Each forum really ought to have its own dedicated moderator. This is pretty much the only forum I've ever seen that doesn't do this.
Forum > Suggestions > I suggest a moderator whose sole job is to moderate FFA
Bartholomew
offline
offline
Originally posted by jared
Originally posted by Homsar16
Originally posted by kevbk6222
what will FFA do when their mod has to ban someone? someone well respected in that forum? obviously i am not saying that will happen but just how will that mod handle it?
If Serenity were to ban someone, there would be no dispute as she had followed rules. The rest of the mods that are there (norsemanvike, Voltron, Jed) tend to overstep their bounds when they're in there a little more than FFA would like.
it isn't FFA's place to choose what the boundaries are, you all agreed to the TOS, so if a mod feels it's lockable or bannable the only choice you have is to deal with it
The point is that the mods who are in there cause trouble and ban people for things that are not expressly against the rules and would not get someone in another forum banned.
Again... ib4l... that randomly gets someone banned. Not everyone who does it. Just one or two people now and then when a driveby mod feels like it. It really isn't any different than threads in suggestions with four or five people saying "Lock"
All this is is one clique looking down on another. And yes, they are reasonable when someone gets banned for a legit reason. When mods come in all sarcastic and shitty and ban someone randomly and then threaten more, they go apeshit. As anyone would.
Originally posted by Homsar16
Originally posted by kevbk6222
what will FFA do when their mod has to ban someone? someone well respected in that forum? obviously i am not saying that will happen but just how will that mod handle it?
If Serenity were to ban someone, there would be no dispute as she had followed rules. The rest of the mods that are there (norsemanvike, Voltron, Jed) tend to overstep their bounds when they're in there a little more than FFA would like.
it isn't FFA's place to choose what the boundaries are, you all agreed to the TOS, so if a mod feels it's lockable or bannable the only choice you have is to deal with it
The point is that the mods who are in there cause trouble and ban people for things that are not expressly against the rules and would not get someone in another forum banned.
Again... ib4l... that randomly gets someone banned. Not everyone who does it. Just one or two people now and then when a driveby mod feels like it. It really isn't any different than threads in suggestions with four or five people saying "Lock"
All this is is one clique looking down on another. And yes, they are reasonable when someone gets banned for a legit reason. When mods come in all sarcastic and shitty and ban someone randomly and then threaten more, they go apeshit. As anyone would.
happylittletrees
offline
offline
Originally posted by Homsar16
Yeah, I'm sure if jared got banned for calling me a dick he would go apeshit too.
probably not, I'm an adult that understands that you have to suffer the consequences of actions
Yeah, I'm sure if jared got banned for calling me a dick he would go apeshit too.
probably not, I'm an adult that understands that you have to suffer the consequences of actions
Last edited Dec 17, 2008 19:08:11
Lightus White
offline
offline
Originally posted by jared
Originally posted by Homsar16
Yeah, I'm sure if jared got banned for calling me a dick he would go apeshit too.
probably not, I'm an adult that understands that you have to suffer the consequences of actions
That is all well and good, and we do accept the consequences of our actions. The BIG point being made is the inconsistency of the drop-in style moderation where the rules change depending on the time of day or the moderator that is around at the time.
Originally posted by Homsar16
Yeah, I'm sure if jared got banned for calling me a dick he would go apeshit too.
probably not, I'm an adult that understands that you have to suffer the consequences of actions
That is all well and good, and we do accept the consequences of our actions. The BIG point being made is the inconsistency of the drop-in style moderation where the rules change depending on the time of day or the moderator that is around at the time.
Bartholomew
offline
offline
Damn guys... It's good you aren't standing in front of me or I'd knock your heads together. You sit on one end of the couch and you sit on the other... don't look at each other. Just eat your damn fishsticks and .... no.... no kicking! I swear I'm going to make you hold hands or something until you knock this shit off.
JazManXII
offline
offline
naturally FFA isnt going to be for everyone because thats a an area where people let loose a little
so im sure FFA does need a lil more leeway in that sense but its still the basics of stopping excessive spam, porn and harassment
but when FFA gets frowned upon by the rest of the sight all we get is voltron (who i actually think does a decent job) and a drive by mod who goes in seeing pointless things and giving a over penalized ban
and is it also so hard to post a comment at the end of a locked thread as why it was locked (it happens rarely)
so im sure FFA does need a lil more leeway in that sense but its still the basics of stopping excessive spam, porn and harassment
but when FFA gets frowned upon by the rest of the sight all we get is voltron (who i actually think does a decent job) and a drive by mod who goes in seeing pointless things and giving a over penalized ban
and is it also so hard to post a comment at the end of a locked thread as why it was locked (it happens rarely)
Bartholomew
offline
offline
Originally posted by Lightus White
Originally posted by jared
Originally posted by Homsar16
Yeah, I'm sure if jared got banned for calling me a dick he would go apeshit too.
probably not, I'm an adult that understands that you have to suffer the consequences of actions
That is all well and good, and we do accept the consequences of our actions. The BIG point being made is the inconsistency of the drop-in style moderation where the rules change depending on the time of day or the moderator that is around at the time.
this
That's the point I've been trying to make. No one who is in that forum consistently and likes to be there is a mod. It's not that the people in there are horrible, exactly (though some of them are). It's that the place does not get regular moderation. Someone pops in now and then and they resent having to do it. Therefore they miss stuff that should be dealt with and take out their resentment on random posters.
Originally posted by jared
Originally posted by Homsar16
Yeah, I'm sure if jared got banned for calling me a dick he would go apeshit too.
probably not, I'm an adult that understands that you have to suffer the consequences of actions
That is all well and good, and we do accept the consequences of our actions. The BIG point being made is the inconsistency of the drop-in style moderation where the rules change depending on the time of day or the moderator that is around at the time.
this
That's the point I've been trying to make. No one who is in that forum consistently and likes to be there is a mod. It's not that the people in there are horrible, exactly (though some of them are). It's that the place does not get regular moderation. Someone pops in now and then and they resent having to do it. Therefore they miss stuff that should be dealt with and take out their resentment on random posters.
Bartholomew
offline
offline
Originally posted by JazManXII
naturally FFA isnt going to be for everyone because thats a an area where people let loose a little
so im sure FFA does need a lil more leeway in that sense but its still the basics of stopping excessive spam, porn and harassment
but when FFA gets frowned upon by the rest of the sight all we get is voltron (who i actually think does a decent job) and a drive by mod who goes in seeing pointless things and giving a over penalized ban
and is it also so hard to post a comment at the end of a locked thread as why it was locked (it happens rarely)
I've seen several suggestions threads locked, usually by Jed. He usually posts the reason for the lock when he does it here. He almost never posts a reason in FFA. Sometimes he posts some shitty sarcastic comment that just stirs everyone up, though.
That's just something I've seen a few times. Generally I go into a forum because the post that's up on the main page catches my eye. Sometimes I stay a while. Not in both of these forums every day, but I have seen it enough to call it a trend.
naturally FFA isnt going to be for everyone because thats a an area where people let loose a little
so im sure FFA does need a lil more leeway in that sense but its still the basics of stopping excessive spam, porn and harassment
but when FFA gets frowned upon by the rest of the sight all we get is voltron (who i actually think does a decent job) and a drive by mod who goes in seeing pointless things and giving a over penalized ban
and is it also so hard to post a comment at the end of a locked thread as why it was locked (it happens rarely)
I've seen several suggestions threads locked, usually by Jed. He usually posts the reason for the lock when he does it here. He almost never posts a reason in FFA. Sometimes he posts some shitty sarcastic comment that just stirs everyone up, though.
That's just something I've seen a few times. Generally I go into a forum because the post that's up on the main page catches my eye. Sometimes I stay a while. Not in both of these forums every day, but I have seen it enough to call it a trend.
JazManXII
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bartholomew
Originally posted by JazManXII
naturally FFA isnt going to be for everyone because thats a an area where people let loose a little
so im sure FFA does need a lil more leeway in that sense but its still the basics of stopping excessive spam, porn and harassment
but when FFA gets frowned upon by the rest of the sight all we get is voltron (who i actually think does a decent job) and a drive by mod who goes in seeing pointless things and giving a over penalized ban
and is it also so hard to post a comment at the end of a locked thread as why it was locked (it happens rarely)
I've seen several suggestions threads locked, usually by Jed. He usually posts the reason for the lock when he does it here. He almost never posts a reason in FFA. Sometimes he posts some shitty sarcastic comment that just stirs everyone up, though.
That's just something I've seen a few times. Generally I go into a forum because the post that's up on the main page catches my eye. Sometimes I stay a while. Not in both of these forums every day, but I have seen it enough to call it a trend.
its just the little things like that though that piss me off
i dont care if its obvious why it was locked and the end of the day does a quick one sentence hurt
Originally posted by JazManXII
naturally FFA isnt going to be for everyone because thats a an area where people let loose a little
so im sure FFA does need a lil more leeway in that sense but its still the basics of stopping excessive spam, porn and harassment
but when FFA gets frowned upon by the rest of the sight all we get is voltron (who i actually think does a decent job) and a drive by mod who goes in seeing pointless things and giving a over penalized ban
and is it also so hard to post a comment at the end of a locked thread as why it was locked (it happens rarely)
I've seen several suggestions threads locked, usually by Jed. He usually posts the reason for the lock when he does it here. He almost never posts a reason in FFA. Sometimes he posts some shitty sarcastic comment that just stirs everyone up, though.
That's just something I've seen a few times. Generally I go into a forum because the post that's up on the main page catches my eye. Sometimes I stay a while. Not in both of these forums every day, but I have seen it enough to call it a trend.
its just the little things like that though that piss me off
i dont care if its obvious why it was locked and the end of the day does a quick one sentence hurt
kevbk6222
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bartholomew
Originally posted by JazManXII
naturally FFA isnt going to be for everyone because thats a an area where people let loose a little
so im sure FFA does need a lil more leeway in that sense but its still the basics of stopping excessive spam, porn and harassment
but when FFA gets frowned upon by the rest of the sight all we get is voltron (who i actually think does a decent job) and a drive by mod who goes in seeing pointless things and giving a over penalized ban
and is it also so hard to post a comment at the end of a locked thread as why it was locked (it happens rarely)
I've seen several suggestions threads locked, usually by Jed. He usually posts the reason for the lock when he does it here. He almost never posts a reason in FFA. Sometimes he posts some shitty sarcastic comment that just stirs everyone up, though.
That's just something I've seen a few times. Generally I go into a forum because the post that's up on the main page catches my eye. Sometimes I stay a while. Not in both of these forums every day, but I have seen it enough to call it a trend.
there is usually a reason post when suggestions are lock because there are clear reasons. break NGTH, already posted on front page, ect. but, in FFA the rules are pretty vague. as the rest of the general rules for these forums are.
Originally posted by JazManXII
naturally FFA isnt going to be for everyone because thats a an area where people let loose a little
so im sure FFA does need a lil more leeway in that sense but its still the basics of stopping excessive spam, porn and harassment
but when FFA gets frowned upon by the rest of the sight all we get is voltron (who i actually think does a decent job) and a drive by mod who goes in seeing pointless things and giving a over penalized ban
and is it also so hard to post a comment at the end of a locked thread as why it was locked (it happens rarely)
I've seen several suggestions threads locked, usually by Jed. He usually posts the reason for the lock when he does it here. He almost never posts a reason in FFA. Sometimes he posts some shitty sarcastic comment that just stirs everyone up, though.
That's just something I've seen a few times. Generally I go into a forum because the post that's up on the main page catches my eye. Sometimes I stay a while. Not in both of these forums every day, but I have seen it enough to call it a trend.
there is usually a reason post when suggestions are lock because there are clear reasons. break NGTH, already posted on front page, ect. but, in FFA the rules are pretty vague. as the rest of the general rules for these forums are.
As far as I know Jed will 99 times out of 100 times post why he locked a thread.
I am with you tho... I hate ninja locks.
I am with you tho... I hate ninja locks.
Last edited Dec 17, 2008 19:20:43
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























