User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
ramart103
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jbleich
Originally posted by vinman

The last thing we need is coaches,hope it is never implemented.



THIS

 
SikoraP13 DTD
offline
Link
 
An idea for the coaches thing, since that's what this thread supposed to be about... a coach gains a bonus to players who plays under him...their training. It increases the percentage of the training of their highest natural attribute.

Ie. A WR with 74 natural speed for whom this was his highest skill, would give all players who play under him a +1% bonus per point in this ability to training percentage, up to a maximum of +5% so each training would always be guaranteed to be 6% at the least (1%+5% from coach ability)
 
Guan Yu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SikoraP13
An idea for the coaches thing, since that's what this thread supposed to be about... a coach gains a bonus to players who plays under him...their training. It increases the percentage of the training of their highest natural attribute.

Ie. A WR with 74 natural speed for whom this was his highest skill, would give all players who play under him a +1% bonus per point in this ability to training percentage, up to a maximum of +5% so each training would always be guaranteed to be 6% at the least (1%+5% from coach ability)


I'm with the people that totally disagree that coaches should have any permanent affects on the build of players on their team. Any advantage to builds should be a one day or at most aun 'until the end of the season" type thing.

Certainly not something that carries over forever. People shouldn't be penalized/rewarded permanently for the misfortune of having no or poor coaches availible when they created their players.
 
tonylieu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vinman
The last thing we need is coaches,hope it is never implemented.


coaches = VAs + flex
 
Lewk57
offline
Link
 
The only way I see a coach being a good idea is if the coach put out a gameplan or training program to the whole team or just the O or D or specials or per unit. All who follow the training for the day get a slight bonus, all who don't get a slight negative for the game. If the coach doesn't put out a plan there is no gain or loss so teams with no coach don't get penalized.

Or it could be set up where if you have a coach, you do get a bonus if they send out a plan and you get a penalty if they don't and teams that have no coach get no gain or penalty. I would also make it so a coach can not be cut during the season, so if you take the chance on a coach for the gain you also get a penalty if that coach should go inactive.

the coach would have no affect in the playoffs.

for this instance we will say by unit. So for O we will have coaches for
1 QB
2 WRs & TEs
3 HBs & FBs
4 OL

The QB coach sends out a plan to focus vision. If the QB clicks on Focus Vision there is a slight game bonus, if the QB ignores it there is no positive or negative and if the QB focuses on throwing there is a negative 2X to vision for the game but you get a 1X bonus to throwing for the game. The coach would know only if the player set a focus or not, they would not know whether they followed their direction.

The WR & TE coach sends out a focus on blocking. If the WR clicks on blocking there is a slight game bonus and just like the QB if you ignore it there is no bonus and if you decide to focus speed you get a 1X speed bonus and a negative 2X Blocking.

 
r87
offline
Link
 
^ That will never happen. Anything that basically forces players to do what the coach/owners wants will never be implemented.
 
Lewk57
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by r87
^ That will never happen. Anything that basically forces players to do what the coach/owners wants will never be implemented.


I think it gives the players more options on where they play, a team with a coach or a team without a coach. The coach wouldn't know if the players followed their direction just if they set a focus or not.

I personally don't like the idea of coaches, it just adds more room for exploits.

 
Gongadan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guan Yu
I'm with the people that totally disagree that coaches should have any permanent affects on the build of players on their team. Any advantage to builds should be a one day or at most aun 'until the end of the season" type thing.

Certainly not something that carries over forever. People shouldn't be penalized/rewarded permanently for the misfortune of having no or poor coaches availible when they created their players.


I concur. Coaches should only give bonuses like equipment or Bonus Token boosts.

Here's a suggestion: Playbook pages. Coaches could buy pages of a playbook. Each time their team called a play in the coaches' playbook, players influenced by that coach (HC, OC, DC, etc) would get a very small bonus to all/some of their attributes.

Here's another suggestion: To make coach money more valuable (and reduce the gross unbalancing that coaches are likely to cause), make most/all coach bonuses one-shot deals they have to buy for cash.
 
SikoraP13 DTD
offline
Link
 
difference btween coaches made and coaches made from players is coaches made from players should start with 1/2 of the money their player ended his career with. Would give incentive to make coaches from players rather than just making them especially if money was used to affect skill sets
 
Jonny do good
offline
Link
 
i did not read through it, but this is my suggestion that i just recenty posted

If coaching is ever added there should be an option to just make a coach. This is so you dont have to have a player over 400 days old to be a coach. You would start as a coach who could only coach pewee for the first year. Based on the teams performance in the league will rate if you can move up to the next lvl of coaching.

Once you pass pewee you go to D leagues and so on. You can be a coach on any cap league. Then again based on the performance of the teams you coach, will rate if you can move into the pro leagues. This suggestion however would not effect the players that are over 400 days old, and retire to be a coach. They would immediatly have full access to all leagues and teams.

There would be a couple requirements(that can be changed based on suggestions)

1. You would have to have more then 5 players to show that you know the game.

2. You would have to have been signed up for GLB for at least 1 month or more(you can decide the actual time signed up)

3. You would have to have been a GM or somethinng for a team.(This is just a thought)

4. You must be cleared by a type of mod to be a coach so we dont have a overload of coaching.( We dont want more coaches then there are teams)

This is my suggestion. WHat do you think? Any suggestions to add to it.

Do not bag on this idea if you dont want coaches in the first place.
Please just constructive critisism or add on ideas.
 
Jonny do good
offline
Link
 
what do you think
 
Jonny do good
offline
Link
 
anyone?
 
Guan Yu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jonny do good
what do you think


Generally I would agree, if you have a 440 day player you get to switch to coach for free or minimal price. If you want to convert a younger one, you'd have to pay a stiffer penalty.

Season one people have always had the best of everything: the best players, a birthright into AAA and Pro Leagues. And while I'ma little envious, I don't begrude them that. They got here first and it really isn't fair that later people should be able to jump up to that level. Thy have to go through the process and put tin the time.

Unfortunatly, the way we're talking, it looks like they'll be allowed that they get access to coaches first. Now they'll have the best coaches. Isn't that taking things too far?

At this point I have to say enough is enough. For season one their coaches, like their players, will continue to always be a step ahead of everybody else. And for the next few seasons, only season one agents or people with ties to season one agent will be the only ones to benefit from coaches. Eventually there will become a glut as wave after wave of players retire. But the best, oldest, most sought after coaches, who wil they belong to? Season ones.

C'mon.
 
Jonny do good
offline
Link
 
See this sounds exactly what i what i was trying to get across. Truthfully i dont think its very far that the older players get every thing.

Bort you should definitely consider this idea.
 
ramart103
offline
Link
 
Coaches in RL are great! The same dosen't apply in a sim that has had 12 or 13 seasons w/o. This should have been implemented in season 1 or 2! Gonna "F" everything,..............let the micro manageing begin!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.