User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
therunner24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oronis
I figured out what pisses me off about all the DE whiners and their arguements. They are hypocrites. You guys want to be great OTs with just strength and blocking. While you don't want the DE to be successful with just speed and agility. Fine, I'm not going to argue that other stats like Strength, Vision, and Confidence should factor in to a DE's performance. BUT at the same time, an OT's performance should also take more than just Strength and Blocking to be effective. Stats like Agility, Vision, Speed and Confidence should factor in to their performance as well.

They are also hypocrites because they want an OT to be able to stop a DE 100%. Well, the way GLB works right now, it's hard for a DE to get any action other than sacks. So if you want to nerf their pass-rushing abilities, improve their run-stopping abilities.


+1
 
Zable
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Been working on trying various things the last few days. I agree that the 90 speed guys getting to the QB in 1 second is dumb.

One thing I will probably put in is the "jump the snap" delay based on vision, which means DE's who have no vision will not get off the line immediately every time.

I'm also experimenting with "holding" code, that would allow the lineman to get a handful of jersey and hold they guy back using primarily strength even if he's mostly gotten past him. Not done on that one, though. I'd need to get the penalty in for it as well. Seems reasonable, though, since NFL blockers pretty much hold on every play .

Also, I'm thinking of improving "Protector" a little maybe to give more of a speed/turning ability boost, and also giving a bonus to side-to-side movement to avoid losing too much speed when blocking.


Bort im sure you realize that the Protector skill does nothing for the Right Offensive Tackle according to the skill description so how will that help them out?
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oronis
I figured out what pisses me off about all the DE whiners and their arguements. They are hypocrites. You guys want to be great OTs with just strength and blocking. While you don't want the DE to be successful with just speed and agility. Fine, I'm not going to argue that other stats like Strength, Vision, and Confidence should factor in to a DE's performance. BUT at the same time, an OT's performance should also take more than just Strength and Blocking to be effective. Stats like Agility, Vision, Speed and Confidence should factor in to their performance as well.

They are also hypocrites because they want an OT to be able to stop a DE 100%. Well, the way GLB works right now, it's hard for a DE to get any action other than sacks. So if you want to nerf their pass-rushing abilities, improve their run-stopping abilities.


Not quite. My OT has 35 speed, 56 agility, 64 strength, 62 blocking, 49 vision, 35 confidence and 41 stamina (with a decent selection of SAs). Those are his natural attributes, show me where I neglected anything, as much or more, than any speed rush DE...

First game of the season I got run around like I was standing still on at least 5 plays (we only had 38 passing plays).

I've already made adjustments, so whatever, I'm not really complaining. I would like to see the game made more realistic, so that it's not the DEs crying... once more OTs figure out to move their EQ. Although, not all OTs have an owner who can and/or is willing to pay for his players to get a second set of EQ (or replace current EQ).

The current system is all or nothing... that has the potential to be a major problem.
Last edited Nov 16, 2008 17:47:44
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oronis
I figured out what pisses me off about all the DE whiners and their arguements. They are hypocrites. You guys want to be great OTs with just strength and blocking. While you don't want the DE to be successful with just speed and agility. Fine, I'm not going to argue that other stats like Strength, Vision, and Confidence should factor in to a DE's performance. BUT at the same time, an OT's performance should also take more than just Strength and Blocking to be effective. Stats like Agility, Vision, Speed and Confidence should factor in to their performance as well.


I'm one of those you might call a "DE whiner," and I don't feel as you say such people feel.

I have a high level DE and a high level OT. My OT has beyond-softcapped Agility, soon will have softcapped Vision, Confidence above 40, etc.. The one thing I argue should be less relevant is Speed, although my OT has over 30 Speed, and since he plays LOT and has a lot of Protect, his effective Speed is significantly higher-- to the point he's successful.

But OT's in real life are slow and really should need very little Speed. Agility and Vision, yes; and Confidence if they want to be consistent (low Confidence should lead to some very good games and some very bad games, if the other points are well distributed).

My DE did pretty well last season, and not as well so far this season (given he just faced a gutted team), precisely because I refused to neglect Strength, Vision, Tackling (because sometimes opponents do this strange thing called rushing) and Confidence, and prioritized Agility over Speed.

The current sim punishes him for that, as he virtually always makes contact. Had I just pumped Speed, enough Agility to get by, and the right SA's, he'd be much better. If you don't see a problem with that...well, I do.

There also are just way too many sacks in a lot of games for realism purposes, and the best sackers are CB's playing DE.

Originally posted by oronis
They are also hypocrites because they want an OT to be able to stop a DE 100%.


I sure don't. If there were way too few sacks by DE's, I'd also complain about that. In fact, way back several seasons ago, I did. I was thrilled when we were given the option to use "Evasive" pass rushing, because I didn't know what it would turn into. But at the time, I thought pass rushing DE's needed help.

Originally posted by oronis
Well, the way GLB works right now, it's hard for a DE to get any action other than sacks. So if you want to nerf their pass-rushing abilities, improve their run-stopping abilities.


The "Containment" SA tree, I think, ought to be better than it is for DE's. But then, the team I own has a strong LDE who's not that good of a pass rusher but is a quite significant force on rushing plays.

It's probably somewhat too hard to build a run-stuffing DE; but I've seen a good one in action now for several seasons on my team, despite that his build is somewhat balanced in an effort to get some pass pressure as well.

If someone really went heavily into run-stuffing and accepted that his DE would get very few sacks (or maybe would get some sacks by bull-rushing OT's made to stop evasive DE's), he could build a very effective run-stopping DE. I'm not sure of that, but also I'm not sure that a 90 Strength DE couldn't be quite effective against runs.

I'm sure of three things:

1) Speed helps DE's too much. The very description of "evasive" pass rushing says the player uses his "agility."

2) Strength isn't important enough to DE's, and (most importantly)

3) There are WAY too many sacks by the best pass rushing DE's.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Been working on trying various things the last few days. I agree that the 90 speed guys getting to the QB in 1 second is dumb.

One thing I will probably put in is the "jump the snap" delay based on vision, which means DE's who have no vision will not get off the line immediately every time.

I'm also experimenting with "holding" code, that would allow the lineman to get a handful of jersey and hold they guy back using primarily strength even if he's mostly gotten past him. Not done on that one, though. I'd need to get the penalty in for it as well. Seems reasonable, though, since NFL blockers pretty much hold on every play .

Also, I'm thinking of improving "Protector" a little maybe to give more of a speed/turning ability boost, and also giving a bonus to side-to-side movement to avoid losing too much speed when blocking.


I'm glad to know you're on it, and that fixes are on the way.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
How did none of that come up in testing?
 
oronis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1


I'm sure of three things:

1) Speed helps DE's too much. The very description of "evasive" pass rushing says the player uses his "agility."

2) Strength isn't important enough to DE's, and (most importantly)

3) There are WAY too many sacks by the best pass rushing DE's.


Thanks for the thoughtful response. I like this list, it's much more balanced and rational than what the majority of complainers are posting. I don't have a problem with DEs needing more Agility to swim and rip past the OT, rather than raw speed to avoid the block all together. I've always thought positions should either have relative stats, or position caps (IE, a WR with 30 speed is faster than a C with 30 speed / or a WR's speed softcap starts at 70 instead of 48, while a C's speed softcap is at 30 instead of 48).

As for Strength, I don't have a problem with that either. If you force contact through natural game mechanics, rather than just hotfixing it and requiring them to lock because Bort can't figure a better way around it, this is probably already taken care of.

And lastly, I don't have problems with reducing sacks for the most powerful DEs, but not at the expense of other DEs. There are some DEs that get 1 or 2 sacks a year. Don't make them even less relevant because they didn't dump all their points into Speed and Agility. Also, as you reduce sacks, you have to give something in return. That way having a DE isn't boring. You either need to increase hurries and the radius of pressure, or somehow figure out a way to get them more involved in the run stopping. Perhaps allow them to attempt tackles even though they are engaged with a blocker more often. Right now a lot of RBS can rush right over the D-line if they are engaged with an O-lineman.

 
Jackula
offline
Link
 
It's annoying how some are complaining about too many sacks and others are complaining about too little. WHAT THE HELL?
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
How did none of that come up in testing?


My guess is the viability of changes is measured more by that cumulative stats found in testing rather than by someone spending a lot of time watching replays to see how those stats happen.
 
navytexas1
offline
Link
 
you need to sing remake of the Song Broken Home. remake to your liking "Broken Game"
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jackula1027
It's annoying how some are complaining about too many sacks and others are complaining about too little. WHAT THE HELL?


then there is a thread now complaining about DE's getting pancake to much
 
UnsaidPlayer
offline
Link
 
Without a good pass rush from the DEs and the WRs being able to hold blocks for 10 seconds has really made it hard for the defense to stop the offense unless both teams are a high lvl.

Meaning young teams are getting their D lit up.


Change it back to what we played with last season..The new OAI alone should be enough to keep the Defense and Offense even.
 
uscbucsfan
offline
Link
 
we have 2 DEs on our team with 8 sacks...Im happy so far
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oronis
Originally posted by Ken1



I'm sure of three things:

1) Speed helps DE's too much. The very description of "evasive" pass rushing says the player uses his "agility."

2) Strength isn't important enough to DE's, and (most importantly)

3) There are WAY too many sacks by the best pass rushing DE's.


Thanks for the thoughtful response. I like this list, it's much more balanced and rational than what the majority of complainers are posting. I don't have a problem with DEs needing more Agility to swim and rip past the OT, rather than raw speed to avoid the block all together. I've always thought positions should either have relative stats, or position caps (IE, a WR with 30 speed is faster than a C with 30 speed / or a WR's speed softcap starts at 70 instead of 48, while a C's speed softcap is at 30 instead of 48).

As for Strength, I don't have a problem with that either. If you force contact through natural game mechanics, rather than just hotfixing it and requiring them to lock because Bort can't figure a better way around it, this is probably already taken care of.

And lastly, I don't have problems with reducing sacks for the most powerful DEs, but not at the expense of other DEs. There are some DEs that get 1 or 2 sacks a year. Don't make them even less relevant because they didn't dump all their points into Speed and Agility. Also, as you reduce sacks, you have to give something in return. That way having a DE isn't boring. You either need to increase hurries and the radius of pressure, or somehow figure out a way to get them more involved in the run stopping. Perhaps allow them to attempt tackles even though they are engaged with a blocker more often. Right now a lot of RBS can rush right over the D-line if they are engaged with an O-lineman.



I always have believed that typical players at any position should be able to do what typical real life players at any position can do. So any reasonably built DE should get 4-5 sacks per season against evenly matched competition...but the best should only be getting 30, not 100.
 
uscbucsfan
offline
Link
 
well it seems that every league has 2-4 gutted teams...so I would say 40-50 would actually be reasonable...When a level 25 DE goes up against a 13 OT they should get 10 sacks...especially when they have a bad build
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.