User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
As far as textual infallibility goes, words only get us so far, with each other and from "on high." There will always be some kind of misinterpretation at some level somewhere. That said, the Bible is God's instruction book to us, a user manual for human life, so to speak. God's intellect is so far different from us, there are bound to be some difficulties in translation, so to speak, because of our limited human faculties

i'm not talking about misinterpretation... i'm talking about literalism/constructivism vs. liberalism/non-fundamentalism.

Originally posted by atom871
The idea that all cultures have a creation myth and stories like the flood, only serves to prove that somehow, somewhere, innately, humans know God exists. A supernatural God who can perform any kind of miracle, globally or locally.

first off, not all cultures have creation myths, so there goes that theory. secondly, you can't draw a cosmological argument from a common feature... it would be like saying reincarnation must exist because so many people/cultures believe in it.

Originally posted by atom871
As far as the significant advancements of prehistorical geology go, there are plenty of scientists who refute the infallibility of carbon-dating. It's not full-proof. Personally, i have not fully committed myself to resolving the evolution/creation dilemma, so i can't really argue all the facts.

not "plenty". not even close. not even remotely close. anyone who actually understands the math of carbon-dating is going to be incredibly hard pressed to disagree with it. and yes, there are those even within the scientific community that air their concerns (not with the technique per se, but its over-application)... but they are, almost to a person, already in possession of certain religious beliefs that subtend their scientific knowledge. i challenge you to find a scientifically credentialed non-theist that has a categorical complaint against carbon-dating.

Originally posted by atom871
I can tell you, i used to question and refute Christianity. I've read more evidence against Christianity in my life, and believed on Darwinistic evolution theories associated with the likes of the Big Bang.

i certainly don't see carbon-dating, evolution, or the big bang as incompatible with christianity proper. and certainly the myriad christians working in those fields don't either. people often assume that academia is godless... i'm very sure that most of my profs (even on the west coast) were theists.

Originally posted by atom871
But when i saw God at work in my life, directly and in the lives of those around me, i made a Choice, the famous "leap of Faith." I just trust the Bible now. It's what God wants and needs me to know. I fully believe that.

i'm in no way challenging that logical move... but its worth noting that it represents an epistemological threshold that would have to include the scientific materialism that drives carbon-dating.

Originally posted by atom871
I have read some apologetics, one in particular, who uses hard science and conventional logic principles to prove why atheists can't be right, is Scaling the Secular City. It's quite complicated. Perhaps even above my capacity to understand fully without a lot more study. However, what i grasped stuck with me, in an intuitive sense. I have studied logic and philosophy all my adult life, and probably a bit longer. I am no scholar, and i am not school trained in the fields, but let's just say i have a grasp on most of the basic concepts and can use them with some effectiveness.

first off, both theists and atheists are actually in the same logical camp... and neither will ever be able to use "conventional logic principles" to prove or disprove either side. it is analytically impossible.

on a similar note, "hard science" is also completely unhelpful in discussions of religion. the scientific method is founded on the philosophy of empiricism... which, as we already discussed, presupposes the absence of the supernatural (or, at least, devalorizes it). that presupposition and religion's opposite presupposition will never meet... and we cannot empirically or analytically prove/disprove either one.
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16

first off, not all cultures have creation myths, so there goes that theory. secondly, you can't draw a cosmological argument from a common feature... it would be like saying reincarnation must exist because so many people/cultures believe in it.


if not all, then the vast majority, more than enough to make the point valid. if something supernatural is happening across the board then there is a good chance it's real. of course, i don't believe either that reincarnation is real, nor do i believe there are enough people to make that supposition valid. however, it IS a general Human trait to acknowledge some sort of creationism.

Originally posted by Catullus 16
not "plenty". not even close. not even remotely close. anyone who actually understands the math of carbon-dating is going to be incredibly hard pressed to disagree with it. and yes, there are those even within the scientific community that air their concerns (not with the technique per se, but its over-application)... but they are, almost to a person, already in possession of certain religious beliefs that subtend their scientific knowledge. i challenge you to find a scientifically credentialed non-theist that has a categorical complaint against carbon-dating.


i don't understand the math. honestly, nor do i claim to have resolved the issues in for my own mind. but carbon-dating has been proven wrong enough times ("plenty") for me to doubt its veracity. i won't accept your challenge, only because i don't think i will get around to it for a while TBH. i have done the homework in the past though. i reconciled the data with my beliefs, took an intuitive understanding and memory dumped the specific facts (names dates etc), leaving me with a general concept.

Originally posted by Catullus 16
i certainly don't see carbon-dating, evolution, or the big bang as incompatible with christianity proper. and certainly the myriad christians working in those fields don't either. people often assume that academia is godless... i'm very sure that most of my profs (even on the west coast) were theists.


i think, in the end i will reconcile them comfortably. there is some truth in science = )


Originally posted by Catullus 16
i'm in no way challenging that logical move... but its worth noting that it represents an epistemological threshold that would have to include the scientific materialism that drives carbon-dating.


doesn't "have to" for me to believe


Originally posted by Catullus 16
first off, both theists and atheists are actually in the same logical camp... and neither will ever be able to use "conventional logic principles" to prove or disprove either side. it is analytically impossible.


i was referring to the studies of probabilities and statistics in that book, with regard to the actual physics of life and the narrow range of circumstances that allow us to type in cyberspace, breathe, eat, sleep and live on the mudball we call earth. you can build a solid argument that way.

Originally posted by Catullus 16
on a similar note, "hard science" is also completely unhelpful in discussions of religion. the scientific method is founded on the philosophy of empiricism... which, as we already discussed, presupposes the absence of the supernatural (or, at least, devalorizes it). that presupposition and religion's opposite presupposition will never meet... and we cannot empirically or analytically prove/disprove either one.


perhaps my lack of school training has led to a semantics problem. also, because im in "stream of conciousness" mode and trying to get my reply out fast. perhaps we need to define "hard science" i tend to speak in generalities. however, i will refer to my reply just a few paragraphs above to answer this reply of yours. as i try to recall the book, i am reminded of how fascinating it was, steeped in classic logic. perhaps you should give it a look.

 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
if not all, then the vast majority, more than enough to make the point valid. if something supernatural is happening across the board then there is a good chance it's real. of course, i don't believe either that reincarnation is real, nor do i believe there are enough people to make that supposition valid. however, it IS a general Human trait to acknowledge some sort of creationism.

not even a vast majority. but i guess i had said "early cultures", so with the qualification, perhaps. but still not valid. you can't so casually move from 'some' to 'all' like that. more importantly, you're falling prey to the common fallacy of confusing correlation with causation. does the presence of god cause this feature of culture? or do cultures tend to create "god" for other reasons?

also, you still have to satisfy the generality and particularity conditions here if you want such a claim to have any sense of proportion. so i'm not so sure you want to so quickly dismiss how many early cultures believed in a sort of reincarnation (there are a lot of people in asia, for starters). also, while a creation myth is relatively common, "creationism" in the western sense is (naturally) just western... or, more accurately, christian.


Originally posted by atom871
i don't understand the math. honestly, nor do i claim to have resolved the issues in for my own mind. but carbon-dating has been proven wrong enough times ("plenty") for me to doubt its veracity. i won't accept your challenge, only because i don't think i will get around to it for a while TBH. i have done the homework in the past though. i reconciled the data with my beliefs, took an intuitive understanding and memory dumped the specific facts (names dates etc), leaving me with a general concept.

the method of carbon-dating has never been proven wrong. not once. where the "doubt" has arisen is when carbon-dating seems to produce wildly divergent results. but this is not the fault of the method or the science behind it. rather, it is part of the variance inherent when working with incredibly old/small specimens... or (in the early days of the technique) with crude equipment. there have been incredible strides in the field (and in technology) since the 60s and 70s when people trumpeted about the so-called errors of carbon-dating. whether or not carbon-dating is over-applied in certain settings is a completely separate discussion that in no way invalidates the method.


Originally posted by atom871
i think, in the end i will reconcile them comfortably. there is some truth in science = )

well... we've somewhat perverted the meaning of the word 'science'. coming from the latin 'scientia' (PP of "to know"), it was usually construed as the sum of knowledge in general... which could be approached in a variety of ways. as we moved through the enlightenment and rationalism bred empiricism, things became fairly positivist and the staunch empiricists came to believe that rational observation could uncover the whole of knowledge (i.e. of science). that 'rational observation' gave way to a loose code known as the 'scientific method'... which purports to be inductive but in practice is rather deductive and paradigmatic (cf. karl popper). my point: just as with carbon-dating, most people confuse the strict method with the theories of the people who use it. further: even in its pejorative sense, "science" has never positioned itself a source of truth... just an avenue to it.


Originally posted by atom871
doesn't "have to" for me to believe

but then you've abandoned any claim to logic. i guess you can still be idiorational, but you cannot from that point pretend to use logic to explain/defend your faith without being a complete hypocrite. and you certainly wouldn't have any grounds to proselytize to a person who is actually epistemologically consistent.


Originally posted by atom871
i was referring to the studies of probabilities and statistics in that book, with regard to the actual physics of life and the narrow range of circumstances that allow us to type in cyberspace, breathe, eat, sleep and live on the mudball we call earth. you can build a solid argument that way.

well... stats are probabilistic claims to causality/description and thus in the family of abductive logic. in other words, they're all 'arguments to the best explanation', which are incredibly tough to analytically falsify. your only path is to proffer an alternate explanation that (1)is not known to be false and (2)is just as good. obviously, this is all very sloppy and the actual practice of it all is squarely in the realm of rhetorical justification. put differently: stats/etc don't matter... it all comes down to what the individual finds most compelling about the argument (charismatic/articulate speaker, stunning visual aids, etc). and just to tuck it in, it sounds like you're talking about a 'design argument'... so you might enjoy this talk (seriously):
http://www.youngphilosophers.org/labels/beebe.html


Originally posted by atom871
perhaps my lack of school training has led to a semantics problem. also, because im in "stream of conciousness" mode and trying to get my reply out fast. perhaps we need to define "hard science" i tend to speak in generalities. however, i will refer to my reply just a few paragraphs above to answer this reply of yours. as i try to recall the book, i am reminded of how fascinating it was, steeped in classic logic. perhaps you should give it a look.

well, when it comes to 'hard science', i was actually quoting you... and i assumed you were contrasting it with the so-called 'soft science' (i.e. social science and some humanities).
 
Little Dragon
offline
Link
 
You know a lot of this can be cleared up by reading the book of Thomas a book that was never published in the bible
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BearBryant
You know a lot of this can be cleared up by reading the book of Thomas a book that was never published in the bible


yeah... a few obvious issues with that one. and the gospel of peter.

ETA: also, i'm not sure how apocrypha is relevant to this conversation.
Last edited Aug 12, 2008 06:43:32
 
EmpYllek
offline
Link
 
So Im away for a few days drinking and stuff and I come back to the same old stuff.

People think the flood actually happened when all but the most scary catholics (the ones who think Jesus would actually vote for a political party in opposition to most of his teachings) know that actually its a metaphor.

People still think youre going to hell if you dont believe in God when youre a good person doing everything He asks of us anyway.

The atheists insist on saying that science makes religion look stupid when they should realise that science is the how and can never be about the why (before anyone starts Im a fucking genius and a scientist so I know my shit - if someone wants we can discuss the paradox of the third law of thermodynamics in a godless existence).

Basically everyones still missing the point. In the start of "The Hitchikers Guide to the Galaxy" (book version) Douglas Adams makes the point about how stupid so much in this world by referring to how "one man had been nailed to a tree for saying how great it would be to be nice to people for a change".

Is that not whats really important? Not ultimately whether we drink, or have promiscuous sex, or go against our own church dogma to say "Hey if stem cell research cures Alzheimers Im all for it" - but if were nice to people?
Last edited Aug 12, 2008 10:00:22
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EmpYllek

Basically everyones still missing the point. In the start of "The Hitchikers Guide to the Galaxy" (book version) Douglas Adams makes the point about how stupid so much in this world by referring to how "one man had been nailed to a tree for saying how great it would be to be nice to people for a change".


I have not missed the point, i did for a VERY long time. It caused a number of troubles in my life. But even when we see fit "to be nice to people for a change" any number of problems can arise and interfere, most commonly our own pride. Anger, selfishness, impatience, greed. These things need put aside. They are almost impossible to resist, without help.

Problem is, they are built-in ways of coping. These fallible coping emotions are not easily removed, without some supernatural help. I lean on that help to put aside such things so i can be more "nice to people for a change" and honor the sacrifice of that one man, Jesus. Along those lines, i have accepted that God is real, he created us, the Bible, and sent Jesus, in a miraculous fashion, to redeem the world. I believe the Bible is right, true and is the living breathing Word of God.

I agree with your point about science being the how and can't be the why. It makes conversing about it frustrating. In the end, actions speak louder than words. Words ultimately will fail at some point. It's what's in your heart that counts, and what you do that speaks volumes.

 
Moh7
offline
Link
 
This is lame, who the hell brings jesus into a mmorpg, are christians that desperate now.
 
My band
offline
Link
 
Its great that you are ministering to people keep up the good work.
 
verus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Football Freshman Phil
Originally posted by verus

You will all burn for your heresy. Allah is the one true God and unless you accept him into your heart, you cannot reach salvation.


Hope you're joking bro, cause' Mohammed wouldn't like your avatar.



Why, because there's only one wife in it?
 
ssaints4ever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by verus
Originally posted by Football Freshman Phil

Originally posted by verus


You will all burn for your heresy. Allah is the one true God and unless you accept him into your heart, you cannot reach salvation.


Hope you're joking bro, cause' Mohammed wouldn't like your avatar.



Why, because there's only one wife in it?


& she's not six fucking years old?
 
The Big House
offline
Link
 
I'll help you out Cagan. I'll preach the gospel to anyone who wants to know. If you want to hear the gospel message, just message me, and i'll talk to you to.
Last edited Aug 12, 2008 15:49:01
 
Phillyboy23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ssaints4ever
Originally posted by verus

Originally posted by Football Freshman Phil


Originally posted by verus



You will all burn for your heresy. Allah is the one true God and unless you accept him into your heart, you cannot reach salvation.


Hope you're joking bro, cause' Mohammed wouldn't like your avatar.



Why, because there's only one wife in it?


& she's not six fucking years old?


lol, that's kinda harsh
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EmpYllek
People still think youre going to hell if you dont believe in God when youre a good person doing everything He asks of us anyway.

any religion without a devotional aspect loses coherence... which, of course, steers us into problems with 'divine command theory' (cf. euthyphro's dilemma).

Originally posted by EmpYllek
The atheists insist on saying that science makes religion look stupid when they should realise that science is the how and can never be about the why

i guess i missed "the atheists" saying such things on this thread. and for the record, the positivists amongst the early empiricists thought that science could also be a 'why'.

Originally posted by EmpYllek
(before anyone starts Im a fucking genius and a scientist so I know my shit - if someone wants we can discuss the paradox of the third law of thermodynamics in a godless existence).

uh... okay. good for you. although i have to say that most self-proclaimed geniuses are anything but.

so fine, third law... but which formulation (nernst1, nernst2, planck)? and where's the paradox? if you're referring to gibbs, i don't know anyone who doesn't think that it can't be satisfied with information theory. did you actually mean the second law with maxwell's demon and loschmidt's paradox and all that? look, all the paradoxes about (ir)reversibility and asymmetry are old hat... and they're still just thought experiments at this point. the jury is still very much out on a lot of this stuff, so it would be very unscientific to get overly bold about their supposed application.

Originally posted by EmpYllek
Basically everyones still missing the point. In the start of "The Hitchikers Guide to the Galaxy" (book version) Douglas Adams makes the point about how stupid so much in this world by referring to how "one man had been nailed to a tree for saying how great it would be to be nice to people for a change".

yes, a fine thought (from a fine author), but where's the devotional aspect?

Originally posted by EmpYllek
Is that not whats really important? Not ultimately whether we drink, or have promiscuous sex, or go against our own church dogma to say "Hey if stem cell research cures Alzheimers Im all for it" - but if were nice to people?

for the record, there are an incredible number of churches who would agree... or simply wouldn't care. not all christians religicize their sociopolitics... in fact, there are a great number who are incredibly depolitical or staunchly apolitical.
Last edited Aug 12, 2008 20:15:13
 
Link
 
Originally posted by moh7
This is lame, who the hell brings jesus into a mmorpg, are christians that desperate now.


how lame are *YOU* for reading a thread about a Christian Club when you aren't even Christian??
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.