User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Riggs_Inator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tim Harper
Originally posted by Bort

Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too

I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?

The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?

I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."

I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.


Tackling = should be at 50 regardless of the back your stopping. That is a huge part of the percentage in making the play.
Strength = Higher the strength, higher the chance of stopping HB in their tracks or slowing down of extra yardage via dive for yards or powerthrough.
SA's = Should be modifiers of the above attributes
Speed = 70+ should give enough players velocity to slow them down


Velocity would have to be added in with weight and strength. Otherwise he would just bounce off the HB.

Strength = better chance of getting a sure wrap up tackle (when on wrap up) or just simply holding onto the HB and slowing him down (being dragged) if his tackling isn't high enough.




Example: CB1: 80 speed, 48 tackling, 20 strength. CB2: 80 Speed 25 tackling, 48 strength. CB3: 90 speed 25 tackling 25 strength.

Power HB: Runs and meets CB1 - He either: A) Wraps up on the HB but does not have enough strength to keep run through a stiff arm. Or gets trucked by power through. Or gets low enough to wrap up around the ankles and the HB fails to get his feet free and falls forward for additional yards.

Meets CB2: Catches the HB from behind, but cannot wrap up and hangs off of the back of the HB as the HB carries him for some more yards. Or he gets stiff armed but is able to semi power through it and hold onto the HB's arm/shoulder and take him down after a few yards/push out of bounds. Puts a big enough hit on the HB's legs to up end him and the HB tumbles for a yard.

Meets CB3: Runs at the hb blindly in a sprint. The HB stiff arms him and puts him to the ground. - The HB lowers his shoulder and slows down for a second or two to regain his balance after deflecting the speedy little gnat. - Dives at the HB's feet and is able to trip him up by grabbing onto a shoe. The HB stumbles for a few extra yards.


Of course this is very cut and dry, there should be a lot more factors and outcomes. But these are some things you see in pro football.


So in summation: Strength: Helps you hold onto the guy, and helps keep from moving forward. Tackling: Helps with technique, being able to wrap up and knowing how to bring the guy down.

One won't work very well without the other, but combined they work fairly consistently.
 
IIAMLEGEND
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jearly
Originally posted by WestbrookFTW

Originally posted by jearly


of course for figuring these things out, we could also treat 48 as the middle of a bell curve, with the 3:1 being within 1 standard deviation, and the 4:1 within 2 standard deviations.

I'm stretching statistices here, but 68 tackling (with appropriate str) should make tackles 97.5% of the time


You can't put a figure like that. Tackling requires Vision, Technique (Tackling), Agility and Strength.


agreed, I was just using a simplified explanation...


STAMINA
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Alpha Q
I'd say to consistently make tackles against the best power backs in this game, you'd need the following amount of tackling (strength being the independent variable)

10 str---100 tkl
20 str---95 tkl
30 str---85 tkl
40 str---75 tkl
50 str---60 tkl
60 str---45 tkl
70 str---35 tkl
80 str---25 tkl
90 str---15 tkl
100 str--10 tkl

This would be much easier to see in graph form...



100 strength plus 10 tackle would work? tell that to adam archuleta next time he serves you are dennys.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by IIAMLEGEND
Originally posted by jearly

Originally posted by WestbrookFTW


Originally posted by jearly



of course for figuring these things out, we could also treat 48 as the middle of a bell curve, with the 3:1 being within 1 standard deviation, and the 4:1 within 2 standard deviations.

I'm stretching statistices here, but 68 tackling (with appropriate str) should make tackles 97.5% of the time


You can't put a figure like that. Tackling requires Vision, Technique (Tackling), Agility and Strength.


agreed, I was just using a simplified explanation...


STAMINA



confidence.
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Alpha Q
I'd say to consistently make tackles against the best power backs in this game, you'd need the following amount of tackling (strength being the independent variable)

10 str---100 tkl
20 str---95 tkl
30 str---85 tkl
40 str---75 tkl
50 str---60 tkl
60 str---45 tkl
70 str---35 tkl
80 str---25 tkl
90 str---15 tkl
100 str--10 tkl

This would be much easier to see in graph form...


That averages about 55 tackling 55 strength. That wouldn't seem to hold a candle to Bort's admittedly unrealistic 100 strength 70 carrying monster.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
I think a tackle high, tackle low is a good idea, but It needs to be able to be selected vs. each HB the team has as your player is smart enough to figure out which HB is in the game.

It should also have a vision based roll to deciding the correct way to tackle. Vison is about the only stat I can think of that can be an intelligence attribute this game really needs. The more "vision" the higher % chance your player has of picking the right way to tackle each HB.


Should be a slider for tackle high, tackle low.
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kira
Originally posted by Alpha Q

I'd say to consistently make tackles against the best power backs in this game, you'd need the following amount of tackling (strength being the independent variable)

10 str---100 tkl
20 str---95 tkl
30 str---85 tkl
40 str---75 tkl
50 str---60 tkl
60 str---45 tkl
70 str---35 tkl
80 str---25 tkl
90 str---15 tkl
100 str--10 tkl

This would be much easier to see in graph form...


That averages about 55 tackling 55 strength. That wouldn't seem to hold a candle to Bort's admittedly unrealistic 100 strength 70 carrying monster.


I have never seen a HB with 70 carry in GLB ever.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Get rid of the soft caps on football skills, and make them more important.


I also think that this is a good idea. Any disputing?
 
Alpha Q
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rusty Trombone
Originally posted by Alpha Q

I'd say to consistently make tackles against the best power backs in this game, you'd need the following amount of tackling (strength being the independent variable)

10 str---100 tkl
20 str---95 tkl
30 str---85 tkl
40 str---75 tkl
50 str---60 tkl
60 str---45 tkl
70 str---35 tkl
80 str---25 tkl
90 str---15 tkl
100 str--10 tkl

This would be much easier to see in graph form...



100 strength plus 10 tackle would work? tell that to adam archuleta next time he serves you are dennys.


my thinking is, if they have the same strength, wouldn't they just run into each other and the defender would be able to stop him? then any amount of tackling would suffice just to get the HB to the ground
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
Originally posted by Deathblade

Get rid of the soft caps on football skills, and make them more important.


I like that, or make the 2;1 start at 61, not 48.

But then again throwing is a Football skill that needs to stay at the current caps place, where tackling, catching and such should move the cap


Make 100 throwing important to throw 100% good passes then. Not that difficult.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Bort needs to add a "strafe" state that slows movement but greatly increases reaction time or something similar for zone coverage and LB's right after the snap.
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by Deathblade

Get rid of the soft caps on football skills, and make them more important.


I also think that this is a good idea. Any disputing?


not blocking
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
Originally posted by Kira

Originally posted by Alpha Q


I'd say to consistently make tackles against the best power backs in this game, you'd need the following amount of tackling (strength being the independent variable)

10 str---100 tkl
20 str---95 tkl
30 str---85 tkl
40 str---75 tkl
50 str---60 tkl
60 str---45 tkl
70 str---35 tkl
80 str---25 tkl
90 str---15 tkl
100 str--10 tkl

This would be much easier to see in graph form...


That averages about 55 tackling 55 strength. That wouldn't seem to hold a candle to Bort's admittedly unrealistic 100 strength 70 carrying monster.


I have never seen a HB with 70 carry in GLB ever.


I think that's because originally people thought it was just for not fumbling.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Riggs_Inator


Example: CB1: 80 speed, 48 tackling, 20 strength. CB2: 80 Speed 25 tackling, 48 strength. CB3: 90 speed 25 tackling 25 strength.

Power HB: Runs and meets CB1 - He either: A) Wraps up on the HB but does not have enough strength to keep run through a stiff arm. Or gets trucked by power through. Or gets low enough to wrap up around the ankles and the HB fails to get his feet free and falls forward for additional yards.

Meets CB2: Catches the HB from behind, but cannot wrap up and hangs off of the back of the HB as the HB carries him for some more yards. Or he gets stiff armed but is able to semi power through it and hold onto the HB's arm/shoulder and take him down after a few yards/push out of bounds. Puts a big enough hit on the HB's legs to up end him and the HB tumbles for a yard.

Meets CB3: Runs at the hb blindly in a sprint. The HB stiff arms him and puts him to the ground. - The HB lowers his shoulder and slows down for a second or two to regain his balance after deflecting the speedy little gnat. - Dives at the HB's feet and is able to trip him up by grabbing onto a shoe. The HB stumbles for a few extra yards.


.


You're obviously forgetting CB4, who does this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XqmdI3tVuMA

 
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
Originally posted by Kira

Originally posted by Alpha Q


I'd say to consistently make tackles against the best power backs in this game, you'd need the following amount of tackling (strength being the independent variable)

10 str---100 tkl
20 str---95 tkl
30 str---85 tkl
40 str---75 tkl
50 str---60 tkl
60 str---45 tkl
70 str---35 tkl
80 str---25 tkl
90 str---15 tkl
100 str--10 tkl

This would be much easier to see in graph form...


That averages about 55 tackling 55 strength. That wouldn't seem to hold a candle to Bort's admittedly unrealistic 100 strength 70 carrying monster.


I have never seen a HB with 70 carry in GLB ever.


jeezus, dont be an idiot. obviously you havent seen every powerback in the league. i'd love to hear what successful powerbacks in the league you've seen stats of.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.