User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by EmpYllek

People still think youre going to hell if you dont believe in God when youre a good person doing everything He asks of us anyway.

any religion without a devotional aspect loses coherence... which, of course, steers us into problems with 'divine command theory' (cf. euthyphro's dilemma).

Originally posted by EmpYllek

The atheists insist on saying that science makes religion look stupid when they should realise that science is the how and can never be about the why

i guess i missed "the atheists" saying such things on this thread. and for the record, the positivists amongst the early empiricists thought that science could also be a 'why'.

Originally posted by EmpYllek

(before anyone starts Im a fucking genius and a scientist so I know my shit - if someone wants we can discuss the paradox of the third law of thermodynamics in a godless existence).

uh... okay. good for you. although i have to say that most self-proclaimed geniuses are anything but.

so fine, third law... but which formulation (nernst1, nernst2, planck)? and where's the paradox? if you're referring to gibbs, i don't know anyone who doesn't think that it can't be satisfied with information theory. did you actually mean the second law with maxwell's demon and loschmidt's paradox and all that? look, all the paradoxes about (ir)reversibility and asymmetry are old hat... and they're still just thought experiments at this point. the jury is still very much out on a lot of this stuff, so it would be very unscientific to get overly bold about their supposed application.

Originally posted by EmpYllek

Basically everyones still missing the point. In the start of "The Hitchikers Guide to the Galaxy" (book version) Douglas Adams makes the point about how stupid so much in this world by referring to how "one man had been nailed to a tree for saying how great it would be to be nice to people for a change".

yes, a fine thought (from a fine author), but where's the devotional aspect?

Originally posted by EmpYllek

Is that not whats really important? Not ultimately whether we drink, or have promiscuous sex, or go against our own church dogma to say "Hey if stem cell research cures Alzheimers Im all for it" - but if were nice to people?

for the record, there are an incredible number of churches who would agree... or simply wouldn't care. not all christians religicize their sociopolitics... in fact, there are a great number who are incredibly depolitical or staunchly apolitical.


i couldn't have said it better myself (no i mean i REALLY couldn't...lol)

well said Cattalus.
 
shepster
offline
Link
 
Didn't Einstein look to a higher power
for answers that were not easily found?
 
David Cain
offline
Link
 
im a christan
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shepster
Didn't Einstein look to a higher power
for answers that were not easily found?


"I am convinced that He (God) does not play dice."
"God is subtle but he is not malicious."
"I want to know God's thoughts; the rest are details."
"Science without religion is lame. Religion without science is blind."
"God does not care about our mathematical difficulties. He integrates empirically."

unfortunately Einstein was not what i consider to be a Christian, according to some of the quotes i found along with the ones above, for example...

"A man's ethical behavior should be based effectually on sympathy, education, and social ties; no religious basis is necessary. Man would indeed be in a poor way if he had to be restrained by fear of punishment and hope of reward after death."

while the first part of this quote definitely fits into Christian values, the second part clearly does not. how sad.

But clearly, he was on the right track, as a good and kind person. This is definitely something that Jesus would have liked...

"A human being is a part of a whole, called by us _universe_, a part limited in time and space. He experiences himself, his thoughts and feelings as something separated from the rest... a kind of optical delusion of his consciousness. This delusion is a kind of prison for us, restricting us to our personal desires and to affection for a few persons nearest to us. Our task must be to free ourselves from this prison by widening our circle of compassion to embrace all living creatures and the whole of nature in its beauty."

That is very very Christian and profound too.
Last edited Aug 12, 2008 22:21:07
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16

(charismatic/articulate speaker, stunning visual aids, etc). and just to tuck it in, it sounds like you're talking about a 'design argument'... so you might enjoy this talk (seriously):
http://www.youngphilosophers.org/labels/beebe.html


took a minute to look at it. my comp sound is broke right now. but i did look at the PDF file handout. it looks to mention some of the same types things i mentioned about JP Moreland's book.

 
EmpYllek
offline
Link
 
I think what I am saying is perhaps being taken out of context. I am after all a Catholic who does in fact go to mass every week, receives the sacraments blah de blah. I believe in god the father,the son and the holy spirit. All very good.

The devotional stuff I was talking about refers not to those who believe but those who dont my basic point being basically that when someone who hasnt believed goes to see the big man Hes probably going to say "ok you didnt believe but you lived a good life which was actually in line with my teaching so hey all is forgiven".

Maybe I brought the atheists stuff from another thread about evolution. If so my bad. Nonetheless I stand by my claim to be a genius. Ill never ever use my genius because Im lazy and would rather drink beer and watch the Sox than do my PhD and contribute to the world but the fact stands.

Now cattalus Im sure in whatever field you study properly youre brilliant. Quoting from wikipedia about the laws of thermodynamics however does not sit well with me. The paradoxes of the second law are yes much more common than the third and indeed without access to academic papers regarding the third law youre unlikely to find great amounts of information on it. Its not good to talk about paradoxes involving perfect crystals which could inadvertantly cause holes in the Big Bang theory to surface especially when CERN is about to go active (I know ejections have happened but the results are still a few weeks away although if the black hole is going to form were screwed already and will get sucked into Switzerland). However, having sat in a thermo-chemistry lecture only a few months ago I can assure you there are theories on what could cause the perfect crystal to break up which create paradox.

Whats pissing me off more about what you said is that you mentioned Nernst and I realised that a year ago I could derive Gibbs,Boltzman and equilibrium Nernst equations starting from the electrochem equation in about two minutes and now I cant....

As for the politics thing - thats more for the right wing idiots who believe what the Republican party tell them. Namely that if youre christian voting Democrat (though were I a Yank Id not vote for them either) is tantamount to signing away your soul to Satan. But hey the peoples flag is deepest red and Jesus would be a socialist so what do the Republicans know.
Last edited Aug 13, 2008 07:47:09
 
stephencagan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Cain
im a christan


cool
 
shepster
offline
Link
 
Jesus would be a Libertarian
and kick Government ruler out of doing
what the people aught ta do
in other words do gods work which is pay unto god whats his
Ceasar gets too much!
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
see below
Last edited Aug 13, 2008 09:36:23
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EmpYllek

The devotional stuff I was talking about refers not to those who believe but those who dont my basic point being basically that when someone who hasnt believed goes to see the big man Hes probably going to say "ok you didnt believe but you lived a good life which was actually in line with my teaching so hey all is forgiven".


That is one of the enemy's biggest deceptions. So many people are fooled, because it caters to the ego. I quoted you Emp, but don't take this personally, this message is for ALL who are reading.

The Bible (referring to some of Paul's epistles) and Jesus' teachings in it, clearly, clearly state that you must believe on him to get to heaven. (emphasis on the period)

If you want to go to heaven, you need to know this. I implore you, because i don't want anyone to suffer eternally, to find out for yourself. Check out Romans 10:9-10; (The Gospel of) John 14:16 and John 3:2-3. Do you want to gamble on your eternal well-being and hope that God will forgive you? If you believe in God, then follow the Bible. You can't just conjure up on your own accord what you think His rules are and hope that He will accept that. Oh, the arrogance of it! Can't you see?

Amazing grace, i was blind but now i see.
Last edited Aug 13, 2008 09:40:19
 
shepster
offline
Link
 
Paul i think did collect for Ceasar then decided a different path.
 
EmpYllek
offline
Link
 
How ironic that you quote something about being blind....

Ive heard catholic priests say that the most important thing is to live in a christian way. Yes having faith is better but forgiveness for not having that faith can come if you have lived a good life.

As for me I do follow the bible. Well actually more the new testament. Some of the old testament stuff I dont agree with at all especially when Jesus says stuff that contradicts it (turn the other cheek as opposed to eye for an eye, sex is evil vs. Jesus is friends with a prostitute stuff like that).

You know you should maybe be a little more open-minded yourself. 100 years ago my church would call you blasphemous simply for having broken away from the True Church (which it still is by the way we just accept that others view the Gospel differently even if we think theyre wrong). So you know be a little judgement yourself as things like this are very open to interprutation.
 
The Big House
offline
Link
 
I have an idea cagan. When I went to church on Sunday, my pastor told us to do most things in secrecy. That's why i ask you to PM me here and think about my idea. I won't do it when nobody is around. PM me sometime.
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EmpYllek
How ironic that you quote something about being blind....

Ive heard catholic priests say that the most important thing is to live in a christian way. Yes having faith is better but forgiveness for not having that faith can come if you have lived a good life.

As for me I do follow the bible. Well actually more the new testament. Some of the old testament stuff I dont agree with at all especially when Jesus says stuff that contradicts it (turn the other cheek as opposed to eye for an eye, sex is evil vs. Jesus is friends with a prostitute stuff like that).

You know you should maybe be a little more open-minded yourself. 100 years ago my church would call you blasphemous simply for having broken away from the True Church (which it still is by the way we just accept that others view the Gospel differently even if we think theyre wrong). So you know be a little judgement yourself as things like this are very open to interprutation.


How can you say you follow the Bible when you don't believe the Word of God? You cling to the parts you like, and throw out the rest. That is arrogance. So, you can decide what parts of the Bible you like and the parts you don't agree with, then God must have been wrong about them.

The Bible is one of our greatest tools to understand how we are to live life. You agree with that to some extent. You agree that the Bible is good. You agree that God is good and real. You agree that the Bible is the way God wants us to live. Now, you want to say parts of it aren't true. It is because you haven't really studied the Bible, allowing the priests to dictate to you how they think. This is a common failing of organized religion. The followers are not encouraged to study the Bible for themselves, but be coached along, for better or for worse by what you hear on Sunday and a few rituals.

You can't just throw out or dismiss the parts that make you uncomfortable. Embrace them, try to understand them.

Last edited Aug 13, 2008 12:21:14
 
EmpYllek
offline
Link
 
Yeah Ill believe that Adam and Eve existed and a snake convinced them to eat an apple.

Or Ill use a little bit of that intellect God gave me and say "Hey! Do you think this could be like maybe one of those parable things Jesus used?".

Also if Jesus says something that contradicts the old testament Ill tend to do what he says. You know on account of being Christian and not Jewish. I dont throw away bits that are uncomfortable - I throw away the bits that are in opposition to the message of Christ (and there are some - just look at homosexuality).

As for "being coached along" - who honestly has a better idea of whats going on in the Bible a guy whos studied it completely on his own or a guy who hears another guy whos ENTIRE life is to deal with it say what he thinks? Let me put it another way - is it easier to get a degree by studying it via distance learning or by going to lectures on the subject?

Im not arrogant at all on this. I might be wrong in which case Im merely a sinner. But to be honest Ill take my chances on my interpretation and my religion's one (you know that 2000 year old entity thats had time to think and rethink all of its messages) over the idea of picking up a book more complex in its meaning than any academic text and trying to work out what it says on my own.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.