User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
Gustoon
offline
Link
 
This is going to be the biggest gamble taken by Bort & Co since the start of this game and one that risks losing advocates of the game.
Bring in the archetypes, but give them their own league, like we have casual, minors etc...


I have already had PMs from folks that have been in this game since season 1 and they have given me 'heads-up' that if this goes through that they will be retiring from GLB altogether, which I empathise with, but its going to leave me and lots of other owners with a huge headache, dammit recruiting good players is already like finding rocking horse shit, god forbid what it will be like after this, IF it goes through.

I should have ansewred on my survery :

Q : Whats the thing you don't like the most about GLB?

A: Constant tinkering with the game. Could we have a couple of seasons where we can go into it knowing what the hell to expect.


I'm one of the older crew on GLB and find it a very welcome distraction from day-to-day happenings in life at the moment, which hasn't been a whole lot of fun for a while now, without going into details . Should this be the demise of building players and designing plays etc... I will have to go elsewhere as well.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
I don't know if it's been mentioned before....but a possible exploit here on both offense and defense.

Some positions get QC/CD as a base SA. What's to stop a player from picking the one they don't get and since they are basically the same thing, getting a 20 in QC/CD.

In other words, is this a potential abuse? bug? maybe just need to change QC to CD or vice versa so we only have one SA that deals with turning?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
Hey kids, rock and roll, rock on.


 
monsterkill
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
I don't know if it's been mentioned before....but a possible exploit here on both offense and defense.

Some positions get QC/CD as a base SA. What's to stop a player from picking the one they don't get and since they are basically the same thing, getting a 20 in QC/CD.

In other words, is this a potential abuse? bug? maybe just need to change QC to CD or vice versa so we only have one SA that deals with turning?


somewhere in those thread/novels, catch22 said they simply wouldn't allow getting both
 
itsme420
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by monsterkill
somewhere in those thread/novels, catch22 said they simply wouldn't allow getting both


I think it was in between the 14th and 15th merged threads
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by monsterkill
somewhere in those thread/novels, catch22 said they simply wouldn't allow getting both


I know you wont be able to pick a bonus SA that is already in your tree.
 
Link
 
Here's the main problem. If you would just set these up so that the gains are not better than they currently are for any position then nobody would complain and there would not be mass retiring. The newer players would be slightly worse, but more build-role focused which is the goal of this, correct? The special SA thing can be added kind of like how VAs were and converting can be helpful to higher level players.

I'm probably not explaining this very well, but the main point is you somehow need to calculate this so that it is not making players built with BETTER overall gains than what we have now. They just need to be more specialized.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Stonewall Paul
Here's the main problem. If you would just set these up so that the gains are not better than they currently are for any position then nobody would complain and there would not be mass retiring.


The new gains are actually worse for C's
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jbleich
The new gains are actually worse for C's


That's fine. But look at LBs, FS, etc. etc.

It has to be worse for each position and then nobody will have a problem.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Stonewall Paul
That's fine. But look at LBs, FS, etc. etc.

It has to be worse for each position and then nobody will have a problem.


I think the "Mass retiring" crowd is going a bit overboard. You will still be able to "transfer" to a new archetype and get your bonus SA's and new ALG's...sure you miss out on 1-22 levels of the "superior" ALG's, however at the end of the day the Season 14 dots will still be 1 season ahead of the S15 dots....will the season 15 dots be better at level 60 as the Season 14 dots where at level 60...well yeah, but the Season 15 dots won't be better as they will always be 6ish levels behind.......The change will close the gap, however the S14 dots will still be better and at the minimum they wont be worse.
 
Link
 
And then they will likely be forced to retire or annoy people in AA one season earlier than previous dots had to.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
^ the only thing I ask is that the ability for an existing player to choose their archetype be available BEFORE the end of this season so we can pick our archetype and then boost our players...instead of having to boost under the old system.
 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
^ the only thing I ask is that the ability for an existing player to choose their archetype be available BEFORE the end of this season so we can pick our archetype and then boost our players...instead of having to boost under the old system.


Hmm, for some, that would be before the playoffs, since a lot hold off on boost till playoffs. I could see it getting held off till the offseason potentially, but in all likelihood, it wouldn't go into effect until next season.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
This may have been mentioned already, but I haven't seen it yet.

Why isn't there an Elusive WR option? It's kind of silly, considering WRs get HF, Juke and Spin, which are all elusive abilities.

There's a Power WR but no Elusive, which doesn't make much sense to me.
 
itsme420
offline
Link
 
so besides the
- bonus/penalty SA's
- additional SA chosen at creation

are the LB SA trees remaining the same?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.