Originally posted by atom871
As far as textual infallibility goes, words only get us so far, with each other and from "on high." There will always be some kind of misinterpretation at some level somewhere. That said, the Bible is God's instruction book to us, a user manual for human life, so to speak. God's intellect is so far different from us, there are bound to be some difficulties in translation, so to speak, because of our limited human faculties
i'm not talking about misinterpretation... i'm talking about literalism/constructivism vs. liberalism/non-fundamentalism.
Originally posted by atom871
The idea that all cultures have a creation myth and stories like the flood, only serves to prove that somehow, somewhere, innately, humans know God exists. A supernatural God who can perform any kind of miracle, globally or locally.
first off, not all cultures have creation myths, so there goes that theory. secondly, you can't draw a cosmological argument from a common feature... it would be like saying reincarnation must exist because so many people/cultures believe in it.
Originally posted by atom871
As far as the significant advancements of prehistorical geology go, there are plenty of scientists who refute the infallibility of carbon-dating. It's not full-proof. Personally, i have not fully committed myself to resolving the evolution/creation dilemma, so i can't really argue all the facts.
not "plenty". not even close. not even remotely close. anyone who actually understands the math of carbon-dating is going to be incredibly hard pressed to disagree with it. and yes, there are those even within the scientific community that air their concerns (not with the technique per se, but its over-application)... but they are, almost to a person, already in possession of certain religious beliefs that subtend their scientific knowledge. i challenge you to find a scientifically credentialed non-theist that has a categorical complaint against carbon-dating.
Originally posted by atom871
I can tell you, i used to question and refute Christianity. I've read more evidence against Christianity in my life, and believed on Darwinistic evolution theories associated with the likes of the Big Bang.
i certainly don't see carbon-dating, evolution, or the big bang as incompatible with christianity proper. and certainly the myriad christians working in those fields don't either. people often assume that academia is godless... i'm very sure that most of my profs (even on the west coast) were theists.
Originally posted by atom871
But when i saw God at work in my life, directly and in the lives of those around me, i made a Choice, the famous "leap of Faith." I just trust the Bible now. It's what God wants and needs me to know. I fully believe that.
i'm in no way challenging that logical move... but its worth noting that it represents an epistemological threshold that would have to include the scientific materialism that drives carbon-dating.
Originally posted by atom871
I have read some apologetics, one in particular, who uses hard science and conventional logic principles to prove why atheists can't be right, is Scaling the Secular City. It's quite complicated. Perhaps even above my capacity to understand fully without a lot more study. However, what i grasped stuck with me, in an intuitive sense. I have studied logic and philosophy all my adult life, and probably a bit longer. I am no scholar, and i am not school trained in the fields, but let's just say i have a grasp on most of the basic concepts and can use them with some effectiveness.
first off, both theists and atheists are actually in the same logical camp... and neither will ever be able to use "conventional logic principles" to prove or disprove either side. it is analytically impossible.
on a similar note, "hard science" is also completely unhelpful in discussions of religion. the scientific method is founded on the philosophy of empiricism... which, as we already discussed, presupposes the absence of the supernatural (or, at least, devalorizes it). that presupposition and religion's opposite presupposition will never meet... and we cannot empirically or analytically prove/disprove either one.
As far as textual infallibility goes, words only get us so far, with each other and from "on high." There will always be some kind of misinterpretation at some level somewhere. That said, the Bible is God's instruction book to us, a user manual for human life, so to speak. God's intellect is so far different from us, there are bound to be some difficulties in translation, so to speak, because of our limited human faculties
i'm not talking about misinterpretation... i'm talking about literalism/constructivism vs. liberalism/non-fundamentalism.
Originally posted by atom871
The idea that all cultures have a creation myth and stories like the flood, only serves to prove that somehow, somewhere, innately, humans know God exists. A supernatural God who can perform any kind of miracle, globally or locally.
first off, not all cultures have creation myths, so there goes that theory. secondly, you can't draw a cosmological argument from a common feature... it would be like saying reincarnation must exist because so many people/cultures believe in it.
Originally posted by atom871
As far as the significant advancements of prehistorical geology go, there are plenty of scientists who refute the infallibility of carbon-dating. It's not full-proof. Personally, i have not fully committed myself to resolving the evolution/creation dilemma, so i can't really argue all the facts.
not "plenty". not even close. not even remotely close. anyone who actually understands the math of carbon-dating is going to be incredibly hard pressed to disagree with it. and yes, there are those even within the scientific community that air their concerns (not with the technique per se, but its over-application)... but they are, almost to a person, already in possession of certain religious beliefs that subtend their scientific knowledge. i challenge you to find a scientifically credentialed non-theist that has a categorical complaint against carbon-dating.
Originally posted by atom871
I can tell you, i used to question and refute Christianity. I've read more evidence against Christianity in my life, and believed on Darwinistic evolution theories associated with the likes of the Big Bang.
i certainly don't see carbon-dating, evolution, or the big bang as incompatible with christianity proper. and certainly the myriad christians working in those fields don't either. people often assume that academia is godless... i'm very sure that most of my profs (even on the west coast) were theists.
Originally posted by atom871
But when i saw God at work in my life, directly and in the lives of those around me, i made a Choice, the famous "leap of Faith." I just trust the Bible now. It's what God wants and needs me to know. I fully believe that.
i'm in no way challenging that logical move... but its worth noting that it represents an epistemological threshold that would have to include the scientific materialism that drives carbon-dating.
Originally posted by atom871
I have read some apologetics, one in particular, who uses hard science and conventional logic principles to prove why atheists can't be right, is Scaling the Secular City. It's quite complicated. Perhaps even above my capacity to understand fully without a lot more study. However, what i grasped stuck with me, in an intuitive sense. I have studied logic and philosophy all my adult life, and probably a bit longer. I am no scholar, and i am not school trained in the fields, but let's just say i have a grasp on most of the basic concepts and can use them with some effectiveness.
first off, both theists and atheists are actually in the same logical camp... and neither will ever be able to use "conventional logic principles" to prove or disprove either side. it is analytically impossible.
on a similar note, "hard science" is also completely unhelpful in discussions of religion. the scientific method is founded on the philosophy of empiricism... which, as we already discussed, presupposes the absence of the supernatural (or, at least, devalorizes it). that presupposition and religion's opposite presupposition will never meet... and we cannot empirically or analytically prove/disprove either one.






























