonus for Bort screwing up. Bort and GLB have screwed up before and will screw up again. By rewarding people for unforeseen screw-ups, is a SLIPPERY SLOPE.

QthisFT
Last edited Feb 26, 2009 23:07:26
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by l4boMb4
Originally posted by Animalmother



I think bort knows people will be bummed out thats why he added it to the OP. We were trying to come up with suggestions to help ease the pain and 4 bonus token and 1 va wouldn't break the game.
That's 1 sp and 1 va. My lvl 33 qb has 9 Va's and my lvl 33 Hb has 5... omg games broke /rage quit? Only bort know hot vet points were given out to begin with and between me and a few friends with HUNDREDS of players nobody's va's match up.

the answer is just give out moar endorcments to EVERYONE so the 1% dont stand out and we can fix it next go around. Block the teams that have multiple players already from being eligible for the next batch....


My point is that while others have been forced to completely give up on builds to due nerfs with NO compensation, why should players that never got nerfed or actually affected in game get some sort of bonus for Bort screwing up. Bort and GLB have screwed up before and will screw up again. By rewarding people for unforeseen screw-ups, is a SLIPPERY SLOPE.

QthisFT


If your build was so one sided that 30 points of equipment and 3 level ups minimum per season wasnt enought to fix it then that is only your fault not Borts.

GLB made a mistake and there going to fix it per the OP I already gave an Idea on how to ease the pain and if you would like to feel free. If nothing is done dotball goes on and I will move on its not the end of the world. Im happy Bort is even listening to us at all tbh and I thin the OP all in all is on the right track.

You can win and lets let other peeps chime in hehe
 
ChuckTaylor
offline
Link
 
compensation should be 8 bonus tokens and 500K for your player. you don't deserve anything else.

 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by smizzy
compensation should be 8 bonus tokens and 500K for your player. you don't deserve anything else.



Thats fine too boss as long as it isnt money and a sorry because money is worthless in glb.
 
l4boMb4
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Animalmother
Originally posted by l4boMb4

Originally posted by Animalmother




I think bort knows people will be bummed out thats why he added it to the OP. We were trying to come up with suggestions to help ease the pain and 4 bonus token and 1 va wouldn't break the game.
That's 1 sp and 1 va. My lvl 33 qb has 9 Va's and my lvl 33 Hb has 5... omg games broke /rage quit? Only bort know hot vet points were given out to begin with and between me and a few friends with HUNDREDS of players nobody's va's match up.

the answer is just give out moar endorcments to EVERYONE so the 1% dont stand out and we can fix it next go around. Block the teams that have multiple players already from being eligible for the next batch....


My point is that while others have been forced to completely give up on builds to due nerfs with NO compensation, why should players that never got nerfed or actually affected in game get some sort of bonus for Bort screwing up. Bort and GLB have screwed up before and will screw up again. By rewarding people for unforeseen screw-ups, is a SLIPPERY SLOPE.

QthisFT


If your build was so one sided that 30 points of equipment and 3 level ups minimum per season wasnt enought to fix it then that is only your fault not Borts.

GLB made a mistake and there going to fix it per the OP I already gave an Idea on how to ease the pain and if you would like to feel free. If nothing is done dotball goes on and I will move on its not the end of the world. Im happy Bort is even listening to us at all tbh and I thin the OP all in all is on the right track.

You can win and lets let other peeps chime in hehe


It makes a big difference if you create a player w/SAs first attempting to find weaknesses within other players' builds. I hit on a few builds by doing this...mainly my HB. He got nerfed and I stuck with it for the rest of season 3, 4, 5, and 6. He clearly was elusive and clearly got hit by another nerf when elusive backs took a hit in season 5/6. It just wasn't worth competing in an overcrowded market of HBs when you dump so many SPs into your SAs right off the bat. He was awesome while it lasted and was exactly what I planned him out to be (his name was Caught Looking). So please don't give me shit about him being not good enough to fix. His future was deliberately altered by Bort for the betterment of the game and I understood it. You didn't see me make a big stink about it and demand retribution though. The only reason this is even a remote possibility is because it was an announced 'big deal' that Bort took pride in. The issue remains the same....it didn't execute as planned and will be changed. People should not get any 'payoff' for the sake of easing Bort's conscience.
Last edited Feb 26, 2009 23:25:25
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
What about for players staying on the same team, and not being promoted/demoted, there be a re-hire for sponsors based on performance...ties to the type of item they're giving (as they want to sell their equipment to Joe Blow Weekend Warrior too! in theory haha)...

Such as, something that's labeled as a Super Sticky Glove pair or something, increasing catching ability...if your WR (or CB/Safety for that matter...and TE) gets this, and doesn't do very well...WR/TE if they have more than say 10 dropped passes in the following season, and Secondary, if they don't pick at least 3 passes off in the following season, the Sponsor pulls the equipment and endorsement...if they MEET the requirements, they keep their sponsor...again, pending not being promoted/demoted/traded/released/etc...
 
bkendall
offline
Link
 
I think I've read through all these posts, so sorry if I missed something obvious.

Losing endorsements when getting cut/traded seems like a terrible idea. "You resign your contract or you'll be cut" (especially since not all contracts end on day 40).

Stats should only be counted against playoff teams for the big awards (the small ones should even themselves out after a bit I would think).

You should be allowed to have back to back endorsements, if your player continually does well... why punish him?

I like the idea of voting + some MVP/fame system. Except I don't know how voting would be done on the biggest level, for smaller tiers it could be fun.

Also, I don't think you should be awarded anything for getting an endorsement and then having it taken away. He already said you could keep the money, so why not just be happy with that. You won an endorsement in an obviously flawed system, it was a fluke, and if it wasn't then there would be no point to ANY of this thread. Why are you entitled to something (or anything) that you won in an faulty system?

Thats my opinion fwiw.
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
If you follow your plan in the original post, they will be toned down quite a bit. My question is this....at this point are the endorsements even worth it?

Just scrap the whole plan and move on to something else to actually improve the gameplay.
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
All I want is to be named after one of the company's giving out endorsements. I don't know how much more money I need to spend on flex points, but I am infamous here on GLB for better or for worse. My precious ego wants it to be made so.

Let's make it happen Bort. You got plenty of pieces that had no name to 'em.
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
As for a feasible contribution to the conversation, I think this is a much better and well-thought out idea for endorsements. I do feel that it is totally unnecessary to exclude A and BBB teams from the national or bigger endorsements. What's the logic? Most teams in A and BBB aren't that great, why even give each team 3 local endorsements? Especially a half-gutted, CPU player team yknow? You may as well just include them to a larger degree. I guess the main rationale behind it is to encourage high level players to stick to the high leagues, but let's face it Bort, guys who play Madden on Rookie are the guys who play Madden on Rookie. They can't be changed. That's just how they do things. They don't like the challenge, they don't like their players playing poorly etc.

I will say that this MVP/national endorsement coding will need to be on point and tested somehow. The main issue to me is when you're just dealing with such a huge sample size, weird things happen. I think #1, averages should be a big factor. Some teams just naturally pass the ball a lot and some don't at all so y'know, finding a happy medium between a QB that threw the ball 600 times for 50 TDs and a QB that threw the ball 300 times for 39 TDs. There's gotta be some kind of weight factored into the team for it to be accurate. The context of the league is also another obvious factor. So many times, you'll check out a player's stats, like I saw a QB who threw well over 100 TDs. But he was playing in a weak league on a pass heavy team and after looking at the game log, you'd see he would throw 20 TDs in a meaningless blowout game and any game they lost, he played like a typical losing QB. 1 TD, 2 INTs. So, like I said, context of the league. Is everybody killing this team? Etc.

The trouble I foresee is that how do you give an OL an endorsement, if at all? The game currently doesn't have any serious stats available to the position outside of pancakes and we all know that doesn't make or break a player. If its at all possible to determine how many yards a team ran for while a particular OL was playing and how many sacks he specifically gave up, then I think it could be more true to life. But I don't know what you've got up your sleeve so I can't say.

I could probably ramble on for every position for another 2000 words. But the underlying theme is always the context of your opposition.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.