So how is this going to work for week 16 match ups?
S.K. Devil
offline
offline
nevertheless - we are dealing with this timeline
1. We are behind you by 0.4 points in the rankings
2. We beat you by a score of 22-3
3. We are behind you by 2.4 points in the new rankings
You GAINED POINTS on us after we beat you.
How does that make sense?
1. We are behind you by 0.4 points in the rankings
2. We beat you by a score of 22-3
3. We are behind you by 2.4 points in the new rankings
You GAINED POINTS on us after we beat you.
How does that make sense?
Vanilla Thunder
offline
offline
Originally posted by S.K. Devil
nevertheless - we are dealing with this timeline
1. We are behind you by 0.4 points in the rankings
2. We beat you by a score of 22-3
3. We are behind you by 2.4 points in the new rankings
You GAINED POINTS on us after we beat you.
How does that make sense?
I quoted your whole post but let me go issue by issue:
Originally posted by
1. We are behind you by 0.4 points in the rankings
Overall rankings yes, roster rankings, no. BJJ has talked of changing this next year, but that's the system he's using. Upsets are based off of roster ranks, which as of gametime, you had us beat up and down in.
Originally posted by
2. We beat you by a score of 22-3
Yes you did, good game Bills.
Originally posted by
3. We are behind you by 2.4 points in the new rankings
You boosted before our game, bringing you further ahead of us, we have only started boosted recently (after our game). The game with the Bills was lopsided because you had boosted before we had (not the whole team obviously, but many). That's a receipe for a beating there, and you delievered, but even ignoring BJJ's rankings and speaking purely from my own standpoint, I'm not sure what you learned from that game other then "boosting is good".
nevertheless - we are dealing with this timeline
1. We are behind you by 0.4 points in the rankings
2. We beat you by a score of 22-3
3. We are behind you by 2.4 points in the new rankings
You GAINED POINTS on us after we beat you.
How does that make sense?
I quoted your whole post but let me go issue by issue:
Originally posted by
1. We are behind you by 0.4 points in the rankings
Overall rankings yes, roster rankings, no. BJJ has talked of changing this next year, but that's the system he's using. Upsets are based off of roster ranks, which as of gametime, you had us beat up and down in.
Originally posted by
2. We beat you by a score of 22-3
Yes you did, good game Bills.
Originally posted by
3. We are behind you by 2.4 points in the new rankings
You boosted before our game, bringing you further ahead of us, we have only started boosted recently (after our game). The game with the Bills was lopsided because you had boosted before we had (not the whole team obviously, but many). That's a receipe for a beating there, and you delievered, but even ignoring BJJ's rankings and speaking purely from my own standpoint, I'm not sure what you learned from that game other then "boosting is good".
dlk9s
offline
offline
In the end, it doesn't matter. The rankings are just for fun and BJJ readily admits that they are imperfect. It's something he did for kicks and will probably goof with the methodology for next season.
KingDan23
offline
offline
Originally posted by dlk9s
In the end, it doesn't matter. The rankings are just for fun and BJJ readily admits that they are imperfect. It's something he did for kicks and will probably goof with the methodology for next season.
Agreed. People should just use these rankings as a fun tool, because at the end of the day the only thing worth looking at are the league tables.
In the end, it doesn't matter. The rankings are just for fun and BJJ readily admits that they are imperfect. It's something he did for kicks and will probably goof with the methodology for next season.
Agreed. People should just use these rankings as a fun tool, because at the end of the day the only thing worth looking at are the league tables.
BobJoeJim
offline
offline
Originally posted by MiniHusk
Originally posted by BobJoeJim
OFFICIAL RANKINGS 5/21
5. Arctic Bay Yetis (11-1, 87.9 [89.8 - 1.9])
Meaning that Arctic Bay over the Jeanhorns and Hudson over the Ambassadors counted as upsets. Therefore...
OFFICIAL RANKINGS 5/23
5. Arctic Bay Yetis (12-1, 89.3 [91.2 - 1.9])
shouldn't our -1.9 change due to our upset?
Your upset was the first one I've encountered where the difference in roster ratings was 1 or less. When I went to calculate how much the upset was worth, I realized that since the log(1)=0, the formula I've been using for upset adjustments doesn't actually work when the difference is that small. This is yet another item for me to add to my list of tweaks for next season, lol...
Originally posted by panther17
So how is this going to work for week 16 match ups?
Yeah... 'bout that... shhhhhhh...
Actually though, I think I'll go ahead and put all 32 teams together, and calculate roster ratings based on the full league, and use those roster ratings to determine upsets.
Originally posted by BobJoeJim
OFFICIAL RANKINGS 5/21
5. Arctic Bay Yetis (11-1, 87.9 [89.8 - 1.9])
Meaning that Arctic Bay over the Jeanhorns and Hudson over the Ambassadors counted as upsets. Therefore...
OFFICIAL RANKINGS 5/23
5. Arctic Bay Yetis (12-1, 89.3 [91.2 - 1.9])
shouldn't our -1.9 change due to our upset?
Your upset was the first one I've encountered where the difference in roster ratings was 1 or less. When I went to calculate how much the upset was worth, I realized that since the log(1)=0, the formula I've been using for upset adjustments doesn't actually work when the difference is that small. This is yet another item for me to add to my list of tweaks for next season, lol...
Originally posted by panther17
So how is this going to work for week 16 match ups?
Yeah... 'bout that... shhhhhhh...
Actually though, I think I'll go ahead and put all 32 teams together, and calculate roster ratings based on the full league, and use those roster ratings to determine upsets.
mcsuede
offline
offline
Roster rating is pretty much a useless way to do things as it calculates ratings in ways that aren't realistic to the effectiveness of that player.
pudley4
offline
offline
Originally posted by mcsuede
Roster rating is pretty much a useless way to do things as it calculates ratings in ways that aren't realistic to the effectiveness of that player.
Well then it's a good thing no one here uses that :|
Roster rating is pretty much a useless way to do things as it calculates ratings in ways that aren't realistic to the effectiveness of that player.
Well then it's a good thing no one here uses that :|
BobJoeJim
offline
offline
Originally posted by mcsuede
Roster rating is pretty much a useless way to do things as it calculates ratings in ways that aren't realistic to the effectiveness of that player.
"Roster rating" in the sense of how I'm measuring it is not the same thing as what you see on the matchup screen, which is what it sounds like you're talking about. Just FYI.
Roster rating is pretty much a useless way to do things as it calculates ratings in ways that aren't realistic to the effectiveness of that player.
"Roster rating" in the sense of how I'm measuring it is not the same thing as what you see on the matchup screen, which is what it sounds like you're talking about. Just FYI.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























