Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by EmpYllek
People still think youre going to hell if you dont believe in God when youre a good person doing everything He asks of us anyway.
any religion without a devotional aspect loses coherence... which, of course, steers us into problems with 'divine command theory' (cf. euthyphro's dilemma).
Originally posted by EmpYllek
The atheists insist on saying that science makes religion look stupid when they should realise that science is the how and can never be about the why
i guess i missed "the atheists" saying such things on this thread. and for the record, the positivists amongst the early empiricists thought that science could also be a 'why'.
Originally posted by EmpYllek
(before anyone starts Im a fucking genius and a scientist so I know my shit - if someone wants we can discuss the paradox of the third law of thermodynamics in a godless existence).
uh... okay. good for you. although i have to say that most self-proclaimed geniuses are anything but.
so fine, third law... but which formulation (nernst1, nernst2, planck)? and where's the paradox? if you're referring to gibbs, i don't know anyone who doesn't think that it can't be satisfied with information theory. did you actually mean the second law with maxwell's demon and loschmidt's paradox and all that? look, all the paradoxes about (ir)reversibility and asymmetry are old hat... and they're still just thought experiments at this point. the jury is still very much out on a lot of this stuff, so it would be very unscientific to get overly bold about their supposed application.
Originally posted by EmpYllek
Basically everyones still missing the point. In the start of "The Hitchikers Guide to the Galaxy" (book version) Douglas Adams makes the point about how stupid so much in this world by referring to how "one man had been nailed to a tree for saying how great it would be to be nice to people for a change".
yes, a fine thought (from a fine author), but where's the devotional aspect?
Originally posted by EmpYllek
Is that not whats really important? Not ultimately whether we drink, or have promiscuous sex, or go against our own church dogma to say "Hey if stem cell research cures Alzheimers Im all for it" - but if were nice to people?
for the record, there are an incredible number of churches who would agree... or simply wouldn't care. not all christians religicize their sociopolitics... in fact, there are a great number who are incredibly depolitical or staunchly apolitical.
i couldn't have said it better myself (no i mean i REALLY couldn't...lol)
well said Cattalus.
Originally posted by EmpYllek
People still think youre going to hell if you dont believe in God when youre a good person doing everything He asks of us anyway.
any religion without a devotional aspect loses coherence... which, of course, steers us into problems with 'divine command theory' (cf. euthyphro's dilemma).
Originally posted by EmpYllek
The atheists insist on saying that science makes religion look stupid when they should realise that science is the how and can never be about the why
i guess i missed "the atheists" saying such things on this thread. and for the record, the positivists amongst the early empiricists thought that science could also be a 'why'.
Originally posted by EmpYllek
(before anyone starts Im a fucking genius and a scientist so I know my shit - if someone wants we can discuss the paradox of the third law of thermodynamics in a godless existence).
uh... okay. good for you. although i have to say that most self-proclaimed geniuses are anything but.
so fine, third law... but which formulation (nernst1, nernst2, planck)? and where's the paradox? if you're referring to gibbs, i don't know anyone who doesn't think that it can't be satisfied with information theory. did you actually mean the second law with maxwell's demon and loschmidt's paradox and all that? look, all the paradoxes about (ir)reversibility and asymmetry are old hat... and they're still just thought experiments at this point. the jury is still very much out on a lot of this stuff, so it would be very unscientific to get overly bold about their supposed application.
Originally posted by EmpYllek
Basically everyones still missing the point. In the start of "The Hitchikers Guide to the Galaxy" (book version) Douglas Adams makes the point about how stupid so much in this world by referring to how "one man had been nailed to a tree for saying how great it would be to be nice to people for a change".
yes, a fine thought (from a fine author), but where's the devotional aspect?
Originally posted by EmpYllek
Is that not whats really important? Not ultimately whether we drink, or have promiscuous sex, or go against our own church dogma to say "Hey if stem cell research cures Alzheimers Im all for it" - but if were nice to people?
for the record, there are an incredible number of churches who would agree... or simply wouldn't care. not all christians religicize their sociopolitics... in fact, there are a great number who are incredibly depolitical or staunchly apolitical.
i couldn't have said it better myself (no i mean i REALLY couldn't...lol)
well said Cattalus.






























