User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Team Loans, Chemistry
Page:
 
DaSaintFan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

- This means: if you make a trade of a player for a player, you lose 3-5 chemistry. If you make a trade of a player for cash, you lose 1-3 chemistry.


Don't get me wrong... but doesn't these seem a little backwards?

Owner is giving up a player for money... would kinda hurt more than trying to trade a player to get a better player?

Why not set it up so that Player for player trade =

Total Levels you Get - Total Levels you give up? (Cash = 0 level?)

So basically if you give up a lvl 6 for a lvl 2 , you GET -4 chem?
If you give up a level 2, and get a level 6.. you get +4 chem.
If you trade a lvl 8 for Cash you lose 8 chemistry?

Getting rid of CPU players you get +1 chem (since now you hope you get an active player)
Gaining a CPU player = -1 chemistry.

So if our owner gave up say a lvl 4 CPU player to get a human lvl 3 player...
Chemistry would be (3-4 {levels} +1 (losing a CPU) = net result of 0)


(yeah, I realized a small problem after I typed this.. "farm teams" would just keep sending higher levels to their better teams to increase chem..)
Last edited Apr 17, 2008 06:21:43
 
shortstack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
I like where you are going with that one Cherrie.

Maybe something like, each team must have 40 different *users* on it to receive the +1 point each day

Teams with less users will not receive the bonus point (as they haven't actually accomplished anything worth being rewarded a chemistry point for as they haven't actually united a bunch of different players)

Nice train of thought there hopefully it can be improved a bit.


This is the best suggestion I have seen, and it encourages active owners who have mastered the art of keeping together and gelling a large group of game participants. The devs should definitely consider this!! Not only does it get at the farm systems, but it also gets at the teams that make all of their own players.
 
karma99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DaSaintFan
Originally posted by Bort


- This means: if you make a trade of a player for a player, you lose 3-5 chemistry. If you make a trade of a player for cash, you lose 1-3 chemistry.


Don't get me wrong... but doesn't these seem a little backwards?

Owner is giving up a player for money... would kinda hurt more than trying to trade a player to get a better player?

Why not set it up so that Player for player trade =

Total Levels you Get - Total Levels you give up? (Cash = 0 level?)

So basically if you give up a lvl 6 for a lvl 2 , you GET -4 chem?
If you give up a level 2, and get a level 6.. you get +4 chem.
If you trade a lvl 8 for Cash you lose 8 chemistry?

Getting rid of CPU players you get +1 chem (since now you hope you get an active player)
Gaining a CPU player = -1 chemistry.

So if our owner gave up say a lvl 4 CPU player to get a human lvl 3 player...
Chemistry would be (3-4 {levels} +1 (losing a CPU) = net result of 0)


(yeah, I realized a small problem after I typed this.. "farm teams" would just keep sending higher levels to their better teams to increase chem..)


I think it's correct as it is, it's about team chemistry, the way people play together. You often hear QB's and WR's saying they practice together so they know what the other one will do in certain circumstance, etc
This reflects that very well.
If a player leaves the team, that chemistry that he had with those around him is lost. If he's a #1 then most likely a backup will step up who the players will already have some idea of and will be a known team member.
However if a totally new player comes in, not only have they lost the old players chemistry with them, but the new guy needs to learn the way his new team mates work.

It's why the Pro-Bowl isn't the best game of the year, despite the players being (arguably) the best players in the league. It's because most of them don't practice together and don't have that instinct for each other's playing.
 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by karma99
Originally posted by DaSaintFan

Originally posted by Bort



- This means: if you make a trade of a player for a player, you lose 3-5 chemistry. If you make a trade of a player for cash, you lose 1-3 chemistry.


Don't get me wrong... but doesn't these seem a little backwards?

Owner is giving up a player for money... would kinda hurt more than trying to trade a player to get a better player?

Why not set it up so that Player for player trade =

Total Levels you Get - Total Levels you give up? (Cash = 0 level?)

So basically if you give up a lvl 6 for a lvl 2 , you GET -4 chem?
If you give up a level 2, and get a level 6.. you get +4 chem.
If you trade a lvl 8 for Cash you lose 8 chemistry?

Getting rid of CPU players you get +1 chem (since now you hope you get an active player)
Gaining a CPU player = -1 chemistry.

So if our owner gave up say a lvl 4 CPU player to get a human lvl 3 player...
Chemistry would be (3-4 {levels} +1 (losing a CPU) = net result of 0)


(yeah, I realized a small problem after I typed this.. "farm teams" would just keep sending higher levels to their better teams to increase chem..)


It's why the Pro-Bowl isn't the best game of the year, despite the players being (arguably) the best players in the league. It's because most of them don't practice together and don't have that instinct for each other's playing.


It is when devin hester has the ball.... ><
 
shortstack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by karma99
Is this not going to be a very harsh penalty on players buying new teams this season? Swapping out CPU players for humans will crush their chemistry before they start, which is fair enough normally, but most of them have been wanting to get a team and get started with it for the past fortnight but haven't been able to.
I think maybe this time a 4-5 day exception of any chemistry adjustments until things settle after what is a pretty abnormal set of circumstances for a season to season change.


How much chemistry does a new football team usually have. They will all be in the same boat.
 
DaSaintFan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by karma99
If a player leaves the team, that chemistry that he had with those around him is lost. If he's a #1 then most likely a backup will step up who the players will already have some idea of and will be a known team member.


That part came to mind, karma... I was thinking along the lines that though that if my WR was only say a lvl 2, and a lvl 7 or 8 WR is brought in, the confidence is gonna go up from QB to WR as to what he can do...

It was the "less penalty" for Cash that had me starting on the thought train to begin with... (I can't see how losing a player for cash, doesn't do MORE damage to a team chemistry/morale than bringing in a new player at least.)
 
karma99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shortstack
Originally posted by Vilita

I like where you are going with that one Cherrie.

Maybe something like, each team must have 40 different *users* on it to receive the +1 point each day

Teams with less users will not receive the bonus point (as they haven't actually accomplished anything worth being rewarded a chemistry point for as they haven't actually united a bunch of different players)

Nice train of thought there hopefully it can be improved a bit.


This is the best suggestion I have seen, and it encourages active owners who have mastered the art of keeping together and gelling a large group of game participants. The devs should definitely consider this!! Not only does it get at the farm systems, but it also gets at the teams that make all of their own players.


I'll bump this too, awesome idea.. maybe a small reduction in the number (30-32?) as having 2 players on a team isn't overkill imo, but basing it on users and not players is loaded with win!
 
karma99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shortstack
Originally posted by karma99

Is this not going to be a very harsh penalty on players buying new teams this season? Swapping out CPU players for humans will crush their chemistry before they start, which is fair enough normally, but most of them have been wanting to get a team and get started with it for the past fortnight but haven't been able to.
I think maybe this time a 4-5 day exception of any chemistry adjustments until things settle after what is a pretty abnormal set of circumstances for a season to season change.


How much chemistry does a new football team usually have. They will all be in the same boat.


Yeah but it's kind of my point, this a "freak" season start in that all these hundreds (sic) of people who want teams would have their rosters sorted by now.. if there had been provision for them. Also with 1000's of players waiting to actually get "into" the game and actually be able to do something at last, encouraging owners to scrimp on recruitment when we start Season 2 can't be good for the game?
Thinking about it, why not allow CPU - Human replacements happen with no chemistry loss. Encouraging owners to take on Human players is vital to the game's growth, and nobody is going to produce a star team of CPU players, that they then swap to Human's just before the playoffs.. they won't win enough games
 
Oren74
offline
Link
 
Awesome update. Need to give owners SOME reason to keep players happy. Otherwise their opinion will be "don't like your spot on the depth chart? To bad..." cause they could just cut you an dpick someone else up.

Now it hurts
 
shortstack
offline
Link
 
The team chemistry idea is great. However it could be greatly improved if it were based on the number of "active player owners" you have on a team. If you have 15 "active player owners" your chemistry goes up more/per day, than if you had say 3 active player owners on your team. It gives people incentive to get rid of CPU players and incactive players. And encourages teams to get everybody out there involved in the game. It's good for goaline blitz, and it could be good for the team. Also, typcially if a team has a number of players going inactive, they probably aren't doing a good job of creating team chemistry anyway. Hope one of the amins/devs can take this and run with it.
 
shortstack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shortstack
The team chemistry idea is great. However it could be greatly improved if it were based on the number of "active player owners" you have on a team. If you have 15 "active player owners" your chemistry goes up more/per day, than if you had say 3 active player owners on your team. It gives people incentive to get rid of CPU players and incactive players. And encourages teams to get everybody out there involved in the game. It's good for goaline blitz, and it could be good for the team. Also, typcially if a team has a number of players going inactive, they probably aren't doing a good job of creating team chemistry anyway. Hope one of the amins/devs can take this and run with it.


Also basing it on the number of "active player owners" on a team is much more difficult to game the system. Much more difficult to get 35 friends to sign up just to increase your team chemistry. Also presents a disincentive to stacking teams with players created by the best player owners. Now there would be more of a distribution of talent throughout the league.

 
DrunkenLemur
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DaSaintFan
Originally posted by Bort


- This means: if you make a trade of a player for a player, you lose 3-5 chemistry. If you make a trade of a player for cash, you lose 1-3 chemistry.


Don't get me wrong... but doesn't these seem a little backwards?

Owner is giving up a player for money... would kinda hurt more than trying to trade a player to get a better player?

....


Ok - I really hope someone makes a FAQ and stickies this because a LOT of people seem to be missing the point on this one.

The reason that it is a bigger hit to your chemistry when you do a player for player trade is because you are making 2 adjustments to your team. You have one incoming player who needs to acclimate and one outgoing player (who presumably will be missed).

In a cash transaction you simply have one player outgoing and no further disruption, hence the team takes less of a hit to the chemistry.

This logic and setup makes perfect sense when you approach it from that point of view.

Thanks,
Razorbacks Owner

 
shortstack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shortstack
Originally posted by shortstack

The team chemistry idea is great. However it could be greatly improved if it were based on the number of "active player owners" you have on a team. If you have 15 "active player owners" your chemistry goes up more/per day, than if you had say 3 active player owners on your team. It gives people incentive to get rid of CPU players and incactive players. And encourages teams to get everybody out there involved in the game. It's good for goaline blitz, and it could be good for the team. Also, typcially if a team has a number of players going inactive, they probably aren't doing a good job of creating team chemistry anyway. Hope one of the amins/devs can take this and run with it.


Also basing it on the number of "active player owners" on a team is much more difficult to game the system. Much more difficult to get 35 friends to sign up just to increase your team chemistry. Also presents a disincentive to stacking teams with players created by the best player owners. Now there would be more of a distribution of talent throughout the league.



The way I see it you add a 53 man roster cap, like the NFL. Then the max number of "active player owners" you could have on one team would be 53. So 53=100% team chemistry. However if one player makes 53 players to fill his roster, which is not in the spirit of the game, he only gets 48 percent (100-52) team chemistry. So the lowest the chemistry could go would be 48% with only one player owner, and the highest it could go would be 100% (47% + 53 player owners). So the more goaline blitz users you get involved on your team, the higher your team chemistry.

Example, if I have 15 goaline blitz users on my team controlling 53 players. Then my chemistry would be 47% (the lowest possible) + 15 (number of goaline blitz users on the team)= 62% chemistry.
Last edited Apr 17, 2008 07:08:28
 
AwpHul
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shortstack

The team chemistry idea is great. However it could be greatly improved if it were based on the number of "active player owners" you have on a team. If you have 15 "active player owners" your chemistry goes up more/per day, than if you had say 3 active player owners on your team. It gives people incentive to get rid of CPU players and incactive players. And encourages teams to get everybody out there involved in the game. It's good for goaline blitz, and it could be good for the team. Also, typcially if a team has a number of players going inactive, they probably aren't doing a good job of creating team chemistry anyway. Hope one of the amins/devs can take this and run with it.


I think you're veering onto a tangent here. The idea of "team chemistry" is that the players playing on a team together will get to know each other, and start to work better together. Remove a player they're used to and replace with a new player, it takes some getting used to.

You're trying to make it more about the chemistry of player's OWNERS. I'm not going to involve myself in the debate about whether a team should be rewarded or not based on the diversity of its player's owners, but wanted to point out that that's NOT the same concept as "team chemistry" when you're talking about football.

I see your suggestion as akin to saying that on a real football team, there would be a better chemistry for a team on which every player had his own agent (Show me the money!) as opposed to those teams where 90% of the players were being represented through the same sports agent. That just doesn't seem relevant to the inter-player chemistry to me, and while I understand that you want a way to reward teams which are comprised of many human gamers working well to manage their players together, this just doesn't seem like the logical place for that, merited (aka your opinion) or not (aka DR EVL's opinion, apparently.)
 
AwpHul
offline
Link
 
In an attempt to recap for anyone just joining this megathread and save them the bother of reading all those pages digging for relevancy:

At the moment, the situation appears to be:

1) start of season 2, all teams will have their team chemistry values reset to 70 across the board.

2) team chemistry numbers will go up by +1 per day.

3) trading/dropping a CPU player will cost you -1 chemistry from the appropriate bar.

4) Trading/dropping a human player will cost you -3 chemistry from the appropriate bar.

5) adding a new player to your roster will cost you -2 chemistry from the appropriate bar.

Net-net of trading one offense player for one from another team: -5 chemistry on your offense bar.

Teams effectively earn 40 points of chemistry per season, and can therefore make a certain number of trades/drops per season without a net change to their chemistry as compared to where it started the season.

There appears to still be some uncertainly about whether chem goes up during the off season -- Bort hinted that it might go up during the off season, but also stated that a team could earn "40 points" of chemistry per season, which was taken to mean "from season X, day 1, to season X+1, day 1" -- but could also mean "from season X, day 1, to season X, day 40" -- thus meaning that the off season days could hold the same bonus/penalties that in-season days do.

To clarify an important point: CHEMISTRY WILL RESET TO 70 ON DAY 1, SEASON 2.

...so get all of your trades done in the upcoming off season to maximize your chemistry during season 2.
Last edited Apr 17, 2008 07:41:35
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.