Also, going to add onto the script so that it keeps track of current speed, rather than just one snapshot
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Corners are too fast
greengoose
offline
offline
Calvin Johnson is limited by two things:
1) Players know he's fast, so the CB gives him the cushion necessary to be able to adjust to that speed and stay with him. That dynamic is not in GLB.
2) He can only run so far before he outruns the QB's ability to hit him to begin with.
The problem with Speed is slower people will make the necessary adjustments to compensate for their lack of it and the longer the throw the more time/distance they have to compensate. In reality like I posted earlier, based on pure speed alone Calvin Johnson isn't gonna get a lot of separation on a CB - it's how he runs his route that helps him get the separation he needs - and even then the Lions QB's so often underthrow him it's pathetic anyway.
The most effective routes in the NFL are often slants - thats because the WR can use the separation he gets early in his break so he can use his speed once he has the ball. Using your speed to get separation vertically doesn't work very often in the NFL - too many things have to work in sync (O-line protection, the QB leading the receiver and the WR actually getting an keeping separation). Any one of those 3 that break down means that speed is completely negated.
1) Players know he's fast, so the CB gives him the cushion necessary to be able to adjust to that speed and stay with him. That dynamic is not in GLB.
2) He can only run so far before he outruns the QB's ability to hit him to begin with.
The problem with Speed is slower people will make the necessary adjustments to compensate for their lack of it and the longer the throw the more time/distance they have to compensate. In reality like I posted earlier, based on pure speed alone Calvin Johnson isn't gonna get a lot of separation on a CB - it's how he runs his route that helps him get the separation he needs - and even then the Lions QB's so often underthrow him it's pathetic anyway.
The most effective routes in the NFL are often slants - thats because the WR can use the separation he gets early in his break so he can use his speed once he has the ball. Using your speed to get separation vertically doesn't work very often in the NFL - too many things have to work in sync (O-line protection, the QB leading the receiver and the WR actually getting an keeping separation). Any one of those 3 that break down means that speed is completely negated.
steellithium
offline
offline
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by chronoaug
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587165&pbp_id=11355220
Check out the speed on this guy. Completely blew by our corner. The Safety was playing a middle zone and was helpless considering how fast this guy was. Maybe he has streaky and was having a "good day" or something. From what i've looked at on the player analyzer and watching the speed of a receiver i know had low 120s speed (as of end of last season at least) this guy was higher by like 2 on max speed so i'm guessing Balls Deep has speed in the high 120s. The FS and CB both have high speed as well but this guy is a freak
Great example to look at. Look where the WR gained max acceleration and max speed. Then look at the CB. The CB breaks in at his highest acceleration, the turns around. The CB wasn't leaving any cushion, and attempted to press a guy running a streak route. There is less speed involved in that play than people realize.
Great example even though he is running much faster than most WRs with 120+ speed. It is also a great example at how poor the cushions and pathing for CBs and FS are. There is no way a FS playing cover 2 with deep strong half coverage should get abused like that.
Yeah but look at how long it takes the FS to spot the play. He gets into position, then reacts to the slot WR post route coming over the deep middle. Only then does he see the pass, and then spins around to chase the WR wide open. My guess is these DB's were all set to aggressive coverage, and they got burned for trying to jump routes. All of this is inside the agent's and DC's control.
Originally posted by steellithium
Originally posted by chronoaug
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=587165&pbp_id=11355220
Check out the speed on this guy. Completely blew by our corner. The Safety was playing a middle zone and was helpless considering how fast this guy was. Maybe he has streaky and was having a "good day" or something. From what i've looked at on the player analyzer and watching the speed of a receiver i know had low 120s speed (as of end of last season at least) this guy was higher by like 2 on max speed so i'm guessing Balls Deep has speed in the high 120s. The FS and CB both have high speed as well but this guy is a freak
Great example to look at. Look where the WR gained max acceleration and max speed. Then look at the CB. The CB breaks in at his highest acceleration, the turns around. The CB wasn't leaving any cushion, and attempted to press a guy running a streak route. There is less speed involved in that play than people realize.
Great example even though he is running much faster than most WRs with 120+ speed. It is also a great example at how poor the cushions and pathing for CBs and FS are. There is no way a FS playing cover 2 with deep strong half coverage should get abused like that.
Yeah but look at how long it takes the FS to spot the play. He gets into position, then reacts to the slot WR post route coming over the deep middle. Only then does he see the pass, and then spins around to chase the WR wide open. My guess is these DB's were all set to aggressive coverage, and they got burned for trying to jump routes. All of this is inside the agent's and DC's control.
jdbolick
offline
offline
Originally posted by PierreThomas
If CBs and WRs virtually had the same speed some college CBs wouldn't fall from 1st round picks to late round picks just because of a slow 40.
This is true, CBs and WRs do fall in the draft because of slower than expected 40 times. But here's a dirty little secret: 40 times are rarely consistent. The same player can run a 4.55 and a 4.45 on consecutive attempts, and times will vary even more over a period of weeks. Players do have concrete differences in their "top speed," as certain guys would never run a 4.35 regardless of how often they tried, but all of them experience variation in how close they get to that top speed.
Originally posted by
In the NFL and college they recruit and draft fast corners because they understand they need raw speed to keep up with receivers at that level. There aren't slow CBs out there because teams don't want them.
This is absolutely, totally untrue. NFL teams fall in love with CB speed just like they fall in love with QB arm strength, but there are plenty of former track stars who completely suck at covering receivers, and there are plenty of other guys who run in that 4.5-4.6 range who are outstanding in coverage. A lot of them compensate for average or slightly below average speed with superior technique and intelligence.
Originally posted by
Right now, every CB with 85 or more speed can hang with any WR not named Jericho Brooks.
That's just not true. I don't get why people keep posting examples of WRs burning CBs and you pretend like it never happened.
If CBs and WRs virtually had the same speed some college CBs wouldn't fall from 1st round picks to late round picks just because of a slow 40.
This is true, CBs and WRs do fall in the draft because of slower than expected 40 times. But here's a dirty little secret: 40 times are rarely consistent. The same player can run a 4.55 and a 4.45 on consecutive attempts, and times will vary even more over a period of weeks. Players do have concrete differences in their "top speed," as certain guys would never run a 4.35 regardless of how often they tried, but all of them experience variation in how close they get to that top speed.
Originally posted by
In the NFL and college they recruit and draft fast corners because they understand they need raw speed to keep up with receivers at that level. There aren't slow CBs out there because teams don't want them.
This is absolutely, totally untrue. NFL teams fall in love with CB speed just like they fall in love with QB arm strength, but there are plenty of former track stars who completely suck at covering receivers, and there are plenty of other guys who run in that 4.5-4.6 range who are outstanding in coverage. A lot of them compensate for average or slightly below average speed with superior technique and intelligence.
Originally posted by
Right now, every CB with 85 or more speed can hang with any WR not named Jericho Brooks.
That's just not true. I don't get why people keep posting examples of WRs burning CBs and you pretend like it never happened.
joeflex73
offline
offline
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by GroovyCheetah
but don't CBs have to also focus on tackling
If they are arguing for speed WR's to get open, they shouldn't spend a single SP on anything besides speed.
Not true at all. If speed=speed and nothing else and not even considering shutdown coverage on a CB then 130 speed WR (about the max on GLB with other decent attributes) and a CB with 110 speed (very easily obtained) the WR would be 11.8% faster. That means for every 50 yards the WR runs in a dead streak he would outrun the CB by 5 yards. A 5 yard cushion could eliminate a WR running by him at all.
I'm not even saying speed should just be speed. I don't care if it is tied to agility or even if agility is made more important but to put a governor on WRs is just simply ludicrous. Tying speed to all other attributes is just as ludicrous. No matter what there are diminishing returns since each cap it costs more and more to increase speed. You could have a 150 speed WR (wont happen) and a well built FS can keep up with him in zone coverage.
DB, I know you are smarter than that. Right now if you just turned speed on then yes, there would be huge problems. If Bort fixes this and gives everyone fair warning while fixing cushions and jumping routes for Cbs then we would have a much more realistic sim that brings player builds back into play for CBs and WRs.
11.8% is arbitrary. Let's say that even 1 SPD (regardless of AGI) reduces a players 40 time by .02. If a player starts at 10 SPD running a 6.00 flat, at 130 SPD we're talking a ridiculous 3.5 40. That corner at 110 SPD is running a 3.9. The CB has cushion, and even if AGI is even, with a small cushion, how long would it take that WR to overtake that CB? 20 yards? 40 yards? QB's don't even hold the ball long enough for that to matter.
There are reasons why CB's will shutdown WR's even if the WR has a flat SPD advantage. CB's and WR's builds shouldn't look similar imo. WR's are bigger on straight line speed IRL, and CB's the 1st thing you hear is "Asomugha has great hips" and how he moves. Does anyone really think Nnamdi, Champ, Clements, Samuel or Trufant (examples) are anywhere near as fast as Joey Galloway (4.19 40 even at 35), Randy Moss, Ted Ginn, or Steve Smith? flames still has you guys brainwashed.
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by GroovyCheetah
but don't CBs have to also focus on tackling
If they are arguing for speed WR's to get open, they shouldn't spend a single SP on anything besides speed.
Not true at all. If speed=speed and nothing else and not even considering shutdown coverage on a CB then 130 speed WR (about the max on GLB with other decent attributes) and a CB with 110 speed (very easily obtained) the WR would be 11.8% faster. That means for every 50 yards the WR runs in a dead streak he would outrun the CB by 5 yards. A 5 yard cushion could eliminate a WR running by him at all.
I'm not even saying speed should just be speed. I don't care if it is tied to agility or even if agility is made more important but to put a governor on WRs is just simply ludicrous. Tying speed to all other attributes is just as ludicrous. No matter what there are diminishing returns since each cap it costs more and more to increase speed. You could have a 150 speed WR (wont happen) and a well built FS can keep up with him in zone coverage.
DB, I know you are smarter than that. Right now if you just turned speed on then yes, there would be huge problems. If Bort fixes this and gives everyone fair warning while fixing cushions and jumping routes for Cbs then we would have a much more realistic sim that brings player builds back into play for CBs and WRs.
11.8% is arbitrary. Let's say that even 1 SPD (regardless of AGI) reduces a players 40 time by .02. If a player starts at 10 SPD running a 6.00 flat, at 130 SPD we're talking a ridiculous 3.5 40. That corner at 110 SPD is running a 3.9. The CB has cushion, and even if AGI is even, with a small cushion, how long would it take that WR to overtake that CB? 20 yards? 40 yards? QB's don't even hold the ball long enough for that to matter.
There are reasons why CB's will shutdown WR's even if the WR has a flat SPD advantage. CB's and WR's builds shouldn't look similar imo. WR's are bigger on straight line speed IRL, and CB's the 1st thing you hear is "Asomugha has great hips" and how he moves. Does anyone really think Nnamdi, Champ, Clements, Samuel or Trufant (examples) are anywhere near as fast as Joey Galloway (4.19 40 even at 35), Randy Moss, Ted Ginn, or Steve Smith? flames still has you guys brainwashed.
Bukowski
offline
offline
Originally posted by jdbolick
That's just not true. I don't get why people keep posting examples of WRs burning CBs and you pretend like it never happened.
Because there are other things responsible for that, other than Speed.
People keep saying that, but you don't believe it.
An 85 Speed CB isn't going to work if he doesn't have the proper build, but it does work with the proper build.
85 Speed isn't just 85 Speed, there are other things going on.
Edited by Bukowski on Jul 10, 2009 00:05:47
joeflex73
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by jdbolick
Right now, every CB with 85 or more speed can hang with any WR not named Jericho Brooks.
That's just not true. I don't get why people keep posting examples of WRs burning CBs and you pretend like it never happened.
Because there are other things responsible for that, other than Speed.
People keep saying that, but you don't believe it.
An 85 Speed CB isn't going to work if he doesn't have the proper build, but it does work with the proper build.
85 Speed isn't just 85 Speed, there are other things going on.
4tw
Originally posted by jdbolick
Right now, every CB with 85 or more speed can hang with any WR not named Jericho Brooks.
That's just not true. I don't get why people keep posting examples of WRs burning CBs and you pretend like it never happened.
Because there are other things responsible for that, other than Speed.
People keep saying that, but you don't believe it.
An 85 Speed CB isn't going to work if he doesn't have the proper build, but it does work with the proper build.
85 Speed isn't just 85 Speed, there are other things going on.
4tw
Bladnach
offline
offline
I just showed an example of where a superfast WR burned a fast CB/FS (they're not the slow ones you guys are talking about)
I've also remembered another fast CB with even higher agility than the one i showed getting burned just the same.
I've played on teams with superfast WRs that burn CBs
You guys have to remember, the WR won't burn the CB every single time. It's a big risk throwing deep like in real life. If you check that game log, they also got picked off by the same FS who covered him better the next time. Just like in the nfl, it isn't as easy as a WR always winning the 1 on 1 battle running a fly route
I've also remembered another fast CB with even higher agility than the one i showed getting burned just the same.
I've played on teams with superfast WRs that burn CBs
You guys have to remember, the WR won't burn the CB every single time. It's a big risk throwing deep like in real life. If you check that game log, they also got picked off by the same FS who covered him better the next time. Just like in the nfl, it isn't as easy as a WR always winning the 1 on 1 battle running a fly route
jdbolick
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bukowski
Because there are other things responsible for that, other than Speed. People keep saying that, but you don't believe it.
No, no, no. Not "people," just you. The vast majority of people are saying that you're wrong, and that CBs can get burned simply by a deficiency in speed. You're a whiner who ignores reality and is absolutely unwilling to ever change your mind or admit that you're wrong about anything, regardless of how much evidence is piled up against you.
Because there are other things responsible for that, other than Speed. People keep saying that, but you don't believe it.
No, no, no. Not "people," just you. The vast majority of people are saying that you're wrong, and that CBs can get burned simply by a deficiency in speed. You're a whiner who ignores reality and is absolutely unwilling to ever change your mind or admit that you're wrong about anything, regardless of how much evidence is piled up against you.
Bukowski
offline
offline
Originally posted by chronoaug
I just showed an example of where a superfast WR burned a fast CB/FS (they're not the slow ones you guys are talking about)
I've also remembered another fast CB with even higher agility than the one i showed getting burned just the same.
I've played on teams with superfast WRs that burn CBs
You guys have to remember, the WR won't burn the CB every single time. It's a big risk throwing deep like in real life. If you check that game log, they also got picked off by the same FS who covered him better the next time. Just like in the nfl, it isn't as easy as a WR always winning the 1 on 1 battle running a fly route
You don't get it.
Speed isn't the thing causing these CBs to get beat.
In fact, it really isn't Speed at all that causes CBs to get beat.
There are other attributes that these CBs are lacking, which is normally why they give up big plays. It's not a Speed issue. There are 110 Speed CBs giving up big plays, just like 90 Speed CBs. They have something else in common, that isn't Speed.
You can figure it out if you want.
I just showed an example of where a superfast WR burned a fast CB/FS (they're not the slow ones you guys are talking about)
I've also remembered another fast CB with even higher agility than the one i showed getting burned just the same.
I've played on teams with superfast WRs that burn CBs
You guys have to remember, the WR won't burn the CB every single time. It's a big risk throwing deep like in real life. If you check that game log, they also got picked off by the same FS who covered him better the next time. Just like in the nfl, it isn't as easy as a WR always winning the 1 on 1 battle running a fly route
You don't get it.
Speed isn't the thing causing these CBs to get beat.
In fact, it really isn't Speed at all that causes CBs to get beat.
There are other attributes that these CBs are lacking, which is normally why they give up big plays. It's not a Speed issue. There are 110 Speed CBs giving up big plays, just like 90 Speed CBs. They have something else in common, that isn't Speed.
You can figure it out if you want.
Edited by Bukowski on Jul 10, 2009 00:12:54
PierreThomas
offline
offline
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by PierreThomas
If CBs and WRs virtually had the same speed some college CBs wouldn't fall from 1st round picks to late round picks just because of a slow 40.
This is true, CBs and WRs do fall in the draft because of slower than expected 40 times. But here's a dirty little secret: 40 times are rarely consistent. The same player can run a 4.55 and a 4.45 on consecutive attempts, and times will vary even more over a period of weeks. Players do have concrete differences in their "top speed," as certain guys would never run a 4.35 regardless of how often they tried, but all of them experience variation in how close they get to that top speed.
Originally posted by
In the NFL and college they recruit and draft fast corners because they understand they need raw speed to keep up with receivers at that level. There aren't slow CBs out there because teams don't want them.
This is absolutely, totally untrue. NFL teams fall in love with CB speed just like they fall in love with QB arm strength, but there are plenty of former track stars who completely suck at covering receivers, and there are plenty of other guys who run in that 4.5-4.6 range who are outstanding in coverage. A lot of them compensate for average or slightly below average speed with superior technique and intelligence.
Originally posted by
Right now, every CB with 85 or more speed can hang with any WR not named Jericho Brooks.
That's just not true. I don't get why people keep posting examples of WRs burning CBs and you pretend like it never happened.
1) 4.5-4.6 guys aren't that slow. My CBs are playing with less speed than my DEs, LBs, FS, SS, RB and even a couple of my DTs are awefully close to the same speed.
2) You show me one corner that ran a 4.7 in the NFL, just one.
3) Yes, a 4.5 guy can cover a 4.3 guy with proper technique and shut him down. I'm not saying Cbs need 130 speed to cover 130 speed WR. Not once I have I said this, in fact I have said just the opposite over and over and over and over and over but you guys just paint the picture that I want a foot race because it is the only way you guys can make an argument.
As for the examples. There are a handful of guys on GLB that can run consistently faster than a CB and you have to dig through thousands of WRs and hundreds of plays just to find one or two links. I'm not saying it should happen every play but it should happen more than once in every 25k plays.
Originally posted by PierreThomas
If CBs and WRs virtually had the same speed some college CBs wouldn't fall from 1st round picks to late round picks just because of a slow 40.
This is true, CBs and WRs do fall in the draft because of slower than expected 40 times. But here's a dirty little secret: 40 times are rarely consistent. The same player can run a 4.55 and a 4.45 on consecutive attempts, and times will vary even more over a period of weeks. Players do have concrete differences in their "top speed," as certain guys would never run a 4.35 regardless of how often they tried, but all of them experience variation in how close they get to that top speed.
Originally posted by
In the NFL and college they recruit and draft fast corners because they understand they need raw speed to keep up with receivers at that level. There aren't slow CBs out there because teams don't want them.
This is absolutely, totally untrue. NFL teams fall in love with CB speed just like they fall in love with QB arm strength, but there are plenty of former track stars who completely suck at covering receivers, and there are plenty of other guys who run in that 4.5-4.6 range who are outstanding in coverage. A lot of them compensate for average or slightly below average speed with superior technique and intelligence.
Originally posted by
Right now, every CB with 85 or more speed can hang with any WR not named Jericho Brooks.
That's just not true. I don't get why people keep posting examples of WRs burning CBs and you pretend like it never happened.
1) 4.5-4.6 guys aren't that slow. My CBs are playing with less speed than my DEs, LBs, FS, SS, RB and even a couple of my DTs are awefully close to the same speed.
2) You show me one corner that ran a 4.7 in the NFL, just one.
3) Yes, a 4.5 guy can cover a 4.3 guy with proper technique and shut him down. I'm not saying Cbs need 130 speed to cover 130 speed WR. Not once I have I said this, in fact I have said just the opposite over and over and over and over and over but you guys just paint the picture that I want a foot race because it is the only way you guys can make an argument.
As for the examples. There are a handful of guys on GLB that can run consistently faster than a CB and you have to dig through thousands of WRs and hundreds of plays just to find one or two links. I'm not saying it should happen every play but it should happen more than once in every 25k plays.
Bukowski
offline
offline
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Bukowski
Because there are other things responsible for that, other than Speed. People keep saying that, but you don't believe it.
No, no, no. Not "people," just you. The vast majority of people are saying that you're wrong, and that CBs can get burned simply by a deficiency in speed. You're a whiner who ignores reality and is absolutely unwilling to ever change your mind or admit that you're wrong about anything, regardless of how much evidence is piled up against you.
You've never accomplished anything in this game - nothing.
You think because you played high school football, or whatever the fuck, that you know everything there is to know about GLB.
Let me tell you something - you don't know shit. You're in here ranting and raving about things that you have no earthly idea about. It's fucking hilarious.
Originally posted by Bukowski
Because there are other things responsible for that, other than Speed. People keep saying that, but you don't believe it.
No, no, no. Not "people," just you. The vast majority of people are saying that you're wrong, and that CBs can get burned simply by a deficiency in speed. You're a whiner who ignores reality and is absolutely unwilling to ever change your mind or admit that you're wrong about anything, regardless of how much evidence is piled up against you.
You've never accomplished anything in this game - nothing.
You think because you played high school football, or whatever the fuck, that you know everything there is to know about GLB.
Let me tell you something - you don't know shit. You're in here ranting and raving about things that you have no earthly idea about. It's fucking hilarious.
PierreThomas
offline
offline
Originally posted by joeflex73
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by GroovyCheetah
but don't CBs have to also focus on tackling
If they are arguing for speed WR's to get open, they shouldn't spend a single SP on anything besides speed.
Not true at all. If speed=speed and nothing else and not even considering shutdown coverage on a CB then 130 speed WR (about the max on GLB with other decent attributes) and a CB with 110 speed (very easily obtained) the WR would be 11.8% faster. That means for every 50 yards the WR runs in a dead streak he would outrun the CB by 5 yards. A 5 yard cushion could eliminate a WR running by him at all.
I'm not even saying speed should just be speed. I don't care if it is tied to agility or even if agility is made more important but to put a governor on WRs is just simply ludicrous. Tying speed to all other attributes is just as ludicrous. No matter what there are diminishing returns since each cap it costs more and more to increase speed. You could have a 150 speed WR (wont happen) and a well built FS can keep up with him in zone coverage.
DB, I know you are smarter than that. Right now if you just turned speed on then yes, there would be huge problems. If Bort fixes this and gives everyone fair warning while fixing cushions and jumping routes for Cbs then we would have a much more realistic sim that brings player builds back into play for CBs and WRs.
11.8% is arbitrary. Let's say that even 1 SPD (regardless of AGI) reduces a players 40 time by .02. If a player starts at 10 SPD running a 6.00 flat, at 130 SPD we're talking a ridiculous 3.5 40. That corner at 110 SPD is running a 3.9. The CB has cushion, and even if AGI is even, with a small cushion, how long would it take that WR to overtake that CB? 20 yards? 40 yards? QB's don't even hold the ball long enough for that to matter.
There are reasons why CB's will shutdown WR's even if the WR has a flat SPD advantage. CB's and WR's builds shouldn't look similar imo. WR's are bigger on straight line speed IRL, and CB's the 1st thing you hear is "Asomugha has great hips" and how he moves. Does anyone really think Nnamdi, Champ, Clements, Samuel or Trufant (examples) are anywhere near as fast as Joey Galloway (4.19 40 even at 35), Randy Moss, Ted Ginn, or Steve Smith? flames still has you guys brainwashed.
No shit, I've been saying that for 20 pages.
BTW, your WR has 0 catches this season.
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by GroovyCheetah
but don't CBs have to also focus on tackling
If they are arguing for speed WR's to get open, they shouldn't spend a single SP on anything besides speed.
Not true at all. If speed=speed and nothing else and not even considering shutdown coverage on a CB then 130 speed WR (about the max on GLB with other decent attributes) and a CB with 110 speed (very easily obtained) the WR would be 11.8% faster. That means for every 50 yards the WR runs in a dead streak he would outrun the CB by 5 yards. A 5 yard cushion could eliminate a WR running by him at all.
I'm not even saying speed should just be speed. I don't care if it is tied to agility or even if agility is made more important but to put a governor on WRs is just simply ludicrous. Tying speed to all other attributes is just as ludicrous. No matter what there are diminishing returns since each cap it costs more and more to increase speed. You could have a 150 speed WR (wont happen) and a well built FS can keep up with him in zone coverage.
DB, I know you are smarter than that. Right now if you just turned speed on then yes, there would be huge problems. If Bort fixes this and gives everyone fair warning while fixing cushions and jumping routes for Cbs then we would have a much more realistic sim that brings player builds back into play for CBs and WRs.
11.8% is arbitrary. Let's say that even 1 SPD (regardless of AGI) reduces a players 40 time by .02. If a player starts at 10 SPD running a 6.00 flat, at 130 SPD we're talking a ridiculous 3.5 40. That corner at 110 SPD is running a 3.9. The CB has cushion, and even if AGI is even, with a small cushion, how long would it take that WR to overtake that CB? 20 yards? 40 yards? QB's don't even hold the ball long enough for that to matter.
There are reasons why CB's will shutdown WR's even if the WR has a flat SPD advantage. CB's and WR's builds shouldn't look similar imo. WR's are bigger on straight line speed IRL, and CB's the 1st thing you hear is "Asomugha has great hips" and how he moves. Does anyone really think Nnamdi, Champ, Clements, Samuel or Trufant (examples) are anywhere near as fast as Joey Galloway (4.19 40 even at 35), Randy Moss, Ted Ginn, or Steve Smith? flames still has you guys brainwashed.
No shit, I've been saying that for 20 pages.
BTW, your WR has 0 catches this season.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























