User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
cannons call
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drake Slaughter
It was explained that Otis did all of the walker wrangling and no new walkers were placed in there since he died. Shane shot him before he knew about their search for Sophie.


The timeline is still extremely wacky, or incredibly coincidental. Sophia getting lost, sleeping in the abandoned house, walking by the river with her teddy bear, getting bitten by a zombie, getting wrangled by Otis, and Otis going out hunting and shooting Carl happened within a very small timespan...and somehow within that timespan no one from the farm was able to connect the dots, or just decided to let the other group risk their lives looking for a girl they knew was dead.

Basically this whole season has consisted of them sitting around the farm, and occasionally going into the woods to search for Sophia. To me it just seems like a lazy way for the writers to add some filler to the season, while not really progressing the story.
 
cannons call
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drake Slaughter
Otis knew a little girl was in there, no one else. Shane killed Otis before he knew they were out searching the woods for a little girl. With 20 to 30 walkers in there, it's not out of the question that Patricia didn't see a little girl in there when she fed the chickens to them, that Maggie and Glen didn't see a little girl in there when they were in there, or that Shane saw her in there when looking through the cracks. Those are the only people who had seen in there since Otis was killed. Hershel said Otis did all the wrangling and no one had done it since he died.


I mean all of that is technically possible but not exactly logical. You would think that Otis probably shared the same views of the walkers as Herschel, so I can't imagine he would keep it to himself that he found an infected little girl.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by cannons call
I mean all of that is technically possible but not exactly logical. You would think that Otis probably shared the same views of the walkers as Herschel, so I can't imagine he would keep it to himself that he found an infected little girl.



Well the time between Sophie going missing and Otis and Shane leaving for the school is about 48 hours, and maybe around 24 since he shot Carl, so he might not of had an adequate amount of time to discuss these things. Cannot say Otis had the same view about them as Hershel though, don't know, maybe, or maybe he respected his wishes about how to treat them. Bottom line is I don't think there was malicious intent to conceal that Sophie was in the barn, they ignorant to her presence.
Edited by Drake Slaughter on Nov 28, 2011 11:56:18
Edited by Drake Slaughter on Nov 28, 2011 11:55:42
 
kevbk6222
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cannons call
The timeline is still extremely wacky, or incredibly coincidental. Sophia getting lost, sleeping in the abandoned house, walking by the river with her teddy bear, getting bitten by a zombie, getting wrangled by Otis, and Otis going out hunting and shooting Carl happened within a very small timespan...and somehow within that timespan no one from the farm was able to connect the dots, or just decided to let the other group risk their lives looking for a girl they knew was dead.

Basically this whole season has consisted of them sitting around the farm, and occasionally going into the woods to search for Sophia. To me it just seems like a lazy way for the writers to add some filler to the season, while not really progressing the story.


there is no proof that sophia was even in the house. it really could have been anyone and the doll could have easily flowed down stream to the spot of the river where daryl found it. she could have been bit soon after rick left her, turned within 24 hours, was wrangled by otis, put in the barn, and otis leaves to go hunting. all of that could have happened in just over 24 hours.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Thats the beauty of it. They don't have to explain shit and there is no need to. The explanation of how she got there is irrelevant. All that matters is that the group grew to hate walkers so much that they forgot their humanity. So they felt they didn't see the world like Hershell does. But then when Sophia showed up out of the barn, nobody could come to shoot her. Except Rick, who of coarse is the one guy that Shane said couldn't make the tough decisions to lead the group and wouldn't make it in this world.

Its fuckin brilliant. I just wish the rest of the season wasn't such a toilet trash of a slow moving story line to have gotten us here. But I went from saying fuck this show to now im back interested again.
 
X
offline
Link
 
Nah, not buying it. Not buying the timeline and not buying that nobody in Hershel's family were aware of a little girl zombie in the barn.

I do applaud them, though, for at least taking one small step towards the despair and brutality portrayed in the graphic novels. Taken out of the context of the lead-in to that scene, I think the last sequence would have been reasonably at home in the graphic novel. That said, the lead-up to it was marred by either sloppy or lazy writing. I kind of figured that was the direction they were heading since it puts the agendas of the two groups on a collision course, but I think it could have been handled much better.

So, yeah, two steps forwards and one step back...
Edited by X on Nov 28, 2011 12:39:20
 
Arawn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drake Slaughter
Originally posted by CNinja

Sophie isn't in the barn.




wow, you can call out someone when they are wrong, just shows what kind of douche bag you are. Hey no one in this thread, better say what they think, without having real evidence.......
Edited by CNinja on Nov 28, 2011 12:53:47
 
kevbk6222
offline
Link
 
i dont see how it doesnt make sense that they didnt know she was in the barn. from what we know, there have only been two people in the barn sense she went missing, otis and his wife. otis died before anyone knew she was missing and his wife could have easily missed her when she threw the chickens in the barn.

as far as the timeline goes, it could have happened within a 24 hour period if you assume that she lost her doll early on and it flowed down stream and that she wasnt the one sleeping in the barn.

day 1: rick leaves sophia, sophia drops the doll, gets bit.
day 2: sophia turns, otis goes out hunting, sees her, wrangles her and takes her back to the farm, goes back out hunting, shoots carl.

on that timeline it would be possible for her to stay in the farm house if she had been bit, but got away and ran there to hide and turned the next day. but that might not be possible given that we didnt see any obvious signs of blood in the house.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by CNinja
wow, you can call out someone when they are wrong, just shows what kind of douche bag you are. Hey no one in this thread, better say what they think, without having real evidence.......


lol, When I say shit keep yo mouth shut!
 
Arawn
offline
Link
 
Edited by CNinja on Nov 28, 2011 12:59:21
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kevbk6222
i dont see how it doesnt make sense that they didnt know she was in the barn. from what we know, there have only been two people in the barn sense she went missing, otis and his wife. otis died before anyone knew she was missing and his wife could have easily missed her when she threw the chickens in the barn.

as far as the timeline goes, it could have happened within a 24 hour period if you assume that she lost her doll early on and it flowed down stream and that she wasnt the one sleeping in the barn.

day 1: rick leaves sophia, sophia drops the doll, gets bit.
day 2: sophia turns, otis goes out hunting, sees her, wrangles her and takes her back to the farm, goes back out hunting, shoots carl.

on that timeline it would be possible for her to stay in the farm house if she had been bit, but got away and ran there to hide and turned the next day. but that might not be possible given that we didnt see any obvious signs of blood in the house.


It's laid out in the episodes.

Sounds like lazy viewing over lazy writing.
 
cannons call
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Nah, not buying it. Not buying the timeline and not buying that nobody in Hershel's family were aware of a little girl zombie in the barn.

I do applaud them, though, for at least taking one small step towards the despair and brutality portrayed in the graphic novels. Taken out of the context of the lead-in to that scene, I think the last sequence would have been reasonably at home in the graphic novel. That said, the lead-up to it was marred by either sloppy or lazy writing. I kind of figured that was the direction they were heading since it puts the agendas of the two groups on a collision course, but I think it could have been handled much better.

So, yeah, two steps forwards and one step back...


this
 
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
Thats the beauty of it. They don't have to explain shit and there is no need to. The explanation of how she got there is irrelevant. All that matters is that the group grew to hate walkers so much that they forgot their humanity. So they felt they didn't see the world like Hershell does. But then when Sophia showed up out of the barn, nobody could come to shoot her. Except Rick, who of coarse is the one guy that Shane said couldn't make the tough decisions to lead the group and wouldn't make it in this world.

Its fuckin brilliant. I just wish the rest of the season wasn't such a toilet trash of a slow moving story line to have gotten us here. But I went from saying fuck this show to now im back interested again.


Well said, I don't think the other episodes were that bad though, you cannot just build to multiple story arcs having a catalyst from nothing.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Nah, not buying it. Not buying the timeline and not buying that nobody in Hershel's family were aware of a little girl zombie in the barn.

I do applaud them, though, for at least taking one small step towards the despair and brutality portrayed in the graphic novels. Taken out of the context of the lead-in to that scene, I think the last sequence would have been reasonably at home in the graphic novel. That said, the lead-up to it was marred by either sloppy or lazy writing. I kind of figured that was the direction they were heading since it puts the agendas of the two groups on a collision course, but I think it could have been handled much better.

So, yeah, two steps forwards and one step back...


She was gone for half a day, that night, and most of another day, then Otis shot Carl. Episodes 1 and 2 of the 2nd season. Noting to buy there, it's laid out for those watching to see.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drake Slaughter
Well said, I don't think the other episodes were that bad though, you cannot just build to multiple story arcs having a catalyst from nothing.


Eh...but there was an ark of like 3 episodes that definitely should have been condensed in order to keep the story moving. It just kinda laid an egg for awhile. This was a big episode tho. Big move by the writers.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.