Man, the DE/OT interaction is so messed up. What's it simulating? Not football...
SWVAHoo
offline
offline
Shhh, Jarl. People don't take kindly around here to things such as the laws of physics, or sound football fundamentals.
Jarl
offline
offline
Originally posted by cdcollins
Shhh, Jarl. People don't take kindly around here to things such as the laws of physics, or sound football fundamentals.
People may not
But I hope some constructive posts will make Bort, and hopefully others, that read them think about it just a little bit 
Shhh, Jarl. People don't take kindly around here to things such as the laws of physics, or sound football fundamentals.
People may not
But I hope some constructive posts will make Bort, and hopefully others, that read them think about it just a little bit 
imking27
offline
offline
true but when have you seen a player that is top in league get four sacks and the top ot get 80 pancakes in 3 or 4 games which one have you seen.
SteelersInsider
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jarl
There is no speed involved from the OT, there is some agility, but most of it is basic movement and OT technique.
Most of what you said makes sense, but not the bolded part.
If you expect the OT to move at all, it has to be SPEED that gets him there. If you want him to "turn" his hips around in a circle really fast while not moving from "point A" at all, then you would be right about the agility.
Agility does not move the OT at all. It doesn't "move the pylon" if you want to look at it that way. The more speed, the further that pylon for the DE to get around. Agility of 4,000 doesn't move that pylon even an inch.
There is no speed involved from the OT, there is some agility, but most of it is basic movement and OT technique.
Most of what you said makes sense, but not the bolded part.
If you expect the OT to move at all, it has to be SPEED that gets him there. If you want him to "turn" his hips around in a circle really fast while not moving from "point A" at all, then you would be right about the agility.
Agility does not move the OT at all. It doesn't "move the pylon" if you want to look at it that way. The more speed, the further that pylon for the DE to get around. Agility of 4,000 doesn't move that pylon even an inch.
Last edited Nov 16, 2008 14:37:22
Jarl
offline
offline
That really depends on how you define SPEED, if speed is movement of limbs, then speed is naturally involved alot.
But for me, speed is a definate ability directly translating into "how fast you can run" I can, but really think its wrong, translate it to backpedal for Corners etc etc.
And, thats really also Borts belief on it.
After all, he has already changed it so Speed = Top Speed, while Agility = Acceleration.
Im not saying an OT should get by with 0 speed, my own has 32 speed, and I reckon to get him to around 40-48 sooner or later.
But the notion some have, that a OT need to almost match a DE both in speed and agility is just plain wrong, and as long as the game advocates that, there is a faulty calculation in the simulation.
The fact that I view speed differently than Bort doesnt mean he is wrong, but it does add some extra need for thought to the simulation, and currently, it is bugging the simulation.
Once again, I have no problem with DE´s getting alot of sacks(though I do think its a bit much), hell, Osi Umeniora got 6 against the eagles last year, and that was against an ok LT.
But he didnt get those sacks in 1.4 seconds each.
And thats the problem.
In football, and its no matter how good the other guy is, as long as your players are close to him.
If you put 2 blockers on a guy, and only do quick routes, there is litterally no way he should get a sack.
The truth is though, with the current stats for players, IE Strength, Speed Agility etc etc.
It will be difficult to truely mimic.
Better stats would be.
Strength
-Explosive
-Max
-Endurance
Maybe even.
Leg Strength.
-Explosive
-Max
-Endurance
Upper Torso Strength
-Explosive
-Max
-Endurance
And so on and on.
But that would propably make leveling your player way to complicated.'
So we have to make do with the stats we have, but, Speed has been stated as mainly being, top speed, and a OT does not need 70-80 top speed.
So an OT would need agility, to move quickly and reach his top speed quickly.
But for me, speed is a definate ability directly translating into "how fast you can run" I can, but really think its wrong, translate it to backpedal for Corners etc etc.
And, thats really also Borts belief on it.
After all, he has already changed it so Speed = Top Speed, while Agility = Acceleration.
Im not saying an OT should get by with 0 speed, my own has 32 speed, and I reckon to get him to around 40-48 sooner or later.
But the notion some have, that a OT need to almost match a DE both in speed and agility is just plain wrong, and as long as the game advocates that, there is a faulty calculation in the simulation.
The fact that I view speed differently than Bort doesnt mean he is wrong, but it does add some extra need for thought to the simulation, and currently, it is bugging the simulation.
Once again, I have no problem with DE´s getting alot of sacks(though I do think its a bit much), hell, Osi Umeniora got 6 against the eagles last year, and that was against an ok LT.
But he didnt get those sacks in 1.4 seconds each.
And thats the problem.
In football, and its no matter how good the other guy is, as long as your players are close to him.
If you put 2 blockers on a guy, and only do quick routes, there is litterally no way he should get a sack.
The truth is though, with the current stats for players, IE Strength, Speed Agility etc etc.
It will be difficult to truely mimic.
Better stats would be.
Strength
-Explosive
-Max
-Endurance
Maybe even.
Leg Strength.
-Explosive
-Max
-Endurance
Upper Torso Strength
-Explosive
-Max
-Endurance
And so on and on.
But that would propably make leveling your player way to complicated.'
So we have to make do with the stats we have, but, Speed has been stated as mainly being, top speed, and a OT does not need 70-80 top speed.
So an OT would need agility, to move quickly and reach his top speed quickly.
Last edited Nov 16, 2008 15:34:44
Been working on trying various things the last few days. I agree that the 90 speed guys getting to the QB in 1 second is dumb.
One thing I will probably put in is the "jump the snap" delay based on vision, which means DE's who have no vision will not get off the line immediately every time.
I'm also experimenting with "holding" code, that would allow the lineman to get a handful of jersey and hold they guy back using primarily strength even if he's mostly gotten past him. Not done on that one, though. I'd need to get the penalty in for it as well. Seems reasonable, though, since NFL blockers pretty much hold on every play
.
Also, I'm thinking of improving "Protector" a little maybe to give more of a speed/turning ability boost, and also giving a bonus to side-to-side movement to avoid losing too much speed when blocking.
One thing I will probably put in is the "jump the snap" delay based on vision, which means DE's who have no vision will not get off the line immediately every time.
I'm also experimenting with "holding" code, that would allow the lineman to get a handful of jersey and hold they guy back using primarily strength even if he's mostly gotten past him. Not done on that one, though. I'd need to get the penalty in for it as well. Seems reasonable, though, since NFL blockers pretty much hold on every play
.Also, I'm thinking of improving "Protector" a little maybe to give more of a speed/turning ability boost, and also giving a bonus to side-to-side movement to avoid losing too much speed when blocking.
Great, I though my DEs were bad enough. Now they are going to get held? All because 3% of DEs in this game have 90 speed?? Sweet.
Originally posted by TenTwo
Great, I though my DEs were bad enough. Now they are going to get held? All because 3% of DEs in this game have 90 speed?? Sweet.
If he's got 10 strength, sure. If he's got more, then he'll be able to get away.
Super weak DE's need to have a penalty of some sort them for being weak, just like slow ones don't get the benefits of being fast, etc.
Great, I though my DEs were bad enough. Now they are going to get held? All because 3% of DEs in this game have 90 speed?? Sweet.
If he's got 10 strength, sure. If he's got more, then he'll be able to get away.
Super weak DE's need to have a penalty of some sort them for being weak, just like slow ones don't get the benefits of being fast, etc.
Faux Bear
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by TenTwo
Great, I though my DEs were bad enough. Now they are going to get held? All because 3% of DEs in this game have 90 speed?? Sweet.
If he's got 10 strength, sure. If he's got more, then he'll be able to get away.
Super weak DE's need to have a penalty of some sort them for being weak, just like slow ones don't get the benefits of being fast, etc.
they should be pancaked and demoralized a lot more than it seems they currently are.
Originally posted by TenTwo
Great, I though my DEs were bad enough. Now they are going to get held? All because 3% of DEs in this game have 90 speed?? Sweet.
If he's got 10 strength, sure. If he's got more, then he'll be able to get away.
Super weak DE's need to have a penalty of some sort them for being weak, just like slow ones don't get the benefits of being fast, etc.
they should be pancaked and demoralized a lot more than it seems they currently are.
Warlock
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Been working on trying various things the last few days. I agree that the 90 speed guys getting to the QB in 1 second is dumb.
One thing I will probably put in is the "jump the snap" delay based on vision, which means DE's who have no vision will not get off the line immediately every time.
I'm also experimenting with "holding" code, that would allow the lineman to get a handful of jersey and hold they guy back using primarily strength even if he's mostly gotten past him. Not done on that one, though. I'd need to get the penalty in for it as well. Seems reasonable, though, since NFL blockers pretty much hold on every play
.
Also, I'm thinking of improving "Protector" a little maybe to give more of a speed/turning ability boost, and also giving a bonus to side-to-side movement to avoid losing too much speed when blocking.
Just improve the pathing of the OT and make breaking a block easier...
Such as the length of time being blocked, increases the chance to break the block. Plus you'll have to improve the shed block SA (maybe by making it part strength and part agility).
You could also work on an OT balance code. A good jump reduces the OT's balance. A good moves also reduces the OT's balance. The lower the OTs balance vs the DEs strength/agility, the more chance the DE has of getting past.
Lastly, make the break block chance be affected by strength and agility both. This will solve the "why take strength?" issue.
If those things can happen, it should fix many of the problems.
Been working on trying various things the last few days. I agree that the 90 speed guys getting to the QB in 1 second is dumb.
One thing I will probably put in is the "jump the snap" delay based on vision, which means DE's who have no vision will not get off the line immediately every time.
I'm also experimenting with "holding" code, that would allow the lineman to get a handful of jersey and hold they guy back using primarily strength even if he's mostly gotten past him. Not done on that one, though. I'd need to get the penalty in for it as well. Seems reasonable, though, since NFL blockers pretty much hold on every play
.Also, I'm thinking of improving "Protector" a little maybe to give more of a speed/turning ability boost, and also giving a bonus to side-to-side movement to avoid losing too much speed when blocking.
Just improve the pathing of the OT and make breaking a block easier...
Such as the length of time being blocked, increases the chance to break the block. Plus you'll have to improve the shed block SA (maybe by making it part strength and part agility).
You could also work on an OT balance code. A good jump reduces the OT's balance. A good moves also reduces the OT's balance. The lower the OTs balance vs the DEs strength/agility, the more chance the DE has of getting past.
Lastly, make the break block chance be affected by strength and agility both. This will solve the "why take strength?" issue.
If those things can happen, it should fix many of the problems.
Last edited Nov 16, 2008 16:09:00
oronis
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Been working on trying various things the last few days. I agree that the 90 speed guys getting to the QB in 1 second is dumb.
One thing I will probably put in is the "jump the snap" delay based on vision, which means DE's who have no vision will not get off the line immediately every time.
I'm also experimenting with "holding" code, that would allow the lineman to get a handful of jersey and hold they guy back using primarily strength even if he's mostly gotten past him. Not done on that one, though. I'd need to get the penalty in for it as well. Seems reasonable, though, since NFL blockers pretty much hold on every play
.
Also, I'm thinking of improving "Protector" a little maybe to give more of a speed/turning ability boost, and also giving a bonus to side-to-side movement to avoid losing too much speed when blocking.
I'm all for you improving the game, adding more options for each player, and evolving the game. Please just don't make it so a 20 speed / 40 Agility OT can effectively manhandle an 80 speed / 80 agility DE. The fast DE SHOULD be able to get around the slow OT plenty. At the same time, when the strong OT should be able to destroy that weak DE when he finally gets a hand on him. I thought the game was working fine, there just needed to be more demoralization for those mega-pancakes.
I mean, a 90 str vs 50 str pancake should drain some energy and morale. A 90 str vs 20 str pancake should completely wind and demoralize the guy.
Been working on trying various things the last few days. I agree that the 90 speed guys getting to the QB in 1 second is dumb.
One thing I will probably put in is the "jump the snap" delay based on vision, which means DE's who have no vision will not get off the line immediately every time.
I'm also experimenting with "holding" code, that would allow the lineman to get a handful of jersey and hold they guy back using primarily strength even if he's mostly gotten past him. Not done on that one, though. I'd need to get the penalty in for it as well. Seems reasonable, though, since NFL blockers pretty much hold on every play
.Also, I'm thinking of improving "Protector" a little maybe to give more of a speed/turning ability boost, and also giving a bonus to side-to-side movement to avoid losing too much speed when blocking.
I'm all for you improving the game, adding more options for each player, and evolving the game. Please just don't make it so a 20 speed / 40 Agility OT can effectively manhandle an 80 speed / 80 agility DE. The fast DE SHOULD be able to get around the slow OT plenty. At the same time, when the strong OT should be able to destroy that weak DE when he finally gets a hand on him. I thought the game was working fine, there just needed to be more demoralization for those mega-pancakes.
I mean, a 90 str vs 50 str pancake should drain some energy and morale. A 90 str vs 20 str pancake should completely wind and demoralize the guy.
TJ Spikes
offline
offline
Originally posted by Faux Bear
they should be pancaked and demoralized a lot more than it seems they currently are.
yeah that
that's why CBs don't play DE in the NFL
one good shove from a strong OT and they'd be knocked over, or at the very least be moved 5+ yards in the wrong direction.
the easy solution seems to be buff the crap out of the OT's pancake math, or conversely nerf the pancake resistance.
the heart of the issue seems to be that DEs only have to update 2 attributes to be dominant -- Speed and Agility. That's how they can get up into the 90s. Something needs to be done so that they have to update as many attributes as their opposition.
Strength seems to be an obvious choice, maybe Vision as suggested above.
they should be pancaked and demoralized a lot more than it seems they currently are.
yeah that
that's why CBs don't play DE in the NFL
one good shove from a strong OT and they'd be knocked over, or at the very least be moved 5+ yards in the wrong direction.
the easy solution seems to be buff the crap out of the OT's pancake math, or conversely nerf the pancake resistance.
the heart of the issue seems to be that DEs only have to update 2 attributes to be dominant -- Speed and Agility. That's how they can get up into the 90s. Something needs to be done so that they have to update as many attributes as their opposition.
Strength seems to be an obvious choice, maybe Vision as suggested above.
Last edited Nov 16, 2008 16:45:29
SAGA45
offline
offline
Bort, when you get a sec, I'd like to get your thoughts on the following:
Originally posted by SAGA45
Originally posted by SAGA45
Here's a couple plays of my OT(LvL 33 at the time of these replays) getting beat by a LvL 36 speed DE:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419932
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419862
Here are the rest of the pass plays in that same game where my OT faced the same DE:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419709
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419744
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419802
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419809
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419879
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419978
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419982
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419992
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420022
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420025
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420040
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420048
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420072
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420095
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420101
As you can see, outside of the 1 play where the DE just blew by my OT for the sack, none were plays where the two didn't engage.
Also, my OT did a solid job of keeping the DE at bay when facing him 1-on-1 with no help from a RB.
You always see my OT getting back, set quickly, and then engage the DE - keeping him at bay except for the two sacks. But even on one of those the DE had to work for it by shedding my OT's block first.
Again, this was against a speed DE who was 3 levels higher. Some good, realistic battles to. Probably the result of a couple of good builds going at it.
If possible, I'd like to get Bort's thoughts on what's likely happening under the hood on these replays as far as the math and interaction between my OT and the DE. I doubt Bort responds but I'm just curious, especially since that DE was one of the 100+ sack guys in season 5 that prompted the code adjustments.
Originally posted by SAGA45
Originally posted by SAGA45
Here's a couple plays of my OT(LvL 33 at the time of these replays) getting beat by a LvL 36 speed DE:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419932
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419862
Here are the rest of the pass plays in that same game where my OT faced the same DE:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419709
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419744
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419802
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419809
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419879
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419978
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419982
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=419992
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420022
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420025
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420040
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420048
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420072
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420095
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=263001&pbp_id=420101
As you can see, outside of the 1 play where the DE just blew by my OT for the sack, none were plays where the two didn't engage.
Also, my OT did a solid job of keeping the DE at bay when facing him 1-on-1 with no help from a RB.
You always see my OT getting back, set quickly, and then engage the DE - keeping him at bay except for the two sacks. But even on one of those the DE had to work for it by shedding my OT's block first.
Again, this was against a speed DE who was 3 levels higher. Some good, realistic battles to. Probably the result of a couple of good builds going at it.
If possible, I'd like to get Bort's thoughts on what's likely happening under the hood on these replays as far as the math and interaction between my OT and the DE. I doubt Bort responds but I'm just curious, especially since that DE was one of the 100+ sack guys in season 5 that prompted the code adjustments.
Last edited Nov 16, 2008 16:51:22
oronis
offline
offline
I figured out what pisses me off about all the DE whiners and their arguements. They are hypocrites. You guys want to be great OTs with just strength and blocking. While you don't want the DE to be successful with just speed and agility. Fine, I'm not going to argue that other stats like Strength, Vision, and Confidence should factor in to a DE's performance. BUT at the same time, an OT's performance should also take more than just Strength and Blocking to be effective. Stats like Agility, Vision, Speed and Confidence should factor in to their performance as well.
They are also hypocrites because they want an OT to be able to stop a DE 100%. Well, the way GLB works right now, it's hard for a DE to get any action other than sacks. So if you want to nerf their pass-rushing abilities, improve their run-stopping abilities.
They are also hypocrites because they want an OT to be able to stop a DE 100%. Well, the way GLB works right now, it's hard for a DE to get any action other than sacks. So if you want to nerf their pass-rushing abilities, improve their run-stopping abilities.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.




























