User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Recent Upgrades(discussion)
Page:
 
coachtabales
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aceinthehouse
Yes...It was a lottery

Not a "endorsement to your specified player" pick one?

Get over it people...Maybe you can get an endorsement in season 9

Great idea and great job Bort


The endorsement lottery is a terrible idea. An endorsement by definition is an approval on your part to use your name towards the usage of a service or consumption of a product. Companies don't just hand those out randomly, you actually have to be someone that the general public can relate to. And before any of you decide to get retarded, yes, I'm aware that this is just a game. But at least call it something different, or do it right.

Endorsements should be handed out by how popular a player is (btw, none of my players would qualify). This also would determine what kind of endorsement you got, tied in directly to the amount of money that you got, and whether or not it would pay in regular intervals.

Instead a very, very small group of people was selected from entire leagues randomly and they got a perk that they probably didn't even deserve? That makes no sense. It's not an endorsement lottery, it's just a lottery. Call it what it is.
Last edited Feb 26, 2009 11:13:10
 
shadow67
offline
Link
 
The idea in principal may have had some merrit, but the way it worked out was an absolute hot mess. Slow builders sitting on teams and never playing a down got endorsements. I have yet to hear the first story about someone deserving getting one. This is just a mess.

At this point, the idea needs to be scrapped and reworked. Totally thrown away in it's entirety and start over. Not only should the items be removed, but the cash bonus as well. It would be better to have agents GMs and owners vote than the way this worked out, and no, that would not work either.

Scrap it and try anew or get rid of it all together.
 
jaxinthebox
offline
Link
 
Would it be possible to base the lottery on the leader boards in each league and thereafter base the endorsement likelihood on the amount of fame? It wouldn't work very well for positions like FB and TE and DT, but something could be done to categorize those positions as well.
 
lilcokeman
online
Link
 
Not really seeing what's happening here!

A kicker in my league was close to the top middle tier, and received an endorsement. My Kicker led the league, and took home the player trophy.

Why would someone not want to endorse my Kicker.

Now I like the idea, Like it was said, it helps some players yes, However, how can we reward the ones just due?

My self, I would also base it upon the top threats of the game. To me that is like a MVP of the game! Why do we not want to have these players endorsed.

MVP of the games, normally get something, even in College. Weather is be in scholarship funds or whatever. Who whas the Ohio RB that let it slip, Marice XXXX? Anyway.

I truly believe that this is Borts game. We are here to play his game because we like it, if we don't, We can make our own decisions of what to. Me I just want play and have fun. If we are to do things like endorsements, Get the real players that deserve it! MVP's of the leagues, The ones that win Player awards.

Sorry, Just my opinion.
Last edited Feb 26, 2009 12:31:26
 
shadow67
offline
Link
 
1: It's a problem that three or four top teams move up every season. It is unlikely that recipients will even be in the league in question.

2: It's a problem that fame is such an abstract thing that low level players get more warming the bench on a highlevel team than normal level players do busting out 82 plays on a team that comes in third.

3: In cases where the lottery has seemed to favor better players, they have all been on the same team, creating an equal problem on the opposite end of the spectrum.

Total = FAIL

First of, I think fame is broken. You should get points for playing not slow building. I'm tired of every single thing that happens in this game having exploits figured out before people even know what the change actually does. Instead of fixing problems, this game is just creating more. Not a good sign.

I don't say things like this lightly, but this is getting to be enough to make me hang up my cleats. I had every intent to purchase flex this afternonn, but decided to put it on the back burner even though I had promised some teams some boosts etc. I guess this straw is really weighing hard on this poor camels back. I know this isn't the end of the world, and just a few skill points and maybe half a mil in the bank for these players, but big picture is the players who play right and want to have fun and make this as close to the real game as possible, have just lost another battle to the WoW/Madden club who just want to find ways to exploit any and every system put in place.
 
Yakoska
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shadow67
I know this isn't the end of the world, and just a few skill points and maybe half a mil in the bank for these players, but big picture is the players who play right and want to have fun and make this as close to the real game as possible, have just lost another battle to the WoW/Madden club who just want to find ways to exploit any and every system put in place.


Especially second these sentiments.
 
coachtabales
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shadow67
...I guess this straw is really weighing hard on this poor camels back. I know this isn't the end of the world, and just a few skill points and maybe half a mil in the bank for these players, but big picture is the players who play right and want to have fun and make this as close to the real game as possible, have just lost another battle to the WoW/Madden club who just want to find ways to exploit any and every system put in place.


I agree with almost all of this. The problem is (as if there was only 1) that no matter what Bort does, he's never going to please the masses. The number of problems will continue to mount until it reaches the point of no return. There really is an easy way to fix it; no more updates until everything on the list gets polished up. But then you run the risk of exploiters not coming back. Now we are talking about the bottom line ($). It's a catch 22 for Bort no matter how you look at it because he won't be willing to make the sacrifice, or the exploiters won't show some degree of common sense and patience, or both.

However, when the lottery allows things like this to happen:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/home.pl?user_id=38439

... then what you have is a clear, giant red flag that something has seriously gone wrong. This guy hasn't logged on in weeks. His player is not even on a team. His team has gone completely CPU, and he gets a nice "endorsement". Are you kidding me? Is anyone paying attention to this nonsense?
 
slackermtg
offline
Link
 
Not to mention a league #1 receiving TD's and #1 receiving yards doesn't get an endorsement... kinda useless...
 
shadow67
offline
Link
 
And to bolster what you said, a good percentage of the cheaters, and I am hesitant to call them that, there are no rules AGAINST what they do, spend boatloads of cash. Some have three full teams worth of players, own a team and a casual or pee wee team, and boost regularly. I can't see Bort tryong to alienate them.

I would hope that the middle 80% or so are people who spend and average amount of money, some more, but comprehend the spirit of the game. The fact that the recent changes seem to cater to the other set is discouraging.
 
salsendardo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aceinthehouse
Yes...It was a lottery

Not a "endorsement to your specified player" pick one?

Get over it people...Maybe you can get an endorsement in season 9

Great idea and great job Bort


says the guy who got an endorsement for his level 12 kicker
 
backell
offline
Link
 
It seems it's discussed to the death already, but the endorsements are whacked.If we're trying to think of this "real world" there's two things to keep in mind.

FIRST you endorse players because of name recognition in the real world and that comes from performing on the field.
SECOND (and this is the part that should be obvious but I think is being largely missed) is that most endorsements are LOCAL

I think there is a VERY easy solution to this. Have the OWNERS or TEAMS determine one or two endorsements per TEAM.
Then BASED ON HOW THEY FINISHED the player being endorse gets a certain amount of money AND "Endorsement Points."
The endorsement points are assigned to the special gear designed by the player receiving the endorsement. Also, more EP can be given out at HIGHER LEVELS

This solves SEVERAL problems.

1 EVERY TEAM gets at least ONE endorsement deal so every player gets to compete for one.
2 PLAYING will be the determining factor, not random lottery.
3. If a team gets promoted it won't matter, because the gear itself isn't tied to the league, it's tied to the team.
4. OWNERS/PLAYERS get to determine who gets it.

I'm just saying it might help to take a completely different look at this. I don't post on here a lot and when I do the posts tend to disappear pretty quick but I hope this one generates some discussion. I like the idea of endorsements but I think a fresh way of looking at them would really help with the controversy.
 
rocomo
offline
Link
 
I don't like the Lottery but I think it does make sense in that some of the BEST players have exploited the system to get their player the best stats. In a perfect world the best performances at each position in each league would get an endorsement. But then the RICH would just keep getting RICHER. This way it allows for the occasional outsider to flourish!
 
shadow67
offline
Link
 
Except when this actually rewardeds cheaters more.

The fame exploit made this whole process an absolute joke.
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by backell
It seems it's discussed to the death already, but the endorsements are whacked.If we're trying to think of this "real world" there's two things to keep in mind.

FIRST you endorse players because of name recognition in the real world and that comes from performing on the field.
SECOND (and this is the part that should be obvious but I think is being largely missed) is that most endorsements are LOCAL

I think there is a VERY easy solution to this. Have the OWNERS or TEAMS determine one or two endorsements per TEAM.
Then BASED ON HOW THEY FINISHED the player being endorse gets a certain amount of money AND "Endorsement Points."
The endorsement points are assigned to the special gear designed by the player receiving the endorsement. Also, more EP can be given out at HIGHER LEVELS

This solves SEVERAL problems.

1 EVERY TEAM gets at least ONE endorsement deal so every player gets to compete for one.
2 PLAYING will be the determining factor, not random lottery.
3. If a team gets promoted it won't matter, because the gear itself isn't tied to the league, it's tied to the team.
4. OWNERS/PLAYERS get to determine who gets it.

I'm just saying it might help to take a completely different look at this. I don't post on here a lot and when I do the posts tend to disappear pretty quick but I hope this one generates some discussion. I like the idea of endorsements but I think a fresh way of looking at them would really help with the controversy.


I think this is a decent post. <obligatory/> Endorsements as done are whacked, see previous 341 pages </obligatory>.
However, I think this could be divided into two different things. Let the GMs and Owners vote on an MVP to get some form
of reward. Then do actual endorsements by league leaders, as has been suggested. You could even do it by conference
to get more people involved. Or give 3, one per conference gets a smaller reward and then one per league gets a larger reward.

Also re: fame, I agree it should be by performance, not by games played or even snaps played. One of my players, a SS, was a conference leader in tackles, almost a league leader. Why should he have the same fame as my FB who basically did squat all season? That makes no sense.
 
Dinien
offline
Link
 
There is hope. It was a good idea to begin with, just needs work. Bort, don't give up the ghost.

I think I'd rather see the whole endorsement be based on a "most valuable player" at each position formulae. I'd like to see the formulae look at each position individually, score each player for the things that the position is supposed to do and eliminate the achievements vs gutted or low level teams and players playing in leagues beneath them.

Fame should be the same.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.