User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Revelation

Originally posted by oldskool


Originally posted by Revelation



The game isn't how football truly is right now bud. Some players were smart enough to understand this and adapt their players to what actually worked, not what should work. Because of that, they are now essentially being punished for trying to make the most effective player possible.


Good, serves them right for exploiting. How is it anything else when it's nothing more than "This shouldn't work, but it does, so I'm going to use it"?


Welcome to the world of gaming. You find what works and use it or else you lose.


Welcome to the world of football gaming, build a football player, not an exploit, or lose Same concept I would argue.


Right, now it is closer to that. So punish those who wanted to win even though it didn't follow what they considered logical at the time?
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
It's funny to you apparently, but I remember Bort himself saying that he was randomizing coverage.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Revelation
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by Revelation


Originally posted by oldskool



Originally posted by Revelation




The game isn't how football truly is right now bud. Some players were smart enough to understand this and adapt their players to what actually worked, not what should work. Because of that, they are now essentially being punished for trying to make the most effective player possible.


Good, serves them right for exploiting. How is it anything else when it's nothing more than "This shouldn't work, but it does, so I'm going to use it"?


Welcome to the world of gaming. You find what works and use it or else you lose.


Welcome to the world of football gaming, build a football player, not an exploit, or lose Same concept I would argue.


Right, now it is closer to that. So punish those who wanted to win even though it didn't follow what they considered logical at the time?


Punish those who wanted to win so badly, that they ignored football logic in a football sim to do so? Most definitely.
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 13:46:56
 
Gisty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
It's funny to you apparently, but I remember Bort himself saying that he was randomizing coverage.


Link or it didn't happen

 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
It's funny to you apparently, but I remember Bort himself saying that he was randomizing coverage.


Since he said this,

Please find us the quote that backs this up.
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Revelation

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by Revelation



Originally posted by oldskool




Originally posted by Revelation





The game isn't how football truly is right now bud. Some players were smart enough to understand this and adapt their players to what actually worked, not what should work. Because of that, they are now essentially being punished for trying to make the most effective player possible.


Good, serves them right for exploiting. How is it anything else when it's nothing more than "This shouldn't work, but it does, so I'm going to use it"?


Welcome to the world of gaming. You find what works and use it or else you lose.


Welcome to the world of football gaming, build a football player, not an exploit, or lose Same concept I would argue.


Right, now it is closer to that. So punish those who wanted to win even though it didn't follow what they considered logical at the time?


Punish those who wanted to win so badly, that they ignored football logic in a football sim to do so? Most definitely.


That's bad business. You don't want to punish customers especially if you change the rules and don't allow them to change with it.
 
Gisty
offline
Link
 
Well what about the other customers who get jipped by the people with the "loophole" builds?? Is their money worth less than the whiners?
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 13:50:41
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Revelation
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by Revelation


Originally posted by sjmay



Originally posted by Revelation




Originally posted by oldskool





Originally posted by Revelation






The game isn't how football truly is right now bud. Some players were smart enough to understand this and adapt their players to what actually worked, not what should work. Because of that, they are now essentially being punished for trying to make the most effective player possible.


Good, serves them right for exploiting. How is it anything else when it's nothing more than "This shouldn't work, but it does, so I'm going to use it"?


Welcome to the world of gaming. You find what works and use it or else you lose.


Welcome to the world of football gaming, build a football player, not an exploit, or lose Same concept I would argue.


Right, now it is closer to that. So punish those who wanted to win even though it didn't follow what they considered logical at the time?


Punish those who wanted to win so badly, that they ignored football logic in a football sim to do so? Most definitely.


That's bad business. You don't want to punish customers especially if you change the rules and don't allow them to change with it.


I see, so the people who followed football logic for three years, we should refund their FP for the past three years, and allow one respec for the guys who exploited the game??

That is what you call good business????
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gisty
Well what about the other customers who get jipped by the people with the "loophole" builds?? Is their money worth less than the whiners?


Those who don't find what works get exactly what they deserve, an average player.
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Revelation

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by Revelation



Originally posted by sjmay




Originally posted by Revelation



Originally posted by oldskool






Originally posted by Revelation







The game isn't how football truly is right now bud. Some players were smart enough to understand this and adapt their players to what actually worked, not what should work. Because of that, they are now essentially being punished for trying to make the most effective player possible.


Good, serves them right for exploiting. How is it anything else when it's nothing more than "This shouldn't work, but it does, so I'm going to use it"?


Welcome to the world of gaming. You find what works and use it or else you lose.


Welcome to the world of football gaming, build a football player, not an exploit, or lose Same concept I would argue.


Right, now it is closer to that. So punish those who wanted to win even though it didn't follow what they considered logical at the time?


Punish those who wanted to win so badly, that they ignored football logic in a football sim to do so? Most definitely.


That's bad business. You don't want to punish customers especially if you change the rules and don't allow them to change with it.


I see, so the people who followed football logic for three years, we should refund their FP for the past three years, and allow one respec for the guys who exploited the game??

That is what you call good business????



Didn't say that. Good business is allowing players to change along with the changes in the game. You don't go to a store and buy something just to find out later it's broken. Then upon returning to the store they don't charge you even more money to fix it. They allow you to get one that works, they don't stick it to you because you were buying a broken product.

At the very least this means a limited respec and a possible allowance to swap old custom equipment purchased before the announced changes.
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 13:58:10
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Revelation
Originally posted by Gisty

Well what about the other customers who get jipped by the people with the "loophole" builds?? Is their money worth less than the whiners?


Those who don't find what works get exactly what they deserve, an average player.


And those that exploit the game, get exactly what they deserve when the game catches up to what it should be, a useless build,

Why should they be rewarded, and the others not????
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Revelation
Didn't say that. Good business is allowing players to change along with the changes in the game. You don't go to a store and buy something just to find out later it's broken. Then upon returning to the store they don't charge you even more money to fix it. They allow you to get one that works, they don't stick it to you because you were buying a broken product.

At the very least this means a limited respec and a possible allowance to swap old custom equipment purchased before the announced changes.


If you buy a toaster, find it's broken, and then take it back, you get a new one.

If you buy a toaster, tear it apart, hook it to a car battery to try to use it as a hot plate, then claim it's broken and demand a new one when it goes up in smoke, you don't get a new one because you deliberately misused the one you had that would've worked fine so long as you didn't intentionally misuse it.
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Revelation

Originally posted by Gisty


Well what about the other customers who get jipped by the people with the "loophole" builds?? Is their money worth less than the whiners?


Those who don't find what works get exactly what they deserve, an average player.


And those that exploit the game, get exactly what they deserve when the game catches up to what it should be, a useless build,

Why should they be rewarded, and the others not????


Everyone could get a limited respec and naturally there would be a varying amount of players who benefit from it according to their current knowledge of the game.

It's punishing your dedicated customers who did what it took to win for buying a bad product if a respec is not put in place.
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by Revelation

Didn't say that. Good business is allowing players to change along with the changes in the game. You don't go to a store and buy something just to find out later it's broken. Then upon returning to the store they don't charge you even more money to fix it. They allow you to get one that works, they don't stick it to you because you were buying a broken product.

At the very least this means a limited respec and a possible allowance to swap old custom equipment purchased before the announced changes.


If you buy a toaster, find it's broken, and then take it back, you get a new one.

If you buy a toaster, tear it apart, hook it to a car battery to try to use it as a hot plate, then claim it's broken and demand a new one when it goes up in smoke, you don't get a new one because you deliberately misused the one you had that would've worked fine so long as you didn't intentionally misuse it.


That's not a very good analogy because in the early seasons some bought the toaster to find out that it best works as a hotplate. Then continued buying the toaster for it's hotplate function only to find out later that they're toasters again.
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 14:11:42
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Revelation
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by Revelation
Didn't say that. Good business is allowing players to change along with the changes in the game. You don't go to a store and buy something just to find out later it's broken. Then upon returning to the store they don't charge you even more money to fix it. They allow you to get one that works, they don't stick it to you because you were buying a broken product.

At the very least this means a limited respec and a possible allowance to swap old custom equipment purchased before the announced changes.


If you buy a toaster, find it's broken, and then take it back, you get a new one.

If you buy a toaster, tear it apart, hook it to a car battery to try to use it as a hot plate, then claim it's broken and demand a new one when it goes up in smoke, you don't get a new one because you deliberately misused the one you had that would've worked fine so long as you didn't intentionally misuse it.


That's not a very good analogy because in the early seasons some bought the toaster to find out that it best works as a hotplate.


That's the point! It worked as a hotplate, but it's meant to be a toaster. If it stops working as a hotplate, you don't get a replacement toaster because you used it wrong.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.