this sim has nothing to do with the love of the game. it is all about the money, and everyone here knows it. technically it's not worth what we pay for it, but i can't really talk when i've spent what i've spent. they have no real competition.
i had seriously looked in to creating a similar game prior to this one being created, but i didn't have enough technical knowledge or assistance to pull it off. my concept was to make the sim itself free, and make money through advertising and other upgrades that focused more around training than player creation and boosting. i always felt that you could grab more money from advertisers in the long run, because your participation numbers would be much much much higher.
i give bort and company credit, and watching this unfold has opened my eyes to just how many problems a football sim poses. they have a decent little business plan, and appear to be doing their best to create a competitive game. they're missing out and losing a lot of customers by making this a pay to play (competitively) game. then again, maybe they didn't want 500,000 users in the first year or two of business. it really is still a beta.
the other main conceptual difference between bort's game and my concept was the layout of teams and leagues. my idea focused less around pre-created leagues, and centered around regional play in the region you live in. it would have allowed users to create their own leagues at the lower levels, or join other leagues being formed year round. it would also have featured a lot of pay-to-play tourneys that featured prizes to the winners. it would have professional leagues like this game that you would have to qualify for, but it would have also allowed users from anywhere to play anyone at anytime in scrimmages.
my concept also created more balanced players, because leveling would not make as much of a difference. i think way too much stock is put into boosting. (but that's where they make their money)
if i ever get hooked up with someone that is technically capable of building the sim, i've already got my domain, and i'm a professional communications guy. i know how to build a business plan, and i know how to create a solid web presence. the marketing and graphics are the easy part for me.