Perfect ending midseason. They threw emotion aside for the sake of their own lives only to have karma fuck them in the end. Fuckin perfect.
decribb83
offline
offline
Originally posted by RagingBoredom
Well damn, I was hoping that she'd still be alive. Totally didn't expect the tv show to pull the "anyone at anytime" card with her character. Then again, it makes perfect sense. They take a character from the comics who lived well into the story and kill them off toward the beginning. Those who haven't read the comics get the "anyone, anytime" vibe from this (especially since it's a child) and those who have read the comics get reminded of it. Still, I wish they'd have done it with another character. Poor Carl got shot and lost his friend/future girlfriend.
I hope Carl is next. I cring every time he speaks.
Well damn, I was hoping that she'd still be alive. Totally didn't expect the tv show to pull the "anyone at anytime" card with her character. Then again, it makes perfect sense. They take a character from the comics who lived well into the story and kill them off toward the beginning. Those who haven't read the comics get the "anyone, anytime" vibe from this (especially since it's a child) and those who have read the comics get reminded of it. Still, I wish they'd have done it with another character. Poor Carl got shot and lost his friend/future girlfriend.
I hope Carl is next. I cring every time he speaks.
Arawn
offline
offline
BTW, Sophie the zombie, was her best acting of the whole show, and it wasn't very believable.
cannons call
offline
offline
So Herschel, the guy who "thinks the zombies are people" and humanizes them, didn't know that a little girl zombie was in the barn? ...or he failed to put it together that the little girl zombie they had to have found within a day or two of meeting Rick and the group, might very well be the girl they were looking for? ...or if he did know why wouldn't he use the fact that one of their own was in the barn to help convey his point that they shouldn't be killed? Or at least lie and say "Hey we found that girl and she was zombified and attacked us, we had to kill her", so the group wouldn't be running around risking their lives looking for a girl that was literally two football fields away from them the whole time.
Even the timeline doesn't make sense. I guess all those clues Daryl found were a whole bunch of nothing because Sophie must have been zombified within maybe a day at the most after being separated from the group.
I actually like the concept of killing off Sophia and that she was a zombie. It portrays that no ones safe, and that hard decisions must be made. I get that. I just can't defend the incredibly lazy writing that got us to this concept.
Even the timeline doesn't make sense. I guess all those clues Daryl found were a whole bunch of nothing because Sophie must have been zombified within maybe a day at the most after being separated from the group.
I actually like the concept of killing off Sophia and that she was a zombie. It portrays that no ones safe, and that hard decisions must be made. I get that. I just can't defend the incredibly lazy writing that got us to this concept.
Edited by cannons call on Nov 28, 2011 07:17:43
trentw
offline
offline
Why the hell do Zombies stop eating? I mean the only time it seems like you would be turned and still have a complete body is if you get bit and get away. I mean Sophie has like a bite on the neck and thats it? Hard to belive that if she got attacked by a walker they would not have eaten her down to the bone.
Arawn
offline
offline
Originally posted by trentw
Why the hell do Zombies stop eating? I mean the only time it seems like you would be turned and still have a complete body is if you get bit and get away. I mean Sophie has like a bite on the neck and thats it? Hard to belive that if she got attacked by a walker they would not have eaten her down to the bone.
Maybe it didn't like veal
Why the hell do Zombies stop eating? I mean the only time it seems like you would be turned and still have a complete body is if you get bit and get away. I mean Sophie has like a bite on the neck and thats it? Hard to belive that if she got attacked by a walker they would not have eaten her down to the bone.
Maybe it didn't like veal
JMcAdams55
offline
offline
Originally posted by cannons call
So Herschel, the guy who "thinks the zombies are people" and humanizes them, didn't know that a little girl zombie was in the barn? ...or he failed to put it together that the little girl zombie they had to have found within a day or two of meeting Rick and the group, might very well be the girl they were looking for? ...or if he did know why wouldn't he use the fact that one of their own was in the barn to help convey his point that they shouldn't be killed? Or at least lie and say "Hey we found that girl and she was zombified and attacked us, we had to kill her", so the group wouldn't be running around risking their lives looking for a girl that was literally two football fields away from them the whole time.
Even the timeline doesn't make sense. I guess all those clues Daryl found were a whole bunch of nothing because Sophie must have been zombified within maybe a day at the most after being separated from the group.
I actually like the concept of killing off Sophia and that she was a zombie. It portrays that no ones safe, and that hard decisions must be made. I get that. I just can't defend the incredibly lazy writing that got us to this concept.
Herschel was trying to keep the barn a secret. If he knew and said she was in there, they'd know about the barn and what happened would have happened.
I guess if they knew, they could have taken her out and let her loose so they could've found her but I don't know how they wouldn't gotten her out quietly or safely.
So Herschel, the guy who "thinks the zombies are people" and humanizes them, didn't know that a little girl zombie was in the barn? ...or he failed to put it together that the little girl zombie they had to have found within a day or two of meeting Rick and the group, might very well be the girl they were looking for? ...or if he did know why wouldn't he use the fact that one of their own was in the barn to help convey his point that they shouldn't be killed? Or at least lie and say "Hey we found that girl and she was zombified and attacked us, we had to kill her", so the group wouldn't be running around risking their lives looking for a girl that was literally two football fields away from them the whole time.
Even the timeline doesn't make sense. I guess all those clues Daryl found were a whole bunch of nothing because Sophie must have been zombified within maybe a day at the most after being separated from the group.
I actually like the concept of killing off Sophia and that she was a zombie. It portrays that no ones safe, and that hard decisions must be made. I get that. I just can't defend the incredibly lazy writing that got us to this concept.
Herschel was trying to keep the barn a secret. If he knew and said she was in there, they'd know about the barn and what happened would have happened.
I guess if they knew, they could have taken her out and let her loose so they could've found her but I don't know how they wouldn't gotten her out quietly or safely.
Arawn
offline
offline
I bet Sophie hid in the barn, cause she thought it was safe, and then got bit, right before someone dumped the chickens in for the walkers to feed on.
Drake Slaughter
offline
offline
It was explained that Otis did all of the walker wrangling and no new walkers were placed in there since he died. Shane shot him before he knew about their search for Sophie.
Fozzy Fiend
offline
offline
Originally posted by Drake Slaughter
It was explained that Otis did all of the walker wrangling and no new walkers were placed in there since he died. Shane shot him before he knew about their search for Sophie.
i musta missed that explanation.
Great episode!
It was explained that Otis did all of the walker wrangling and no new walkers were placed in there since he died. Shane shot him before he knew about their search for Sophie.
i musta missed that explanation.
Great episode!
kevbk6222
offline
offline
Originally posted by CNinja
I bet Sophie hid in the barn, cause she thought it was safe, and then got bit, right before someone dumped the chickens in for the walkers to feed on.
i figure that someone would have seen her going into the barn. they had dale on lookout duty the whole time.
I bet Sophie hid in the barn, cause she thought it was safe, and then got bit, right before someone dumped the chickens in for the walkers to feed on.
i figure that someone would have seen her going into the barn. they had dale on lookout duty the whole time.
cannons call
offline
offline
Originally posted by JMcAdams55
Herschel was trying to keep the barn a secret. If he knew and said she was in there, they'd know about the barn and what happened would have happened.
I guess if they knew, they could have taken her out and let her loose so they could've found her but I don't know how they wouldn't gotten her out quietly or safely.
Like I said they could have just lied and said that they had found the little girl in the wild and they had to kill her because she attacked. Now the group wouldn't be running around the woods in danger looking for the girl, nor would he have to tell them about the farm.
Herschel was trying to keep the barn a secret. If he knew and said she was in there, they'd know about the barn and what happened would have happened.
I guess if they knew, they could have taken her out and let her loose so they could've found her but I don't know how they wouldn't gotten her out quietly or safely.
Like I said they could have just lied and said that they had found the little girl in the wild and they had to kill her because she attacked. Now the group wouldn't be running around the woods in danger looking for the girl, nor would he have to tell them about the farm.
Drake Slaughter
offline
offline
Originally posted by cannons call
Like I said they could have just lied and said that they had found the little girl in the wild and they had to kill her because she attacked. Now the group wouldn't be running around the woods in danger looking for the girl, nor would he have to tell them about the farm.
Otis knew a little girl was in there, no one else. Shane killed Otis before he knew they were out searching the woods for a little girl. With 20 to 30 walkers in there, it's not out of the question that Patricia didn't see a little girl in there when she fed the chickens to them, that Maggie and Glen didn't see a little girl in there when they were in there, or that Shane saw her in there when looking through the cracks. Those are the only people who had seen in there since Otis was killed. Hershel said Otis did all the wrangling and no one had done it since he died.
Like I said they could have just lied and said that they had found the little girl in the wild and they had to kill her because she attacked. Now the group wouldn't be running around the woods in danger looking for the girl, nor would he have to tell them about the farm.
Otis knew a little girl was in there, no one else. Shane killed Otis before he knew they were out searching the woods for a little girl. With 20 to 30 walkers in there, it's not out of the question that Patricia didn't see a little girl in there when she fed the chickens to them, that Maggie and Glen didn't see a little girl in there when they were in there, or that Shane saw her in there when looking through the cracks. Those are the only people who had seen in there since Otis was killed. Hershel said Otis did all the wrangling and no one had done it since he died.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























